Considering the immediate success of South Park, which catapulted its creators into the stratosphere and crowned it the defining firebrand animation of the late 20th and early 21st century (before that sort of badge became so hotly-contested, really), it's quite shocking how long it took for there to be a truly seminal episode.
Sure, there are classics in the first few seasons and they're eminently quotable and probably all the more memorable because there were fewer of them at the time, but it took until the fourth season for the real greatness to begin. And that's not just a supposition pulled out of thin air, either - it's based entirely on the one metric that really dials into fan reactions to shows (beyond viewer figures) - the IMDB star rating.
With that metric taken into account, it took until that point until an episode that now sits at over 9.0 - the true mark of greatness and a benchmark of awesome. And while there have now been HUNDREDS of episodes, there are still relatively few that have broken the barrier. So you just know they're great...
18. Black Friday (Season 17 Ep 7)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.0
A delightful skewering of the modern festive sales nastiness, which sees the kids at war over sale-price computer consoles.
17. Cartman Joins NAMBLA (Season 4 Ep 5)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.0
Where it all started to get very good - and very outrageous - this classic saw Cartman joining NAMBLA to find more mature friends. Yikes.
16. All About Mormons (Season 7 Ep 12)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.0
As a nice precursor to The Book Of Mormon, this 2003 episode sees Stan learning about the religion when a new family moves in from Utah.
15. Imaginationland (Season 11, Ep 10)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.0
Only South Park could take a story of terrorists invading a world of imaginary beings and make the biggest stakes about Cartman trying to make Kyle suck his balls.
14. Imaginationland Episode II (Season 11, Ep 11)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.0
With Imaginationland uncovered, the kids find themselves at odds with the government and Cartman still attempts to make Kyle make good on his testicle sucking bet.
13. Imaginationland Episode III (Season 11, Ep 12)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.0
As testament to how great the three-part event was, the finale also picked up the magic 9.0 rating too. Watch it as a movie though (uncensored) and it's even better.
12. Tsst (Season 10 Ep 7)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.0
In one of the best celebrity episodes, dog trainer/psycho Cesar Millan to teach Cartman how to behave and unwittingly almost turns him into a murderer.
11. Christian Rock Hard (Season 7 Ep 9)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.1
Taking in both Christian Rock and illegal music downloads, this Cartman-heavy episode is a Christianity-baiting joy.
10. Woodland Critter Christmas (Season 8 Ep 14)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.1
Christmas episodes often do particularly well (possibly because it's easy to mock), and the addition of an unlikely anti-Christ here makes for a great recipe.
9. Trapped In The Closet (Season 9 Ep 12)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.1
The R Kelly stuff makes for somewhat difficult watching now, but the religious stuff in this tale of Stan being the second coming is just genius.
8. The Death Of Eric Cartman (Season 9 Ep 6)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.1
Cartman having some self-awareness is always a good source of content and this episode in which he assumes he's dead and tries to atone for his sins is inevitably great value.
7. Grounded Vindaloop (Season 18 Ep 7)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.1
One of the few later season greats, this one sees the introduction of an Oculus Rift and blurs the lines between reality and VR world for some great fun.
6. AWESOM-O (Season 8 Ep 5)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.2
The Simpsons might have done it first, but this one sees Cartman dress as a Japanese robot to trick Butters, which inevitably escalates with Britney Spears and the military thrown in.
5. Good Times With Weapons (Season 8 Ep 1)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.2
In possibly the best season opener ever, the boys lie to get ninja weapons leading to delightful hi-jinx and a ninja star injury to Butters. Standard.
4. Casa Bonita (Season 7 Ep 11)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.2
Another typically normal Cartman episode, this 2003 heyday episode sees him kidnap Butters in a bomb shelter when he's invited to Kyle's party in his place.
3. The Return Of The Fellowship Of The Ring To The Two Towers (Season 6 Ep 13)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.4
Now more famous as the key episode for The Stick Of Truth, this near-perfect film parody is one of the most rewatchable of all the episodes.
2. Make Love, Not Warcraft (Season 10 Ep 8)
Comedy Central
Rating: 9.5
A surprise not-winner given how famous the episode is, this Warcraft parody is about as close to perfect as South Park gets.
1. Scott Tenorman Must Die (Season 5 Ep 4)
ViacomCBS Domestic Media Networks
Rating: 9.6
Ultimately, it's a Cartman vehicle episode that wins out and this is the loveable monster at his worst, darkest and most conniving. Which is why it's the best.