7 Ups & 2 Downs From Star Trek: Discovery 5.9 — Lagrange Point

Two black holes; two teams for a Breen heist; two starships and worlds collide.

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point
CBS Media Ventures

I thought time was supposed to slow down (relatively speaking) when the gravity gets a little stronger, like being in close proximity to two black holes. Instead, it's hurrying by at an alarming rate. We're already at episode nine, the penultimate of the entire series, regrettable as that is to write. Lagrange Point is, for all intents and purposes, the first of a two-parter to be concluded by next week's finale.

Contracted in screen time, although by no means to its detriment, Lagrange Point is also a relatively short episode by Star Trek: Discovery standards. It packs a punch, however, and a lot in, with its fewer minutes, all under the expert direction of Jonathan Frakes. In a duranium nutshell, it's a mini-heist movie, a cunning plan to get the encased Progenitors' technology back from Moll and the Breen.

Overall, I found Lagrange Point to be extremely entertaining, a well-executed episode of Star Trek with one hell of a ship-on-ship space battle near the end! There were a few differences of opinion this time between me and Seán, however. Perhaps we will go to war, after all! Only kidding… Let's not start a whoopsie-daisy! I'm sure we can all get along at that Breen 'party' we have this evening!

10. UP — Cold Open, Warm Bridge

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Bridge
CBS Media Ventures

The relatively lengthy cold-open to Lagrange Point begins on the dramatically twisty-turny at Federation HQ, as if the camera itself had been propelled there right out the spore drive from last week's 'Burnham Manoeuvre'. It ends on a hook which is equally a reversal, not of motion but of circumstance. Whilst not necessarily the most shocking put to screen, the Breen smash-and-grab of the Progenitor structure is up there with the best executed pre-credit turn-of-events.

When the Discovery crew jumps to the final coordinates of the clue trail, the literal gravity of the life-and-death situation doesn’t seem to hamper their spirits either. They all pull together, and once on the other side of some pretty high odds against them, there is a much-deserved pause for levity (almost) all-round.

"It's tonight somewhere. Do we have to wait?" We'll all join you for those drinks! No Detmer and Owosekun yet, but absolutely glorious work from commanders Asha and Jemison in their stead. The moment certainly made me chuckle as much as it did Captain Burnham. Jemison's deadpan, immediate reply to Burnham's request for an ETA on the Breen — "Right now!" — was also pure (operations) gold!


9. UP — Badda-Bing, Badda-Burnham; Badda-Bing, Badda-Breen

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Burnham Breen Suit
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek has drawn from, and played on, the heist movie before, most notably the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode Badda-Bing, Badda-Bang, which took direct inspiration from (the original) Ocean's Eleven. Star Trek: Voyager's Dark Frontier then traded casino for the 'Fort Knox' of a Borg sphere in its transwarp coil caper. If you're a Lurian, or just Morn, you can always get away with it by hiding the liquid latinum in your second stomach! (See: the Lissepian Mother's Day Heist)

What Badda-Bing…, and to a certain degree Dark Frontier, also had was what TVTropes would call the "Unfolding Plan Montage". In Lagrange Point, we equally see Burnham and team(s) (Alpha and Bravo) plan the (crazy but do-able) plan to steal back the Progenitors' tech from the Breen. Even, and especially, when it all went wrong, it was still thoroughly, shuttle-explodingly, gripping.

Aboard the dreadnought, we were treated to a mix of out-and-out caper comedy, extra points on Breen lore (some are 'badda'; others, a little flirtatious), and surely one of the riskiest, most dangerously daring rescues ever attempted! Hold on to your helmets, for all the best-laid schemes of Burnham and Breen gang aft airlock'd!


8. UP — A Three-Body Problem Solution

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Navigation
CBS Media Ventures

With Netflix's recent adaptation of Liu Cixin's novel, which also featured Rosalind Chao (Keiko O'Brien to us), we're probably all aware of the celestial 'problem' by now. The fault, dear Astrometrics, is not in our stars, but in our ability to accurately and forever predict their movements. There are some solutions to the three-/n-body problem, however — one of which, in restricted form, is Lagrange (or Lagrangian) points.

Just an UP for the supreme scientific beauty of it. I mean, we have had mention of Lagrange points in Star Trek before — in Survivors and Unification III, for example — but never anything nearly like this! The location of the technology of the Progenitors, the species who seeded life as we know it across the galaxy, had to be spectacular. Right at an equilibrium (Lagrange) point between two (primordial) black holes — which they themselves put there billions of years ago — is that and then some!

Even if it doesn't always get it right, science and Star Trek go hand in hand — test tube in cathode-ray tube. Over the years, Trek has inspired countless many to study, take up careers, or just an interest, in the sciences. A lot of us (me included) will have been unfamiliar with the finer points of Lagrange points before this week's episode, but it will have encouraged plenty to find out more. Star Trek tells us to ask the next question, to find the interesting in the detail — that imperative expressed ever effervescently, here, through the persistently curious Tilly.


7. UP — Tilly-isms, Part 3

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Tilly
CBS Media Ventures

If you've been following my Ups & Downs — and I'll forgive you if not — you'll be having that Yogi-Berran feeling of 'déjà vu all over again'. Why settle for a two-parter when only a threequel will do? This week, the Tilly-isms are back in force, making Lagrange Point a strong third outing for our lieutenant-teacher saga.

In Lagrange Point, it's Tilly who saves the ship, first by figuring out the black hole binary system ("which is interesting"), and by suggesting the plan to use the gravity of one to fly away from both. Tilly also then pinpoints and deciphers the duranium-encased Progenitors' tech at the Lagrange point. The lieutenant really shouldn't have been surprised when Rayner asked her to serve as his acting first officer! "Yes, sir. Thank you. Very… good," she replies. Pricelessly Tilly!

A little later on, the Tilly-Rayner "[it's] the pacing" interaction further solidified our affinity for them both. Rayner won't sit in the chair, but he wouldn't kill Tilly "in a foxhole" either. All that "fuzzy encouragement," Rayner claims he can do without, daring the debut of a smile. Tilly simply grins back at him.


6. DOWN — Split Over Split Screen

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Adira Booker Rhys
CBS Media Ventures

As Star Trek fans, we're all accustomed to splitting the microscopic hair's breadth of canon into a debate or two. If you had the Infinity Key to the TrekCulture Infinity Room, you'd see we take the mandate of discussing the finer points at length very seriously, and with a good deal of fun, too. One such point of pettifogging without the pedantry for Lagrange Point was the functioning of those replicated Breen suits.

We did wonder how the two teams on the dreadnought kept their communication channels so distinct. To use an analogy, we assumed they were just switching between game-mode and party-mode for their chats. Nonetheless, and whilst I'm all for linguistic challenges, the mid-sentence transition of dialogue between English/Federation Standard internally and Breen in translation with subtitles externally was a little jarring at first.

Opinions did then diverge between us over the three-way Adira/Book/Rhys interior helmet split screen, although not enough to start the aforementioned war. Maybe a minor skirmish? Seán took a neutral stance, but to my mind it was all a bit gimmicky — a gimmick they'd already used during the hover-bike chase in the season opener. Seán did admit that it was "a bit Power Rangers," so maybe I'll stand down from red alert. "I have a [splitting] headache," anyway!


5. UP — Action Saru Now Comes With Nuptial Bouquet…

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Saru
CBS Media Ventures

… batteries still sold separately. Saru's back — UP! And are those flowers for me? Oh, you really shouldn't have! No… they're for your "dearest T'Rina"? My bad! You two carry on. If you need me, I'll be in my portable pattern buffer!

Last week, both Seán and I gave a DOWN, in part, to Saru's on-going absence from this season of Star Trek: Discovery. All is forgiven, though, if it comes with flowers. The bouquet Saru beamed in with, like Tom Paris on a secret surprise rendezvous with B'Elanna Torres, was from planet Elpanah, apparently believed to bring good fortune to "those with impending nuptials".

Saru and T'Rina are going to need it, especially if this spot of bother with the Breen gets any worse. It has? Let's walk and talk! It turns out the rest of the Breen Primarchs had already heard the news about Ruhn — "And people are always saying that space is so big" (~ Alternate Admiral Janeway). Primarch Tahal had mobilised her fleet. Later, in a rather touching, but #totesawks, moment, to use one of those outdated expressions, Saru volunteers in front of T'Rina to go after Tahal for a little diplomatic tête-à-bucket-tête.

Suddenly, then, T'Rina and Saru's pre-marital topsy-turvy is reversed somewhat from its prior state in Jinaal. It is T'Rina who is now in a position of worrying for Saru. "Vulcans are not the only species capable of choosing logic and duty over emotion," Saru offers. "Fair point," T'Rina replies. That bit of dialogue alone is worth all the Progenitors' tech!


4. LATINUM UP — Crash Course In Crash Courses

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Stamets Culber
CBS Media Ventures

Whether it's trying to calculate Pi to the last digit, being taught basic arithmetic by Quark, fearing fractal calculus, or just appreciating the "creative use of the minus sign," mathematics — as a discipline — is a constant in Star Trek, even when the laws of physics (pace Scotty) are not. "Math doesn't lie," as Stamets adds in Lagrange Point. Maths is incapable of such a thing, but a/the person behind the equations is never infallible. In this case, proof of the proof comes in the success of the ramming. The pudding will have to wait!

I can't resist the thought of Rayner's best Michael Caine over the comm to a bewildered Stamets had things gone wrong: 'You were only supposed to go and blow the bloody containment field off!' Fortunately, Burnham's idea, cleverly related through a throwback to Red Directive, and Stamets' mathematical solution did not make liars out of either of them.

We were almost expecting a "prepare for ramming speed," or for Deanna Troi to appear suddenly at the helm beforehand, but, tucking up its nacelles, the Discovery dives down directly through the containment field, phasers and photons firing. In the shuttlebay, explosive decompressions erupt. All the Breen, and the Progenitors' tech, get thoroughly Harry Kim'd!


3. UP — Rayner's Lagrange Point

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Rayner 2
CBS Media Ventures

To be frank, I hesitated over this one. I wasn't sure whether I loved or loathed Rayner this week. It was as if I was at a Lagrange point of my own making, pulled both ways by the gravity of the UP and the DOWN, yet heading towards neither because of the centrifugal pseudo-forces of my mind. An exterior nudge soon forced me out of my inertia. It's an UP for Rayner and his ever complex, curmudgeonly but caring, personality!

In amongst the curter quips, clapping of hands, and back-to-business splashes of cold water, Rayner does show his softer side. His aforementioned exchanges with Tilly were a highlight of the episode. Rayner has also suffered a lot, and whilst that is, for so long as he maintains his own agency, not an excuse to be rude, it is an explanation, a reason to allow him his own 'ups & downs,' especially given the news that Tahal was on the way.

The crew of the Discovery have all seemed to warm to Rayner, too, not in spite of, but because of his quirks. They even eventually persuaded him to stop wearing a hole in the deck-plating and give the chair a go! The theme of the episode is equilibrium, and Rayner is reaching a balance — his very own Lagrange point.


2. DOWN — Chair-Hanger

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Rayner
CBS Media Ventures

Not to end on a negative, but at least Rayner is (finally!) sitting down for it! It's not the chair slap that gets the DOWN either. Like Rayner, by Lagrange Point's end, we were creeping towards the edge of our seats, but we needed to be hanging over a cliff!

The ending to Lagrange Point was as heart-pumpingly exciting as it gets, don't get us wrong, with its duranium barrel rolls and portal piercing explosions right back at the black holes. Burnham had gone inside the portal after Moll, scans couldn't detect her, but Book knew she was still alive. Then came Rayner's emboldening speech as he sat in the chair. "Failure is not an option […] Let's do this!"

That should have been epic enough, but, as you know by now, we are picky for the finer points at TrekCulture. We simply felt the ending needed something just a little extra, one last hook to push it over from chair- to cliff-hanger. Unlike that duranium shell, a shot of Burnham, perhaps, inside the Progenitors' portal, might just have sealed the deal.


1. Cetacean Observations

Star Trek Discovery Lagrange Point Moll Portable Pattern Buffer
CBS Media Ventures

Speaking of duranium (Star Trek down to the bones of its ships), let's crack open whatever structure this counts as and see what other references await us inside. We did get the likes of a "transwarp tunnel," the pathway drive, and even a (all-too-brief) Voyager-J flyover, but there was one observation from about halfway through Lagrange Point that caused considerable debate here at TrekCulture — the 'portable pattern buffer,' used by Moll to preserve L'ak's body until his possible, Progenitorial revival.

Some of us — naming no names — thought that the new miniaturised version of relatively standard Star Trek tech should have been called something a bit less clinically descriptive by the then of the 32nd century. On the whole, I personally liked the 'says on the tin' approach to 'portable pattern buffer'.

Originally designed to be a temporary storage medium within the regular operation of the transporter, the pattern buffer has almost certainly always been a part of the human version of the technology. It was there in the version installed aboard the NX-01, as Ensign Hoshi found out in Vanishing Point. In Star Trek: The Original Series, a pattern could also be "suspended in transit" (per the Klingons in Day of the Dove, for example), and in Star Trek: The Next Generation, Lieutenant Barclay was held in temporary transporter stasis in Realm of Fear.

In on-screen chronological time, it wasn't until Relics that we saw the pattern buffer be used for lengthy periods of suspension (75 years for Scotty). Before that, in canon-time, Doctor M'Benga had employed a similar approach to keep his daughter alive. Star Trek: Voyager and Star Trek: Discovery would also make use of transporter suspension in Counterpoint and Stormy Weather respectively.

In any case, however Moll's version works, and for however long, walking around with a corpse inside a device the size of a memory stick is either seriously creepy or somehow very cool!


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jack Kiely is a writer with a PhD in French and almost certainly an unhealthy obsession with Star Trek.