10 Absolute WORST Wrestling Moments Of 2023

Buried world titles, the AEW Women's Division, and Cody Rhodes' rubber chicken...

Cody Rhodes Roman Reigns
WWE

The world is an ugly place.

Not to dig much deeper than that - you presumably arrived here for an escape of some kind from thinking about that - but the world's an ugly place, wrestling and wrestlers are part of the world, and some of the things some people within wrestling have said and done in 2023 are the actual worst moments for the industry. But that's the case every year, and regrettably in every industry, so rather than looking at gross facts, how about instead enjoying some grim fiction?!

Professional wrestling can be absolutely anything, which is great because the boundaries of creativity are wider than in just about any other medium. Couple that with the drama of sport and there's a reason why it's the best thing you've chosen to invest your time and money into. Unfortunately, stretching of premises, breaking of in-universe rules and the playing of politics can result in any number of on-screen calamities and callbacks.

Though the peaks were sky high in 2023, the valleys were as low as always. As the year draws to a close, it's time to relive some of the depths...

10. WWE Bury The Lede & The New Title

WWE Night Of Champions 2023 Triple H Seth Rollins World Heavyweight Title
WWE

With vibes around the company's top title already damaged by Roman Reigns' victory over Cody Rhodes and Triple H struggling to shake off a reputation as Vince McMahon/TKO's corporate puppet, the introduction of the World Heavyweight Championship brought about a feeling that the Power was well and truly gone.

'The Game' looked a sorry figure during his April presentation of the new belt, simultaneously trying to bury Roman Reigns for being a part-timer and put him over for being the smartest guy in the company. It was impossible to receive the title as anything other than a compromise and consolation prize, even though inaugural holder Seth Rollins began his quest to legitimise it in earnest over the summer months.

As 2023 draws to a close, the jury remains out on its inherent value while Reigns and also Gunther sit atop their respective thrones, but its reveal was yet another dank moment in the darkest tunnel of Paul Levesque's current run.


9. Adam Cole & Chris Jericho Almost Kill The Town

Adam Cole Chris Jericho
AEW

"Almost" because nothing can kill the 24/7 magic of Las Vegas, though AEW tried when they booked Chris Jericho and Adam Cole to go almost 20 minutes in an Unsanctioned Match that peaked when the 58-year-old Sabu put some JAS goons through tables in the opening seconds.

Double Or Nothing 2023 is typically considered amongst the very weakest of the company's pay-per-views, with a series of gimmick matches doing more to dilute each other than pay off the various storylines feeding into the show.

Cole/Jericho was both a victim of the excess and the primary reason for the disdain. A supposed blood feud descended into parody as the contest become a tonal nightmare and a protracted and unconvincing mess. Easily the worst singles match of either man's pay-per-view career within AEW, it could also realistically be extended to their work beyond the company too.

Ahead of his programme with MJF, Adam Cole's summer was looking in disarray. Jericho, meanwhile, required yet another rethink to pull him back from the brink.


8. Shane McMahon's Return

Shane McMahon The Miz
WWE.com

Sorry, the title was clickbait.

This was the best, obviously, but in an effort to keep this list about the protection of kayfabe and how wrestling is supposed to look, there were fewer embarrassments as grand as Shane McMahon's at WrestleMania 39.

Making his first appearance since being fired by his own Father one year earlier, 'The Money' returned to be the second opponent for show host The Miz in as many nights, generating a nice nostalgia pop that would have at least justified the short brawl had everything gone to plan.

But it did not.

"Shane's still got it", Michael Cole gleefully exclaimed as a WrestleMania rematch ostensibly kicked off, but it was over before he'd completed the sentence - McMahon fell awkwardly on a leapfrog, tore his quad and lay there in agony as Miz improvised a mini-match with Snoop Dogg instead. This calamitous showdown was the last on-screen appearance of the man once considered the heir to the family business. He was left looking at the lights in that respect too.


7. Powerhouse Hobbs Joins QTV

Powerhouse Hobbs QT Marshall
AEW

Powerhouse Hobbs joined two stables in 2023, which is perhaps the problem when he'd spent long enough in one following an impressive 2020 debut.

Back then, Hobbs was the monster force in Team Taz, but when that group naturally dissolved, the last thing he needed was to be cast as a heater for another crew. Twice. The jury remains out on how he will fare as a key component to Don Callis' violent and vengeful Family, but one thing's as good as certain - it can't be worse than when he was inexplicably paired with QT Marshall.

After initially helping Hobbs defeat Wardlow for the TNT Championship to theoretically validate his place alongside him, Marshall completely downgraded the big man's aesthetic via his cynical and lazily-executed QTV stable.

Hobbs had been able to show personality and endless fire alongside the 'Human Suplex Machine'. Neither were on show as a walk-behinder for an IRL backstage producer.


6. Roman Reigns Vs Jey Uso Bleeds The Story Dry

WWE SummerSlam 2023 Roman Reigns Solo Sikoa Jey Uso Bloodline
WWE.com

As of writing, Roman Reigns has wrestled eleven matches in 2023, but it's not just a fantastic contract preserving both his body and his aura.

'The Tribal Chief' has completely transformed the way he works, turning energetic hybrid main events into evocative slow-burners thanks to rivalries with the likes of Sami Zayn, Cody Rhodes and The Usos that have resulted in full arenas and packed stadiums living or dying by the babyfaces in question. Sadly, SummerSlam only brought the latter, and with it a further realisation that The Bloodline should have gone out on top at WrestleMania 39 rather than spending another year trying to extract gold from decidedly silver medal material.

The thing about WWE's fruitful 2023 is that objective business metrics robustly disprove this thinking, but the creative cul-de-sac was reached at the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer'. By the time the hideously drab main event concluded with an Uso-on-Uso heel turn and Roman's lamest retention, the only reason left for the stable to continue was to strap 'The American Nightmare' up 12 months later.


5. Paul Wight Completes A Weird Quartet

WELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL it's Paul Wight
AEW

The former Big Show became a totem for AEW's creative decline in November 2023 when he appeared on the stage of a Dynamite and stood still as Kyle Fletcher ran into his "WMD" fist.

Wight's hire in 2021 was a weird one, but even then he was used as the man to talk about a man - a random appearance on the Revolution go-home edition of Dynamite was was used to tee up Christian Cage's surprise debut. Two years later, and he was the surprise.

As the fourth man joining Kenny Omega, Chris Jericho and Kota Ibushi against the Don Callis family, Wight was seen an aged veteran too far. Just a week after Ric Flair's debut with the group (and 24 hours before his official signing), the organisation felt as far away from its initial mission statement as it had ever been. Wight was not the only symbol of it, but he was fittingly the biggest.


4. Adam Cole, MJF & Roddy Strong's Story Jumps The Shark

Adam Cole Kingdom
AEW

It was sad to watch a hilarious running gag run all the way out of steam as it did when Adam Cole and Roderick Strong's strange bond resulted in a Misery-style capture of the former Undisputed Era leader.

Whatever was due to go down between MJF and Cole following Grand Slam 2023 was parked when the latter suffered a serious injury, but the follow-through and/or delaying tactics soured audiences on the showdown between the "brochachos" before Cole was even out of surgery. Strong as the spurned friend had been a joyously dumb add-on to 'The Salt Of The Earth' seemingly using his devilish powers to corrupt AEW's nicest wrestler. By the time we were watching slow-motion shots of peanut butter sandwiches being made, the entire bit had gone to hell.

Cole's eventual return could make much of these seem merely low-rent in retrospect, but as All Elite Wrestling's creative direction continued to raise questions, four guys drooling over a sandwich with a toy giraffe didn't provide the answers.


3. The Raw After WrestleMania

Brock Lesnar Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Between 2022 and July 2022, the sinking feeling Vince McMahon brought to the collective stomachs of many WWE fans was a dull ache - a pain that had become so familiar that it no longer even hurt that much. A pang once in while, but mostly just an irritation the body had adjusted to over time, occasionally more or less prevalent but always present.Then, he resigned in disgrace.

The changes new creative chief Triple H made in the aftermath were enough for that same core base to wake up each day and noice that dull ache subside. The holidays were atypically healthy, but that was nothing compared to the Royal Rumble-to-WrestleMania run. The pain had completely disappeared - bodies were powered back thanks to an army of exceptional babyfaces led by Cody Rhodes and his euphorically inevitable WWE Championship triumph.

McMahon’s grim return to the seat of power was subsequently a gut punch that, by the time the post-WrestleMania Raw had wrapped, became a a flurry of fists to the stomach. Out of nowhere (or more specifically, his own shadowy regret) his diseased creative was everywhere, poisoning just about everything that had seemed healthy for over half a year.

It was, thankfully, a short-term return. But Cody Rhodes pathetically falling to the floor as WrestleMania weekend concluded made the infection look back, and worse than ever.


2. Cody Rhodes Fails To Finish The Story

Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes
WWE Network

The most divisive and debated storyline moment of 2023 was seemingly as much to do with the reality of a multi-billion dollar takeover than the fantasy escape professional wrestling is designed to promote.

A hot babyface like few in company history, Cody Rhodes had to "Finish The Story" he'd put in place one year earlier and dethrone Undisputed WWE Universal Champion Roman Reigns, but he failed. As arguments raged over how much adversity the character had faced, the importance of Reigns hitting 1000 days with the top title by virtue of the win and just who managed to throw that rubber chicken in the ring next to 'The American Nightmare' living his worst life, things were happening behind the scenes with even bigger ramifications than a storyline belt switch.

After orchestrating some corporate chair-switching in WWE HQ thanks to some grim gamesmanship, Vince McMahon was un-"retired" and overseeing a sensational sale offer that culminated in the company merging with UFC under the newly-combined TKO brand. The stability of Reigns on top seemingly trumped the fantastic WrestleMania story, and audiences were made to wait (at least) another year for the next Steve Austin/John Cena-like figure to finally ascend.


1. The Continued Death Of The AEW Women's Division (Various)

Ruby Soho
AEW

Not a moment on its own, but the constant shortcut and/or under-thought storylines that dictate the actions and outcomes of AEW's female roster remain a source of some significant frustration on a weekly basis, and resulted in countless moments that revealed the worst of the creative process.

The death of the rankings hurt much of the A-to-B booking patterns that used to underpin everything in the company, but when the belts are virtually the only stories, the lack of direction so often results in dour or dry outcomes. Ruby Soho once got a title shot by doing the "I want the belt" hand motion. Toni Storm got enormously over with her new "Timeless" persona, but rather than take the opportunity to tell two stories, she was rushed back into the title picture just to pad time between pay-per-view. Random four-ways that act as shortcuts for storytelling have been reframed as being part of a "rich history", when in reality there's no bigger tell than powerful people haven't given enough of a toss.

Add to the grim fact that Dynamite failed to break its one-match-per-week streak (as of writing) in 2023 and even the lowest bar yet again wasn't cleared. Asking for any kind of change feels futile, and plenty of viewers seem to have glumly accepted the unchanging reality.


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.