UFC: Anderson Silva - Legacy Or Fallacy?

€œIf ignorant both of your enemy and yourself, you are certain to be in peril.€ €“ Sun Tzu

He€™s considered by every MMA outlet, website, and expert to be the greatest fighter of all time. The numbers are astounding: 33-6-0, 20 Knockouts, 6 Submissions, and 7 Decisions. He went unbeaten for seven years and in that time amassed 14 successful defenses of the UFC Middleweight Title. His counter striking and anticipation is the best anyone has ever seen. His knockouts occur in the blink of an eye, his Jiu-Jitsu is like entering a tangled web, and his movement is like water. He€™s considered the closest thing to Bruce Lee in competition. He€™s a ghost, a ninja, and a soon-to-be legend of the MMA world.

He€™s Anderson €œThe Spider€ Silva and he was coming off the first Knockout loss of his career as he headed into UFC 168.

On July 6th, 2013, I attended the house of a friend-of-a-friend who was ordering UFC 162. My six pack, snacks, and eight dollars allowed me access to a cramped living room of 20-something males who were all big UFC fans. After the pleasantries and introductions, conversation quickly shifted to predictions of Silva€™s main event bout with Chris Weidman. A showering of praise began to echo through the room with statements such as, €œHe€™s so fluid, man, I don€™t think anyone can beat him,€ or €œHe€™s just so fast, no one can touch him,€ and €œHe€™s my favorite. He€™s the reason I started training BJJ downtown.€ From fan to practitioner, Anderson Silva is the pinnacle.

Then I made the comment, €œI don€™t think he€™s that good. At least, not as good as he should be.€

You would have thought I shot a puppy in the middle of the throw rug. The debate quickly became heated. Defeated foes of Silva were named off one at a time, with each fight explained and examined over and over again. An attempt was made to make a point about respect and integrity, but it was all set aside in favor of tallies in the win column and successful title defenses. When I stated, €œHe disrespects the fans and his opponents with the way he acts in the ring,€ I was met with €œIt€™s not his fault he€™s that much better than them.€ The conversation turned into a losing battle, the same losing battle that Anderson Silva would encounter later that evening.

Silva hit the UFC with a bang in 2006. His first contest was an easy KO victory over Ultimate Fighter Season One star Chris Leben. The impressive win launched Silva into a Middleweight Title shot against accomplished champion Rich Franklin, whom Silva made short work with a first round TKO win. The title defenses that followed were nothing short of magnificent. For the next two years, UFC fans would bear witness to no fighter making it past the second round with Anderson Silva: Travis Lutter, Nate Marquardt, Rich Franklin, Dan Henderson, and James Irvin, all fell into the web. Triangle chokes, Rear-naked chokes, Knockouts, and TKOs littered the proverbial scorecard. €œThe Spider€ was amassing a resume to rival any legend of the sport.

Then, something happened. After defeating Patrick Cote at UFC 90 (Silva was awarded victory after Cote couldn€™t continue due to a knee injury), Silva went on to UFC 97 to defend the Middleweight Title against Thales Leites that went to a 5 round decision. Both fights were considered to be lackluster and involved uninspired performances by Silva. The UFC 97 bout especially drew the ire of UFC President Dana White.

€œThe other thing that I didn€™t like,€ said White in the post-fight presser, €œwas once he had Leites on his back and was hitting him, he would just stop and stand up again instead of trying to finish the fight.€

Silva€™s fighting style and antics in Montreal that night exuded disinterest, which was met with a chorus of boos from the crowd at the Bell Centre. White noted as well from a company perspective, €œWe run a fight company and when guys don€™t fight€ It€™s like having any other business and a guy doesn€™t come out and perform at work.€ In a rather unique situation, an athlete on pace to be one of the greatest of all time was, in theory, purposely not living up to expectations.

(Dana White's UFC 97 comments may be found here & here)

Click "next" below for part 2...


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WG_6Z6Zw09Q

In an attempt to remedy situation, Silva was moved up a weight class and put into a match with a less skilled, but larger competitor in Forrest Griffin at UFC 101. Silva would make very short work of Griffin as he bobbed and weaved around punches and KO€™d the Ultimate Fighter Season One winner in embarrassing fashion. Many considered the performance to be an enormous statement on Silva€™s true abilities, as well as a return to form. However, this would not ring true.

Silva had originally been slated to take on UFC legend Vitor Belfort at UFC 112, but instead fought BJJ expert Demian Maia as Belfort suffered an injury during training. The event took place in Abu Dhabi, being the first UFC show to be held in the Middle East. Being a card of great importance, it seemed only fitting that Silva would choose to make a spectacle of himself. Yet again, rather than asserting his dominance over what appeared to be an inferior opponent, Silva instead rode Maia on the ground and taunted him for 25 minutes. The performance garnered Silva not only a decision victory, but another public lashing from Dana White.

At the press conference following UFC 112, Dana White noted, €œI don€™t think I€™ve ever been more embarrassed in the ten years of being in this business, and it€™s the first time I€™ve ever walked out on a main event and given the belt to the guy€™s manager and told him to put it on him.€

White would go on to apologize to the fans for the performances of Silva and Maia. About Silva specifically, White said, €œI think this guy is incredibly talented € If you€™re that talented, be Mike Tyson. Go in and finish it in two minutes.€ The UFC president would later state that the dream match between Silva and Welterweight Champion Georges St. Pierre would not be taking place because Silva didn€™t deserve the fight.

(Dana White's full comments may be found here)

It was a difficult task for fans to make heads or tails of Silva€™s antics. This is an athlete who is clearly a step ahead of his competition, but chooses to express this superiority by refusing to actually display his talents. Imagine Barry Sanders being handed a football and just running in place, then taking a knee. Picture Michael Jordan on the court for a full game, but only dribbling when he got the ball, never passing or shooting. It€™s hard to envision an elite athlete purposely not doing what they are capable of.

Many had theorized it was a motivation issue due to the lack of depth in the division. Whatever the reason was, €œThe Spider€ was acting as if he was above the entirety of MMA. He presented himself in his fights as if he was insulted by his proposed competition. Yet, instead of quickly defeating these opponents to prove his point, he instead toyed with them, and the fans, to make an example of what he felt his stature was. In essence, he was disrespecting the very people that sign his paychecks, while disgracing his own legacy in the process.

The answer may have been that Silva needed heightened competition, but the nature of MMA provides only so much of a talent pool. Could it be the Silva had bought into his own hyper? Perhaps he felt disenfranchised by the nature of the business? Even still, he is paid by the UFC, via profit generated from live attendance, pay-per-view buys, and merchandise. To act as a jester in the octagon, rather than the king of the division, is an insult to those that are competing against him, as well as the fans that view UFC events expecting a hard fought contest.

There had been developing interest in a fight between Silva and St. Pierre ever since both fighters began to emerge as the cream of the crop of their divisions. With both competitors fighting in weight classes that were only 15 pounds apart, it seemed highly likely that a bout between the two could occur to settle the debate of who the best pound-for-pound fighter in the world is. Silva€™s antics, however, forced Dana White to scrap the plans for the fight, given that Silva couldn€™t be trusted to bring his A-game to the contest. The performances of Silva were not only hurting his credibility, but also hurting his worth. €œThe Spider€ would be of no value to any card, for any profit, if he refused to compete to his level.

Click "next" below for part 3...


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_uSOkYzyTzk

The insertion of Chael Sonnen as the next contender for Silva€™s Middleweight Title seemed to provide a spark in Silva€™s game again. The cocky and fearless Sonnen talked a big game heading into UFC 117, and he backed it up. Silva had only lost one round in the UFC to that point (against Dan Henderson in 2008) and was taken to task by Sonnen for four rounds of combat. UFC fans finally saw Silva put in a situation where he was at a disadvantage and have to persevere. There was finally a dent in the armor of the untouchable fighter.

After four rounds of being taken down at will and suffering damage from Sonnen€™s ground and pound attack, Silva was able to lure the Oregon wrestler into a 5th round triangle submission. It was later revealed that Silva was fighting with a rib injury, which may have explained the ease in which Sonnen was able to dominate him. Regardless, UFC 117 became a huge turning point in Silva€™s career. He had finally been met with adversity inside the octagon and was able to prevail when his back was against the wall. At the 11th hour, with numbers against him, he found a way to win. These are the moments that truly great athletes are capable of.

It was after his performance versus Chael Sonnen that Anderson Silva returned to the form that earned him his notoriety at the start of his UFC career. Silva would claim a first round KO victory over UFC veteran Vitor Belfort in his next fight, then go on to dominate Yushin Okami, a rematch with Chael Sonnen, and Ultimate Fighter Season One Finalist Stephan Bonnar, each within two rounds. The arguably best pound-for-pound fighter it the world was back to utilizing his skills to demonstrate his worth as being considered a legend of the sport.

Next in line to challenge the champion would be budding star Chris Weidman.

Weidman was riding an enormous winning streak heading into UFC 162. At an impressive 9-0 and having won five straight UFC Middleweight contests to that point, €œThe All American€ was the most logical challenger to Silva€™s title. A feather in Weidman€™s cap as well was his ability to combine superior wrestling skills with finishing capabilities. Three of his five UFC victories at that time were ended by submission or KO. Furthermore, many MMA analysts and fellow fighters were coming out in droves to predict that Weidman actually would be the man to dethrone Silva. They all cited issues with Silva getting older or discussed Silva€™s struggles with capable amateur wrestlers. Whatever the technical reasoning was, there was a buzz about Weidman heading into the fight that hadn€™t been felt since Silva fought Sonnen at UFC 117.

Back in that living room, we all sat anxiously and watched the entrances for both men. After the announcements by Bruce Buffer the fight was underway. Weidman came out stoic and in concentration, whereas Silva came out loose and half-interested. The first round was as much of a show as it was a personification of Silva€™s UFC career. €œThe Spider€ was tested on takedowns and was caught briefly in a submission, but able to overcome and stand his ground. After a short feeling out process of striking, Silva became comfortable and the antics began. He dropped his hands, made gestures challenging Weidman to come after him, and feigned being hurt by any jabs that Weidman would make contact with.

At the end of the round there was a feeling of affirmation in the room that Silva had the fight in hand yet again. Some of us marveled at his quickness and showboating, others groaned that they just wasted money to watch Silva not actually fight again. Whichever sentiment it was, the feeling was clear that the spider had caught himself another fly.

Click "next" below for part 4...


The start of the second round saw Silva dial up the clown act. He openly mocked Weidman, danced around, and continued to pretend to be bothered by Weidman€™s abilities. Unfortunately for Silva, he was toying with a fighter who wasn€™t the least bit deterred by his showmanship and also carried a heavy hand. After being caught with a left hook, Silva acted like he was rocked and wobbled his knees. Weidman pursued quickly with an erratic combination of punches. Silva bobbed, weaved, ducked, and then €“ BAM. A Weidman left hook caught Silva square on the chin.

Silva€™s eyes rolled back, his legs gave out, and the living room erupted.

There was equal amounts cheering and shock. €œHe€™s not out, he€™s not out. He€™s faking it,€ said the kid who trained BJJ. He couldn€™t believe what he saw, nor could most of the MMA world. It was Silva€™s first defeat in the UFC and the first KO loss of his entire career. In a matter of a few seconds, Anderson Silva€™s dominant UFC run was relegated to a moment of disrespect, where settling for a cheap trick resulted in a forfeit of a sure thing. The king was no longer such, his crown replaced by a Fool€™s hat.

The post-fight interview conducted by Joe Rogan was a surreal moment as well. Silva was met with a chorus of Boos from the live crowd at the MGM Grand as he launched into a pseudo-retirement speech that read more like a cryptic apology than a curtain call. When Rogan asked about the taunting and showboating leading to the knockout Silva replied, €œI work hard for this fight. I respect my fans in UFC, the fans here tonight. I respect USA because my big dream is working. I changed my life and changed the life of my family because I live in the United States.€ Silva went on to thank everyone in the UFC, cited Weidman as the best now for becoming champion, and declined a rematch for the title. Silva stated that he would fulfill the remainder of his UFC contract, but he would not like to compete for a title any longer. It was as if there was a stench in the air. The magnitude of the title change was left in the shadow of this surprising revelation from the former champion. Yet, the moment felt more like a tired man€™s revelation. Silva was as somber as a sad clown. It was like the jig was up.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rj54WsLq-o4

Criticism and speculation poured in following the fight with terms like €œfix€ and €œwork€ being thrown around left and right. Dana White was quick to refute any of these claims at the post-fight press conference by noting, €œThat€™s the stupidest (expletive) thing I€™ve ever heard in my life. That is just stupid.€ White also noted that Silva€™s loss meant that any potential super fight, with either GSP or Jon Jones, were now entirely off the table. There€™s a gamble associated with the way Silva chooses to use his talents and it has affected not only his image, but his wallet as well.

Dana White was then directly asked about the ramifications of the fight on Silva€™s legacy. White presented a sobering response. €œWhat he€™s done is amazing,€ the UFC President continued, €œNobody has ever done what this man has done. Nobody has ever done it the way that he has done it and this doesn€™t do anything to his legacy. ..The stuff that he was doing, if he had done that stuff and won the fight, they€™d be talking about what a genius is. He got clipped, he got caught.€ The line between strategy and disrespect is a rather blurred one.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8zXWq1n3i8

Click "next" below for part 5...


Anderson Silva However, it wasn€™t too long before Silva reneged on his statement that he would not take a rematch with Chris Weidman for the belt. A few short months after his dramatic exit from UFC 162, the announcement was made that Silva would have a rematch with Weidman at UFC 168, taking the co-Main Event slot alongside the Ronda Rousey vs. Meisha Tate fight. It may have been the promise of pay out associated with the rematch, or it could have been that Silva was looking to redeem himself after the events of UFC 162. Either way, his attitude had changed, but his games were still being played.

€œThe Spider€ spent a majority of the post-fight presser at UFC 162 singing the praises of Chris Weidman. He reiterated, ad nauseam, that Weidman was the better fighter and the new champion and that the €œAll American€ should be respected for the victory and his abilities as a fighter. At a UFC 168 presser, which clips of may be found here, Silva was quick to note that Weidman€™s knockout strike was lucky and, when asked if he thought the win itself was lucky, Silva merely chuckled and asked for another question.

There are tendencies of hypocrisy with Silva that border on personality disorder. Much like how Silva decides one fight to the next about whether he will bring his A-game or his C-game, his interactions with fans and media fall into the same kind of game. Silva is a counter-striker in his fighting style, so perhaps that mentality ventures over into his self-promotion as well. Like a blank slate, he lies in wait and only acts in response to what is imposed on him. The rematch with Weidman presented an opportunity to answer all the questions about the previous fight. Was Silva really clowning around with an inferior opponent and paid the price? Or, was Weidman the superior fighter that beat Silva by defeating the game plan?

Unfortunately for fans, UFC 168 left those questions entirely unanswered. Just like the first contest, the battle between Silva and Weidman would only reach the second round. However, in a freak accident that happens from time to time in MMA, Weidman checked a leg kick from Silva that resulted in a gruesome break of the tibia and fibula. Weidman earned a TKO victory, securing a successful title defense, an 11-0 overall record, and more importantly, an undefeated record against the greatest fighter of all time. It wasn€™t a definitive victory, nor was it an assertion of Weidman being the better fighter, but it remains another win for Weidman that established a losing streak for Silva.

It€™s almost apropos that a fighter with such controversy surrounding his accolades would face an air of uncertainty around his decline. Though, we don€™t know just yet if this actually is a decline. Silva is nearing 40-years-old and barring the outcome of his recovery from the injury suffered against Weidman, he still had plans to finish his contract with UFC. Yet, with his illustrious Middleweight Title run at an end, the two remaining images of his legacy are being knocked out for showboating and having his leg snapped by his opponent€™s knee.

Perhaps the MMA Gods are trying to send Anderson a message to cut the crap and quit while he€™s ahead.


Contributor
Contributor

Nick Boisseau is a feature writer and poet, currently existing on the fringe of academia. He holds a B.S. in History and is a graduate of the September 2006 class of Storm Wrestling Academy. @DBBNick DonnyBrookBoys.com