5 Reasons VAR Is Ruining Football
A scathing account on the murder of the beautiful game…
Behold, you are being watched, every move you make is scrutinised by a group of men in a secluded room far, far away. At their behest, a call is made and your dreams are crushed. Nobody is safe.
A quote from George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four, perhaps? Or maybe a historical account of life in Stalin’s Soviet Union? Whilst one would be forgiven for assuming either of these, this is in fact what modern day football has become under the scandalous surveillance regime that is the ‘Video Assistant Referee’ (VAR).
Today, football may be the most lucrative sport there is, with mediocre players earning in a week what NHS nurses earn in a year. Traditionally however, it finds its roots in working class culture: The simplicity with which two jumpers can become goalposts and the sport’s immunity to any climate are just two things that attest to how simple, adaptable and welcoming the beautiful game really is.
But this hospitality has come under strain, with such mass appeal bringing conflict. Enter the referee: a ‘neutral’ judge? Maybe not, for their controversy has made way for the leviathan of ‘control-room refereeing’. As a result of its severe overuse, it sinks hearts, kills the flow of the game, and pulls the rug out from underneath its exciting unpredictability. Moreover, it’s not even 100% accurate!
Make no mistake, no matter your team, this is not based on a few isolated cases. It is the death of football as we know it.
5. What Do We Need The Ref For Anymore?
Let’s face it, who would want to be a referee? Surely someone who likes football enough to run around the pitch for 90 minutes in their mid-30s would feel frustrated not being able to touch the ball. They suffer verbal, sometimes physical, abuse from players and fans. When having a bad day, they are scapegoated, receiving hate mail and a place on the tabloid back pages, and when they do a good job, they are forgotten. Could you even name a referee?
Despite all this, they are essential. Or were. Today the referee is no longer the master, but the servant, no longer alert, but asleep. Before VAR, a marginal offside call or a slide tackle inside the box would ring alarm bells in the referee’s head as he came quickly to a decision. But there is no need for this level of concentration anymore, for all the ref has to do now when unsure is tune into his earpiece and wait for the decision of his superiors who have the benefit of the replay. They are puppets, their strings pulled by a group of retired referees hidden in a room somewhere probably sipping away at a mojito.
We cannot have our cake and eat it. Referees are becoming a waste of time, money and energy: either we scrap VAR and hand full authority to the ref or the latter’s role will suffer the same fate as shop-workers with the invention of self-checkouts.
In such a scenario, who would be left for the players to harass?
4. It Is Confusing
How simple is football? You can touch the ball with any part of your body except your arms and whichever team puts it into a goal frame more times wins. At a competitive level, it becomes a little more complicated with the offside law etc., but on the whole, the spectator has an easy job following the game, leaving them either happy or unhappy.
But with the rise of VAR, a new state of mind has taken shape: confusion.
Confusion is common in daily life: we experience it both at work and in our private lives. Traditionally, people would watch football knowing we would be safe from this emotion. But not anymore.
As happens week in, week out, a goal is scored, emotions are running high, but then something catches your eye: the referee puts his hand to his ear. What does it mean? Who is he talking to? Will the goal be disallowed? If so, why? Minutes go by and tens of thousands of people in the stadium have no clue what is going on. Finally, the goal is disallowed, but no explanation given. It is left to the commentators to interpret what happened. But what if you’re in the stadium? The fans are left in the dark.
Welcome to the world of over-crowding referees into one room. Although having so many screens at their disposal that they see, literally EVERYTHING, they still like to debate. The long, nerve-wracking confusion this leads to is torture.
Football has become a Christopher Nolan film.
3. It Creates A Paranoia Culture
In some legal systems, there is the concept of a statute of limitations: the idea that you cannot be prosecuted for a crime once a certain period of time has passed. Incidentally, you would think that when the referee makes a decision and play is allowed to continue for several minutes, that the game wouldn’t then be allowed to stop in order to reverse that earlier decision. As football enthusiasts will testify, VAR knows no such boundaries.
It is for this reason that both players and fans can never be sure of anything. If your team scores a last-minute winner, how can you celebrate knowing that at any point in the game, that could be reversed? If a defender on your team makes a life-saving tackle to prevent conceding a goal, how can you be sure that the referee won’t later pull it back for a penalty?
You may think that in the majority of cases, you can be sure that no rules have been broken and therefore be free from any paranoia. But how? We, players/fans, don’t see everything like the VAR officials do. Given this, even if you’re confident, you can never be 100% sure that nothing happened somewhere on the pitch that could dash your hopes at any point in the game.
VAR wasn’t designed to be used in every single decision, but every week, its reach over football becomes ever more terrifying. With such paranoia plaguing our minds, how can we enjoy the game we all love?
2. It Is Slow
When Frank Lampard famously scored against Manuel Neuer in the 2010 World Cup, the world gasped, not for the merit of the goal, but because the goal wasn’t given. Thankfully, the cries of injustice didn’t fall on deaf ears. Along came goal-line technology: a system whereby the referee is notified instantaneously by a sensor if the ball crossed the line. It has since proven flawless (unless you're a Sheff Utd fan...).
Unfortunately, VAR hasn’t turned out this way. If you received a dollar for every minute in every game that has been wasted waiting around for the referee to come to a decision, deliberating as he watches the replay in slow motion countless times, you’d be richer than Jeff Bezos. This sluggishness completely kills the flow of the game.
Indeed, VAR is not a correction, but a long pause and a rewind, done for tedious things like a few millimetres worth of an offside call. Imagine having it in your life - it would be like restarting your day if you’d added too much milk to your morning coffee! You could never just get on with your life. Football is becoming Groundhog Day, doomed to never move on if it does not play ‘perfectly’ by the rules. But football isn’t supposed to be perfect - it is a Messi sport (ahem), and this unpredictability is what makes it so exciting.
The sooner we realise all this and fall in love with spontaneity again, the sooner we will break the spell and wake up from this nightmare.
1. It Is Cruel
What’s worse than denying a person something they desperately want? Giving it to them, then snatching it away. As a result of all the flaws discussed in this article, it has become apparent that VAR is more than just a dawdling, authoritarian, mystifying machine: it is also fundamentally evil.
Football is a very emotional game; players give their blood, sweat, and tears and fans follow them to the ends of the earth. Indeed, there is no greater pain than reaching a tournament final and watching the game slip through your fingers. Or is there? Loss is hard to accept, but infinitely harder if you know what victory tastes like…
It’s the greatest feeling on earth: that 30-second seventh-heaven of scoring a last-minute winner. In that moment, nothing else matters. But then, an O’Henry twist: the referee draws a rectangle in the air… your euphoria is blown to smithereens. It’s one thing to lose a match, but this is pure cruelty. It’ll take months to get over this. From the amount of times we have seen this happen over the last few years, it’s almost as if VAR gets off on sending tens of thousands of people into depression.
My friends, it doesn’t matter what team you support. The abolition of VAR will take back control of our beautiful game from the bureaucrats who have stolen it from us, players and fans. Let them tremble at this. We have nothing to lose but our discontentment, and an entire sport to win.
Football aficionados of all teams, UNITE!