8 Muhammad Ali Opponents Who Suffered Tragic Fates

Fame can be fleeting and tragedy can strike at any moment.

FILE - In this Aug. 29, 1974, file photo, boxer Muhammad Ali makes a face during a press luncheon in New York, to promote the sale of tickets to Madison Square Garden where the battle against George Foreman in Zaire will be shown in October on closed circ
Ron Frehm/AP

In a sport full of icons, no name looms larger than that of Louisville, Kentucky native Muhammad Ali.

Ali’s accomplishments in the boxing ring, combined with his political activism, made him both a popular and controversial figure during his lifetime.

Moreover, his wins over boxing legends like George Foreman, Sonny Liston, and his bitter rival Joe Frazier are why he is considered to be among the greatest boxers of all-time.

While Ali went on to become a sporting icon; many of the men he shared the ring with were not so fortunate. In fact, a number of Ali’s opponent would go on to suffer terrible hardships during, as well as after their boxing careers had ended.

It may be difficult to imagine, but men who competed against one of the most famous athletes ever went on to perish in relative obscurity or even disappeared altogether.

These pugilists suffered some of the most horrible fates that any professional athlete has ever had to endure.

The following tales serve as a reminder that fame can be fleeting and tragedy can strike at any moment.

8. Cleveland Willams

Muhammad Ali Cleveland Williams
Flickr - Brett Jordan

Cleveland “Big Cat” Williams was a 6-foot-3 power puncher who was thought to be a future heavyweight title holder during his prime in the 1950s. The former champion Sonny Liston claimed that Williams was the hardest puncher he had ever been in the ring with.

Tragedy struck Williams even before his bout with Ali, when he was shot by a police officer after being pulled over for speeding in 1964. The officer claimed that he was resisting arrest. Following the incident, Williams underwent numerous operations to repair both his colon and right kidney; nearly dying on the operating table on more than one occasion.

The heavyweight contender was able to make a full recovery and returned to boxing in February of 1966. He was even able to win 4 consecutive fights and earn himself a shot at Muhammad Ali’s World Heavyweight Championship.

The bout between Muhammad Ali and Cleveland Williams took place on November 14, 1966, at the Houston Astrodome. Ali thoroughly dominated the fight knocking Williams down 4 times, before ultimately winning the contest via TKO early in the 3rd round.

The cash-strapped “Big Cat” would go on to box for another 6 years; though he never fought for the world title again. When he arrived in Denver, Colorado for his final bout in October of 1972, he was carrying his gear in a cardboard suitcase which was held together by an electrical cord.

In the years following his retirement, Williams struggled with kidney issues which resulted in regular hospital visited. Following one of his visits, he was involved in a hit and run accident while crossing the street in 1999. Sadly, the injuries he suffered from the impact proved to be fatal.

Cleveland Williams was 66 years of age when he tragically perished.


7. Zora Folley

Zora Folley was a veteran of the Korean War who learned to box during his time in the United States Army. He was a heavyweight contender who held victories over division standouts such as George Chuvalo and Oscar Bonavena.

Folley had a reputation as being quite the gentlemen. In fact, even Ali himself was quoted as saying, “That Folley’s such a nice, sweet old man, eight little kids, calls me Muhammad Ali, thanks me all the time for giving him a chance. How’m I ever gonna get mad at him and build up this fight?”

Folley challenged Ali for his title back in March of 1967 at Madison Square Garden. The 34-year-old landed some nice shots during the contest but was ultimately knocked out by the champ in the 7th round. The army vet continued to fight for 3 more years before retiring in 1970.

In 1972 the former contender was found dead in a hotel swimming pool. The death was ruled accidental; as Foley was said to be horsing around with a friend near the pool and ended up hitting his head and drowning.

However, the motel clerk indicated multiple wounds were found on Folley’s head, including a bump on his forehead, a hole on the top of his head, as well as wound on the back of his head. The injuries seemed excessive given the nature of the incident.

Years after his death, several theories arose regarding the cause of his demise. There were reports that suspicious men were seen around the hotel the day of the incident and there have also been suggestions that his death was mob related.

Folley was just 41 years of age when he met his untimely end.


6. Oscar Bonavena

Argentinian heavyweight Oscar ‘Ringo’ Bonavena was known as a wild-swinging puncher who earned his nickname by having a haircut similar to that of The Beatle’s drummer Ringo Star. Prior to competing against Muhammad Ali, Bonavena had been involved in 2 competitive bouts with Joe Frazier, both of which Frazier ultimately won via decision.

The Argentinian, who had a reputation for being outspoken, referred to Ali as a black kangaroo and a chicken in the build-up to the fight. The comments were in reference to the America’s refusal to fight in the Vietnam War. However, the remarks were apparently unable to throw the champ off his game as Ali was able to win the competitive bout via TKO in the 15th round. Ali took the opportunity after the fight to set the stage for his legendary bout with Joe Frazier by proclaiming, “I have done what Joe Frazier couldn't do--knocked out Oscar Bonavena. Now, where is he? I want Joe Frazier.”

Bonavena fought on for over 5 years after the bout but was never able to earn another shot at the gold.

Outside the ring, Oscar Bonavena had a reputation as a hard partier and womanizer, the latter of which ultimately led to his demise.

In 1975, Bonavena began having an affair with the wife of Mustang Ranch brothel owner Joe Conforte. The affair combined with the fact that Bonavena had bragged about his intent to take over the ranch, lead to Conforte banning his wife and the boxer from the famed brothel. Moreover, Conforte even ordered his guards to shoot the heavyweight pugilist if he showed up.

On May 22, 1976, Bonavena arrived at the ranch demanding to speak with Conforte and was shot through the heart with a .38 revolver by one of his security guards. Bonavena was just 33-years-old at the time of his death.


5. Buster Mathis

Buster Mathis was an American heavyweight who won his first 23 fights after turning pro in 1965, before ultimately losing his first bout to Joe Frazier. He was a large man even by heavyweight standards whose weight fluctuated a great deal during the course of his career.

Mathis had left professional boxing after a loss to Jerry Quarry in 1969. However, the big man was coaxed out of retirement by being offered a shot at Ali and the World Heavyweight Championship.

He returned after a 2 ½ year absence and was thoroughly dominated by Ali. The champ sent Mathis to the canvas 4 times on his way to a unanimous decision victory.

Buster Mathis fought a couple more time before retiring for good in 1972, following a KO loss to heavyweight standout Ron Lyle.

He continued to struggle with weight even after his career had ended and developed numerous health problems including high blood pressure and diabetes.

Mathis ended up weighing as much as 550 pounds, which resulted in the former contender suffering a fatal heart attack at just 51 years of age.


4. Rudie Lubbers

Rudie Lubbers was a 2-time Olympian who hailed from the Netherlands. His biggest accomplishment as a professional was winning the Dutch heavyweight title in 1971.

Lubbers had a 21-1 record prior to his bout with Ali, though he hadn’t exactly faced the stiffest competition. As a result, Muhammad Ali entered the bout as a 4 to 1 betting favorite. Lubbers was able to go the distance, but the match ended up being a one sided decision victory for Ali.

The Dutchman would go on to lose 6 of his next 13 bouts, before calling it quits in 1981.

Following his retirement, Lubbers severed nearly 4 years in prison for smuggling drugs in Portugal. After he had served his time, the former Dutch champ worked as a carny.

By 2009 Rudie Lubber had gone from fighting the most famous boxer in the world to being bankrupt and living in a shoddy caravan with 20 dogs.


3. Trever Berbick

Jamaican boxer Trevor Berbick was a former WBC heavyweight title holder who had an excellent career in his own right. Besides being remembered as Muhammad Ali’s last opponent, Berbick was also the man who lost the heavyweight strap to a young up and coming 20-year-old by the name of Mike Tyson.

The showdown between Berbick and Ali took place in 1981. Prior to the fight, doctors claimed that Ali had already suffered brain damage from absorbing too many blows over the course of his career. Trevor Berbick defeated the aging former champ via decision in what would be Muhammad Ali’s final professional fight.

Berbick would continue to fight for nearly two more decades before finally hanging up his gloves in May of 2000.

In 2006 the former champ was involved in a land dispute with his nephew, Harold Berbick. Harold Berbick (and a man named Kenton Gordon) followed his uncle home from a party on October 28, 2006, and viciously murdered him with a steel pipe. Trevor Berbick’s body was found in a courtyard in Portland, Jamaica; he was just 52-years-old at the time of his death.


2. Jim Robinson

Muhammad Ali File Photo
PA/PA Wire

Jim Robinson had an unspectacular 8-25 record as a professional fighter. In truth, if he hadn’t stepped in as a last minute replacement to face a young prospect named Cassius Clay (who would eventually come to be known as Muhammad Ali), his career would have likely been forgotten.

When Ali faced Robinson in Miami, Florida back in 1961, it was only his 4th professional fight. Ali made short work of Jim Robinson knocking him out early in the very 1st round of the contest.

Robinson continued to fight until 1968; losing most of the bouts he was involved in.

In a 1979 Sports Illustrated interview Robinson (who was a military veteran) stated that he was receiving veterans’ benefits and spending most of his time at a local Miami pool hall. The interview would turn out to be the last time Robinson has been seen or heard from publicly.

Years later a Muhammad Ali memorabilia collector named Stephen Singer set out to obtain the autograph of every opponent Ali had ever faced. After about 18 months singer was able to collect every signature with the lone exception of Jimmy Robinsons. Robinson was nowhere to be found; even a private investigator was unable to locate the journeymen boxer.

ESPN reporter Wright Thompson launched his own investigation in order to find Robinson’s whereabouts but was also unsuccessful.

Ultimately, the fate of Muhammad Ali’s 4th professional opponent remains a mystery.

Singer summarized Robinson’s sad tale rather nicely, "He was like hundreds of fighters who look to boxing for the American dream, and when they fall there's no net to catch them. There are lots of Jimmy Robinsons."


1. Sonny Liston

Ali Sonny Liston
wiki

Sand Slough, Arkansas native Sonny Liston was a former world champion who is often listed among the greatest heavyweight fighters of all time. The heavy handed pugilist’s greatest achievement came in September of 1962 when he knocked out the legendary Floyd Paterson in the 1st round of their bout and became the undisputed champ.

Liston faced Ali on two separate occasions in 1962 and 63 respectively. Muhammad Ali won the first contest when Liston quit on his stool before the start of the 7th round. Ali also won the 2nd bout via 1st round KO, though many believe the second fight was fixed.

Following his controversial 2nd loss, Liston continued to fight and won 15 of his next 16 bouts. His next opponent was supposed to be Canadian champ George Chuvalo. In fact, Chuvalo had even signed the contract before he received some unsettling news. The Canadian recalled; “A day or so later a news report flashes up saying former heavyweight champion of the world Sonny Liston found dead at his Las Vegas home. I’d actually signed a contract to face a dead man.”

Sonny Liston died of what had been officially ruled a heroin overdose on December 30, 1970. However, many friends and family members publicly stated that the former champion was deathly afraid of needles.

For years after the incident, several conspiracy theories have surfaced regarding Liston’s death.

Boxing promoter Harold Conrad suggested that Liston was killed by a Vegas loan shark which he had become involved with.

One of the most popular theory’s among boxing insiders was that the mob hadn’t paid him for taking a dive in the 2nd Ali fight and Liston threatened to go public with the information and was killed as a result.

The circumstances surrounding Sonny Liston’s death remains one of boxing’s great mysteries.


In this post: 
Muhammad Ali
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

From 1999-2003 Jacques performed on the Florida independent pro wrestling circuit. He also has an amateur wrestling background and currently holds a certification in Krav Maga. Jacques graduated from the University of Central Florida in 2003, with a bachelor's degree in Political Science. He currently resides in Chicago, Illinois. Follow him on twitter @goodeals79.