10 Bad-Ass WCW Gimmicks Wasted On Terrible Wrestlers

Did Wrath or Glacier make this list? Read on to find out!

After our previous trip down memory lane spent looking at various WWE and ECW gimmicks that could and should have had worlds of potential, but were given to the wrong person, for one reason or another... this one will be hopping the fence to the other side of the Monday Night War, and looking at WCW. Maybe the person just wasn't a very good wrestler, unable to keep the gimmick prospering in the ring. Maybe they simply had a run of bad luck, and things never quite fell into place. Maybe they just had injuries help to take fate out of their hands. Whatever it is, they simply were not able to hold up their end of the bargain after being given something special by writers. WCW has certainly had their fair share of moments and decisions, bad and good, and this will be looking at both sides of that. Sure, they came up with some very good gimmick ideas, but they also decided to give those very good gimmick ideas to the wrong people.

10. Norman The Lunatic

We've seen similar gimmicks and parts of gimmicks since, but with Norman "The Lunatic", WCW had themselves an intriguing take on the "crazy wrestler" gimmick. Norman was portraying someone who came from an insane asylum, but he wasn't just all crazy, all the time. He had multiple sides to him. He had a softer side, too, but being managed by heel Teddy Long, he wasn't always able to be the person he wanted to be. Long would carry a key with him, and the key was indicating to Norman that Long got him out of the asylum, but could send him back to the asylum at any time if he didn't follow directions. We've seen people like Kane have a "I'm crazy, but some dastardly heel has control over me and my actions" phase, but there wasn't the night and day difference between "crazy" and "not so crazy" like we saw with Norman, and the Norman gimmick was happening nearly a decade before we ever knew who Kane was. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yz_kdzRgUJ8 Unfortunately, Norman was a lumbering, stumbling mess in the ring at this point, so the gimmick never really went anywhere, even though he did receive some decent pushes. Fortunately for Mike Shaw (the man behind the gimmick), this was still better than what he got in the WWF, where they turned him into Friar Ferguson (a pissed-off Monk) and then Bastion Booger (a hunchbacked slob who burped and farted all the time).

9. Tank Abbott

Taking someone who has success in the world of Mixed Martial Arts and bringing him to the world of pro wrestling is something we've seen on several occasions in the last two decades. With Tank Abbott, though, there was another level of buzz because he very well might be crazy. People could see him being successful with WCW, but they could also see him taking on the entire arena in a series of fist fights when something didn't go his way. Tank's highlight in WCW might very well be the event that nearly led to him being fired. During a match at the 2000 SuperBrawl pay-per-view with Big Al, both men tumbled to the outside. Tank pulled a knife out, put it to Al's throat, and yelled that he would kill him. Again, a reminder... this happened on live pay-per-view. When that's your highlight, you know things aren't going well. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tsAW8jGukY In another sign of just how poorly his time in WCW went, Vince Russo pitched the idea of making Tank the WCW World Champion. WCW's reaction? They fired Russo. Think about that for a moment. Think about all of the things you feel WCW should have fired Russo for, and then think about him wanting to make Tank Abbott the World Champion as being the proverbial nail in his coffin. Need I remind you that this is the man who made David Arquette the WCW Champion at one point?

8. Asya

If you're running a wrestling promotion, and you decide you want to have some sort of women's division, you'll want to have an "amazon" in there at some point to mix things up. Sure, the "models" can be some nice eye candy, and the good in-ring workers can add diversity, but the "monsters" work well in those divisions, just like they work well in men's divisions. The WWF had a very successful "amazon" in Chyna, who would actually go on to become one of the more over workers in the company, male or female. WCW saw this success, and they decided they wanted to have some of that for themselves. They brought in a female bodybuilder named Christi Wolf, and they could have given her any name on the planet. They decided to call her Asya, in what is probably the most transparent ripoff in the history of the wrestling business. While Asya was very strong and muscular, she didn't have the same stature as Chyna. Chyna stood nearly six feet tall, and actually fit in when standing next to several of the men on the WWF roster. As muscular as Asya was, she was still only 5'3", and the affect just wasn't the same. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMgJtZHmiC8 They tried to push her as a woman that could hang with the guys, but crowds weren't buying it, and she just wasn't very good at her role. Less than a year after she actually began wrestling, the company released her.

7. Ernest "The Cat" Miller

A martial artist in wrestling? Good idea. A James Brown impersonator in wrestling? Interesting idea. If you take the two and put them together, that should be some sort of magic, right? If you throw in a dash of Muhammad Ali-like trash talking, things should have been perfect for Ernest "The Cat" Miller, but they were actually far from it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDgiHgdpPjw Miller was actually able to get over through his promos and his dancing, but when he actually wrestled, the wheels fell off, and everyone could see he wasn't ready. He wasn't even supposed to be a wrestler. He was Garett Bischoff's karate trainer when Garett was a kid. Eric Bischoff saw how Miller was, and invited him to join WCW. That was it. There's no crazy story to it. Had he been teaching karate to just about anyone else in the world, we wouldn't even know who Ernest Miller was, but because he was teaching a Bischoff, here we are.

6. Johnny The Bull

Jon Hugger was another case of someone who didn't set out to become a wrestler, but because of the right circumstance, WCW came knocking on his door, instead of the other way around. As a nightclub bouncer in Atlanta, he worked out at the same gym owned by Sting and Lex Luger, and frequented by many WCW wrestlers while they were in town. One day, Diamond Dallas Page saw him working out and approached him about attending a WCW tryout, and that was that. Given a veiled Italian Mafia gimmick, he was teamed with Big Vito and managed by Tony Marinara (better known as Tony Mamaluke of ECW fame), and received an immediate push. He and Vito won the WCW Tag Team Titles within a month of first teaming with each other. Being a champion didn't do a thing to hide The Bull's inexperience in the ring, though. It wasn't long before they dropped the titles and would be moved back down the card, with The Bull eventually injuring himself and being sidelined for a few months. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DekRoS74748 To his credit, he has gotten better in the ring in the years since, and he's still active to this day, after spending time working in both Japan and Mexico to hone his craft.

5. Disco Inferno

Any sort of dancing gimmick in wrestling can be successful, whether the worker is a face or a heel. As faces, they can be fun "comic relief", of sorts, able to get families involved in the action. As heels, they can be great annoyances, able to get heat from choosing to dance more than they choose to wrestle. As someone portraying a disco-loving dancer in the late-1990s, they should be able to attract a lot of heat, as disco hadn't been worth a damn in 20 years at that point. Disco Inferno was annoying, that's for sure, and from all accounts that have come out in the years since WCW's demise, that annoyance was felt by wrestling fans as well as his co-workers, many of whom haven't had many flattering things to say about him. For all of the annoyances that he caused during promos and backstage segments, he did nothing but cause nap time to hit wrestling fans when they watched him wrestle. He just never really got out of first gear, so to speak, even though the company tried and tried to push him, giving him different directions to take. Nothing quite worked out for him. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sCl6NZLNNI

4. Vampiro

If we're going to be fair, WCW didn't create the Vampiro gimmick. After spending the better part of seven years in Mexico, and doing some minor stints in Japan, Vampiro finally showed up in WCW in 1998. There was a lot of buzz surrounding his arrival, as he was a huge star in Mexico for those years, transcending wrestling and appearing in television shows and movies while he was there. As a dreadlocked, rock star vampire, Vampiro just had a look that captured your attention from the moment you saw him. He was something different, which is always good in wrestling. Unfortunately, he never was that great in the ring, even in Mexico. It was his look that allowed him to become a huge star in Mexico, but that look didn't exactly match the hype he was getting while in WCW. Hulk Hogan praised him as one of the better upcoming stars in the business, and he got to work with the likes of Sting and The Great Muta almost right off the bat, even picking up a pay-per-view victory over Sting (albeit in a Human Torch Match, which goes down as one of the dumbest gimmick matches in the history of the business). That's a lot of pressure to live up to, but things just weren't working the way they once did. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGIISUJCe4k Less than two years after his arrival in WCW, he was gone, and he went back to Mexico and Japan, but even there, he never quite found the same level of success that he had before WCW, almost as if working for them tainted his career and his legacy.

3. 3 Count

Yes, you're reading that right. 3 Count has just been placed in an article discussing badass wrestling gimmicks. The idea of a "boy band" is a good heat-getter and opens the door for plenty of comedic moments. The fact that it took place at a time when boy bands were all the rage in the music world only made it better, as men were sick and tired of hearing from groups like the Backstreet Boys, NSync, and 98 Degrees all the time, while women were almost guaranteed to be in love with these guys from the start. There is a bit of a catch here, though. Evan Karagias? Terrible wrestler. Shannon Moore? Terrible wrestler. Shane Helms? Not a terrible wrestler. Karagias and Moore were definitely given the roles based on their looks, although many people still don't think Helms really fit the "theme" that well. However, Karagias and Moore were, for all intents and purposes, the Kardashians of WCW at the time... famous for their looks, but not really possessing any sort of skills or abilities that made people think they deserved to be famous. The fact that neither of them ever achieved any real level of semi-regular success after 3 Count proves that. Meanwhile, Helms had great success as The Hurricane, as well as when he was using his real name in WWE. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f1HwxjgpOdI

2. Glacier

Sub Zero Glacier The living and breathing version of Sub-Zero from Mortal Kombat. Again... the living and breathing version of Sub-Zero from Mortal Kombat. It should be impossible to not get that gimmick over and make it successful, but Ray Lloyd and WCW made it possible. For five whole months, WCW aired vignettes for Glacier's debut, showcasing martial arts skills and special effects that probably cost a nice chunk of change. Of course, that was par for the course here, as the effects that were needed for his ring entrance cost $500,000 and his entire costume cost another $35,000. That's a ridiculous amount of money spent on one wrestler, period, let alone one that had no history behind him. Oh, WCW. By the way, that costume and those effects lasted a month before they were scrapped, and he would go back on the shelf for a couple months before debuting new ones. Oh, WCW. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jB3C0fflMxQ The entire thing was never accepted by fans, who had already grown tired of him through his vignettes before he even made his debut. It didn't help that he was really bad in the ring, more focused on putting on martial arts exhibitions, throwing kicks and punches at the air, than at actually performing wrestling moves. His nonsensical feud with Mortis, Wrath, and James Vandenberg only made things worse for him. They took an impossible-to-screw-up gimmick and screwed it up. Say it, everyone... oh, WCW.

1. The Road Warriors

Ooh, some controversy to close things out here. Yes, Hawk and Animal formed one of the greatest tag teams in wrestling history, winning Tag Team Titles over 20 times throughout the world in their illustrious careers. However, a bunch of title reigns doesn't mean you're any good in the ring, and that's exactly the case with these two. They were never any good. Ever. They got over because they were two big, bad, face painted freaks who wore giant spikes on their shoulder pads and wrist bands. They were unlike anything wrestling had seen before, and that is why they began to win, win, win everywhere they went. Go ahead and watch any of their matches, though. It doesn't matter when... whether it's some of their late-80s work in the NWA all the way up to their early-2000s work with the WWF... what you see when you watch them is a bunch of sloppy in-ring work, no technical ability whatsoever, complete inability to sell (when they decided they even wanted to try and sell opposing offense, that is), and general carelessness with the health and well-being of anyone they were facing. It's very rare that you'll find a good match of theirs that didn't involve War Games or some other type of stipulation that allowed them to be as violent as possible with having to wrestle as little as possible, and even then, it's not like they made their War Games matches good. They were just along for the ride. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ztRVpp2_hnY They are enshrined in the NWA Hall Of Fame, the Pro Wrestling Hall Of Fame, the WWE Hall Of Fame, and the Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall Of Fame. All the Hall Of Fames in the world aren't going to take away from the fact that they were just never that good. Just imagine how far the gimmick could have gone if two capable workers had donned the face paint and the spikes.

In this post: 
WCW Wrath
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Columnist/Podcaster/Director at LordsOfPain.net for nearly seven years, with nearly 2000 total columns written. Interviewed and/or involved in interviewing the likes of Tyler Black/Seth Rollins (twice), Diamond Dallas Page, Jimmy Jacobs, Christopher Daniels, Uhaa Nation and more.