10 Best Matches From WWE ECW

WWE's ECW was pretty awful, but there are a few matches worth revisiting.

Kurt Angle ECW One Night Stand 2006
WWE.com

Sigh. Oh, what could have been...

WWE's version of ECW had a lot of promise at the start. Hot off the heels of another spectacular addition of ECW One Night Stand, the debut of the ECW brand as its own entity in 2006 had fans genuinely excited for the extreme revival. Sadly, what we got instead was zombies, vampires and one of the worst PPVs of the 21st century.

While both versions of the original ECW One Night Stand format were beyond awesome, the product that followed was simply not what was advertised. The label read "ECW" but the product reeked of WWE...and not even good WWE at that. It was the wrestling equivalent of ordering an English dish from an Indian restaurant; the presentation seemed familiar, but the taste just wasn't the same.

Within weeks, it was clear to see that the ECW presented by WWE was lightyears away from the ECW of old. The gritty presentation, the bloody violence and overall anarchic vibe just wasn't there. However, there were sprinkles of brilliance amongst the sludge of C-show filler.

Several superstars in particular went out of their way to deliver the extreme content that the marquee advertised - and the results made for some truly great matches on an otherwise awful show.

10. Kurt Angle Vs. Brooklyn Brawler (1 August 2006)

Kurt Angle Brooklyn Brawler ECW 2006
WWE.com

On the very first televised ECW event held at the Hammerstein Ballroom since One Night Stand, the hardcore homecoming of WWE's extreme revival was a memorable and rowdy affair.

While the main event of Batista vs. Big Show for the ECW Championship will forever go down in history as the prime example of booking without consideration for the audience, the undercard was every bit what the crowd wanted to see.

One such example of this was Kurt Angle's decimation of The Brooklyn Brawler. The Olympian had undergone a violent rebirth since switching to the extreme brand, and had become noticeably more intense in the ring as well as increasingly more stiff to boot.

Angle's a**-kicking of The Brawler in his hometown made for brilliant TV; the vicious headbutt in the early going from 'The Wrestling Machine' was simply brutal. A quick ankle lock to follow spelt the end for Brooklyn's favourite son, and Angle's transition into the extreme badass of ECW continued.

Angle would wrestle just one more time on TV for WWE, before emerging in TNA two months later, headbutting Samoa Joe and appearing just as violent and intense as he left off.


9. Bobby Lashley Vs. Rob Van Dam - ECW Championship (2 January 2007)

Rob Van Dam Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

Voted by the fans as the No. 1 Contender for the ECW Championship, extreme fan favourite Rob Van Da, got a shot at new ECW Champ Bobby Lashley on the first show of 2007. The all-babyface affair split the audience throughout, with some in support of the champ and others firmly behind the ECW stalwart.

The sheer mass of Lashley saw the bout develop into a strength vs. agility contest. As the veteran, RVD did a great job in carrying the musclebound champ, who was still only in his second year in WWE at the time. Lashley seemed dominant, Van Dam seemed dangerous - it was a great dynamic between champ and challenger. With Angle out of the equation, having left WWE several months earlier, Lashley did his best to fill the void of ECW's resident suplex specialist. Meanwhile, RVD pulled out all the stops to seal victory, including a huge diving clothesline from the second rope to the outside.

Sadly, the move resulted in referee stoppage - which did let the match down considerably and drew the ire of the fans with chants of "bulls**t" as a result.

Had the bout been given a legit conclusion, it would have likely been even higher on this list.


8. Hardcore Holly Vs. Rob Van Dam (26 September 2006)

Hardcore Holly Blood
WWE Network

WWE's ECW isn't memorable for too many matches - however, the Extreme Rules bout between Rob Van Dam and Hardcore Holly is a notable exception. The graphic nature of the injury sustained by Holly was a shocking sight - one that saw repeated air time in the "Don't Try This At Home" videos in subsequent years.

After several minutes of back and forth battling, the two men jockeyed for position as both tried to suplex each other. With a table set up outside the ring, Holly lifted RVD high into the air for a huge suplex off the apron. The landing looked brutal and the table crumpled on impact. Weirdly, Holly came off worse.

The connection had caused the broken table to slice the WWE veteran's back wide open, leaving huge gash across his left lat. The laceration left a wound several inches long. It required 24 stitches to close after the match.

Incredibly, the bout continued for several minutes more - including a spot that saw Holly take a suplex onto a steel chair - before RVD walked away victorious. Despite the loss, Hardcore Holly lived up to his moniker, and gained another measure of respect from the fans in the process.


7. CM Punk Vs. Justin Credible (1 August 2006)

cm punk ecw reboot
WWE.com

From the same card as the Angle/Brawler match, the debut bout of CM Punk in WWE couldn't have happened under better circumstances. With a smart, knowledgeable and vocal crowd on hand, 'The Second City Saint' received a hero's welcome when he arrived in ECW.

Squaring off with former ECW Champion and a man very familiar with the ECW faithful, Justin Credible, Punk was given credible competition in his maiden voyage in the land of extreme. The crowd were pumped from the opening bell, and clearly very eager to see the Ring of Honor legend make his mark.

With a string of unique offensive moves, Punk did just that. In hindsight, the bout itself probably should have headlined the show, as the scheduled show closer between Batista and Big Show bombed dramatically. Nevertheless, the bout was a fitting coming out party for the indie superstar, and allowed Punk to make his first appearance on the WWE stage in style.

Had this match taken place in any venue other than Hammerstein Ballroom, it's safe to say that 'The Straight Edge Superstar' would have likely not received such an overwhelmingly positive reception. The fact that it did set him up on the right path, and made for one of the best starts he could have asked for.


6. Sabu Vs. Rob Van Dam - Ladder Match (16 August 2006)

Sabu RVD
WWE.com

Whether it was with or against each other, Rob Van Dam and Sabu made a great pair in the original ECW, with the two acrobatic extremists sharing the stage at several PPV events over the years. As such, the match-up was a natural fit when the brand returned to our screens in 2006.

Unfortunately, it had been ten years since they first waged war in Paul Heyman's playground. Time had taken it's toll on Sabu in particular in the years since. Nevertheless, RVD and the death-defying maniac were two of the most physically able performers of all the ECW originals. The addition of a ladder made it all the more enthralling.

With the No. 1 Contendership for the ECW Championship on the line, the two men used the lax rules to their advantage, while making use of the weapons at their disposal. While sloppy in parts and far from perfect, it was a cool throwback to yesteryear. Both men did well to cover the other's mistakes.

The match was a true glimpse into the company of old: anarchic, crazy and botchy at times, it was as close to the original ECW as the revived brand ever got outside of One Night Stand.


5. CM Punk Vs. John Morrison - ECW Championship (4 September 2007)

cm punk john morrison
WWE.com

Billed as Punk's last chance to win the ECW Championship, the pressure was on for 'The Voice of the Voiceless' to get the job done when he squared off, one more time, with his long-time rival, John Morrison.

Despite several bouts together, the two had failed to capture lightning in a bottle in their previous outings, having been victims of time constraints and a jarring lack of chemistry. However, on this night, it finally all clicked. The two young grapplers put on a hell of a show with the title on the line.

Given ample time to tell a genuine story from bell to bell, Punk and Morrison gave the performance of their WWE careers up until that point. The bout was a vast improvement on their SummerSlam match a week earlier (that notably lasted half the time). Stiff chops followed by stiffer kicks and a whole lot of drama made this the best of their series - and a win for Punk saw him claim his first championship under the WWE banner.

The clean finish gave Punk the singles victory he needed at that stage of his career, and the genuine reaction of the crowd proved that Punk's ascent up the WWE ladder had well and truly begun.


4. Rob Van Dam Vs. Big Show - Ladder Match (24 October 2006)

Big Show Rob Van Dam
WWE Network

Two months after RVD had wrestled Sabu on ECW in August, 'The Whole F'n Show' would once again find himself fighting under ladder match rules - this time against 'The Extreme Giant', The Big Show.

Despite Show being the ECW Champion at the time, the ladder match was bizarrely not for the title but, instead, for a title match contract. Nevertheless, the crowd were into it every step of the way. The action was thick and fast from the get-go.

RVD utilised his quickness to gain the upper hand on his larger opponent, incorporating the ladder into his existing arsenal and using his famous "educated feet" to deliver some stiff ladder shots to the giant. As a result, it didn't take long for Big Show to see red. The seven footer was also wearing the crimson mask within minutes.

Despite only lasting around ten minutes, Mr PPV pulled out all the stops in this one, delivering all of his greatest hits in pursuit of the contract. The match was a hard-hitting joyride between two athletes that genuinely cared about the brand they were representing.

Both men put their bodies on the line, and the ugly spill over the top for the finish summed up the match perfectly.


3. Ric Flair Vs. Big Show - ECW Championship (11 July 2006)

Ric Flair Big Show
WWE Network

In the summer of 2006, Ric Flair was in the midst of a heated rivalry with Mick Foley that would culminate in an "I Quit" match at SummerSlam 2006. However, before he got there, 'Naitch' looked to prove just how hardcore he was by challenging Big Show for the ECW Championship.

If that sounds a tad insane, it's because it was. Ric Flair was the complete antithesis of ECW, yet it also made all the sense in the world. 'The Nature Boy' was no stranger to blood and violence; in fact, Naitch got more colour in one 2005 promo than the entire PG era combined. If anything, Flair was custom made for the extreme.

Show and Flair really did go above and beyond the call of duty in this bout. Intent on proving that the new ECW lived up to the extreme name, the giant and the legend threw caution to the wind and rode the wave of blood, barbed wire and thumb tacks to create a rare, unexpected classic from the revived brand.

The battle between 'The Dirtiest Player in the Game' and 'The Extreme Giant' made for great TV and, no matter how unlikely it seemed, the action genuinely sucked you into the story, and had the fans believing that 'Slick Ric' could well walk out a 17 time World Champ.


2. Kurt Angle Vs. Sabu (8 August 2006)

Sabu Kurt Angle
WWE Network

On paper, the pairing of Sabu and Kurt Angle was somewhat of a dream match in 2006, pitting two industry icons against each other. In practice, it was also symbolic of the old ECW meshing with the new, as Sabu's extreme ways surprisingly complimented Angle's rugged mat bullying.

With the Olympic gold from Atlanta around his neck, Angle looked all business. It was clear that Angle wasn't going to be intimidated by the extreme credentials of his suicidal opponent - a fact proven by the immediate double leg takedown and the subsequent slaps to Sabu's face.

Angle's viciousness continued throughout, displayed by his rugged manhandling of Sabu and never more evident than his nonchalant fireman's carry on the outside. Angle simply snatched him up on his shoulders and tossed him over to the thinly padded floor below.

Despite the match being contested without Extreme Rules, Sabu held his own against Angle, and proved that he didn't need chairs and barbed wire to get the job done. The grounded offence of Angle against the high flying assault of Sabu made for an entertaining clash of styles.

The match also marked the final TV appearance of Angle's original WWE tenure; he left the company just days later. Angle made his way to TNA shortly after, and wouldn't return to WWE for 11 years.


1. Kurt Angle Vs. Rob Van Dam (27 June 2006)

RVD Kurt Ange
WWE

Having squared off several times in the past - most notably during the Invasion storyline of 2001 - Angle and RVD were undoubtedly the most tenured and skilled performers on the revamped ECW roster. As such, their tussle on the June 27th episode of ECW was a hugely anticipated match-up.

Just days ahead of his scheduled WWE Title defence at Vengeance, RVD would have to take on the Olympian with Edge and Lita watching from the crowd. Worse still, if Van Dam lost, the match at Vengeance would become a three way, making the main event all the more intriguing.

Angle's suplex heavy style blended well with RVD's high octane assault and kick-heavy arsenal, and the two men waged war in a back and forth affair. With big high spots, stiff shots and general disregard for heir well-being showed that neither man was holding back.

Both RVD and Angle seemed intent on creating a match that was as intense and realistic as possible. By the time the final bell had tolled, that is exactly what they had achieved.

RVD walked away the victor, but not before taking a spear for his troubles, courtesy of a guardrail-hipping Edge.


Contributor
Contributor

Occasional wrestler, full-time gym rat and lifelong lover of the grapple game. Would probably buy you a shot of Jack at the bar in exchange for witty banter...and preferably more Jack. @MartynGrant88 for more wrestling-related musings and weight room wisecracks!