The Walking Dead: 10 Most Underrated Episodes

The gems lost amongst the classics.

The Walking Dead
AMC

Over its 150 episodes, The Walking Dead has aired some truly phenomenal episodes. Pretty Much Dead Already, Seed, Too Far Gone, No Sanctuary, Spend - these and so many more are synonymous with the show's power to write great stories and create brilliant character moments.

Many viewers are often quick to say that the show passed its peak long ago, but given how many amazing episodes are buried within the show's weaker seasons, this is far from a fair assessment. No season of The Walking Dead is completely bad, as there's always an episode or two that stands out.

The opposite is true of the stronger seasons - with so many great episodes, it could be that some are overshadowed by their surroundings.

When a show has that many episodes under its belt, it's guaranteed that an episode or two aren't going to receive the praise they're due.

Whether relentlessly violent, quiet and focused, or unique and surprising in their execution, the following list will take a look at the best episodes of The Walking Dead that have either been forgotten too soon or have received unnecessary hate in the past. Major spoilers follow.

10. The Storm (Season 9, Episode 16)

The Walking Dead Season 9 Daryl
AMC

Season nine's finale was unfairly criticised upon its release. There's no denying why this happened - the previous four episodes were nothing short of phenomenal, with its predecessor offering audiences the chance to see the show's most shocking death scene since Glenn (Steven Yeun) and Abraham (Michael Cudlitz).

Whilst The Storm could easily have been another action-packed, twisting hour of television - which is clearly what people wanted - it is instead a quiet and character-driven episode which is just as emotional with the season's high points.

Focusing on Carol (Melissa McBride) and Ezekiel (Khary Payton) as they deal with the death of their son (Matt Lintz), the episode is a exercise in how to create tension out of grief. Daryl (Norman Reedus) tries to vouch for Lydia (Cassady McClincy) and the residents of the Kingdom must brave a harsh storm in order to find safety.

Also, Negan (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) gets time to shine out of his cell when he saves Judith (Cailey Fleming) and Dog, and the whole dreary escapade ends with a sweet and hopeful snowball fight, promising at least some kind of peace in the future.


9. Mercy (Season 8, Episode 1)

The Walking Dead Mercy Season 8
AMC

Mercy has the unfortunate label of being a part of the mostly-iffy season eight. But don't let that put you off: it is actually a brilliant, violent, battle-heavy hour of TV that deviates wonderfully from the slow, soul-destroying aspects of season seven.

The war against Negan in full swing, everyone is geared up and ready for a fight. Lives are lost, the bullets fly without pause and fans finally get the chance to see the various communities banding together to take down a common enemy.

The rest of the season may not have lived up to its premiere's genuinely strong start, but Mercy has so many wonderful plot threads running through it that it's impossible not to love.

The best subplot of the episode, amongst the wonderful carnage of the shoot-outs, sees Carl (Chandler Riggs) trying to get his dad (Andrew Lincoln) to trust people for once after they run into Siddiq (Avi Nash), laying the seeds for Rick's decision to spare Negan at the season's end and aim for a less violent and more trusting future.


8. Self Help (Season 5, Episode 5)

walking dead abraham self help
AMC

Season five is full of so many perfect episodes that it's to be expected that one or two are going to get lost in the pack.

Self Help is one of those episodes. Taking place on the road as Abraham, Glenn, Rosita (Christian Serratos), Maggie (Lauren Cohan) and Tara (Alanna Masterson) attempt to lead Eugene (Josh McDermitt) to Washington, the episode sees the group hit some serious road blocks on their journey.

Abraham becomes obsessed with his "mission", Eugene wipes out a mini-herd with a hose, and we finally get a chance to see where Abraham came from. Giving quick but full flashbacks to the former soldier's early days in the apocalypse, we're finally able to see why he is so determined to get Eugene to DC.

Drawing Abraham as a committed and broken man filling the void of his past tragedy with work, Self Help makes for a harsh and powerful character study and ends with the sudden announcement that Eugene isn't even a scientist and there is no mission.


7. Sick (Season 3, Episode 2)

The Walking Dead Season 3
AMC

The Survivors taking the prison in season three's first episode makes for an epic and violent spectacle, in which Hershel is bitten and the claustrophobic horror makes for tense viewing.

Sick takes a brief step back from the violence to introduce audiences to the real-life residents of the prison - criminals who don't know the world has ended. Striking up a deal with Rick, Daryl and T-Dog (IronE Singleton), the prisoners agree to clear a nearby block and stay clear of the others.

It makes from some darkly humorous moments, as the prisoners struggle to grasp the reality they've been faced with, but also offers audiences the chance to see Rick turn on his usual instincts and kill the psychopathic Tomas (Nick Gomez) in order to secure the safety of his people and his family.

It's an important episode in the road to the ruthless survivor Rick Grimes would very shortly become, and is truly pulse-pounding to watch.


6. Internment (Season 4, Episode 5)

Walking Dead Internment
AMC

Hershel Greene (Scott Wilson) had been a hero since his very first day on the show, when he saved Carl from a gunshot wound and worked to keep Rick, Lori (Sarah Wayne Callies) and Shane (Jon Bernthal) calm in the face of overwhelming odds.

Always a voice of wisdom and reason, he gets the opportunity to take centre stage in the season four episode Internment. With the flu virus raging throughout the prison, Hershel elects to go into the sick ward in hopes of keeping as many people alive as possible, no matter the consequences that may come.

As he works to save Glenn and Sasha (Sonequa Martin-Green), he also attempts to keep the kids sheltered from the horrors taking place around them.

It's a mostly bleak and harsh episode, in which things go south quite quick, but thanks to Hershel's unwavering perseverance and a brilliant performance from Wilson, Internment not just as a great character study for the wise old man, but a in-depth look at just how brutal and unforgiving the world has become.


5. Thank You (Season 6, Episode 3)

Glenn Walking Dead
AMC

Thank You gets a lot of hate thanks to its divisive and teasing conclusion. Many have even considered it to be the moment where The Walking Dead lost its way and began to drop in quality.

These complaints, whilst reasonable on paper, aren't entirely fair when you watch the episode as a whole. There can be no denying that pretending to kill off Glenn was a poor narrative decision, but the episode that comes before it really is quite good.

On the one hand, you've got Glenn and Michonne trying to keep a small group of Alexandrians alive, a tighter focus on the people in the community that Rick and the gang have taken over, and a great dynamic between Glenn and the broken Nicholas (Michael Traynor). Watching Nicholas deal with his crippled mental state makes for riveting TV, promising a major twist.

Along the way, Rick tries to lure the horde away from Alexandria and Daryl grapples with the need to help Sasha and Abraham lead the horde or help Rick.

All told, it's a great episode which balances everything The Walking Dead does best, from its quieter character interactions to its horror and its violence.


4. Monsters (Season 8, Episode 3)

The Walking Dead Season 8 Morales Rick Daryl
AMC

Like Thank You, season eight's Monsters is a divisive episode, but it might also be the strongest episode of the show's eighth outing.

Monsters is all about morality and the fine line between good and bad that is created in the midst of war. Rick struggles with his need to fight and win the war at all cost, whilst simultaneously no longer wanting to kill to secure peace. Daryl has given up on giving people a chance to prove themselves, killing everyone who's not on his side.

Though this shifting dynamic makes for some thrilling viewing, the episode's strength comes from the diverging views of Morgan (Lennie James) and Jesus (Tom Payne). As Jesus tries to keep some of the Saviors alive, Morgan fights with him every step of the way as he hopes to kill them all for their ways.

The tension builds and builds throughout the episode, until finally Morgan and Jesus come to blows. The fight is epic and surprising, especially given how strong Morgan is but how easily Jesus manages to best him, and perfectly highlights the conflicting views of the various main characters.


3. Arrow On The Doorpost (Season 3, Episode 13)

The Walking Dead Governor Season 3
AMC

Ever since the introduction of The Governor (David Morrissey) earlier in the season, this was the episode things were building up to: a face off between the unhinged leader of Woodbury and Rick.

Orchestrated by Andrea (Laurie Holden), the meeting sees the two strong personalities clash without coming to blows, instead threatening each other, weighing each other up and verbally sparring.

Outside, Hershel bonds with innocent intellectual Milton Mamet (Dallas Roberts) whilst Daryl tries to one-up The Governor's lieutenant Caesar Martinez (Jose Pablo Cantillo).

In a brilliantly written series of character interactions, Rick and The Governor's clearly volatile, unfixable relationship is perfectly contrasted in these outside confrontations, as both sides of the building war come to realise they're not too different from one another.

Outside of the great acting from every main player and the genuinely funny banter that goes on between the mis-matched group, Arrow on the Doorpost is a prime example of how tense the show can be without resorting to violence, because the whole thing is just one big mind game.


2. What Happened And What's Going On (Season 5, Episode 9)

Tyreese The Walking Dead
AMC

Before it was released, Robert Kirkman stated that season five's mid-season premier was going to be a "fan favourite" and a "fan hated" episode because of how shocking and daring it is.

Needless to say, What Happened and What's Going On is a shocking episode, but to hate it should really be impossible.

As Rick, Michonne, Glenn and Tyreese (Chad Coleman) head with Noah (James Tyler Williams) to his old neighbourhood, Tyreese finds himself bitten and succumbing to the bite whilst separated from the others.

As he slowly dies, he hallucinates conversations with those who have recently died but played a big part in his life, including The Governor, Beth (Emily Greene), Lizzie (Brighton Sharbino), Mika (Kyla Kenedy) and Bob (Lawrence Gilliard Jr). He tells them he wants to keep fighting and won't give up, whilst his hallucinations keep telling him to let go and join them.

It's a shocking and completely unique episode of the show, showcasing a phenomenal performance from Chad Coleman and allowing fans to see the full effects a bite has on someone's mind. With its striking visuals and cruel twists, it hammers home the fact that the group is more broken than ever.


1. 30 Days Without An Accident (Season 4, Episode 1)

The Walking Dead Daryl Michonne 30
AMC

30 Days without an Accident is one of The Walking Dead's best episodes. It's also one of its most overlooked.

The season four premiere, the episode follows two plots. One sees Rick, no longer going on runs and happily living the life of an idyllic farmer, as he briefly ventures out beyond the walls of the prison and comes face to face with a disturbed woman (Kerry Condon) who wants to find food for her husband. The other follows Daryl, Michonne, Glenn and some others as they go on an ill-fated run to a local store.

Both stories highlight that no matter how good things can seem, the outside world hasn't changed and tragedy always awaits those who venture out into it.

As Rick deals with the trauma of his most recent confrontation, Daryl begins to feel the weight of all the people they've lost along the way.

It's violent, harsh, thoughtful and its constantly surprising, and it deserves so much more praise for what it achieves.


Watch Next


The Walking Dead Quiz: True Or False?

Walking Dead Tyreese Williams
AMC

1. Tyreese's Weapon Of Choice Is A Cleaver.

Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/