10 AEW Stars Who Desperately Need New Gimmicks
Penta Oscuro, Kris Statlander, and other AEW wrestlers in need of a character tweak...
That the average AEW wrestler isn't as heavily-gimmicked as they might be in WWE is to the company's benefit.
In unshackling his wrestlers creatively, not hiring writers, shunning heavy scripting, and largely letting the workers dictate what comes out of their mouths, Tony Khan has cultivated a roster comprised largely of three-dimensional personalities, not caricatures. AEW's greatest characters feel real and authentic because they aren't being shoved into ill-fitting boxes or reading lines they wouldn't believably say. Eddie Kingston, Jon Moxley, Jade Cargill, Bryan Danielson are performers, though their character work rarely registers as a performance.
Even AEW's more outlandish gimmicks show restraint. Kris Statlander is the 'Galaxy's Greatest Alien' but doesn't pilot a flying saucer. The "zombie", Abadon, once bit Hikaru Shida, but you aren't being asked to invest in her literally eating people. Orange Cassidy's laconic hands-in-pockets shtick exists within the confines of accepted pro wrestling psychology.
None of this is to say that every AEW character works, though. Like any other promotion, the company houses a pool of wrestlers hamstrung by their current personas and crying out for something new.
Let's run through them...
10. Kip Sabian
The best thing about Kip Sabian's spot on this list is that it looks like he's about to get a new gimmick.
Calling himself 'The Forgotten One', the 29-year-old recently hit Twitter teasing a run to television after almost a year away from AEW. Splitting from his former 'Best Man' Miro in April, the Englishman revealed he was undergoing surgery, necessitating a lengthy period on the sidelines shortly after he and real-life wife Penelope Ford were married on air.
Sabian has since re-emerged with a cardboard box over his head. Reading "Under Rated, Over It" and with two large eyeholes cut out, Kip and his new attire have been caught in the crowd on Dynamite, Rampage, Dark, and Dark: Elevation without express acknowledgement several times over the past few months. It's a near-weekly occurrence at this point, sustained by fluttering online buzz without yet becoming a fully-fledged storyline.
Whatever form his new character takes, Sabian would do well to break from his old 'Superbad' self. As entertaining as he was, he hit a creative ceiling in the Best Friends feud that he and Miro lost prior to his injury-enforced hiatus, and could use a change if he's to find upward mobility in AEW.
9. JD Drake
This entry comes from a place of love.
JD Drake is incredible, though you wouldn't necessarily know it from his AEW output. Not to dismiss the Wingmen, whose "waxed, vaxxed, and ready for a hot boy summer" schtick is fun enough for a heel jobber crew, but there's a chasm between those wacky characters and what Drake does best. Influenced by Arn Anderson and other territory hard-asses, the 'Blue Collar Badass' is a bruiser, not a jester, and while amusing in his deliberately ill-fitting Wingmen role, he is in a suboptimal gimmick belying his strengths as a performer.
AEW audiences have seen only flashes of what Drake does on the independents. Most recently, he stood up to Jon Moxley and Bryan Danielson in their first tag outing, briefly matching William Regal's violent charges in their extended squash. This should serve as an appetiser for the entree to come.
Repackaged as his hard-nosed indie self, Drake would open many an eye in AEW. Better yet, bring in the excellent, underrated Anthony Henry, JD's WorkHorsemen partner, and let one of the best independent tag teams of the decade do their thing, with Drake as the sh*t-kicker and Henry the gleeful prick luxuriating in his own brutality.
8. Kris Statlander
Kris Statlander's is not a supernatural gimmick. She doesn't bend reality to extent that it's impossible to buy into her existing within AEW's world with its broadly sport-centric ruleset, nor does she do anything that shatters the suspension of disbelief. There are no little green men, UFOs, or special powers. Nose boops, face paint, a nickname, and a few cosmically-themed moves are the extent of the gimmick.
But that doesn't mean she shouldn't switch it up.
The 'Galaxy's Greatest Alien' has taken one of the best wrestlers in AEW's women's division as far as it can. Statlander has relied on boops and other idiosyncracies for too long. If she's to become a standard-bearer, she must develop discernable personality traits and tricks, building a new character to match her tremendous in-ring skills.
Last week's episode of Dynamite hinted at a change, with Kris captured face-to-face with recent failings, wiping her paint away. This was followed by her showing up in all-black attire for Rampage two days later. A step in the right direction, whatever her new persona becomes.
7. Tony Nese
AEW commentator and coach Mark Henry recently said the following of Tony Nese during an episode of Busted Open Radio:-
“I think that Tony Nese is a hell of a talent. I would like to see Tony Nese develop more outside the ring. Tony needs more bells and whistles. He’s a guy that doesn’t jump off the page on the microphone. He seems like a nice guy... the question that needs to be asked to Tony Nese is, ‘Who are you besides one of the best wrestlers in the game today?’ How many people look like Tony Nese? Not many. He is spectacular looking to the eye. How many people can just work any match, any style, with anybody, and do it as fluently as Tony Nese? Not many. So what’s the problem? The problem is identity."
He isn't wrong.
Nese's bout with Swerve Strickland showed his value on a crowded roster. He is the kind of wrestler you bring in to help make others look great, as he'll always do a clean, professional job. Whether working a supreme talent like Strickland or guiding a less-seasoned worker in a smaller spotlight, Nese is going to do exactly what is asked of him. His floor is high. At worst, he'll give you something "pretty good."
But as things stand, all of Nese's strengths lie between the ropes. He is a fantastic athlete with a diverse, exciting style, but these adjectives can't yet be applied to his character, which he is yet to hone.
Finding his charisma would help lift Nese up even in a jobber to the stars role, helping him to a higher hit appearance than the one TBS/TNT match every three months he currently averages.
6. Wheeler Yuta
Told to prove himself after a patented William Regal slap across the face on last week's Dynamite, the time is right for Wheeler Yuta to figure out who he is going to be in AEW.
Introducing the 25-year-old through Best Friends was a good idea, given Yuta's connection to Orange Cassidy and Chuck Taylor, though he is very much behind his trainers, Kris Statlander, Danhausen, and Trent Beretta in the group's pecking order. He hasn't yet demonstrated what's going to make him stick out on the character front, either. Best Friends are entertaining, over, and eternally endearing, but their train will only take a potential breakout star so far.
The former IWTV Independent Wrestling World Champion's brush with Regal, Jon Moxley, and Bryan Danielson should be used as a catalyst to unleash the personality within. He'd make a fine inductee into the Danielson Dojo should AEW choose to go down that route. Alternatively, standing out as a more serious, driven character in the aloof Best Friends unit before eventually splitting off would suit as well.
Yuta is a long-term project whose youth gives AEW and the wrestler himself plenty of time for tweaks and adjustments. There's no express need to package him with an immediately marketable character, though it'd be a shame to see the fantastic Regal interaction go to waste.
5. Varsity Blonds
While it'd be foolish to write such a young group off entirely, the Varsity Blonds are currently close to circling the drain as an act.
Brian Pillman Jr. and Griff Garrison have worked just two televised tag matches this year, one of which was a battle royale. Julia Hart, meanwhile, is in the midst of a Malakai Black-induced transformation. Increasingly aloof and mentally detached from the group, the eyepatch-clad cheerleader has done a great job in her shifting role, particularly with muting the enthusiasm that once defined her, while her House of Black induction is teased elsewhere.
Hart helped complete the Varsity Blonds following her introduction. Now, with their forward motion effectively levelled by the Kings of the Black Throne, Garrison and Pillman Jr. are aching for something new.
The duo have only been together for two years and yet their gimmick already feels long in the tooth. Ditching the varsity jackets and hair metal would serve them well, whether they are to progress together apart, even if it's to be a while before they are seriously pushed.
4. The Men Of The Year
Scorpio Sky and Ethan Page are the most WWE Raw act on AEW Dynamite. This has been true since they came together and while the Dan Lambert/American Top Team affliction has added a new flavour to their original recipe, they still aren't getting over to a noticeable degree.
In particular, Sky isn't drawing consistent crowd reactions as TNT Champion. It's a shame, as he's a great wrestler and Lambert branding himself co-champion is a great bit, but worrying. If audiences are already reacting to heel skullduggery and ill-gotten victories with indifference rather than heat, what's the point?
The current presentation of Page and Sky is too overcooked to land. Goofy rather than loathsome, forced rather than natural, they need to find something that suits them better. Lambert, as divisive as his verbiage can be, is the group's most compelling component at the moment.
AEW should at least try to give Scorpio Sky: TNT Champion a chance to get over, though they're swimming against the tide at the moment. Course correction begins with better, more focused character work that isn't so reliant on over-the-top mannerisms and worn-out tropes.
3. Jungle Boy
Maybe today isn't the day. Maybe it won't be tomorrow, or even a month or two from now. But sooner rather than later, Jungle Boy is going to need to shed the more gimmicky aspects of his AEW presentation if he is to emerge as the company-carrying babyface his Pillar status demands.
AEW has thus far done a great job of highlighting Jungle Boy in 2022. Revolution 2022's Tag Team Title scramble was calibrated specifically to make him look excellent. He has since followed that with good showings against The Acclaimed and Adam Cole/reDRagon, continuing his in-ring evolution while continuing to sharpen up his promo game. Working alongside Christian Cage has helped him in that regard. Though he still comes off shy at times, Jungle Boy is slowly emerging from his shell, bit by bit, segment by segment.
At some stage, though, the 24-year-old is going to need to lose the little booties and other Tarzan-isms. Jurassic Express was an effective vehicle to showcase his AEW run's nascent stages. It can continue, absolutely, but the Boy needs to become a man.
Jim Ross' insistence on referring Jungle Boy by his real name, Jack Perry, may serve as inadvertent future-proofing. A light reboot will eventually prove critical to his long-term success.
2. Penta Oscuro (And Alex Abrahantes)
We arrive at the least effective gimmick in AEW today.
The rollout of Penta Oscuro has been such a flop that the character is already unsalvageable. Introduced with minimal build following a short vignette, we are supposed to receive this darker gimmick as an imposing nightmare even though the company has done nothing to reinforce this. Penta and Death Triangle lost their feud with House of Black. Their only win since Penta's Malakai Black-induced "transformation" was a seven-minute banana skin job on 23 February.
Oscuro's cartoonish presentation doesn't help either. His prop spade and headstone are Fiend-like in that they almost make the gimmick slapstick. Alex Abrahantes's 'Dark Priest' deal, meanwhile, is pure cringe. A nice guy by all accounts, Death Triangle's mouthpiece resembles a pantomime villain more fit for a children's Halloween party than somebody we're supposed to be afraid of.
The whole Death Triangle needs a reboot. Penta is too cartoonish, PAC has nothing to chew on, and Alex is better suited to other roles. AEW might as well rip it up and start again once Rey Fenix is back.
1. Most Of The Dark Order
They're a loveable group, The Dark Order, and each has plenty to offer onscreen and off, but the group has lost much of its purpose since 'Hangman' Adam Page became AEW World Champion. Now, they require a rethink. Page maintaining his friendship with the crew while leaning more towards Jurassic Express as effective allies is a good start that needs to bring substantial change to the Order and its characters.
Evil Uno and Stu Grayson haven't wrestled a traditional two-on-two tag team match since August 2021 and could perhaps benefit from a revamp towards their former Super Smash Bros selves, albeit without the copyright-baiting aspects. Alan Angels lost his mask but hasn't been developed beyond that. John Silver remains a blistering in-ring dynamo, but the Johnny Hungiee bit is now irritating instead of endearing. Ten, for all his brawn, doesn't really do anything beyond standing in the background and looking large.
For what they have come to represent in the wake of Brodie Lee's tragic passing, The Dark Order should always have a place in AEW. They still come off as a lively group of genuine friends on this roster. But that so few of the stable genuinely stand out these days suggests the gimmick needs work, even if the changes aren't wholesale.