6 Ups & 3 Downs From Star Trek: Discovery 5.10 — Life, Itself
The Progenitors come full circle; a series comes to a coda; life goes on but without Discovery.
"This is the end, my friend," as that one character said in the final season of another series. We've come to the very last episode of Star Trek: Discovery. In the words of Michael Burnham, "It's been a hell of a ride". To say there's a sadness would be an understatement. I already feel bereft of the characters, most of whom we've known since 2017. From then to now, when life itself changed so drastically, there was always the next dance at the Disco.
"The Federation has so many wonderful possibilities ahead because of you and your crew," Zora tells Burnham in the coda, in what is, no doubt, not just a testament within universe, but a knowing nod without to the show and all those who made it. It remains a truism, but a good one, that Discovery was responsible for the contemporary revival of Star Trek. Zora's 'possibilities for the Federation' are the possibilities for us all to enjoy breadth and bounty of Trek like never before. After all, life itself is also to beget it.
Discovery is the first Trek series to come to an end after cancellation since Star Trek: Enterprise, and without Riker too. The inevitable comparisons will be made. Life, Itself is not These Are The Voyages…, however; there are no holographic hijinks to be had. Discovery — and the Discovery — is allowed to stand on its own. Life, Itself deftly succeeds in being both a fitting conclusion to a fantastic season and a fine ending to an unforgettable series.
10. UP — Shape Of The Many
Burnham's beginning to Life, Itself, as the virtual camera descends down into the Progenitors' portal through a tesseract/hypercube-esque structure, might not have been entirely novel, but it was just as stellar. Arguably, it might have better served as a cliff-hanger for last week than an opener for this, and debates were had at TrekCulture over the look of the 'lobby' that came next.
A 'health and safety nightmare,' the Progenitors might have thought to put up a couple of railings, at least! ("Fence for a reason, Alice.") More generally, the CGI visuals are also likely to divide fans down the middle, some liking the use of the AR wall, others thinking it's the worst thing since sliced Breen. For those of you who play Cyberpunk — Konpeki Plaza vibes?
On the whole, this is an UP from me for the idea, the concept of it. It's not easy to encapsulate the sheer magnitude of the endeavour that is seeding life across the galaxy. To manage to inspire such awe, as they did, in the physics and the physical of the place is another great achievement entirely. It could only ever have been grandiose!
Then, there were the planets below, up, and to the sides. We reckon Sha Ka Ree (in purple) for sure, and Galorndon Core (rocks and wind speeds), then Rura Penthe/Andoria for the ice, Veridian III or (appropriately) Vilmor II for the rocky, cloudy world beneath the walkway, and perhaps even Risa just before the credits!
9. UP — Shape Of The One
Sadly, I'm not writing this article in any kind of liminal space-time as there is a lot to get through, not least, in this case, the appearance of a Progenitor. Reading between the lines, this was (the mind of) a real one too, not a projection — from a re-configured tricorder or otherwise.
The c/Chase is over, and Burnham has met the result — the end of a few weeks of a Red Directive is the culmination of decades of wanting for some viewers. What Star Trek: The Next Generation began, and gave up on unceremoniously, Star Trek: Discovery has concluded (and continued) with panache. Not only did we meet an actual Progenitor in the in-between flesh, we also found out that the trans-galactic life-seeding technology they were standing on was not built by the Progenitors in the first place. Q'what, now?!
As the Progenitor put it, "We theorised that whoever created this created us […] [in] a cycle of creators and creations countless times over. This place predates them all". That doesn't leave many options in canon. If the 'who' weren't the Q, then perhaps the Preservers? The Arretans?
Either way, Burnham was now the one in charge of it all. Whilst I and others at TrekCulture were definitely team scientific curiosity with Stamets, we can understand why anyone would not want to hold on to such vast power. Plus, as Burnham herself noted, there was no longer a need for the technology. The galaxy was already teeming with the diversity of life itself.
8. DOWN — Literal Hole In The Plot
Burnham's first falling out and down/up with gravity in Life, Itself was to a world —Galorndon Core, we think — that had echoes of nods to that (in)famous set on Stage 16 at Paramount Studios, used from the start of Star Trek: The Next Generation. Its nickname, 'Planet Hell,' is never more earnt, however, than when it is on fire.
It was this second use of the infernal-type locale, dramatic as it was, that took us out of the action a little. Moll and Burnham, in their fisticuffs, find themselves on 'fire world,' but then, contrary to their exit from Sha Ka Ree, they are back in the lobby in the next scene without an explanation as to how they got there! I know that's picky, but it threw me off, like anyone with so much as a loose shoelace on that walkway! All that suit/transporter gadgetry, and we couldn't get a grappling hook or some Spock boots?
We did get to speculating too. Candidates for fiery Planets Hell could include Melnos IV/Bersallis III from Lessons, or, at a push, maybe even Excalbia or the actual 'Planet Hell' from Parturition, if someone lit a plasma torch in those Trigemic vapours? Our favourite, as it were, was by far the unstable Benev Selec, aka Drema IV, aka Sarjenka's planet from Pen Pals.
7. UP — Vahar'ai To Eye
The first Kelpien in Starfleet, Saru changed the destiny of his entire species (still a pre-warp civilisation when he joined). Homeworld Kaminar was rather unique in that all Kelpien were prey to predators the Ba'ul, biologically and environmentally pre-programmed to live in a state of fear until the time of the vahar'ai and their culling.
That is until Saru went through the vahar'ai himself aboard Discovery and survived, learning a few things about the history of his planet in the process. Bye, bye 'threat ganglia' and Googling the best captains; go, go, Action Saru with head darts!
Skipping ahead several episodes and several hundred years to Life, Itself, we witness the culmination of Saru's change in character in his thoroughly fearless negotiation with Primarch Tahal. "I am Kelpien, first and foremost," Saru declares to the holo-head. "My species are predators, and I have studied you like prey". Tahal then accuses him of bluffing, to which Saru simply replies, "Look into my eyes, and tell me if you see even the slightest glimmer of doubt". More chills than a Breen refrigeration suit! Just don't play Saru at "Ferengi rummy," as Nhan — whose presence was equally appreciated — pointed out.
6. DOWN — Culber's Anti-Climax
For Whistlespeak, I gave a DOWN to a lack of logic in Doctor Culber's 'journey' post-Jinaal, with the caveat that it might all be leading to something bigger. "I was hoping for an answer, but there isn't one," Culber concludes in Life, Itself. For one of the key characters in Star Trek: Discovery, played by a fine actor, such inconclusiveness leaves a lot to be desired.
Perhaps it was just me once more, but I simply did not get what was so mysterious about the impromptu tractor beam solution. Culber has at least some of Jinaal's memories, we find out, so the "why that [memory], why now" could reasonably just be an unconscious association triggered upon his hearing of Booker's plan to go after the portal. On some level, Culber knew that Jinaal's knowledge could help and so felt compelled to do so.
Besides, it is even more important, I think, in the age of rampant conspiracy theories and a general distrust and misunderstanding of science and medicine, for any doctor character in particular to remain a powerful, unwavering advocate for the scientific method, for the need for knowledge and understanding, the search for answers, and the good that can bring.
Culber just seems to 'give up' and surrender to 'the mystery' when the solutions aren't quite as forthcoming as he'd like. Moreover, a lack of explanation should drive him crazy! He's a doctor, and a scientist. Finding the answers is very much the point!
5. LATINUM UP — Kovich Is A Code-Name
Ever since his first bespectacled appearance in Die Trying, theories have run wild as to the 'true' identity and/or occupation of Doctor Kovich, played by the legendary David Cronenberg. Some thought he might be a Lanthanite, others hypothesised he might be Voyager's EMH with a different visage, and there were those who said he was an android. Others still supposed he might be head of Section 31 or Starfleet Intelligence (which he still could be), and/or that he might be a Terran.
Amongst the other suggestions for Kovich have been 'Future Guy,' a Supervisor, a Preserver, a Progenitor, and a Temporal Agent. Over the years, only a handful have got it exactly right, however. As we now know, Kovich is, in fact, "Agent Daniels, USS Enterprise, and other places". All of the UPs, all of the latinum, all of the everything. Take it! Take my money!
"I've lived many years, Captain, and many lives," Kovich tells Burnham in his office in Life, Itself. In fact, the first time we met Daniels, in Cold Front, he died "in a manner of speaking" at the end of Silik's pistol. He died again in the NX-01 sickbay in an alternate 1944, only to return by the end of the Storm Front two-parter. On the one hand, time travel can give you the biggest of headaches; on the other, it can do wonders for your health! By our calculations, and moving linearly, Daniels/Kovich has to be at least 171 years old by 3191!
4. DOWN — Your L'ak Is Lacking
"This isn't how our story ends," Moll said to a moribund L'ak in Erigah. Of course, that was a hope, not a promise, as far as we, the audience, were concerned. The reminder is, no doubt, that Life, Itself is also Death, Itself, not that death has been a hindrance to rebirth in Star Trek before. If the Progenitors et al. won't do, maybe try Borg nanoprobes instead? Worked for Neelix! Like Moll, we just want L'ak back!
There was another post-mortem sticking point that arose in our TrekCulture Infinity Room discussions on Life, Itself. We've previously UPPED Moll, both before and after L'ak, for her forward planning, her strength of character, and, deep down, her caring nature. After acting with intent, strategy, and purpose without L'ak in previous episodes, in Life, Itself, Moll seems irrational, and atypically, overly violent.
Whilst a degree of desperation and hopelessness — trapped in an endless maze trying to save the one you love — is understandable, I can't help but think that L'ak wouldn't necessarily like the lengths and risks undertaken to save him. Then again, he did poison that one guy. Ultimately, it was a little frustrating to see Moll return to square/window one time and again after making peace with Burnham.
Kovich still had plans for her, however, it would seem. Section 31, maybe? For a lack of season six, we'll probably never know!
3. UP — Fashionably Late
I don't think there would have been a plane with a banner big enough had we not got to see the wedding of the year, nay the next millennium! We still weren't on the guest list for the ceremony, but at least we got to gatecrash (down into) the reception. Whether planned or not pre-cancellation, keeping the nuptials fashionably late, as late as possible, in fact, was a choice matched in elegance by T'Rina and Saru's gowns. There were a couple of faces missing at the party, but we'll not get too crabby over that. This coda pre-Coda was about as good as it gets. To the newlyweds, bathed in orange hues!
Also late — blame the Talaxian pirates — but "very dapper," Booker arrives to greet an equally well dressed Michael Burnham. No sooner has he arrived than the pair are off alone for a stroll on the beach. I mean, are weddings really about the couple getting married anyway? Besides, Burnham and Book have left it long enough, although it's never too late to re-try.
Not to ignore Book, whose sentence has been commuted, but it's really just a delight to see Burnham so happy after so much heartache. "You, me, and Grudge, it is," Burnham concludes. It looks like Kovich might have to fit in there somewhere as well. Or perhaps he was just calling about the wedding? He's Daniels — 'fashionably late' might mean missing it by a century or two.
2. UP — Wax Lyrical
As I mentioned in the introduction, all of Life, Itself, and especially its coda, is bound to be compared to These Are The Voyages… The latter, in its entirety, was a coda, a hasty flash-forward in an attempt to wrap up. It wasn't an episode of Enterprise, however, but the deleted scenes for one of TNG.
For different reasons, and for different circumstances, Star Trek: Discovery has avoided all that. This is an epilogue done right, on their own terms. As we've noted before, the good fortune was that season five was always leading back to the beginning (of all things… of "life, itself" via the Progenitors). The symbolism of Doctor Kovich/Daniels' closed, infinite loop was ever more prescient when it and the Red Directive became the beginning of the very end. In that sense, they only had to add to what was already there. They could wax lyrical… with a little wax.
Whilst the beach could have been ending enough, and no doubt originally was, I personally found the time-jump coda to be deeply moving and particularly poignant. It was deceptively simple, but beautifully executed, with nods to the past, present, and future — from a telescope, to Alice, to tenure. Memories… all alone in the bridge light might have been a little maudlin, but not saccharin, and surely the best they could do at short notice. To quote something that will come up in about a thousand years or so — " 'S Wonderful"!
1. Cetacean Observations
This final week, if each one of those windows in the portal structure were a cetacean observation, we'd be in for quite a long walk. Seán is also a far better tour guide than I, but allow me, nonetheless, to show you through a few before our spaghettification in the black hole.
Peeking through the side of just one of those frames opens up an entire world of objects in Kovich/Daniels' office — not the least of which was a baseball and a visor. My personal favourite of them all was a certain microscope, shelved just behind Kovich to the (our) left. By and after all comparisons, we can safely say that this is the same microscope that Captain Janeway kept in her ready room aboard Voyager — a 600-year-old (at the time) gift from her grandfather as she told the overly inquisitive Kashyk in Counterpoint.
If you also stared especially hard at that bottle of Château Picard, you'll have noticed the vintage — 2249. That was the year of Michael Burnham's graduation from the Vulcan Science Academy and the start of her service aboard the Shenzhou. In fact, this might very well be the same bottle that Captain Georgiou had on display in her ready room.
Like all the good things in life itself, wine is meant to be enjoyed. I say we open that bottle, raise a glass of it to Star Trek: Discovery, and play a few games of Ferengi rummy. Aye, (aye), and yes, ma'am! To Discovery!