8 Most Controversial UFC Refereeing Decisions Of 2019
The biggest moments from the third man in the Octagon - but not always for the better...
Being a referee is commonly known as a thankless job. You have to make hard decisions in the heat of the moment that can have huge ramifications on not only a fighter's career trajectory, but occasionally on the sport as a whole.
In essence, you have to act as though you don't exist until you are needed to prevent a fighter suffering further injury and to enforce the rules. However, there are certain times a referee steals the limelight from the fighters they watch and end up in the headlines themselves.
This is never for doing a good job, because a referee doing a decent job isn't all that interesting. Instead, it's the juicy moments when they decide to go completely off-script and make you question what you just witnessed onscreen that grabs the top billing of MMA news outlets.
2019 was actually a rather good year for MMA referees as the training they receive improves, and the rules are better understood and unified across the world. As always though, there were also wildly crazy choices made across the past 365 days that sent UFC fans into frenzies this year - which we'll get right into.
8. Dan Miragliotta Decides A Punch Was To The Nose - UFC 238
In Tony Ferguson's grand return to the Octagon following his mental health episodes, against all-time legend Donald Cerrone no less, referee Dan Miragliotta caused quite the uproar when he awarded 'El Cucuy' the win via TKO.
After Ferguson landed a blow clearly after the bell right to Cerrone's dome, 'Cowboy' was then checked on by the doctor due to his eye swelling to comical size. The doctor rightfully waived the fight off due to Cerrone now resembling Popeye, and big Dan had to decide if it was the cheap shot that caused the swelling or not.
Following a video replay of the strike, he decided the shot after the bell landed on Cowboy's nose. People at home were then treated to the visual of the 49-fight veteran blowing his nose, something every fighter is taught not to do.
It was clear this was the real reason his eye ballooned, as air instantly filled his socket, though the Cerrone loyal still contend that Ferguson's punch was the true cause.
In hindsight, this seemed like the correct call. However the minutes long series of boos, the saddening visual of Tony Ferguson's head hung low in what was his comeback victory, and the explosion of anger for stopping such a great fight this way is hard to forget.
7. Marc Goddard Continuously Stops Grappling - UFC 235
Marc Goddard is one of the most divisive referees in the sport today. At UFC 235, when reffing the Welterweight Championship bout between Tyron Woodley and Kamaru Usman, he was in rare form coaxing the ire of fans.
While Usman dominated Woodley with his wrestling at a relentless pace, Goddard would separate them on three occasions against the cage and issue a stand up of the men. This despite Usman being in a dominant position and working hard to keep it that way.
Even commentator Jon Anik stated on Twitter that Goddard's reffing was 'wildly inconsistent'. And Usman was working his ass off'. The referee received huge backlash online for seemingly giving Woodley more opportunities for his only way to win the fight via a standing knockout.
After a particularly confusing separation, when Usman asked Goddard why he was doing this mid-fight, the ref responded with, 'It's a fight'.
This naturally garnered even more criticism, especially from the wrestling allegiance of the sport who felt Goddard was pushing the notion that wrestling was not a legit fighting style. It also seemed to support the mentality of blood-hungry fans who will boo a match the second fighters hit the mat.
Goddard's aggressive retorts to the critics of his choices, his claims that the commentary team did a poor job, and apologizing for his comments to Usman only fuelled the fire of hate for his decisions.
He was lambasted long after this one was decided.
6. Herb Dean Jumps In Far Too Quick - UFC Fight Night: De Randamie Vs. Ladd
Aspen Ladd is a rising star in women's MMA as an exciting, young contender with skills and the ability to viscously end fights. In her first main event against controversy magnet Germaine De Randamie, that hype and her unbeaten record would come crashing down in just 16 seconds.
After Germaine's first punch dropped Aspen to her knees, the 24-year-old looked a little out of it for a half-second, but recovered quickly and rolled to her back in preparation to defend. Respected referee Herb Dean would then step in and call the fight, as a sea of boos rained down on the event and tainted the proceedings.
When to call a fight is one of the toughest jobs for a referee. Do it too early and you rob a fighter of the chance to recover and build back to a victory. Do it too late and you risk Mario Yamasaki levels of ridicule and blame for risking the health of a fighter.
A loss brings so much negativity to a career that a fighter will never stop, even if their arm hangs by a tendon from an armbar, so a referee must save them from themselves at times. In this case, it was clear Ladd was nowhere near done and could have continued.
No one was happy with the stoppage, but Ladd took it well, accepting the decision and bouncing back with an impressive TKO victory her next match against Yana Kunitskaya. Hopefully, they get a chance to run this one back.
5. Rebin Saber Causes Both Fighters Grief - UFC Fight Night: Hermansson Vs. Cannonier
In the fight between Alex Oliveira and Nicolas Dalby, referee Rebin Saber made a multitude of curious choices that had you wondering if he'd ever seen an MMA fight before.
First off, both fighters stopped suddenly after Oliveira turned away from his opponent and stated he was poked in the eye. Rebin just went along with it, making it seem as though the fighters were calling the shots over the referee who was meant to be watching the action closely.
Then in Round 2, he issued a stand up when Dalby had top position for seemingly no reason, and taking away the advantage he had gained from the Brazilian knockout artist. This allowed 'Cowboy' to land some more strikes to the Dutchman that he would not have otherwise.
In Round 3, the referee then did the exact same thing to Oliviera. He grabbed Cowboy's arm mid-punch like an anime character to stop him dropping the bombs he was throwing, before once more standing a fighter up from the dominant position. It was as if he was saying sorry to everyone for the first time he did it.
This halted almost two minutes of control Cowboy had earned and Dalby would go on to win via unanimous decision. The strange choices tainted what was an uplifting UFC comeback win for Dalby and Oliviera's manager stated their intent to appeal.
Like all appeals in MMA, it ultimately went nowhere and now the fight remains a frustrating piece of MMA refereeing history.
4. Andrew Glenn Decides To Allow A Sanctioned Beating - UFC Fight Night: Joanna Vs. Waterson
In one of the most lopsided beatdowns in UFC history, Mike Davis would demolish Thomas Gifford for almost three entire rounds. The first two rounds were scored 10-8's and the third was likely en route to an extremely rare 10-7 scorecard.
The controversy arose due to the fact the fight should have been halted after the first round when Davis landed a devastating 67 signature strikes, of which 46 were direct to his opponent's skull. Thomas was outclassed, outgunned, and the more the fight continued the harder it was to watch.
Even the commentary team pleaded for some type of mercy and begged for the onslaught.
Eventually, referee Glenn would be forced to end the butchering when Gifford lifelessly face-planted the canvas with 15 seconds to go. It looked worryingly like it could have been the first death in the UFC cage.
The entire MMA community at large criticized the referee for allowing the fight to go on, and also the fighter's corner for not throwing in the towel. Though Gifford posted he was alright afterward, he most likely had at least 10 years shaved off his life.
Glenn would be pulled from his future referee duties on the card and replaced by the much more experienced Herb Dean. All due to him allowing a man to continue taking a mauling for ten minutes more than he should have.
3. Dan Miragliotta Motivates Struve - UFC On ESPN: Overeem Vs. Rozenstruik
On the same night he questionably took away Alistair Overeem's win four seconds from the end of the main event fight. Dan Miragliotta also decided to become Stefan Struve's coach mid-fight early on.
After a second hard low-blow from opponent Ben Rothwell put Struve down for the full five minutes, Miragliotta sat down to explain to Struve he was up on the scorecards and would make the fight a no contest if he decided to stop.
Dan seemed to want to will the seven-foot Dutchman to continue as if he had a bet on a Struve victory. It is not the referee's job to give fighters advice on how to continue; he just has to relay to others if the fighter wishes to stop or restart the fight in the middle of the cage.
The pep talk appeared to work and seconds after the fight restarted a desperate Rothwell swarmed the now beetroot coloured giant and stole the victory.
It was an exceptionally questionable move by Miragliotta, but it also led to one of the funniest moments of the year. Every time Struve rose up during his recovery from the nut shots the crowd cheered ecstatically, and booed when he fell back down.
Eventually, the crowd got comically fast at switching between happiness and anger as all it took was a lift of the head of Struve to gain a response. Click the video above to see the hilarious scene.
2. Kevin Sataki Calls A Submission With No Tap - UFC Fight Night: Till Vs. Masvidal
In a thrilling fight, Claudio Silva and Danny Roberts ended up in a scramble with Roberts eventually getting entangled in an armbar. Roberts slammed Silva on his head and appeared to be sliding out of the hold when, suddenly, the referee stepped in to declare the fight over despite no tap happening.
Roberts had bloodied up Silva, was winning the round and the call cost him what was to be a three-fight winning streak. Roberts made his disdain known as he shouted at the referee and hammered his feet into the canvas. The commentary team was just as dumbfounded even when watching the replay multiple times.
It was made even harder to swallow when Roberts gave a tearful post-fight speech about how he had escaped other submissions similarly in the previous rounds, and that his son was in the audience. He would explain he let out a grunt when pulling his arm free which the referee took for a verbal submission
It raised the question: when a fighter vocalizes, does it equal that they are in too much pain? Or are they merely pushing themselves that extra bit to escape a hold?
Roberts never screamed in agony like BJ Penn when he had his foot almost ripped from his leg by Ryan Hall, and he never looked to the referee for help.
Alas, Roberts did vocalize during an armbar and thus became a cautionary warning to others that they better become a mime in similar situations before a loss is stamped on their record.
1. Herb Dean Spoils Ben Askren's Debut - UFC 235
It really couldn't be anything else at number 1. No fight-ending sequence has caused as much uproar as this one in a very long time.
Ben Askren's overdue debut was already as hyped as it could be, with his decade long unbeaten streak and absolutely magic microphone abilities attracting attention.
Finally, in his first fight against 'Ruthless' Robbie Lawler, he was quite literally Angle slammed and almost KO'ed in the first minute. He somehow survived the beating and worked his way into securing a bulldog choke.
Herb Dean would call that Lawler had fallen unconscious only for Robbie to instantly rise to his feet and debate the decision. Replays would show Lawler's arm limply fall to the canvas, then give a thumbs up just as Dean ran to stop it.
The official word from Lawler was that he was perfectly fine. Meanwhile Askren stated he felt Lawler go limp, so loosened his grip and then Robbie came to. Herb Dean has been mixed on his own decision, but the choice was greeted with almost unanimous negativity from every outlet reporting the fight.
There was an outcry for an immediate rematch, but 'Funky' was having none of it and went on to have one of the worst profile years a fighter has ever had. It all began with this stoppage that will no doubt be debated for years to come.
Have a watch above and decide for yourself if the victory was warranted.