Next England Manager: 10 Best Candidates To Replace Sam Allardyce
Big Sam is gone, but who will fill his shoes?
Sam Allardyce’s reign as England manager has ended after 67 days in charge. Appointed in June, Big Sam’s custodianship lasted just a single game (a drab 1-0 victory over Slovakia) earlier this month, and he leaves under a black cloud of controversy.
Implicated in a scandal alleging he had offered advice on how to circumvent the Football Association’s rules on player transfers, Allardyce’s reputation took a big hit this week. The 61-year-old is purported to have used his position to negotiate a £400,000 deal to represent a Far East firm, and while Allardyce officially departs by “mutual agreement,” there’s a strong chance the FA decided to cut their losses.
Allardyce inherited the job after Roy Hodgson’s disastrous Euro 2016 campaign, and the FA now find themselves hunting for a new manager for the second time in as many months. Gareth Southgate will take temporary charge, and with the likes of Glenn Hoddle and Alan Pardew among the bookies’ favourites, the FA aren’t exactly spoiled for choice.
Who will they entrust with leading the Three Lions through the 2018 World Cup qualification campaign? English managers will be heavily-favoured, of course, but quality homegrown options are thin on the ground, and while English fans are wary of overseas appointments, the FA may be forced to look outwith their own shores.
Excluding all unrealistic candidates, here are the 10 best candidates to be England’s next manager.
10. Alan Pardew
Alan Pardew as England manager is a hard sell. He broke countless negative records during his near-catastrophic tenureship at Newcastle United, and while Pardew’s backers still point towards his 5th-place Premier League finish in 2011-12, the years that followed were nothing short of grim. Pardew’s move to Crystal Palace was met with widespread jubilation, and it’s worked well for both parties.
For all his flaws, Pardew retains a great deal of media support. Even when his Palace side have struggled for results, Pardew has rarely faced any kind of backlash from the press, and his teflon-like ability to deflect all blame would serve him well in football’s most scrutinised managerial position. He was among the favourites last time around, and he’s among the favourites again. Like it or not, Alan Pardew is well and truly in the running.
Though he seems comfortable in his role at Selhurst Park, Pardew has expressed his desire to one day work within the national set-up, claiming he has “strong opinions” on the English team. Perhaps he’d benefit from a national job, which he’ll find a lot less hands-on, particularly when dealing with the minutiae of organising a football team.
9. Guus Hiddink
Although there’s a widespread opinion among fans that only an Englishman can truly understand and appreciate the ins and outs of England’s national team, the FA could do a lot worse than approach Guus Hiddink.
Strongly linked with the job before Allardyce was appointed, Hiddink has been out of work since concluding his second interim spell as Chelsea coach last season. He brings a great deal of managerial experience at both club and international level, and after successful spells with South Korea, Russia, and his native Netherlands, Hiddink is more than qualified to lead the Three Lions.
There are a few things working against him though. First, Hiddink has been a top-level football manager for close to 30 years, and he’ll turn 70 this November. His time in the game is fast approaching its end, so he’d be a short-term appointment at best, and it’s questionable that he’d want to deal with the level of stress associated with the England job at this stage in his life.
Secondly, Hiddink’s last spell with the Netherlands didn’t go too well. He was relieved of his duties in June 2015 after winning just 4 of his 10 games in-charge, and the team failed to qualify for Euro 2016 as a result. Still, if England are looking for a stopgap, there are far worse options on the market.
8. Steve Bruce
There’s still something weird about Steve Bruce’s departure from Hull City. The Geordie left the Tigers a few weeks after achieving Premier League promotion, and claimed that he was making the decision “for the sake of the club.” Mike Phelan has occupied the role in an interim capacity ever since, and Hull are yet to officially replace Bruce.
The former Manchester United defender’s name is always brought-up when the England job becomes available, but he’s always been employed at the time. This obviously isn’t an issue this time around, and with no Premier League jobs on the immediate horizon, Bruce is a natural contender for the position. He’s cheap, English, immediately available, and has achieved promotion with multiple clubs. That’s what he has going for him.
But Steve Bruce wouldn’t exactly be the most exciting appointment in the world, and he’s never really been able to raise a club’s fortunes beyond mid-table at the highest level. As uninspiring as Allardyce’s appointment was, Bruce’s would be met with widescale apathy, though he’s almost certain to be considered for the role.
7. Sean Dyche
Burnley manager Sean Dyche is a shrewd operator who has achieved great things on a tiny budget with his current club. Under his leadership, have been promoted to the Premier League on two separate occasions (2014 and 2016), and while the club’s 2015 relegation might be seen as a mark against Dyche, they didn’t go down through his incompetence.
Far from it, in fact. Dyche’s Burnley are a feisty, well-organised side whose leader understands the value of leadership, cohesion, and team spirit. The club never spend beyond their means, and their summers are characterised by very little player turnover compared to other sides. This year saw Burnley sign just 4 new players on permanent deals, with Dyche reluctant to break-up the team that brought them to the Premier League in the first place, and all of this works in his favour.
With just one full season of Premier League management under his belt, Dyche is lacking in experience, and the FA may see him as one for the future rather than an immediate option. His Burnley contract is another stumbling block, and with Dyche seemingly happy as Larry at Turf Moor, he might not even take the FA’s phone call. Still, he’s a strong English manager who doesn’t always get the credit he deserves.
6. Laurent Blanc
Laurent Blanc left Paris Saint-Germain this summer after three full seasons in-charge and a jam-packed trophy cabinet. Though much of his success is down to PSG’s wealth of riches, he left Paris with three league titles and five domestic cups to his name, and even though the team didn’t have the Champions League impact they’d have liked, Blanc is statistically one of Europe’s most successful managers.
Prior to PSG, Blanc was France manager from 2010 to 2012, and he’s used to operating under difficult circumstances. The French FA banned all 23 players who were part of France’s squad at the 2010 World Cup, much to Blanc’s dismal, but he was still able to lead them to a Euro 2012 quarter-final, where they lost to eventual winners Spain.
There’s a strong argument for Blanc, and he has some familiarity with English football following a two-year spell with Manchester United at the end of his playing career. Sir Alex Ferguson and, crucially, current FA Vice Chairman David Hill are among his admirers in the English game, meaning that if England are keen on an overseas option, Blanc will likely top the list.
5. Gareth Southgate
Former England defender Gareth Southgate will hold the fort until Big Sam’s full-time successor is announced, though he’ll remain a heavy favourite himself throughout the process. He’s occupied a number of roles within the national team’s hierarchy since 2013, when he was appointed manager of England U21’s, and he spent much of Euro 2016 composing technical reports for Uefa.
Having worked as part of the English national team’s system for three years, no other candidate can match Southgate’s familiarity with the job. The current England squad features a number of players that have previously featured for his U21 and U20 sides, though he’s found mixed success in his role. Southgate’s U21’s failed to make it out their group at the 2015 European Championships, though he did lead them to their first Toulon title since 1994 this summer.
Southgate is very highly thought-of among FA officials, and he’s made no secret of his desire to manage England in the future. Sam’s dismissal may have come just a little too early for him, however, and with his unsuccessful Middlesbrough spell still his only experience of top-level management, he doesn’t have the resumé. Regardless, no other candidate can match Southgate’s time spent in the current setup, making him a more enticing prospect than most of his countrymen.
4. Arsene Wenger
The Premier League’s current longest-reigning manager is our list’s least likely appointment, but it’s not completely outwith the realm of possibility. The FA have reportedly always coveted Arsene Wenger, and the Frenchman’s Arsenal contract is set to expire at the end of the season. It’d likely take an extended caretaker spell from Southgate, as Wenger would find it difficult to balance both Arsenal and England, but it might just fall into his place.
Though his name’s gradually become a punchline for Premier League failure over the past few years, Wenger has been an unqualified success at Arsenal. He deserves to be remember among the league’s greatest ever managers, and for all the criticisms levied at his current Arsenal side, they haven’t finished outside the top four since 1995-96.
That’s a huge achievement, even if they always seem to fall short in their quest for championship glory. Though he’s never managed at international level, Wenger is a master tactician whose Arsenal sides have always played eye-catching football. He’s a strong personality who rarely compromises on his values as a manager, and his sleek, fluid teams couldn’t be further removed from Allardyce’s primitive, hammer-throwing style.
Besides, if the FA appointed Arsene Wenger, all those horrendous memes about his transfer policy would suddenly disappear from your Facebook feed. That’s gotta be worth something, right?
3. Louis Van Gaal
It’s safe to say that Louis Van Gaal doesn’t have the best reputation in English football at the moment. Sacked after a wholly disappointing spell in-charge at Manchester United, LVG was an almighty flop on English shores. His Red Devils side played regularly struggled to impose their will on opposing teams, with the manager preferring a reactive rather than proactive approach, and their matches quickly became drab, joyless affairs early in his tenureship.
That being said, on a tactical level, LVG might be exactly what England need. His playing style at Manchester United wasn’t conducive to winning championships at the highest level, but nobody’s expecting the next England manager to go out and win the 2018 World Cup. Media expectations remain high, but England will be underdogs against sides like Brazil and Spain, and Van Gaal’s tight, unadventurous style could work in their favour in such games.
Van Gaal certainly has the pedigree. He’s managed the Netherland twice, and led them to a third-place finish at the 2014 World Cup. At club level, he has four Dutch Eredivisie titles to go with his two La Ligas and one Bundesliga trophy, and he won the Champions League with Ajax back in 1995. LVG can be criticised for a number of reasons, but his track record isn’t one of them.
A stern, cold, and intimidating personality, Van Gaal isn’t the most likeable or charismatic man in football, but he knows how to get results. His Manchester United spell is a rare blotch on his copybook, and history suggests he’d make a fine appointment.
2. Jurgen Klinsmann
A German as England manager? Surely not.
Frankly, Jurgen Klinsmann is one of the best appointments that England could make at the moment, even if he does hail from the Three Lions’ biggest rivals. There’d be a few droning complaints regarding Klinsmann’s appointmentment for that reason alone, but the FA can’t afford to take such trivial grumblings into account, particularly with the paucity of quality alternatives.
Klinsmann more than fits the bill. The current USMNT manager has a wealth of experience as an international manager, and oversaw Germany’s third-place finish at the 2006 World Cup. He’s immensely popular in his current role with the United States, but has been in that position for over five years now, and may feel like it’s time for a change of scenery.
More importantly, Klinsmann’s time with Germany and Bayern Munich means he has substantial experience working with superstar players. The current England squad isn’t as star-studded as it was ten years ago, but it takes an expert man manager to get the likes of Wayne Rooney and Raheem Sterling on the same page: a task which Klinsmann should be more than capable of performing.
His German side was known for a fluid and exciting playing style, though he’s pragmatic enough to alter his system according to the players at his disposal. While Klinsmann’s England would likely play in a more reserved manner than his German side, the change in tactics would be welcomed after ten years of Steve McClaren, Fabio Capello, and Roy Hodgson.
1. Eddie Howe
English? Check.
Young? Check.
Attack-minded? Check.
A successful underdog? Check.
Eddie Howe fits the bill in almost every category, with only experience working against him. Aged 38, Howe has only been a manager for eight years, with only one of those coming in the Premier League. Still, his underpowered Bournemouth squad survived against the odds last season, and he’s well-established as English football’s hottest managerial prospect.
He’s an early favourite, and rightly so. Howe’s managerial career is still in its infancy, and if he continues along his current development curve, he’ll either elevate Bournemouth to a new level, or he’ll be working for a bigger club before long. He’d be the youngest England manager in history, but there are few credible arguments against his candidacy.
Though he’s clearly happy on the south coast, the right deal would almost certainly lure him away from Bournemouth. The club struggled early in their first Premier League campaign, but Howe stayed true to the players and system that had got him there in the first place, and they played they way out of trouble. Such a strong will puts him in great stead for England’s high-pressure hot-seat, and his football is a joy to behold at times.
Inexperience bedamned. If the FA truly want to make the most of their next appointment, they should be banging Eddie Howe’s door down.