10 Best Options To Be WWE's Next Top Guy

The show must go on, even without the star.

seth rollins
WWE.com

For the last five yeas, Roman Reigns has been pegged to lead WWE in the Hulk Hogan/John Cena role of top babyface. While his fan reactions were usually mixed to negative, he was more or less "the guy" do to the intensity of said reactions, and WWE's insistent push. The company was operating under the assumption that he would be occupying the role or at least the next five years, plenty of time to find a new top face in the process.

Obviously, their plans have now hit a snag. Look, we have no idea what kind of leukemia Roman Reigns has right now, but no kind is to be taken lightly. It could be months before we see him again, it could be several years, it could be never, we just don't know right now, and something tells me WWE doesn't either.

With that said, there's still shows to be put on every week. There's still the matter of SmackDown moving to FOX next fall. Someone has to step up to the plate and be promoted as "the guy" until Reigns can come back, or take the role permanently if he's not able to.

Thankfully, it's not as though WWE are hurting for candidates. While some (Styles, Nakamura) are too old, while others (Strowman) are too one-dimensional, there are plenty of young guys with good looks and great athleticism that, we think, would fill the role of top guy perfectly.

10. Ricochet

Ricochet And Adam Cole 'BayBay'
WWE

Roman or not, Ricochet is destined for main roster stardom, that much is for certain. At 30 years old, the man with springs for knees has been wowing indie audiences for years with his high-flying maneuvers that defy logic. Now the North American Champion, he's established himself as one of NXT's most gifted performers. Regardless of what happens, so long as Ricochet keeps himself healthy, he's destined for the Rey Mysterio superhero slot.

However, with the massive power vacuum that exists at the top at the moment, perhaps Ricochet could be even more. Granted, he has road blocks ahead of him. For one thing, he stands at only 5 foot 9 and weighs less than 200 pounds. Plus, he's never been known as a dynamo on the mic.

That said, I would hope WWE at least consider him for that top guy role. Wrestling has changed so much since the days of Hulk Hogan or even John Cena's heyday. Your average TV viewer thinks of pro wrestling as big meaty guys slugging each other with chairs. Ricochet neither looks nor moves like that, and with SmackDown's impending move to FOX, what better way to change the public's perception of your product than by pushing a guy like that as the centerpiece?

Just as Rey Mysterio created a whole new generation of fans back in Ruthless Aggression, so too could Ricochet.


9. Adam Cole

Adam Cole
WWE

When it comes to look, charisma, and in-ring ability, Adam Cole is the total package (no offense to Lex Luger). Heralded as one of independent wrestling's brightest young prodigies, Cole has made a name for himself to his largest-ever audience over the last year in NXT, heading his own stable and winning titles and accolades along the way.

At 29 years old, Cole has a long time ahead of him to become a top star on the main roster, and it stands to reason that with Triple H gaining more creative control over RAW and SmackDown, he'll be a prime player. The comparisons between Cole and Hunter's bosom buddy Shawn Michaels are unavoidable: both are of similar height and build, they have long hair, they both have cocky, show-off-y personas, and they're the type of guy women want and men... want (bay-bay).

Still, the height and build may play to Cole's detriment. At six foot and 210 pounds, it's not like's particularly small, but in the land of giants, he's of fairly average stance. It'll be a challenge for Cole to convince someone like Vince McMahon to give him the ball and run with it. But with how chaotic things are now and Cole's other strengths, he has as good a chance as anyone else.


8. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

Drew McIntyre has had quite the glow-up (as the kids these days would call it). After getting a huge push in 2009 and being positioned as a top guy, McIntyre sputtered and wound up as a comedy enhancement talent.

Years later, all of that has been swept under the rug. Now the muscle for Dolph Ziggler, McIntyre has been the most pushed and protected member of the RAW roster over the last six months. Many, including Dave Meltzer, have alluded to the similarities between the Shawn Michaels/Diesel relationship and the Ziggler/McIntyre, with Meltzer claiming that WWE plan to eventually push McIntyre as a singles talent the way they pushed Kevin Nash.

From a physical standpoint, McIntyre doesn't need to convince McMahon to push him. At six foot five, 265 pounds, and long, flowing hair, he's basically a Scottish Roman Reigns. From a in-ring standpoint, he has decent to great matches. And he has no problem cutting a good promo.

The obstacles I see for Drew McIntyre boil down to the fans. While right now, they like him as this bad*ss bodyguard for Dolph Ziggler, how they would perceive him as a top singles star remains to be seen. Would fans really get behind him in that role, or would they just resent his looks-based push like they did for Roman Reigns?

Ultimately however, regardless of those hypotheticals, it's safe to say McIntyre is one of the front-runners at the moment to take up that Top Guy slot.


7. Aleister Black

Aleister Black
WWE.com

Here's where we get into dark horse territory. Or should I say Black horse?

No, no I shouldn't. The phrase is dark horse.

Aleister Black is not someone you would picture as the leading player of a brand, let alone be the face of a company. However, Triple H has never been afraid to think outside the box when it comes to his main players, and the former Tommy End certainly defies all conventional boxes. With his aggressive death metal theme, body riddled with tattoos, and vaguely supernatural abilities, Black immediately stood out in NXT at a time when the brand was sort of on auto-pilot and the most they had as far as characters was "hot free agent we just signed."

In the time since, Black has continued to be one of the more beloved babyfaces on NXT, even with the creative renaissance the show has had as of late. He has a unique moveset, his finisher is over, and people buy into the character and aesthetic. Like Ricochet, he neither looks nor moves like what your average person would expect of a pro wrestler.

But again, that would be his biggest hurdle when under the control of Vince McMahon, who will look at the thin, pale, tattooed former NXT champion and say "Gross." Still, if Vince is able to look past his biases and see how he connects to his audience, Aleister Black could possibly be so much more than the next Papa Shango.


6. Keith Lee

Keith Lee
WWE.com

Keith Lee was a longtime veteran of the independent scene, but at 33, there's still time to take him seriously as a potential top guy. A somewhat recent breakout, Lee made major waves in Evolve and PWG with his combination of size, arsenal of power moves, and freakish athleticism. Standing at six foot five and weighing nearly 300 pounds, he's definitely someone Vince McMahon would want to keep around in a prominent position.

Although, maybe he's too big. Vince McMahon certainly loves his big, sweaty men, and Lee is certainly a massive, powerful dude, but Vince also likes big, well-defined muscles. Keith isn't fat, but he is T H I C C (as the children stylize it), and history shows that would put you more in an upper-midcard or main event heel role, but not as the face of the company.

Plus, as Lee learns the WWE style at the performance center, it's possible he'll be stripped of a lot of the athletic maneuvers that made him such a breakout performer to begin with. But if he knows how to work a crowd (and history shows he's very good at that), such a thing should be a minor obstacle. Lee is still early in his NXT run, so we're well off from his debut on the main roster. However, when that time comes, hopefully, he'll get his chance to prove himself as a featured player.


5. Big E

Sheamus Big E
WWE.com

Time was, WWE had big plans for Big E Langston. Brought in as Dolph Ziggler and AJ Lee's silent bodyguard, Langston was a prominent performer on TV throughout 2013. Eventually turning face, he was buddied up with the likes of John Cena and CM Punk, and by the end of the year, was the Intercontinental Champion.

Unfortunately, E lost practically all his momentum, and by the middle of 2014, he was off television. He eventually re-debuted with Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods as The New Day, and the rest is history.

While Big E has maintained a prominent midcard role thanks to The New Day, fans have always thought he could be doing much more as a singles performer, and it's clear WWE thought that at one point as well. Physically, the dude makes up for his short stature with an amazing physique and great power moveset. On the mic, he's easily the most engaging and intense out of his New Day companions, and it's clear online and in less scripted environments he's got charisma and humor for days.

Unfortunately, while it was the New Day that helped Big E get over in a big way, they're ultimately that are holding him back in the long run. While it's commendable that the group are insistent on staying together, WWE historically have never been interested in main event babyfaces as part of stables (the recent Shield reunions notwithstanding).

So with this recent power vacuum that's emerged, maybe it's time Big E really think about success vs. loyalty.


4. Dominik Dijakovic

Donovan Dijak
WWE.com/Bob Croslin

Despite being signed to the WWE Performance Center, Chris "Donovan" Dijak has barely appeared on NXT. Moreover, he's been given a new, stupid name that I refuse to type out (save for the header), but hasn't appeared on TV with said stupid name. Historically, keeping a superstar off NXT usually means higher powers want to put them straight on the main roster when they're ready and not have previous NXT baggage (see also: Braun Strowman, Mandy Rose).

It's easy to see why Vince and his crew would want Dijak to themselves. At six foot eight and 275 pounds, dude has the size that you can't teach, but unlike other giants from WWE's recent history, Dijak has the wrestling acumen to hold his own in the ring. With a diverse arsenal of power moves and aerial assaults, Dijak is a giant who moves like a cruiserweight. Really, if WWE are interested in pushing someone as the next Diesel, forget about Drew McIntyre, Dijak is your man.

Although, as promising as Dijak is, there's still a lot of question marks. From a character standpoint... well, he doesn't really have one. Although, given WWE, they're probably more than willing to craft one to him, and knowing Vince, Dijak is probably someone he'll have a keen personal investment with ("God damn, pal, you're HUGE!!!")

Of course, before WWE does anything with Dijak... lose that stupid name. Seriously, just call him Chris Dijak.


3. Matt Riddle

Matt Riddle
WWE.com

After his career in UFC faltered due to the organization's shady politics, Matthew Riddle decided to switch vocations and traded the octagon for the squared circle. The King of Bros absorbed wrestling like a horse to water, winning the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Rookie of the Year award in 2016, and only getting better since. With breakout performances all over the indies, Riddle has his choice of companies to sign long-term deals with, and ultimately, he chose WWE. Now in NXT, Riddle is set to make his television debut very soon.

Some will claim that Riddle's history of marijuana usage will hold him back in is potential to be top guy. But frankly, that fear is exaggerated. It's 2018, and every wrestling fan knows Riddle smokes pot. And if they don't, they'd most likely shrug at the revelation.

Where Riddle clearly has an advantage is SmackDown's move to FOX next fall. Numerous reports have indicated that the network wants a more sports-oriented presentation and focus than WWE's usual fare. This includes courting UFC Heavyweight Champ Daniel Cormier as a color commentator. Given Riddle's history in UFC, WWE would be foolish to not push him as a key performer on SmackDown in an attempt to court an audience more accustomed to mixed martial arts than sports entertainment.

Plus, from a looks standpoint, Vince probably can't refuse those luscious locks of hair.


2. Kenny Omega

Triple H Kenny Omega
WWE/NJPW

Okay, let's get really ambitious.

So, you're WWE. You've decided you have absolutely no problem taking exorbitant amounts of blood money from the Saudi government, so you're not hurting for cash in the slightest. But you've got some problems Your top star is gone indefinitely with a life-threatening illness. Plus, you have this pesky New Japan Pro Wrestling continuing their expansion into your territory, including your spiritual home. They're not a threat, but they're mightily inconvenient. However, their top foreign star, their champion, has his contract expiring soon, and he's intentionally coy about where his loyalty lies.

So with WWE flushed with cash and lacking a clear top guy... the idea of signing Kenny Omega must be even more tantalizing at this point. Obviously, Omega is a proven commodity as a top guy, even if it's in a much smaller company like New Japan. The fact is: he has the tools that would get him over in any capacity, and if WWE would allow him to be more-or-less himself, he could be a huge asset for them.

Ultimately, the ball appears to be in WWE's court. Do they make the big investment... or do they look to someone who's been there from the start?


1. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins Double Champion
WWE.com

This article has been a fun bit of speculation about the possible futures of guys in and out of WWE. But frankly, when it comes to this immediate power vacuum in the aftermath of Roman's terrible announcement, only one name logically stands out as the guy to pick up the ball and run with it with the most success.

After a tepid year or-so following his return from knee surgery, Seth Rollins has had an in-ring renaissance. The Architect has established himself as one of the company's most valuable assets in terms of putting on must-see matches. Plus, he's finally found his groove as a babyface, and before he was sidetracked by the Shield reunion, no one was as red-hot as him. He was finally the top-tier babyface everyone knew he could be during his championship heel run in 2015.

From a real-life and storyline standpoint, all the stars have aligned for Rollins to once again be on that warpath to the top. His best friend Reigns has lost the title due to a terrible illness, and his other best friend Ambrose has betrayed him. Seth is now the most sympathetic character in the company. Just as Shawn Michaels and Steve Austin nearly lost their careers in 1995 and 1997 just before their ascensions, Seth has that same kind of drama that will have the people totally invested in him.

Needless to say, if the plans right now are not for Seth to win the Royal Rumble, capture the title at WrestleMania, and for WWE to begin the Era of the Architect, they are the biggest fools imaginable.


In this post: 
seth rollins
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A mystery wrapped in an enigma wrapped in bacon wrapped in wrestling listicles wrapped in tin foil wrapped in seaweed wrapped in gak.