10 Best Team Players In Survivor Series History
Who've been the most reliable teammates when it comes to the Survivor Series pay-per-view?
With Goldberg returning to face Brock Lesnar for his first WWE match in 12-and-a-half years, as well as multiple inter-promotional SmackDown vs. Raw matches to look forward to on the card, it’s easy to see why WWE has rolled with the “fantasy warfare just got real” tagline for this year’s Survivor Series.
So in keeping with this idea of fantasy warfare, as well as the Survivor Series theme of team-based action, who do we reckon would be our top picks for an all-time all-star Survivor Series team? In other words, who do we think are the greatest team players in the history of the pay-per-view?
By my humble calculations, we’ve seen a total of 75 elimination matches in the 29 years since 1987, with more than 300 names participating in those bouts. Obviously some have had more success than others though, as we’ll soon see in the coming slides.
Based on factors such as win-loss records, appearances as captain, sole survivals and total eliminations, this article takes a stab at listing ten of the very best team players in Survivor Series history.
10. Christian
With nine Tag Team Championships to his name, it’s fair to say that Christian is something of an expert when it comes to working in a team. And the success he enjoyed in two-man action seemed to translate fairly well to these multi-man Survivor Series bouts.
Christian’s featured in four elimination matches at the PPV over the years, helping himself to a handy six eliminations in the process.
Two eliminations in 1999 were followed by another one the following year, and he’d be back in the mix in 2003 before picking up another pair in 2009. However, it’s noticeable that in each of those appearances he actually ended up on the losing side. Every single time.
Ultimately, it looks like Christian could be a good guy to have around to consistently score some eliminations along the way, but he’s arguably not the greatest omen for success. Think of him as the wrestling equivalent of Gareth Bale during those early days at Tottenham.
9. Roman Reigns
Roman Reigns makes it onto this list despite having only appeared in one Survivor Series elimination match in his four-year WWE career. Still, that one appearance also happened to be a record-breaking one, as Reigns took the term “one-man team” to a whole other level.
In 2013, when teaming with his Shield brethren, Cesaro and Jack Swagger to face Cody Rhodes, Goldust, the Usos and Rey Mysterio, Roman Reigns absolutely cleaned house. He managed to knock off Jimmy Uso, Rhodes, Goldust and Mysterio to end the match as the sole survivor and with four eliminations to his fast-rising name.
No one else in WWE history has ever been able to match that tally of four pinfalls in a single match, making Reigns exactly that type of guy you’d fancy having on your side.
Incidentally, the only opponent he failed to pin was his cousin Jey Uso, and the man who pipped him to the punch on that one was his friend-turned-foe-turned-friend again—and partner at this year’s Survivor Series—Seth Rollins.
8. Rey Mysterio
As Mick Foley will try to tell you, it’s not the size of the dog in the fight, but the size of the fight in the dog that counts. And in the diminutive form of Rey Mysterio, we have perhaps the most telling example of that phrase.
Mysterio made a total of six appearances in Survivor Series elimination matches, eliminating an admirable eight victims along the way and ending with an even more impressive record of five wins and just the one defeat.
That one loss was of course the aforementioned beating he took from Roman Reigns in 2013, but given that it came at the twilight of his WWE career I think we can overlook that one blemish.
Mysterio’s also had a pretty good knack of lasting through to the bitter end—something that our earlier entrant Christian struggled with. In total, Mysterio’s finished as one of multiple survivors in three of his five victories, making him a useful addition to any team.
7. The Rock
On paper, the Rock’s numbers may not be quite as strong as those of Rey Mysterio; he has just two wins and seven eliminations under his belt, although admittedly he was rather prolific with his septet coming from just three appearances.
Still, it’s the significance of those victories and eliminations that make the Rock such a coveted teammate when it comes to Survivor Series matches. His first win arrived in what was actually his official WWE debut; a four-on-four clash at Madison Square Garden at the 1996 PPV. Undaunted by the occasion, a rookie Rocky scored two eliminations to finish as his side’s sole survivor, but it was five years later that we’d see his best performance at the Thanksgiving showcase.
Representing Team WWF, he was instrumental in helping his side to victory, in what was arguably the most important elimination match in the show’s storied history (with kayfabe, of course).
Rock took out a star-studded cast of Booker T, Kurt Angle and finally Stone Cold Steve Austin to finish the match as the sole survivor after a 45-minute epic. Not a bad pick at all for Vince McMahon’s Team WWF.
6. Big Show
With a record-equalling 13 total eliminations to his name, you may be questioning why Big Show isn’t ranked a little higher on this list. For your answer, look no further than the 2014 PPV when Show turned on John Cena, his team captain, and very nearly cost his side the match.
After knocking out Cena and allowing Seth Rollins to pin him, Show then revealed that he was actually in cahoots with the Authority before walking out on Dolph Ziggler, his one remaining team member.
That being said, beyond that treachery the big man does have a pretty impeccable record, including a near-clean sweep in his Survivor Series debut in 1999.
With the odds against him in one-on-four action, Show eliminated Mideon, Prince Albert and Viscera, and would probably have done the same to the Big Boss Man had his opponent not chickened out and fled the arena.
At the end of the day though, that doesn’t change the fact that he remains a turncoat, which isn’t really the best way to define a true “team player”.
5. Shawn Michaels
It’d take a bold man to opt against having Shawn Michaels on his Survivor Series team, given that he's racked up a mighty 12 eliminations to his name. Now, that figure may not necessarily be quite as many as the Big Show’s, but what makes Michaels a more desirable ally is that he's never turned on his teammates before.
Or at least, he hasn’t done so intentionally. There was the incident in ’94 when he inadvertently clocked Diesel with some Sweet Chin Music when Razor Ramon ducked at the last minute, and that kerfuffle did lead to his side’s eventual demise and defeat. Other than that though, Michaels has been one of the most memorable performers in Survivor Series history.
On top of the dozen eliminations he's clocked up, he’s also ended up on the winning side on five separate occasions. However, he’s also been eliminated a joint-record eight times (tied with Kane, of all people) so perhaps I’m being a little generous here.
Still, while he may not have been one for surviving all the way to the end of the match, he was always a safe bet to pick up some scalps before eventually bowing out—making him something of a strategic choice of teammate, I guess.
4. John Cena
In John Cena, resident company poster-boy and babyface extraordinaire, you’ve got yourself one of the most reliable Survivor Series teammates in WWE history.
Cena has twice been named as the captain of his team, first in 2006 and again in 2014 when he helped his side defeated Team Authority, thus ousting Triple H and Stephanie McMahon from power. For like, three weeks, at least.
In fairness, Cena doesn’t have too many eliminations to his name, but he more than atones for that by the fact that he’s often on the winning side. In fact, John Cena is always on the winning side, with an immaculate record of 4-0 from his appearances in 2003, 2004, 2006 and 2014.
That kind of a success rate, combined with the leadership qualities he’s shown time and again—not to mention the fact that the guy’s very motto is “Never Give Up”—means that even the most jaded of PG-era fans would be clamouring to have Super-Cena on their team.
3. Ultimate Warrior
Speaking of immaculate records, the Ultimate Warrior actually matches John Cena with a 4-0 record from his Survivor Series matches, including two contests in the space of one night at the 1990 extravaganza.
Plus, Warrior managed to pick up some extra eliminations along the way, pinning Ron Bass and Greg Valentine in 1989, Arn Anderson and Bobby Heenan in 1988, as well as Ax, Mr. Perfect and Hercules in that 1990 double-header. For me, that’s enough to see him placed ever so slightly ahead of Cena.
Warrior was a pivotal player and a staple part of the Survivor Series diet in the PPV's embryonic years, and it certainly shows in his stats at the event.
And on top of all of this, he was also the sole survivor on a staggering three separate occasions to make for a truly formidable Survivor Series record. In fact, only one other man in company history can match those three sole survivals—more on that story shortly though.
2. Hulk Hogan
Another man who was rather instrumental in the early days of Survivor Series was Hulk Hogan—perhaps even more so than Warrior was.
Hogan actually has the exact same number of eliminations as Warrior, with his list of victims including Butch Reed, Haku, Ted DiBiase (twice), Dino Bravo, the Barbarian and Paul Roma. However, he can’t quite match Warrior's immaculate record as he actually lost in his appearance at the first-ever Survivor Series in 1987, though that was due to shenanigans from King Kong Bundy and the One Man Gang. Or rather, a two-man gang then.
Beyond that though, Hogan has been a pretty stellar team player, captaining his sides on two occasions and finishing up as a sole survivor in another pair of outings.
Ultimately, its actually pretty difficult to decide who had the better record between Hogan and Warrior, but I’ve given Hogan the nod on this one simply because he tended to be billed slightly higher than Warrior during those early Survivor Series PPVs.
And besides, everyone wants to be on the popular kid’s team, right?
1. Randy Orton
Earlier I mentioned that Big Show had the joint-most eliminations in Survivor Series history, and Randy Orton is the man with whom he shares that accolade. That factoid is only a fraction of Orton’s overall Survivor Series résumé though.
On top of his 13 eliminations of Rob Van Dam, Shawn Michaels (twice), Edge, Triple H, Kofi Kingston, Batista, Mark Henry, Christian, Dolph Ziggler, Jack Swagger, Hunico and Alberto Del Rio, he’s also finished as the sole survivor in three successive years (another record he shares, this time with the Ultimate Warrior) while he’s also been listed as a team captain on a whopping four different occasions.
Plus, he was a co-captain alongside Edge in 2006, making him arguably the most seasoned veteran, as well as one of the most successful, when it comes to the Survivor Series elimination match.
It’s a pretty incredible record, and one that makes him my pick as the best team player in Survivor Series history—something that could well bode nicely for Team SmackDown at this year’s PPV.