10 Best NXT TakeOver Matches Of 2017
Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting
In 2017, NXT was forced to absorb the most damaging knock to what had otherwise become one of the hottest products in all of wrestling. Not the loss of a particular talent, nor an unexpected interjection from Vince McMahon meddling with Triple H's careful plans, NXT was made to face up to an inconvenient truth - it wasn't actually working.
Or, put pragmatically, it was working too well.
As the weekly show became Sports Entertainment's hottest hour in 2014, the product looked bursting from the seams with emerging potential megastars. Between January 2014 and January 2017, 36 talents left Full Sail for the big leagues. The number represented a huge percentage of the brand's golden era, and flooded the split Monday Night Raw and SmackDown Live! rosters with talent already known and beloved by WWE's core audience. On paper it was perfect, in practice it was too often a complete nightmare.
It highlighted how ill-equipped the main roster was at nurturing characters week-to-week. Bonds between audiences and special talents were ripped apart as said superstars were reduced to rank-and-file. Even the most iconic NXT performers were normalised, humbled and abused more by the system than their opponents.
The potentially fatal wound reframed NXT altogether. Why pine for your favourite to make the main roster, when the main roster can't make them your favourite? To be enjoyed for what they are at little else, the isolated TakeOver specials remained just that - special.
10. Andrade 'Cien' Almas Vs Johnny Gargano (Brooklyn 3)
Crafted exquisitely to reflect Andrade Almas' major career upswing after associate Zelina Vega reversed his losing streak, the Brooklyn 3 opener between 'Cien' and Johnny Gargano was a glorious assault on the senses.
Hugely over and garnering massively sympathy following Tommaso Ciampa's turn on him at the climax of the last TakeOver: Special, Gargano was the perfect foil for the rejuvenated Almas, affording him the best match he'd had on NXT to that point as well as briefly welcoming him into the fringes of the #DIY split.
Gargano's acting performance bell-to-bell made the match. As he entered, commentator Nigel McGuinness noted how he just couldn't get over the split, and the obsession revealed itself in his desperation as the match progressed.
Entering a scintillating final stretch, Almas powered out of a Gargano Escape with vicious buckle bomb/running knee combo. Where lesser opponents would have failed, 'Johnny Wrestling' fought back, chasing misplaced redemption against the Mexican star.
Just as Gargano set himself to finally finish Andrade, Vega lobbed a #DIY t-shirt at him. Frozen in regret, rejection and remorse, he was subsequently defeated after a wicked dropkick to the face and a hammerlock DDT. A powerful closing shot of the crumpled t-shirt next Gargano spotlighted the profound turmoil at play.
9. DIY Vs The Authors Of Pain (San Antonio)
The dust had barely settled from #DIY's November Tag Team title celebrations when The Authors Of Pain sent them a very physical message on NXT television. The hefty beatdown was a signal of intent ahead of their San Antonio tussle, but few predicted their dominance would continue so comprehensively.
Paul Ellering's stocky pair weren't the polished duo Full Sail followers had become used to after several stellar years of doubles action post-Ascension. After still looking substantially behind the quality curve at November's TakeOver: Toronto Dusty Rhodes Tag Classic finale, their title victory just two months later was a breakout display.
Credit must be given to opponents Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano for the beatings they were willing to absorb, drawing the duo into their own superbly scripted style as the match progressed. Subduing Akam and Rezar with dives and strikes, Gargano in particular sustained an ungodly sh*tkicking before finally Ciampa's hot tag finally gave the pair hope.
When The Authors powered out of the dual #DIY submission that famously dethroned The Revival though, the Champions were beaten. Gargano was slammed forcefully onto his own partner's chest, leaving them both prone for a Super Collider and title-winning Last Chapter. Thankfully, this story was far from over.
8. Asuka Vs Ember Moon (Orlando)
Ahead of her first crack at the unbeaten Asuka's NXT Women's Title, Ember Moon promised to 'take the division back'. It was the type of grand statement required to somehow inject some believability into her chase. As Asuka's reign grew, so too did the unlikeliness of a challenger ever reaching a point at which they could realistically dethrone her.
Asuka had spent months showcasing the countless ways she could destroy just about anybody that came within a fingernail's scrape of her prestigious title since breezing past Bayley a year earlier, but the challenger needed only one. Her 'Eclipse' finisher (a diving corkscrew Stone Cold Stunner) was potent match-winning weapon that seemed to be the one finisher that was actually 'Ready For Asuka'.
Borrowing an artistic crutch from the maiden Kenny Omega/Kazuchika Okada encounter from January's Wrestle Kingdom 11, 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' simply found a way to stop her using it.
Driven to desperation when she couldn't push Ember to the back of the queue with submissions and strikes, the Champion peered into the dark side for the very first time in her NXT career. Pushing the referee onto the ropes as Moon scaled the corner, the challenger slipped before striking the killer blow. With both the official and her opponent rattled, Asuka almost removed the challenger's head off a kick and retained her treasured crown.
7. The Undisputed Era Vs Sanity Vs The Authors Of Pain & Roderick Strong (WarGames)
A bloody, barbaric and brutal battle, 2017's unexpected WarGames retread satisfied much of the nostalgia fans had for the WCW double cage showdown. The match deserves far more praise for bravely bringing the stipulation into the 21st century with some aesthetically pleasing and creatively malleable new twists.
The lack of wide shots focussing on the structure itself suggested that somebody high up within WWE still doesn't think an awful lot of the two-ring set-up, and may also explain why the roof was extricated beforehand. It was a good decision too - Adam Cole's desperate crawl away from the battle midway through the contest and a latter multi-man high spot from the corner of the cage justified omitting the oppressive ceiling.
Cole, as all great professional wrestlers should, did the most by doing the little, too. Whilst Killian Dain made himself a star by launching his almighty frame around the structure and eating the key that would have released the nine men from the locked cage, the former Ring Of Honor Champion did so by avoiding conflict wherever possible. His 'Undisputed Era' triumvirate won this battle, but with a few echoes of 'The Game' watching backstage, Cole won the war.
6. The Authors Of Pain Vs DIY (Chicago)
Thanks to the unfortunate timing of Tommaso Ciampa's injury shortly after this show. the #DIY implosion story arc may never even earn a payoff worthy of such an incredible build. But really, is there even such a thing?
Going out with a bang (as well as a crash and a wallop), the pair lost their last shot at The Authors Of Pain in another absorbing NXT ladder match with a series of death-defying moments almost entirely overshadowed by Ciampa's heartbreaking post-match assault on his former friend.
Entrusted with the show-closing spot on May's NXT TakeOver: Chicago special, the quartet flew at one another having already given everything to incredible efforts in San Antonio and Orlando (more on that later). The saddest (and most brilliantly booked) fact of of all revealed itself as the duos attempted to scale figurative and literal heights - Gargano and Ciampa couldn't beat The Authors Of Pain.
That nothing in their arsenal would subdue Akam and Rezar long enough to allow them to scale a ladder only made the heartbreaking demise of #DIY all the more depressing. Ciampa let his growing frustration manifest in the form of a brutal beatdown to his closest confidant, but this bruising war highlighted how nothing 'Johnny Wrestling' did on the night would have changed the grim reality. It was, subsequently, a perfect contest for the team and the feud to climax with.
5. Bobby Roode Vs Shinsuke Nakamura (Orlando)
Shinsuke Nakamura and Bobby Roode told a sensational story in a rematch that would prove to be the former's NXT farewell match and unpick any unfair criticism of their choice San Antonio clash two months earlier. Selling the knee injury sustained that night, 'The King Of Strong Style' had to rely on wits as well as kicks, and expressed his refined game plan by going hold-for-hold with 'The Glorious One'.
Assembling a technical masterpiece with one of the best to inhibit the style, Shinsuke tried his best against Roode before again succumbing to the NXT Champion's laser-focussed technical prowess.
After launching Roode across the ring with his arsenal of suplexes and throws, Nakamura rapidly re-built himself as a threat, but his plan fell apart when Roode took out his knee during a failed Kinshasa attempt. Relentless in his assault on the challenger's injured limb, Bobby was sly and nefarious but nonetheless efficient. It also allowed Nakamura to exhibit his underrated flair for desperation, adding a new string to his bow as a sympathetic babyface.
Selling the impact of his own kicks but with little energy left to do much else, Shinsuke suffered yet another brace of Glorious DDTs in defeat. Yet to come close to similar glory in WWE up to this point, the match remains a peak of his North American career.
4. Asuka Vs Ember Moon (Brooklyn 3)
Asuka's final title defence on the developmental brand was not only the best match of her series with Ember Moon, but the best match either had been involved in in NXT and a fitting farewell to one of Full Sail's finest fighters.
In a mesmerising display that saw Moon build on their first match by finally hitting her devastating Eclipse finisher, the challenger gave everything still in vain to the incomparable 'Empress Of Tomorrow'.
Stubbornly refusing to lose having snuck out the back door during their Orlando battle, Asuka shocked her opponent and the crowd in kicking out from the devastating manoeuvre and a follow-up superkick. Shock and awe turned to confusion in Ember, having thrown her best shots at the Champion only to emerge still without a title.
Just as all looked lost for the titleholder, she suckered Moon in to a cross armbreaker, forcing her to agonisingly tap out like so many others had before her. The rivalry was over, as too, we'd later find out was her title reign and unblemished NXT tenure. Like many others to travel through the developmental brand, she left an imprint on Brooklyn greater than perhaps anything she'll ever accomplish on the main roster.
3. Velveteen Dream Vs Aleister Black (WarGames)
A rarity in 2017, Aleister Black's TakeOver: WarGames victory over The Velveteen Dream was a legitimate star-maker for both men. For Dream, it marked a coming out party for Patrick Clark's enigmatic Prince-like act in just about the perfect manner possible.
Beloved by the discerning Houston crowd, the persona had raised the ire of Black on television by forcing him to take the histrionics seriously. The match subsequently became a much bigger deal for the 'Dutch Destroyer'. It was the first angle of any significant emotional heft since debuting for NXT back in April, and afforded the much-touted star an opportunity to build a match around more than just a glittering independent reputation. And what a battle they crafted.
Built on a battle of wills over Black's refusal to merely say Dream's name in the build-up or match itself, fans latched on to the plot when the pair traded taunts in the early going. 'Say His Name' chants got louder, with Velveteen Dream forced to adapt some of his offence in order to not become a complete babyface and hijack the match. It was the act of a professional many years his senior.
His obsession became his undoing, refusing to say die until his opponent said his name. He was leathered with kicks and the Black Mass for the climactic fall. In an ultimate show of babyface respect, Black sat next to him and finally uttered 'Velveteen Dream'. It was wrestling catharsis unlike much else this year.
2. The Authors Of Pain Vs DIY Vs The Revival (Orlando)
The Usos, The Bar, The New Day and The Shield will justifiably gobble up most of the praise for 2017's tag team wrestling renaissance, but none of those quality quartets can lay claim to WWE/NXT's best tag team match of the year.
A mind-blowing festival of action, drama and pathos, The Authors Of Pain built on their January title victory with another worthy effort against the two teams the audience desperately wanted to see restored at the top of the tag team tree.
The Champions even survived brief complicity between fierce foes #DIY and The Revival. Kicking off an incredible sequence, Tommaso Ciampa, Johnny Gargano, Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder collaborated first on blasting Rezar through a ringside table. The smash of his body going through the wood seemed to awaken a logic in the duos, and the four went next for Akam. After Rezar recovered to save his partner from a double submission, the pair were blasted with Meet In The Middle, Shatter Machine and a series of dives between the mixed combos.
Entering rarified air from a booking perspective, a superplex on Ciampa from Dawson onto the other six bodies on the arena floor brought the match's middle section a close when #DIY were promptly pinned at the 20 mark. Without anymore flies to swat, The Authors Of Pain took just four and a half more minutes to dispose of The Revival. It's perhaps the best-constructed multi-man match in company history.
1. Tyler Bate Vs Pete Dunne (Chicago)
More rode on the second high profile meeting between Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne than just the clunky title adorning the 21-year-old's waist. As the two breakout stars from January's United Kingdom Championship tournament, Bate and 'The Bruiserweight' were carrying the weight of expectation and pretty much the entire division as they electrified Chicago with the best WWE-sponsored singles match of the year.
As ITV's World Of Sport offer predictably faded into obscurity, so too did Vince McMahon's interest in his new toy. Network weekly shows turned into one dimly-lit special, with title shots lumped on to NXT to make up the numbers and the rest of the division barely used outside of a humbling week for the whole crew on 205 Live during the company's November UK tour.
This contest was a faint light in the middle of the tunnel.
The British Strong Style partners performed the most amplified versions of their alter-egos, creating a beautiful contrast in how they set about the task at hand. Dunne was deliciously vicious, whilst Bate refused to be drawn beyond his skilled array of moves. Their holds and counter-holds dragged a guttural reactions from the Chicago crowd, with a rare 'Fight Forever' call topped by an almost unheard-of 'UK! UK! UK' chant that would have been trotted out in the 1980s if Jim Duggan was from Exeter.
Pete Dunne's dethroning of his fellow Dudley boy emphasised his mental and physical win. Pushed to breaking after Dunne kicked out from a beautiful corskscrew senton, Bate whiffed on a dive to the floor, making him easy pickings for a Bitter End. It couldn't have been sweeter.