10 Players Who Probably Regret Leaving Aston Villa
Leaving Villa Park doesn't always lead to positive things...
If you were expecting a blank list, then think again.
As hard as it might be to believe, there are actually some players out there who wish that they had not left Aston Villa - even as soon as last summer.
There are no prizes for guessing who that particular player is but regardless of whether Villa have been competing for European places at the top of the Premier League table or fighting to avoid relegation from the top flight, there are examples of when members of the first-team squad should have stayed put rather than believing that they could achieve bigger and better things elsewhere.
We'll admit that it took some extensive research in order to compile a list of 10 players worthy of featuring on this list but even Villa themselves must wonder what could have been had they been able to tempt some of these players into committing to playing in Birmingham for a longer period of time.
10. Gordon Cowans
Gordon Cowans is considered to be one of the greatest players to wear the claret and blue shirt but his time at Aston Villa would come over three separate spells.
It's an impressive feat to be held in such high regard after spending three periods of your career at the same club but it also demonstrated that the midfielder was always longing to represent Villa whenever he was given the opportunity.
In a distinguished first spell in the West Midlands, he won the First Division title and a European Cup before spending three years at Bari.
It had been written into his contract that Villa had first option on Cowans should he ever leave the Italian club and both parties agreed to the move as soon as he became available.
Ron Atkinson would eventually sell him to Blackburn Rovers but it wouldn't be long before he returned to Villa once again for another season.
There's no doubt that Cowans would have taken plenty from the experience of playing in another country but his heart was always at Villa and a part of him must wonder if he would have achieved more at the club had he remained in Birmingham.
9. Stewart Downing
Stewart Downing ended his long-term association with Middlesbrough with doubts over whether he could perform at another club after playing all of his career in the North-East but he soon showed at Aston Villa that he had the quality to perform on both the Premier League and international scene.
However, a successful two years in the West Midlands resulted in interest from Liverpool and given their status as one of the biggest clubs in the world, Downing perhaps felt obligated to accept a move to Anfield.
He had earned the Aston Villa Player of the Year award for the previous season but he never came close to making a similar impression for Liverpool as he ended his first campaign at the club without contributing a single goal or assist in the league, although he did score the winning goal in the FA Cup quarter-final with Stoke City.
The left-sided player improved slightly during his second year in the North-West but five goals in 45 appearances was not enough to tempt Liverpool to keep him and he was sold to West Ham United for a quarter of the £20m they were said to have paid in 2011.
Downing has played an influential role in Middlesbrough's promotion challenge this season but since leaving Villa, he has barely featured for England.
8. Carlos Cuellar
Carlos Cuellar has enjoyed a strong relationship with the supporters of many of the clubs that he has represented and it was no different at Aston Villa.
After making 120 appearances in four seasons in the West Midlands, he announced that he would leave the club at the end of his contract and he described his final home fixture as "one of the saddest days".
Unfortunately for the Spaniard, it would become even sadder after failing to make a sustained impact at his new club Sunderland, who at the time were managed by former Villa boss Martin O'Neill. He featured 26 times during his first season but he was restricted to just four Premier League games in 2013-14.
He played his part in a North-East derby success over Newcastle United but his final two matches would see him put through his own net in a 1-0 defeat to Hull City and be hauled off during a 5-1 thrashing from Tottenham Hotspur.
After being released by the Black Cats, he would drop down to the Championship with Norwich City but 10 appearances later meant he would end his time in Great Britain and return to his homeland.
7. Ronny Johnsen
Ronny Johnsen is known for playing his part in Manchester United's success between 1996 and 2002 but he also had two years at the heart of the defence at Aston Villa.
The West Midlands outfit only lost one of the last 11 Premier League fixtures that Johnsen featured in during the back end of the 2003-04 campaign but the veteran was tempted into a transfer to Newcastle United.
At the age of 35, Johnsen was making what he had hoped would be the last move of his career but his time at St James' Park was disappointing to say the least.
He started just five games in all competitions - with his debut for the club not coming until the end of October - and after spending two months out of the team due to fitness issues, he announced his retirement from the sport.
Johnsen would eventually change his mind and end his career in his homeland with Valerenga but he must wonder if he could have continued at the top level had he remained at Villa.
Villa had finished in sixth position with Johnsen at the back but his departure partly led to David O'Leary's men ending the following season in 10th spot.
6. Julian Joachim
Julian Joachim ended the 2000-01 campaign out of the Aston Villa starting lineup but he still seemed to be a part of John Gregory's plans having scored eight goals in 25 games in all competitions.
However, the attacker was used as bait to tempt First Division side Coventry City into selling Mustapha Hadji to Villa and the move did not pay off for Joachim.
He scored just one goal in 18 games in all competitions in his first season and two in 11 in his second. He seemed a million miles away from playing his part in a squad competing in the top 10 of the Premier League table and to make matters worse, Hadji had been a flop at Villa Park.
His final six months at the Sky Blues were filled with goals but there was little chance of Joachim remaining with the club and he signed for recently-relegated Leeds United on a free transfer.
From the moment he left Villa, his career fizzled out. It seemed as though he was pushed out of the club rather than leaving of his own accord but as soon as he departed the top level, he never returned.
5. Gary Charles
Gary Charles had endured severe injury problems during his time at Aston Villa but playing regularly in the 1998-99 campaign had attracted interest from abroad and he would move to Benfica in January.
No-one can be judged for switching Birmingham for Portugal but it had nothing but a detrimental effect on Charles's career. It could be argued that he may have only continued to suffer fitness issues had he remained at Villa Park but after suffering another injury less than a week after his transfer, he probably wished he had.
During the second half of that same season, the defender made just four appearances for the European giants although he did manage to score a rare goal. He would have hoped for a second chance the following year but we spent the entire summer on the sidelines and would find himself on the transfer list.
Less than 10 months after his departure, he returned to England with West Ham United but he barely played during his three years at Upton Park and would eventually retire at the age of 32.
4. Dalian Atkinson
Dalian Atkinson had already tasted life on the continent with Real Sociedad so when he began to enjoy success with Aston Villa, it seemed likely that he would remain at the club for the long term.
His partnership with Dean Saunders had been a fruitful one but Saunders was sold to Galatasaray in July 1995 and a month later, Atkinson would follow suit and join Fenerbahce.
Atkinson impressed during the early stages of his time in Istanbul but he failed to fully adapt to life in the country and he would eventually be loaned out to FC Metz in France.
Despite being just 28, Atkinson's professional career began to run down from this moment and he never replicated the impact that he had previously made at Villa.
After ending the 1996-97 season on loan at Manchester City in Division One, he would move to Saudi Arabia and never play another game in English football before retiring at the age of 33. After playing regularly in La Liga and holding down a first-team place at Villa, it was a sorry end to what had been a promising career.
3. Christian Benteke
Everyone apart from Liverpool seemed a winner when the Merseyside giants paid Aston Villa over £30m for striker Christian Benteke and it has taken less than a season for that theory to come true
In all fairness to the Belgian international, he has made more appearances from the bench than he has from the starting lineup but a return of eight goals in all competitions does not come close to justifying his transfer fee.
Reds boss Jurgen Klopp was patient with him when he replaced Brendan Rodgers but there does not appear a way back for Benteke after scoring no goals from open play in 2016 and falling behind both Daniel Sturridge and Divock Origi in the pecking order.
The million dollar question is what happens next? If he does not feature in Liverpool's plans, then he will want to find another club but what club will be prepared to shell out the desired transfer fee and wages? Liverpool could loan him out but only if they can get Mario Balotelli off the books. Sending both away on a temporary basis would see a lot of money wasted.
Villa would have probably still gone down even with Benteke but he would have far more options available to him had he remained in the West Midlands.
2. Tony Daley
Tony Daley spent the first nine years of his career representing his hometown club Aston Villa and it was a period where he would progress into an England international and make 233 league appearances for the club.
During the 1993-94 campaign though, he spent time on the substitutes' bench and when Wolverhampton Wanderers boss Graham Taylor came calling, he jumped at the chance to move to Molineux to play for a manager who he had enjoyed his best years under at Villa and with England.
However, injury would restrict the winger to just one appearance in his first season and while 23 in his second was an improvement, it still wasn't the playing time that he had been hoping for.
He barely played in his final two seasons at Wolves before being handed a free transfer. Being given the freedom to leave Wolves may have come as some relief to Daley and he was able to help Watford to promotion to the top flight but he never recovered from leaving Villa at the age of 27 - a time when he was supposed to hit his peak years.
1. Mark Bosnich
Injury had restricted Mark Bosnich to only 17 appearances at Aston Villa during the 1998-99 season but he was still offered the opportunity to replace Peter Schmeichel at Manchester United.
It was an offer that the Australian stopper could not refuse but after the switch failed to pay off and he was later criticised by Sir Alex Ferguson for his professionalism at Old Trafford, he surely wishes he had stayed at Villa.
All went well from for Bosnich during his first season back at the club where he began his professional career as he made 35 appearances in all competitions and won both the Premier League and Intercontinental Cup.
However, that would represent his final season at the top level despite being aged just 28. He would be replaced by Fabien Barthez and he would never play for United again.
He would later spend two years at Chelsea but he only made seven appearances at Stamford Bridge before a failed drugs test resulted in his dismissal.
He would end his career back in his homeland.