10 Biggest FIFA World Cup "What Ifs"
The World Cup offers the ultimate prize. It also has the same ability to create and crush dreams.
Every football fan and player has one dream - winning the World Cup. Nothing compares to the agony and ecstasy that the tournament can arouse. With so many great teams and players falling short, no other sporting event has a list of "what if" moments like it.
Sometimes the pain of failure is brief and fleeting in nature. On other occasions it is brutal and lasting. Football transcends the world of sport and acts as an allegory for life. It has defined the careers of players, the lives of fans, and the trajectory of national identities.
We all remember World Cups with fondness and a rose tint, but often we cannot help ourselves from asking how different things could have been, if only. From stories of redemption, substance abuse, and the loss of life, to more light-hearted matters such as the stereotypical English football fan, these questions are as existential in nature as the works of Sartre and Descartes.
Instead, we will focus on the works of Socrates, Maradona, Hurst, and a certain Divine Buddhist.
10. The Entire 2002 World Cup
The 2002 World Cup was without a doubt the most controversial tournament to date. It had it all. Dodgy refereeing calls? Check. Dramatic collapses? Check. Major upsets? Check. A story of redemption? Check and check.
The list of "what ifs" reads rather long. France, Portugal, and Argentina head up the list of major teams who didn't manage to get out of the group stages. With three of the strongest line-ups at the tournament, nobody predicted such dramatic implosions from the two top ranked teams (France and Argentina), as well as that of Portugal's golden generation.
The last 16 saw Italy defeated by South Korea in a match that will forever live in infamy due to the sheer number of dubious refereeing calls made by an official who also tried smuggling 6 kilograms of heroin into the USA. Enough said. Spain coincidently bowed out to South Korea in the following round. The match wasn't quite as bad as the Italy fixture, but La Roja were denied a goal and many legitimate opportunities to win the game.
Due to underperformances from major teams and a degree of favouritism towards the hosts, we were robbed of an England vs. France tie in the Round of 16. The quarter finals would have been stuff of fantasy as likely matches would see Germany face Portugal, Spain vs. Italy, and Brazil vs. England or France. Semi Final possibilities include Germany/Portugal vs. Spain/Italy and Brazil/England/France vs. Argentina.
With so many of these teams sporting once in a lifetime talents and squads, it is unlikely that we would or will ever see so many stars go head to head at a World Cup. I guess it's time to call up some friends, dust off our PlayStation 2s, and relive what could have been.
9. Colombia's 1994 World Cup Campaign, USA 1994
The story of Colombia's 1994 World Cup campaign is the most tragic one in the tournament's history. Prior to the Finals, Colombia looked like one of the favourites. With a 3rd place finish at the 1993 Copa America and a blistering qualification run (which saw them hammer South American champions, Argentina, 5-0), they looked like the team who was peaking at the right time.
Sadly, the state of the country did not resemble its footballing strength. A civil war raged between paramilitary and communist groups against a backdrop of drug cartels usurping the state in terms of power held within the country. Football seemed like the only thing people had to keep their hopes alive.
Instability reared its ugly head when the national team became the targets of various betting syndicates and cartels trying to exercise influence over the squad. Players and coaches had to deal with death threats, kidnappings of family members and various other forms of intimidation. This had a dramatic effect on the team and left them a shell of themselves on the pitch. The assassination of Andres Escobar capped off a truly horrendous summer.
The Colombian team was blessed with immense talent. Escobar, Higuita, Valderrama, Rincon and Asprilla were the headliners. Capable of spectacular attacking football, they were also a solid defensive unit, capable of combining individual brilliance with selfless team play.
Had they been able to play without any of these distractions, replicating the performances of Sweden and Bulgaria seemed possible. At their peak though, they were more than capable enough to win the tournament. Not only would this triumph have provided inspiration for Colombia's people to get back on their feet, but we would also have been able to see the talent of Andres Escobar reach its full potential.
8. Italy Vs. Australia, Germany 2006
Francesco Totti is a once in a lifetime talent. A true Bandiera, and an anomaly in the modern game. Blessed with unmatched vision, passing, control, and a fearsome shot, he was one of the best players of his generation. Amongst perhaps the most gifted generation of players ever to grace the beautiful game, Totti was right at the top.
For all of his incredible performances, it was on the 26th of June, 2006, when Totti would make his biggest contribution to Italian football. Italy was struggling against Australia in their Last 16 tie. Out of ideas and looking more and more vulnerable to an Aussie counter, Fabio Grosso "won" a last-minute penalty.
Any non-Italian observer would say that Grosso "simulated". Totti stepped up, did what he does best, and the rest was history. However, had the referee called it correctly, the game would have gone to extra time. Wilting in the summer heat and performing well below par, Australia had every chance to dispatch the Azzurri.
If they did manage to do that, the footballing landscape could have changed rather dramatically. Zidane would most likely have had the ideal swansong, Calciopoli's damage would be tenfold and one could even say that Italian club football would not have rallied through the lean times that were to follow. No Kaka inspired Milan, no Mourinho's Inter and none of Conte's revolutionary Juventus.
In the end, Australia had to be the sacrificial lamb to spare us from such a grim footballing scene. Quite the 'what if.'
7. Diego Maradona's Positive Drug Test, USA 1994
Despite all the drama Maradona went through since Italia '90, at USA '94 he once again resembled the man who could take Argentina all the way. He even had Argentina's most capable team in recent memory to help him, a squad which boasted a prime Batistuta, Redondo, Balbo and Caniggia.
Truth be told, most of the other top teams looked shaky. Spain and Germany struggled to play well for more than 60 minutes, Italy were almost solely dependent on Baggio, Brazil was regarded as one of the poorest teams they had sent to the finals in many years, and the Dutch seemed incapable of anything resembling consistency.
Argentina had the chance to win yet again on a golden platter. Then a certain banned substance showed up. A firm belief in the Argentine camp that they could win it all was replaced by dismay, chaos and panic.
All confidence evaporated after Maradona's B sample tested positive and he was banned from further participation in the tournament. Regardless of having a squad stacked with talent, they fell apart in the first knockout round.
Now, had El Diego kept his nose clean, it would be a safe bet that Argentina could have gone very far. Winning the World Cup far. A greater fairytale could not have been written. After losing it all and becoming the villain in Naples, Maradona could have done the business one more time, to prove once and for all that he is and forever will be the greatest.
At 34, there wasn't much left for Diego football wise. But for the rest of their squad, it would have acted as the springboard to push them towards greater things. Not just cult status.
6. England Vs. Germany, England 1966
Geoff Hurst defined English football with THAT goal. Not as World Cup winners. But rather as the team who would go on to be wronged out of winning it again for the next 54 (and counting) years. Had he missed and England lost, would the lack of pressure on English teams have allowed them to perform better and with greater freedom?
Every England footballer from 1967 to now would say 'yes', and could we argue? The 1966 win was quite a sensational result. Something akin to the "Miracle Of Bern" in 1954. England had a talented team but had no real place among football's giants. England failed to qualify for the 1964 European Nations Cup Finals after losing 6-3 to France in the first qualifying round. A stronger showing at the 1968 tournament followed, along with a solid campaign at the 1970 World Cup. But from there, England never really managed to live up to expectations.
Despite establishing themselves as a force in world football, the success of 1966 would always hang over the Three Lions. At every major tournament, they would be subjected to a level of scrutiny that no other team could even imagine. It would be naive to think that this weight of expectation hasn't hampered the national team.
As with all things English football, every blessing is a double-edged sword.
5. Gonzalo Higuain's Miss, Brazil 2014
Gonzalo Higuain has the dubious honour of missing one of the easiest chances ever created in a World Cup final. In a dull and mostly eventless game, the one goal lead would have been enough to seal the deal in regulation time.
It wasn't the first time, or the last time, Higuain would miss an easy chance in a major final. But missing one in the World Cup final is about as bad as it gets. In this instance, one could say with a high degree of certainty that Argentina would have won. Germany struggled to create decent chances, even though their possession football made them appear to be in control of the tie.
Higuain would go on to have very prolific spells with Napoli and Juventus, with more forgettable ones at Milan and Chelsea. There is no doubt that converting the chance in Rio would have pushed Higuain into the top tier list of players. He is a prolific striker with the ability to handle pressure and deliver when it matters most.
Unfortunately, Higuain let the magnitude of the moment get to him. This, along with misses in two separate Copa America finals, unfairly relegated him to be seen as an "above average" talent, rather than the superb player he really is.
The miss also left Messi with the one thing he'd never have over a certain other Argentina legend...
4. Diego Maradona's Hand Of God, Mexico 1986
A big what if, but perhaps the most talked about one on the list. Often looked at with rose tinted glasses, few who watched the game could honestly say that England was the better team. A simple re-watch of the match will prove the point. While a gutsy team, England lacked inventiveness.
Yet, if they played the way they did in the last 15 minutes, Argentina would have struggled to keep their composure, especially after England's equalizer. For all their brilliance, Argentina also had a frailty, most often hidden by Maradona's genius.
At 1-1, heading into extra time, England's grit would definitely have given them a shot at winning. Much like 1998 though, England's fate was not a simple one. A very strong German team waited in the final. Again, one could say that on any given day, history could repeat itself.
If England conquered all in Mexico, it would have gone a long way to sooth the pain of the post Heysel ban that excluded English clubs from European competition for the following five years.
As for the national team, it might have inspired the likes of Paul Gascoigne and co. to play with more confidence and a firmer belief in themselves. Perhaps allowing them to do the business at Italia '90 as well.
Alas, El Diego had other ideas. It's up to England's new golden generation to break the cycle of "nearly men" status. If Russia 2018 was any indication, they're on the right track.
3. David Beckham Red Card, France 1998
Until 2006, David Beckham had the distinction of receiving the most famous red card in World Cup history. A petty trip on Diego Simeone in the Last 16 clash with Argentina saw him sent off. England lost on penalties and Beckham became the scapegoat for all of England's failures.
Few at the time considered that England would have had to beat the Netherlands and Brazil to advance into the final. Nor the fact that a victory over Argentina was far from a forgone conclusion. Yet, the media and fans latched onto the idea that this was down to Beckham's immature act. History proved that his career would not be defined by this moment but galvanized by it instead.
That being said, Beckham's career could have been very different. He could have become an even bigger superstar if the media chose to build his idol status. The impact of this would mean that he either would have been too big to lose for Manchester United, or that the move to Madrid came earlier.
Another take on this is that Beckham would not have evolved into the great player he was. Without the adversity, would he have had the determination to prove everyone wrong? Would he have been able to build the mental strength to take him to the heights he'd eventually reach? Perhaps not.
2. France Vs. West Germany, Spain 1982
Harald Schumacher committed the worst foul in World Cup history when he knocked Patrick Battiston out cold in their semi-final encounter at Spain '82. Had Schumacher been fairly punished, a red card would have followed.
With a free kick and a numerical advantage, the safe money would have been on France to advance and play a dream final against Italy. After eventually winning the European Championship in 1984, France surely had what it took to beat the Italians.
Not only were we robbed of a potential classic final, we also never saw French football hit its real peak. The Euro '84 title felt a bit like being the 1st runner up. It didn't take the sting away from the loss to Germany.
A World Cup victory would have invigorated French football to a higher level and instilled a winning mentality into a team that failed dismally in the decade proceeding their 1984 Euro victory. Instead, the national team took on an apathetic identity, perhaps best embodied by their failure to qualify for the 1994 World Cup.
On a more positive note, it gave the golden generation of Zidane et al even more motivation to prove themselves and inspire a new generation to succeed them.
1. Baggio's Penalty Shootout Mis, USA 1994
In 1994, Roberto Baggio was not only considered the best player in the world, but already seen as one of the all time greats. Held in the same esteem as Maradona, Cruyff, Beckenbauer and Platini, he was undoubtedly the game's biggest star.
Imagine combining Lionel Messi, Xavi, Andres Iniesta, and Andrea Pirlo. Baggio was all of the above. Tactically more versatile and adept than Messi, a better all-round passer than Xavi, more skilful than Iniesta, and as cool as Pirlo. With this on pitch presence, he captivated fans from all over. He was Serie A's poster boy when the league was the strongest in the world.
Italy's run to the World Cup final was less than impressive. They struggled to get out of the group stages and made hard work of their knockout games. However, Baggio made the tournament his own by bailing Italy out every time. His performances resembled those of Maradona in 1986. The tournament proved once and for all that he had no equal.
The final was one of the tensest encounters in tournament history. After 120 minutes of close calls and near misses, penalties. One of the most iconic moment in football followed. Every fan remembers that miss. If Baggio scored, Italy had the upper hand going forward in the shootout.
Had Italy won, Baggio would not have had to carry the burden of losing the final, one which undoubtedly weighed heavily on his shoulders and affected his career dramatically afterwards. Instead, we would have seen Baggio grow into the biggest star the game had ever seen.