6 Ups & 3 Downs From The Arrowverse In 2018 (So Far)
It's been an interesting year for The CW's Arrowverse.
When it comes to superhero television, few networks have ever achieved the level of success that The CW has. With Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl, and Legends of Tomorrow all part of its regular line-up, the network has amassed an impressive collection of DC's superheroes all in one place. With heroes faster than light and villains smarter than any human, the Arrowverse is one of the richest shared universes in TV history. It has thrilled us all for almost six years - and this year was no different.
All four Arrowverse shows returned from their midseason breaks earlier this year, but unfortunately, it wasn't all good news for these superheroes. While some delivered enjoyable outings and strong stories, other faltered along the way and ultimately disappointed. Then there were those that confused us altogether and gave us the best and worst that it had to offer in a consecutive string of bizarre episodes.
It's safe to say that 2018 has been one of the Arrowverse's more intriguing years, but is that a good thing or a bad thing? Let's find out what it had to offer.
Ups...
6. A Stronger Portrayal Of Female Characters
Over the years, the Arrowverse has been criticised for the way it portrays the majority of its female characters. This all started on Arrow when Laurel Lance suffered a lot of injustice at the hands of the writers. But it wasn't exclusive to the leading lady as supporting characters like Felicity lost their way and eventually became intolerable. Furthermore, The Flash made similar mistakes last season, portraying Iris West like a damsel in distress who needed to be saved by the Scarlet Speedster. While the second wave of shows, Supergirl and Legends of Tomorrow aren't entirely exempt, they have a much better track record with their female characters than the two original Arrowverse shows.
However, this season has seen a significant improvement across both shows in regards to their female characters. The Flash made up for its mistake with Iris by making her the sole leader of Team Flash in Barry's absence, allowing her to be both independent and intuitive. Additionally, Caitlin's struggles with Killer Frost led to some of the season's most compelling moments, while supporting character Cecile Horton stole the show with her humorous new metahuman ability. In addition, Arrow was populated with multiple strong female characters and the rivalry between Black Siren and Dinah Drake gave both women some well-deserved spotlight. Though Felicity played a more reduced role this season, she functioned like the supporting character that she was originally intended to be - a role she thrived in far more than she ever did when she was the show's primary focus.
While some of the Arrowverse's shows saw a decrease in overall quality this season, the universe's portrayal of women characters is undoubtedly on an upward trajectory. Hopefully, the writers will continue to do right by them as they head into their next respective seasons.
5. Constantine Finally Has A Home
Constantine was undoubtedly one of the most underappreciated comic-book shows in recent memory. The Matt Ryan-led series received a positive reception from fans of the Hellblazer comics because it was a dark and faithful adaptation of the John Constantine character. But unfortunately, it never really got a chance to get off the ground as a sharp drop in ratings led to its abrupt cancellation.
But the character found new life when he was introduced into the Arrowverse two years ago, with Matt Ryan reprising his role on Arrow as Constantine helped Green Arrow and Black Canary retrieve the soul of Sara Lance. But it seemed like this was merely a one-off appearance... until 2018. The rise of the demonic Mallus on DC's Legends of Tomorrow led to the character's return, as he showed up to help the resurrected Sara stop the demon once and for all. He then returned in another two episodes before the season finished.
However, the best thing about all of this is that it was simply a precursor of things to come, as The CW confirmed that Ryan has been promoted to a series regular for Season 4 of Legends. Many of us had been hoping to see Constantine aboard the Waverider for quite some time because, with his suggestive comments and quick-witted responses, the demon hunter will be a perfect addition to the line-up of outcasts and misfits. Moreover, it's great that Ryan's Constantine once again has a permanent home on TV.
4. Interesting Stories To Explore Next Season
While some of the Arrowverse's offerings this year were far from perfect, it's hard to deny that they all left us with some highly intriguing possibilities for next season. With Oliver Queen's identity as the Green Arrow outed and a life behind bars awaiting him, Arrow's seventh season will look a lot different from what we're used to. Furthermore, with Laurel looking to avenge Quentin's death, things are bound to get personal.
The same could be said for The Flash next season. The show left us with the revelation that Mystery Girl is none other than Nora West-Allen, the daughter of Barry and Iris. But as she didn't seem too fond of her own mother, we couldn't help but wonder what happened between the pair in her own time and why Nora has turned up in the present. The Flash never fails when family is at its heart, so we're excited to see how this new family dynamic will play into Season 5.
Supergirl's finale saw the departures of Mon-El and Winn. But it wasn't all bad because we got Brainiac 5 as a permanent addition to the DEO. But with J'onn stepping down as Director and Alex taking over, it's safe to say that there will be a lot of changes for Kara and her team going forward. The finale also teased us with the arrival of another Kara, who showed up in Siberia (a nod to DC's Superman: Red Son comic).
But while all these shows deal with change, Legends of Tomorrow looks set to continue doing what it does best: being as off-the-wall as ever. The Season 3 finale revealed that dragons and monsters will be making their debut in the Arrowverse next season. With the permanent additions of John Constantine and Ava Sharpe to the team and an array of the unknown awaiting them, the Legends could be in for their most unforgettable adventure yet. And with that, the Arrowverse could produce one of its strongest years when the shows return next season.
3. Outstanding Standalone Episodes
Ideally, we'd like to live in a world where our favourite TV shows stick to the season's main arc at all times and that none of the episodes divert into filler territory. But unfortunately, that isn't the case and the majority of network shows still produce a few fillers each year to fulfil the episode-count. However, when it comes to superhero television, filler episodes often translate to "villain-of-the-week". So, filler or not, if the episode has a good villain, it will likely be a good episode.
Thankfully this year brought us some incredible standalone episodes from the Arrowverse. When Legends of Tomorrow took a break from its time-travelling demon Mallus to focus on Zari's relationship with her teammates, we were treated to a hilarious yet heartfelt episode in which the newcomer was stuck in a time-loop and ended up bonding with the Legends. Arrow shifted the focus to its villain Ricardo Diaz for a single episode, allowing us to see his and Black Siren's escapades in Bludhaven. Unlike the rest of the season, it was gritty and violent and finally allowed us to understand Diaz's motivations.
But the standout single episode this year came from The Flash's "Enter Flashtime". The Scarlet Speedster was forced to forget about DeVoe and focus solely on the nuclear bomb that was activated in Central City. The whole episode took place over a few seconds as Barry utilised Flashtime to overcome the problem. Not only was it a refreshing change from the convoluted DeVoe arc, it also reminded us why The Flash still has the potential to be the best superhero show on TV. With real stakes and authentic drama, it ended up being one of the show's overall best episodes - highlighting that sometimes fillers can be even better than the primary storyline.
2. Compelling Redemption Arcs
If there is one thing that the Arrowverse does well, it's a good old redemption arc. Whether it's from a once-villainous doppelganger or a former slave-owner, we can't help but watch to see if these leopards really do change their spots. And thankfully, this season was full of redemption.
Recycling Damien Darhk wasn't Legends of Tomorrow's most original idea, but it allowed us to see a vastly different side to him. He may have been helping Mallus, but the former Arrow Big Bad found himself questioning everything when his daughter's life was at risk. In doing so, he tried to atone for all of his evil actions and eventually sacrificed himself to save her. It was a maturely-written dramatic arc for a character that sometimes verges on corny.
But the most important redemption arc this season took place over on Arrow with Black Siren. Initially aiding crime lords, Laurel Lance's Earth-2 doppelganger ended up getting attached to Quentin Lance (the father of Earth-1's Laurel). Their unusual father/daughter bond made Siren question everything she once believed in. And although she struggled with her loyalties, Quentin's love for her eventually helped her see the light. Both Katie Cassidy and Paul Blackthorne delivered some of their finest work in what was undoubtedly the show's most compelling storyline this season.
One of the main reasons why the redemption arcs were a standout aspect this year is down to the fact that they weren't just about the villains changing their ways, they were also the writers' attempts to redeem themselves for previous mistakes that their respective shows had made. Just as Black Siren's redemption was Arrow's atonement for unjustifiably killing off the original Laurel, Mon-El's character development highlighted just how much the writers of Supergirl had learned from some of their mistakes in Season 2. And as part of the process is all about learning what went right and what went wrong, this redemption from the writers suggests a promising future for the Arrowverse.
1. Legends Of Tomorrow Reigns Supreme (Again)
Who would have thought that a fight scene between a giant plush doll and a time-traveling demon was the key to success? It may have been the most ludicrous sight to ever grace your screen but it also highlighted that Legends of Tomorrow can literally do no wrong. The show that started off as a means of giving the Arrowverse's secondary characters something to do has grown into the most consistent program on The CW. Not only is this incredibly ironic, it highlights just how remarkable the show actually is.
Though it had a predictably rocky start during its first season, Legends rose to new heights during Season 2. Since then, it has become the most outrageous show on television. But the beauty about this is that the show is fully aware of just how ridiculous it is... and it embraces it. It never takes itself too seriously and, as a result, neither do we. The characters could (and usually do) end up facing off against the most unorthodox threats imaginable and we would buy it, hook line and sinker.
The colourful collection of characters never fail to remind us why their blend of crazy shouldn't work, but as they prove time and again, it absolutely does. While some of the Arrowverse's newer additions haven't been handled very well on other shows, Legends is a primary example of how to introduce new characters in the correct manner. In a few episodes, Wally West got some well-earned spotlight while recurring characters like Ava Sharpe and John Constantine felt like fully-fledged members of the group.
Of all the Arrowverse's offerings, Legends of Tomorrow was the only one to tick all the right boxes in 2018. For the second year running, it outshone its fellow superheroes and reminded us why it is a force to be reckoned with. Never change Legends, never change.
Downs...
3. Underappreciated Characters Continue To Be Overlooked
It's a sad state of affairs when Kid Flash gets more screen time on an ensemble show than he ever did on his own show. But the painful truth is that The Flash simply had no idea what to do with Wally West, so he was ultimately moved to Legends of Tomorrow. This situation is a microcosm of the entire Arrowverse because, Legends aside, the majority of the shows tend to overlook some of the core characters — and this raises some important questions about the size of each show's cast.
Much like Wally, Thea Queen was one of Arrow's most beloved characters. But this year once again saw the former vigilante overlooked as she played a background role to far less interesting characters. In fact, the show's inability to produce some worthy material for her eventually resulted in her exit. In addition, Winn Schott and James Olsen are often forgotten about on Supergirl, despite the fact that both have been compelling protagonists in previous storylines.
With the full-time departures of Keiynan Lonsdale, Willa Holland and Jeremy Jordan, the Arrowverse may never get the chance to give Wally, Thea and Winn the spotlight they deserve. But if there's one thing that the writers can learn from their absences, it's that these gems should have been appreciated more when they were part of the universe.
2. Contrived Storylines
One of the biggest pitfalls of the Arrowverse this year was the manipulative writing. There were multiple occasions where you could see the writers' work at hand as they tried to force certain storylines upon us that just weren't believable. This resulted in a quite a few major plot development coming off as contrived.
The civil war between the original and new members of Team Arrow was undoubtedly a low point for The CW's veteran show. Instead of having the characters resolve it swiftly and focus on saving the city, the writers decided to push the team members further apart by having Dinah, Rene and Curtis behave completely out-of-character. The storyline was not well-received by fans, with the majority of them turning on the new arrivals because of their bizarre behaviour (which was unfortunate because they were initially right to be angry at Oliver, Diggle and Felicity for their mistrust).
Supergirl was also guilty of this in its season finale when Mon-El departed without so much as a farewell kiss with Kara. The scene was intentionally written without any romantic tension between the pair whatsoever in an attempt to lessen the blow of Chris Wood's departure. But we weren't buying what the writers were selling simply because robbing us of the romantic reunion that was promised to us was nothing short of a letdown.
With these seasons now in the rear-view mirror, the writers can go back to the drawing board for the show's next outings. But let's just hope that whatever happens next, the events naturally progress and don't come off as forced or contrived.
1. Too Many Episodes
One problem that plagues the majority of shows on network television is the significant number of episodes that must be produced. Unfortunately, the Arrowverse isn't exempt from this. With Arrow, The Flash and Supergirl having to produce 23 episodes a season in order to run all-year round, it's no surprise that the standard begins to decline as the season goes on. All of the shows have struggled with this in the past but it was more obvious than ever this year.
The Flash was unfortunately the biggest loser this year. After bringing in Clifford "The Thinker" DeVoe as this season's Big Bad, the writers had to concoct a narrative which allowed the arc (and DeVoe's master plan) to run all year round. What we got was a convoluted plot in which DeVoe needed a specific bus of metahumans for his evil plans. As a result, there were countless episodes devoted to Team Flash's attempts to track down every single "bus meta". With each episode focusing on a different metahuman, the majority of the season was effectively a series of filler episodes.
Elsewhere, Supergirl started off strong with a compelling Big Bad in Reign. But when it returned for the second half of its season, the standard began to slip because of the simple fact that there were too many episodes. Due to this, the writers were forced to come up with unique ways of delaying the final battle until the season finale. So Kara's return to Argo City and Reign's premature destruction were simply plot devices in order to drag the story out a little longer.
We're living in an age where the strongest shows on TV produce a relatively small number of episodes. Even The CW's own Legends of Tomorrow alters between 13 and 17 episodes a year. So why can't the network afford the same treatment to its other Arrowverse shows? There are far too many episodes each season and it continues to dilute the content. If there's anything that The CW can learn from 2018, it's that, in this case, less is definitely more.
Did you enjoy the Arrowverse shows this year? Tell us in the comment section below!