10 Most Forgettable Star Trek: Voyager Episodes
Anyone remember that time in Star Trek when Torres inspired poetry? ...didn't think so.
For better or worse, Star Trek: Voyager has some truly memorable episodes. There are those remembered for being epic and explosive such as the season 4 two-parter, Year of Hell, or the show's 100th episode, Timeless. There are others which are remembered for their controversial storylines - looking at you, Tuvix! And then there are the ones everyone remembers but maybe for the wrong reasons - ahem, Threshold.
But whilst viewers forever discuss these common few, what about the unfortunate episodes that get lost in the fold? The less-than-amazing stories that become overshadowed by the best, and worst, of the batch.
To be clear, we're not suggesting that these are bad episodes, but rather the underlings, carrying Voyager to its 26 episode count per season, while maintaining a low profile amid the higher achievers. In words all Voyager fans will understand, think of these episodes as Chakotay in the later seasons - there, but relegated to the background.
10. Alice
Remember when Tom Paris became obsessed with a shuttle? No, not the Delta Flyer! In fact, in this season 6 episode, his beloved Flyer and even his beloved B'Elanna are forsaken for the titular Alice.
After arriving at an interstellar junkyard, Paris persuades Chakotay that this derelict shuttlecraft - aptly named Alice, after a "lost cause" from his academy days - would be a worthwhile investment for Voyager and quickly gets to work on fixing it up. Soon, though, what started as a hobby, turns into an unhealthy obsession, abetted by the interface of Alice appearing to Paris in the form of a beautiful woman. Under her influence, Paris swaps his Starfleet uniform for a grey flight suit, neglects his duties, bails on holodeck plans with Harry, demands - and later steals - supplies and equipment, and completely overlooks his relationship with B'Elanna.
Of course, by the end of the episode, Paris is saved and the Voyager crew live on to journey another day.
One of the biggest factors for Alice flying under the radar is that it had the unfortunate position of being sandwiched between fan-favourite episode, Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy, and the higher stakes storyline of Riddles. The proposed implications in these two stories are far more engaging than that of Alice. Viewers are invested in the trials and tribulations of the EMH attempting to enhance his programme and the comical tones of Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy adds an extra layer of memorability. Likewise, the prospect of Tuvok losing his intelligence and emotional control is engaging for viewers who are used to the stoic nature of Vulcan characters.
By comparison, Alice doesn't really show viewers anything unusual or unexpected. Tom Paris, while on a path of redemption, is a character notorious for his brash ideas and selfish behaviour, and, therefore, the events of this episode, while extreme, aren't particularly surprising and by extension, aren't particularly memorable.
9. Nightingale
Oh, Harry. The forever Ensign. Many fans have joked and criticised the absence of a promotion for Harry Kim in the seven years that Voyager travelled the Delta Quadrant. However, the events of season 7 episode, Nightingale, might just remind said fans as to why Harry didn't receive any more pips.
After responding to a distress call while out in the Delta Flyer, Harry Kim finds himself caught in the middle of a war between the Kraylor and the Annari. Under the illusion that the Kraylor ship is transporting medical supplies, Harry agrees to take temporary command of the vessel and help them return home. Along the way, however, not only does it become clear that the Kraylor have not been entirely truthful, forcing Harry to break the Prime Directive, but Captain Kim also demonstrates extremely poor leadership skills in his first solo command.
Alongside this main thread, there's the rather odd subplot of Icheb wrongly assuming that B'Elanna has developed romantic feelings for him.
So why is this particular episode seldom remembered? Well similar to Alice, this episode is preceded by one with more comedic undertones in the form of the EMH and Seven of Nine sharing a body in Body and Soul and succeeded by the hard-hitting Flesh and Blood.
Beyond that, however, for as much as we all love him, it's a hard truth that Harry Kim is not as exciting a character as the likes of Seven of Nine or the Doctor. By this point in the show, it's a common observation that Voyager had become more focused on Janeway, Seven, and the EMH, while the rest of the characters were given less invigorating storylines.
Nightingale is a perfect example of this. Rather than gracing Harry with a story of triumph and even the achievement of a much anticipated promotion, the writers delivered an episode that once again put Mr. Kim down. While it was a great lesson in learning through failing, viewers would have been far more likely to remember this episode if it had been the one where Harry Kim was finally given a promotion!
8. Random Thoughts
This season 4 story perhaps deserves more recognition than it gets. The premise of Random Thoughts explores the notion of craving something forbidden and presents an interesting allegory for the extreme lengths someone might go to obtain such contraband.
On a planet where crime is all but eradicated, B'Elanna is arrested after her violent thoughts supposedly influence an attack in the marketplace. With Tuvok working to prove her innocence and prevent the punishment of a risky engramic purge, he uncovers a black market network dealing in violent thoughts.
This particular episode suffers two misfortunes. As is a common theme with many entries on this list, Random Thoughts directly follows the epic two-parter Year of Hell. Airing in the shadow of such a popular and memorable story meant that this episode was destined to be forgotten, despite its premise and unexpected twist.
On top of that, this is another episode that suffers from a lack of creativity with regards to its characters. While there is a great twist in the plot itself, the characters behave predictably. It comes as no surprise that it's the half-Klingon character who is accused of violence. It is equally unsurprising that Tuvok channels his inner Sherlock Holmes to crack the case or that Paris wants to ignore protocol and break B'Elanna free. Even Neelix keeps things consistent, setting his sights on pursuing yet another impressionable young woman in an entirely unnecessary micro subplot which ultimately ends in said young woman's murder.
Of course, it wouldn't be logical for every episode to explore established characters acting unusual - that would undermine the impact of the instances when it does happen - but naturally, it is those storylines that remain more memorable, and, unfortunately, Random Thoughts just isn't such a story.
7. Alter Ego
Holodeck episodes are such a clever tool in Star Trek. They allow a break in the usual structure of space and aliens, offering the chance for a story based in history or fiction. This lends itself well to Voyager where the characters are often missing the luxuries of home or require a distraction from their hapless situation.
Alter Ego started as a promising holodeck story but by the end had fallen back into the space and alien format. Poor Harry Kim is struggling to deal with the heartache of developing feelings for a holodeck character - Marayna. He goes to Tuvok for help in suppressing his emotions and ends up introducing Marayna to a more desirable match. It is later revealed that Marayna is not actually a holodeck character but a lonely alien on a nearby space station seeking companionship in her isolated duty.
The biggest problem with Alter Ego is that it contains plot threads that are explored far better elsewhere.
Compared to the likes of The Killing Game, Worst Case Scenario, Bride of Chaotica! or even, Real Life, the holodeck setting is entirely forgettable and somewhat secondary to the plot.
And let's not forget Fair Haven, which, as well as being a massively divisive - and therefore memorable - holodeck episode, also explores the consequences of a holodeck romance in much greater detail than this story does.
Even the love triangle element isn't something unique to this story. Season 2 had already explored this concept with Neelix, Paris, and Kes. That plot, however, made more character sense, with Neelix feeling threatened by Tom's flirtatious charm, whereas, a conflict between the shy Harry Kim and stoic Tuvok over the affections of a never-seen-before hologram just seemed too random and fleeting to be remembered in any great detail.
6. Muse
When it comes to Muse, it would seem that the writers took a risk that ultimately didn't quite land as successfully as they had hoped.
In this season 6 episode, B'Elanna crash lands the Delta Flyer on a pre-warp planet. She is discovered by a local playwright who believes she is an "Eternal" and uses her logs and experiences to inspire his writings.
The main risk this episode took was to forgo a discernible conflict for Voyager's crew and focus on a more thought-provoking, metaphorical plot in the form of Greek style theatre. The irony, of course, being that the entire purpose of Muse is to provide a meta commentary on the lazy nature of writers relying too heavily on big twists and adrenaline-fuelled set pieces, rather than the deeper truth and purpose of storytelling.
While it is a commendable effort and, to the more analytical of viewers, a truly ingenious feat of meta storytelling - a message delivered with regards to a fictional play within a fictional television series about the nature of fiction - to the more casual viewers, it simply didn't appeal.
Star Trek has never shied away from lacing its episodes with allegorical plot threads but this particular commentary lacked the usual conflict or high stakes that make other examples far more memorable.
It is also worth considering the previous episode, Live Fast and Prosper, also centred around the idea of Voyager crew members being "played" by someone else. By comparison, though, Muse went for a more strait laced approach, whereas Live Fast and Prosper had a more comical tone to the impersonations. Although they are significantly different stories, airing one directly after the other, despite these similar themes, means that the comedic episode will likely be better remembered over the cerebral one.
5. Non Sequitur
As previously mentioned, a show like Voyager must get creative with the structure of its stories, so as not to become too repetitive or predictable. Another way this is achieved in Star Trek is through episodes focused on time travel and alternate realities.
These themes are explored many times throughout Voyager, with season 2's Non Sequitur being one of the earliest examples. Harry Kim wakes up in his San Francisco apartment with his fiancé, Libby, having never been a crew member on the USS Voyager. Evading Starfleet - who think he's either crazy or a spy - he discovers that his reality has been altered after a collision with a temporal anomaly and, with a little help from a snarky, pre-Caretaker Tom Paris, works to recreate the accident in the hope of returning to his original timeline.
There are a few reasons why this episode gets lost in the fold. First and foremost, the majority of the main Voyager cast are absent for most of the runtime. Besides Harry and Tom, we see only Janeway, Chakotay, Tuvok, and B'Elanna, very briefly, in the closing 2 minutes, while Neelix, Kes, and the EMH don't appear at all. Of course, it is common for the main focus to switch between the core players from episode to episode but in this instance, the absence of so many recognisable characters caused viewers to lose interest.
Following that point, we return, again, to the sad truth of Harry Kim not being as enticing a character as others. Perhaps viewers would have remembered this particular storyline in greater detail had it been Paris or Janeway affected by this reality shift. Viewers were familiar with the relationship between Janeway and Mark, so it may have had stronger emotional value to witness the turmoil of this dilemma on the Captain rather than the less established relationship with Harry.
Non Sequitur also suffers the common factor of following the laughably memorable Elogium. While far from being one of Voyager's best, it almost certainly overshadows this story - and for all the wrong reasons!
4. Natural Law
Chakotay became somewhat obsolete in the later years of Voyager. The earlier seasons explored his involvement with the Maquis; his native spirituality; a complex, manipulative storyline with Seska; and even teased a potential romance between the commander and Captain Janeway. By season 7, Chakotay was one of the few characters lacking any depth or personal plot threads
And that's where Natural Law comes in.
Chakotay and Seven of Nine crash their shuttle within a shielded area of a planet where they encounter a primitive, yet curious species. While - rather poorly - attempting to maintain the prime directive, the pair work to salvage enough equipment from the wreckage to contact Voyager for assistance.
This episode was meant to introduce a relationship between Chakotay and Seven, to be revisited a few episodes later in Endgame. This relationship wasn't popular. The biggest issue comes from how abrupt and underdeveloped it seemed.
For an episode designed to establish a budding romance, the pair spend a great portion of the story separated. This relationship only appeared in a small number of episodes and, of those few, this one is by far the most forgettable. Endgame established a potential future marriage between the pair, as well as being the explosive series finale, and then there's the hugely divisive, Human Error.
3. Emanations
Sadly, yet unsurprisingly, we have another Harry Kim episode. Emanations holds the status of being Voyager's first Harry-centric story.
While investigating what appears to be a burial site found on an asteroid, Harry Kim is somehow transported to an unknown planet whilst a, seemingly dead, alien woman materialises in his place on Voyager. The beings on this planet believe that, after death, they move on to a greater afterlife. Harry's arrival places doubt on that theory and he is eager to return to Voyager before he can interfere too much with their cultural beliefs.
Though the examination of different cultural rituals and beliefs about death is certainly a thought-provoking topic, Emanations lacks anything epic or challenging to stick in the memory of viewers.
The solution to Harry's return is obvious - go back through the same rift that brought him - yet it takes the entire episode to achieve despite there being very little conflict or restriction. Yes, the planet's doctor insists on analysing Harry's biology but he isn't a prisoner per se. If he had been locked in a cell, or physically restrained in some way, then his plight to escape and activate the cenotaph would have added a level of thrill and anticipation to the episode.
Season 1 had already introduced the high stakes conflict between Voyager and both the Kazon and the Vidiians, so a standalone, tame story such as Emanations gets lost in the crowd. It is also followed by Prime Factors which explores the desperate measures certain crew members are willing to take to find a way home - another episode with much more relatable and emotional stakes for both the crew and also the viewers.
2. Gravity
Season 5 boasts some of the most popular and unforgettable episodes of Voyager's entire run. Unfortunately, this means that an even greater shadow hangs over the remaining stories. Gravity is one such episode.
In this mid-season story, Tom, Tuvok, and the EMH are pulled through a spatial sinkhole. Over the months that they are stranded, Noss - an alien woman whom they encounter on the planet - falls in love with Tuvok, who struggles to return her affections. Spliced between flashbacks of Tuvok's youth, Tom tries to convince the Vulcan to indulge his emotions and allow himself, and Noss, to be happy.
Directly following Bride of Chaotica! - a fan favourite episode remembered greatly for its humorous holodeck plot and unique creative style - a shadow was cast over this more conventional Star Trek story. The epic Borg drama Dark Frontier aired just two weeks later.
Tuvok's struggles with emotions had been explored before. Unfortunately, the instances where he is battling a more aggressive outburst - such as season 2's Meld or season 7's Repression - or even facing a distressing internal struggle for control - like season 3's Flashback or season 6's Riddles - tend to be more memorable than a rather tame love story.
Despite a wonderful guest performance from Lori Petty and its perfectly 'fine' story, Gravity just doesn't display anything particularly unique or invigorating to keep it etched in the memories of Voyager's viewers.
1. Unforgettable
Never has an episode been more inaccurately and ironically titled as season 4's Unforgettable.
Voyager comes across an alien woman, Kellin, who claims to have been onboard the ship before, yet no one has any memory of her. She further claims that she and Chakotay had fallen in love in that time and hopes that they can rekindle those feelings. Despite having no recollection of their previous relationship, Chakotay falls in love with her all over again, just for Kellin to have her memories erased by episode's end and leaving Chakotay to return home.
As with many other examples, there is the unfortunate disadvantage of being followed by Living Witness - an episode often described as Voyager's closest comparison to the Mirror Universe - but the truth is, Unforgettable has plenty of other downsides too.
Even the guest appearance of Virginia Madsen wasn't enough to keep this one in viewer's minds. Perhaps much of the issue comes from how unrealistic the premise is - even for Star Trek. Similar to the criticism of the relationship between Chakotay and Seven of Nine, we once again see the commander fall head-over-heels for a woman in a matter of days, simply on the basis that she says they loved each other before. It verges into the ridiculous and viewers are led to feel more uncomfortable by their interactions rather than invested in a happy ending.
There is also an air of pointlessness to the entire plot. It opens with Chakotay having no memory of his relationship with Kellin. It closes in the exact same position, with nothing lost or gained for the crew or their journey. As such, viewers are likely to dismiss the events just as easily as the crew managed to forget them.
Oh, the irony!