10 Longest Absences From The Premier League

49 teams have graced the top flight during its 29 Year history. Who has been MIA the longest?

coventry city fc
© Kieran McManus/BPI/Corbis

Following the conclusion of the recent Premier League season, the longest in the competition’s history thanks to the pandemic, we’re just a few weeks away from the beginning of the next campaign. It’s come a long way since 1992, when players from outside Britain and Ireland were a rarity and transfer fees in the single digit millions were considered extortionate, but continues to maintain its status as the greatest spectacle in the footballing world.

Forty-nine teams have contested the league since its inception, a total of twenty per year with the exception of the first three campaigns, which boasted twenty-two. Of these, three endure the pain of relegation each year, though with the ever-growing gulf between the Premier League and the Football League, the same teams seem to drop out and quickly return every time.

Not every team has enjoyed this ‘bouncebackability’ (as Iain Dowie once coined it), however, and many have endured years or decades trying and failing to return to their former home. Leeds United were one of these until they ended eighteen years of misery with their Championship victory this year and the following teams have suffered absences on a par with or far greater to theirs.

10. Charlton Athletic - 13 Years

Charlton Athletic's Tony Watt (left) and Huddersfield Town's David Edgar
Daniel Hambury/EMPICS Sport

Had Leeds not finally made their way back to the Premier League for the upcoming season, they would’ve occupied this position. Instead, Charlton take it, having failed to secure another promotion since the end of their last stint in 2007.

At any given point, around a quarter of the league is made up of London-based teams. Arsenal, Chelsea and Spurs have competed in every season and West Ham in most, but Charlton fall into a camp with the likes of QPR, Fulham and Crystal Palace, having fluttered between the top two divisions.

They made their debut after beating the more fancied Sunderland, who have exited the division on no fewer than four occasions, in the 1997/98 playoff final. Favourites for the drop from the off, they only succumbed to their fate after Southampton managed to win all three of their final games to beat them to 17th in the table.

Returning at the first time of asking, Charlton were then firmly established in the division for the next seven years, finishing as high as 7th in 2004 and narrowly missing out on Europe.

Since their most recent relegation, however, the club’s fortunes have plummeted and they have regularly switched between the Championship and League One, being relegated to the latter yet again this season.


9. Ipswich Town - 18 Years

Ipswich Town's Daryl Murphy celebrates after scoring his sides second goal of the game during the Sky Bet Championship match at the City Ground, Nottingham.
Nigel French/PA Wire

Though their rivals Norwich City have been regularly able to return to the Premier League over the course of the last two decades, Ipswich held the record for the most successive seasons spent in the Championship after their relegation from the Premier League in 2002, competing in the division for seventeen years without being promoted or relegated until they finally fell to League One the year before the last.

The relegation of the Tractor Boys was something of a shock given that they had defied all expectations to finish 5th in the 2000-01 campaign, qualifying for the UEFA Cup, which they notably won in 1981, in the process.

Manager Craig Burley had put together a cohesive unit, but they fell victims to ‘second season syndrome’ and were bottom of the table at Christmas with just a single win to their name. A run of form saw them rise to the 12th, before they ultimately finished in 18th.

The perils of administration plagued the club thereafter and a youth academy that had produced a plethora of promising English players seemed to dry up, with Darren Bent the only notable name to buck the trend.

Having finished their inaugural League One campaign in mid-table, Ipswich are now a long way from their glory days, with fans having to take solace in Norwich’s repeated relegations rather than any of their own successes.


8. Bradford City - 19 Years

Bradford City's Stan Collymore scores a spectacular overhead volley on his debut
Nick Potts/EMPICS Sport

The League Cup is seen as a waste of time by many clubs, who field youth and fringe players to avoid fatiguing their regular starters, but Bradford City almost turned it into a Cinderella story in 2013. Having finished in 18th place in League Two the season before, they went all the way to the final of the competition, dumping out Arsenal and Aston Villa before coming up short against Swansea.

It was hard to believe that the Yorkshire club had been in the Premier League just over a decade prior. Bradford earned promotion from Division One in 1999 to return to the top flight for the first time in eighty years, most of which had been spent in Divisions Three and Four.

They found the going tough, narrowly avoiding relegation by virtue of the horrendous seasons endured by the three teams beneath them, before finishing rock bottom by some margin in their second campaign.

Two administrations and two further relegations followed over the course of the next few years and the Bantams have not even played in the Championship since 2004. They are currently plying their trade in League Two, having ended a six-year stint in League One the season before last.


7. Coventry City - 19 Years

Darren Huckerby, Coventry City battles with Robert Elliott, Newcastle United
Tony Marshall/EMPICS Sport

The Midlands has been very poorly represented in the Premier League in recent years, with only Leicester from the East and Aston Villa and Wolves from the West. Gone are the days when the region had almost a third of the league’s members, as the likes of Derby County, Birmingham City and Coventry City become longer running absentees with each passing year.

Coventry had enjoyed a thirty four year spell in the top flight before their relegation in 2001, though they never once finished in the top half of the table during the nine years of that run that followed the Premier League’s creation, only surviving by the tiniest of margins in 1997 when they won their final fixture whilst Sunderland lost to an 85th minute goal.

Their subsequent descent through the divisions hit its lowest point in 2017 when the club were relegated to the fourth tier for only the second season in their entire history, though they quickly recovered and will grace the Championship once more in the upcoming season by virtue of having topped League One when play was suspended.

Though they are now closer to returning than they have been in over a decade, Coventry’s problems are far from over. They currently lack a stadium and their financial situation remains somewhat perilous.


6. Sheffield Wednesday - 20 Years

David Hirst, Sheffield Wednesday
Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

Sheffield United defied all expectations to finish in the top half of the Premier League table this season, having occupied a European berth before dropping off after the resumption of play following lockdown. The Blades have had three spells in the top flight, but spent a long time in the shadow of their cross-city rivals, who were perennial midtable finishers throughout the 1990s before they plunged into the-then Division One at the end of the 1999/2000 season.

The Owls have never been back since, despite having reached the playoffs twice in 2016 and 2017 whilst United were still a division behind them in League One. Aside from those two years they have been closer to the bottom of the table than the top on every occasion since their own return to the Championship from League One.

Wednesday can still arguably cling to the claim of being the more successful Sheffield club given their solitary League Cup win in 1991. The two have seven FA Cups between them, but the most recent of those was in 1934.

There has been little to celebrate in the city from a footballing perspective in a long time. Hopes of a United run in Europe were dashed by their poor post-restart form and Wednesday are one of the bookies' favourites for the drop back to League One this year.


5. Wimbledon - 20 Years

Wimbledon captain Vinnie Jones looks over Aston Villa's injured Andy Townsend
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Wimbledon were a mainstay of English football during the late '80s and early '90s. Christened the ‘Crazy Gang’, their style was widely derided as basic and overtly physical, though it saw them achieve three promotions and an FA Cup win in six years. They started the Premier League era as one of the division’s stronger sides, finishing 6th in 1994, but rapidly dropped down as they struggled to replace their ageing side, and were relegated in 2000.

Wimbledon disappeared entirely shortly after their relegation, as the club was relocated to the town of Milton Keynes and renamed the MK Dons. Though commonplace in American sports, the relocation of teams is considered sacrilege within English football and a phoenix club, AFC Wimbledon, were formed to assume the club’s legacy.

Beginning life in non-league football, they rose up the ranks to reach the Football League in 2011, earning promotion from League Two to League One in 2016 and remaining there since, squaring off against the team that once bore their identity in three of their last four campaigns.

Having never finished above 15th, narrowly avoiding relegation in the two most recent seasons, the chances of AFC Wimbledon returning to the Football League’s lowest level are far superior to them making the step up to the Championship and being within touching distance of the Premier League once more.


4. Nottingham Forest - 21 Years

Jamaal Lascelles, Nottingham Forest
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Nottingham Forest are one of the most successful teams in English footballing history thanks to their two European Cup successes under the legendary Brian Clough. One of just five teams from the country to lift the trophy, they hold the bizarre record of having won more European championships than domestic ones (having been league champions just once).

Forest were a shadow of their former selves by the time the Premier League formed, however, finishing bottom of the league in its inaugural campaign. Clough left the club after eighteen years in charge and they returned to the top flight at the first time of asking, but lasted just three more seasons before finishing last once again.

Another instant return followed, but this resulted in yet another last-placed finish in the final season of the twentieth century. This time there was no comeback.

Forest have now spent almost two decades in the Championship, a run interrupted only by three seasons in League One in the mid-2000s. Since being near-bankrupted by the reviled David Platt and his infamous ‘trio of Italians’, the club have been through a painful twenty-seven managers and fallen in the playoffs in four separate occasions, missing out on them this year after a dreadful run of form took them from being automatic promotion contenders to 7th.


3. Barnsley - 22 Years

Barnsley's Mason Holgate (left) and Coventry City's Nick Proschwitz battle for the ball.
Nigel French/EMPICS Sport

Situated between the major metropolitan centres of Leeds and Sheffield, there’s not a great deal that can be said about the town of Barnsley. Their football team had never played in the top flight in their history when they achieved an unlikely promotion to the Premier League in 1997.

The 1997/98 season is memorable only for the fact that Arsene Wenger’s Arsenal won the league for the first time, shutting out Manchester United after a prolonged period of dominance for Sir Alex Ferguson’s men. Barnsley compounded their misery by dumping them out of the FA Cup, ensuring that they went trophyless for just the second time in the entire decade.

Bar this cup run, which took them to the quarter finals, Barnsley had a torrid time and were ultimately relegated alongside Bolton and Crystal Palace, the only time in the league’s history that all three promoted teams have then been relegated at the first time of asking.

Though their relegated companions would eventually bounce back, Barnsley have yet to do so after twenty-two years. They are just one of three clubs to have only spent a single season in the Premier League in total. Having yo-yoed between the Championship and League One in recent years, don’t expect them to change that anytime soon.


2. Oldham Athletic - 26 Years

OLDHAM PLAYERS CELEBRATE AS THEY STAY IN PREMIER LEAGUE OLDHAM ATHLETIC V SOUTHAMPTON
Paul Marriott/EMPICS Sport

After London, Greater Manchester has the largest concentration of professional football teams in the country, though only Bolton Wanderers and Wigan Athletic have regularly shared a division with the peerless Manchester United and their once-mocked but now enriched ‘noisy neighbours’ Manchester City. The likes of Bury (RIP), Rochdale and Oldham Athletic have always been mainstays of the lower divisions, though that wasn’t always the case for the latter.

Oldham were promoted to the old Division One a year before it became the Premier League, almost seventy years after their only previous stint in the top flight. After narrowly avoiding the drop in the first campaign, beating Crystal Palace by virtue of their -11 goal difference to the Eagles’ -13, they fell after the second, failing to win any of their final eight games as they finished 19th.

After dropping to the third tier just three years later, Oldham remained in the same division for twenty-one years, reaching the playoffs on two occasions but otherwise consistently finishing midtable. They dropped to League Two in 2018 and seem destined to stay there given how they have hovered just above the drop zone so far during their two-year tenure.


1. Swindon Town - 26 Years

Manchester United's Eric Cantona tangles with Swindon Town's John Moncur in an incident that led to Cantona's sending off
Andy Heading/EMPICS Sport

The answer that’s almost guaranteed to score zero whenever a Premier League question comes up on Pointless, Swindon, like Barnsley, had never spent a single season in the top flight before they earned promotion to the Premier League for its second campaign.

They were woefully unprepared. With results including 5-0 losses to Liverpool, Arsenal, Leeds and Aston Villa and a 7-1 mauling at the hands of Newcastle, they quickly returned to the second tier, winning just five games in total and ending up ten points below their nearest rivals, though they did hold champions Manchester United to a 2-2 draw at home.

The most notable element of Swindon’s diabolical season was that they conceded 100 goals in total. This unwanted honour has yet to be matched to this day, though the official record is now held by Derby County’s conceding of 89 goals in 2007/08 given that it occurred in a 38-game season in contrast to Swindon’s 42.

The fact that the Robins were punching well above their weight is evidenced by their subsequent fortunes. They haven’t played in the second tier since 2000, having become mainstays of League One.

They did once boast a player called Danny Invincible, however, so maybe they should get some props for that at least…


Contributor
Contributor

Alex was about to write a short biography, but he got distracted by something shiny instead.