10 Best (Worst) Wrestling Horror Matches

Terrifying or terrible?

The Undertaker Casket
WWE.com

At WrestleMania, Bray Wyatt conjured up images of bugs to try and shake Randy Orton during their WWE Championship match, but it was all for naught. Orton was unfazed by the mysterious apparitions, and managed to defeat Wyatt in order to claim the championship.

Wyatt's tricks weren't quite done yet, though. After Orton's win, Wyatt challenged the new champion to a "House of Horrors" match. While fans learned that the bout would take place at Raw's Payback PPV on April 30 (Wyatt was drafted to the Raw brand on April 10), no details regarding what the match actually entails have been released.

Perhaps it's just as well that things are kept under wraps for as long as possible. In the history of pro wrestling, horror-themed matches tend not to go off so well. While there are some notable exceptions, that level of gimmickry often lends itself to cartoonish overbooking, and the results are often a little inconsistent to say the least.

Which offenders are the worst of the worst, and which ones often enhance a battle? This list counts down 10 horror-themed matches that run the gamut from good to so-bad-they're-acutally-pretty-good. Hopefully, the "House of Horrors" match is more the former than the latter, but let's not get our hopes up.

10. Hell In A Cell Match

Undertaker Foley Hell in a cell
WWE.com

While not specifically a horror-themed match the way that most of the other entries on this list are, the intimidating name (and, of course, the terrifying legacy) of Hell in a Cell ensures that it belongs alongside the scariest match stipulations in wrestling.

The very first use of the stipulation - which sees a gigantic, roofed cage covering the ring and surrounding area - came at Badd Blood '97 and saw The Undertaker beat Shawn Michaels to a pulp... until the evil Kane made his debut, ripped the door off the Cell, and attacked The Undertaker. If that wasn't enough to cement the Cell as absolutely horrifying, the second major Hell in a Cell match - pitting Undertaker against Mankind - was one of the most brutal bouts in wrestling history.

There's no doubt that the gimmick has been watered down and used for nonsense over the years - just think about the Kennel From Hell match and The Undertaker's hanging of The Big Boss Man - but the announcement of the right Hell in a Cell bout will still strike terror in fans' hearts.


9. Casket Match

Daniel Bryan Kane Casket
WWE.com

A casket match (or, if you're a Lucha Underground fan, "Grave Consequences") is The Undertaker's specialty. For years, 'Taker would subject his most hated foes to the bout, in which a competitor could only claim victory by shutting his opponent inside an airtight casket, simulating the pre-burial process of handling the dead. Foes like Yokozuna, Mabel, and The Big Show all suffered this fate.

Casket matches are a variation on the whole "getting somewhere/retrieving something" theme that's so prevalent in stipulation matches, but with the added element of having to drag one's opponent along for the ride. That can make the bouts slow at times, but the casket leaves plenty of room for swerves - at In Your House: Beware of Dog, Mankind was lying in wait in the casket during the match, and he attacked The Undertaker when it was finally opened, helping Goldust claim victory.

With the apparent retirement of Undertaker and the inactivity of Kane, the casket match has seen its best days come and go - but odds are, one'll pop up when fans least expect it.


8. Last Ride Match

For those occasions when a death metaphor is necessary but a casket simply isn't enough, there's the Last Ride match. Named after The Undertaker's erstwhile finishing move, the Last Ride match is similar to an Ambulance match in that the object is to throw an opponent into a vehicle and drive it out of the arena - only in this case, the vehicle in question is a hearse.

To date, there have only been two Last Ride matches, and it's doubtful that anyone is clamoring for more. The first, at No Mercy 2004, saw Undertaker challenge JBL for the WWE Championship. Undertaker was dominant, but Heidenreich interfered on JBL's behalf, knocking Undertaker out with chloroform and putting him in the casket. That wasn't enough to put Undertaker down for the count, but a further assault from Heidenreich and JBL allowed Paul Heyman to drive The Undertaker out of the arena, where Heidenrich subsequently drove a car into the hearse, causing an explosion.

The second match, which was better, saw Undertaker defeat Mr. Kennedy, marking the only time he ever drove a vehicle that wasn't a motorcycle or a limousine used to kidnap someone.


7. Buried Alive Match

Undertaker Buried Alive
WWE

Completing WWE's death trifecta is the Buried Alive match, a thematic successor to the Casket match. Both bouts involve putting an opponent somewhere that he doesn't want to be, then covering him up to bring an end to the match. In this case, though, there's a whole cemetery setup by the ring, including an open grave just hungering for a warm (cooling?) body.

In a sport where a lot of the time less is more, the Buried Alive stipulation often takes away from the quality of a bout. The stuff that starts out the match - in the ring - can be good, but as the bout progresses, it's just a lot of brawling in dirt while trying not to fall. It also takes a lot to put a guy down long enough to be buried, so usually other wrestlers or backhoes get involved. It's a big mess in more ways than one.

Still, if Undertaker ever wrestles again, maybe it should be in a Three Stages of Hell match - first a Casket match, then a Last Ride match, and finally a Buried Alive match. No? Okay, maybe not.


6. Boiler Room Brawl

Big Show Mankind Backlash 1999 Boiler Room Brawl
WWE Network

The Undertaker isn't the only WWE superstar with horrifying specialty matches. Hardcore legend Mankind - who was purportedly from "The Boiler Room" - took on hated foes in the Boiler Room Brawl.

The rules of the Boiler Room Brawl weren't particularly consistent, but they always involved fighting in a dank boiler room filled with weapons. In the first appearance of the match, at SummerSlam 1996, the winner would be the man who could not only escape the boiler room, but make his way to the ring and take Paul Bearer's urn from him. This match was unique - not only was it the only good Boiler Room Brawl, but the first part of the match (in the room) was actually pre-taped. The rest of the bout - when Mankind and Undertaker fought to the ring and Bearer turned on Undertaker - occurred live.

Three other Boiler Room Brawls happened in 1999, with Mankind wrestling Big Show once and Triple H twice. In these, the point was simply to escape the boiler room, and they were complete messes.


5. Inferno Match

Kane The Undertaker Inferno Match
WWE.com

Wrestlers can work a punch or a Tombstone Piledriver, but they can't really work fire. With that in mind, the Inferno match - which happened four times between 1998 and 2006 - was always a sight to behold, even if the matches in question weren't the best of the best.

The match was a staple for Kane, who according to WWE lore, was burned and presumed dead in a childhood fire set by his brother, The Undertaker. That seemed to make Kane comfortable around fire - unless he got too close. The brothers clashed in the first Inferno match at Unforgiven 1998, with flames rising up from under the ropes and the object of the match being to set one's opponent on fire.

Needless to say, it couldn't have been comfortable working around so much fire, and the match was more spectacle than athletic contest. Undertaker won, tossing Kane's foot in the flames. In subsequent matches, Kane would lose to Undertaker and Triple H, which pretty much had to happen, given that Kane wore a full-body costume. The match came out of mothballs in 2006, where Kane finally won in a bout with MVP, before making a rare return for Bray Wyatt's 'Ring of Fire' contest opposite 'The Big Red Machine' at Summerslam 2013.


4. Graveyard Match

Demon Vampiro
WWE

Quick, what's the only way to make a Buried Alive match even worse? If you said, "Make the whole thing take place in a graveyard with really bad lighting," congratulations - you could have worked for WCW. Unfortunately, the company's been out of business for 16 years.

In 2000, Vampiro got a major heel push that led to some moments that were memorable for all the wrong reasons. He feuded with Sting (more on that later) and The Demon, battling the latter in a Graveyard Match at Bash at the Beach 2000. Though the match was less than seven minutes long, it felt a whole lot longer, and saw the two men fight around a barely-visible cemetery and down by a river. In the end, Vampiro managed to lock The Demon in a casket and throw him into an open grave, so apparently, he won.

This was the only Graveyard Match in WCW history, though Vampiro and Sting did have a poorly-lit brawl in a cemetery on an episode of Nitro two months earlier.


3. Human Torch Match

Sting Vampiro Human Torch Great American Bash 2000
WWE.com

Just a month before the Graveyard Match, Vampiro took on Sting in a Human Torch Match at The Great American Bash 2000. Unfortunately, it wasn't a contest to see who owned more Fantastic Four comics; like the Inferno Match, it was about setting one's opponent on fire, and like the Graveyard Match, WCW put a unique spin on it.

At the beginning of the match, Sting appeared on top of the TurnerTron with a torch, telling Vampiro that he'd have to meet him up top to fight. Vampiro did, and they fought on the screen, then down to the ring, and finally up the screen again. Nobody really remembers that, but everyone who saw the bout remembers the ending.

Sting ducked out of view of the camera, allowing a stuntman dressed as the former WCW Champion to take his place. Vampiro then took the torch and lit "Sting" on fire, and the flailing Stinger fell off of the 'Tron, crashing to the entrance stage in a blaze.


2. Clockwork Orange House Of Fun Match

Clockwork Orange House Of Fun
TNA

A Clockwork Orange House of Fun Match (or simply a "House of Fun" match, if you don't want to get sued by the Burgess estate) was a creation of Raven's, both on- and off-screen, in TNA. The match saw poles attached to the ring posts, chains suspended from the poles, and weapons (and sometimes steel cage panels) attached to the chains.

The match made several appearances in TNA during the company's early years, usually with Raven involved. The first time, the way to win the match was to knock an opponent off a scaffold and through a pair of tables, but later, it just became a falls-count-anywhere match.

So with all the refuse and metal in the ring, were the bouts any good? Not usually - typically, the whole thing was an overbooked mess. In an interesting historical tidbit, though, CM Punk - who was aligned with Raven in the early days of TNA - competed in a House of Fun match. Odds are that it didn't make the list of Punk's career highlights.


1. Chamber Of Horrors Match

Again, there's no telling what the House of Horrors Match between Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt will look like, but one thing's for sure - if it turns out to have anything in common with WCW's Chamber of Horrors Match, people will be talking about it for a long time... and not for the right reasons.

At Halloween Havoc 1991, Sting, The Steiner Brothers, and El Gigante took on Abdullah the Butcher, Vader, Cactus Jack, and The Diamond Studd in an eight-man tag cage match. The structure had a special roof piece attached, making escape impossible. So far, so good, right?

The problem is that the match could only end after a second, smaller cage - with an electric chair inside - was lowered into the ring. Then, one team would have to force an opponent into the chair and throw the switch, "electrocuting" him. If that weren't bad enough, the switch kept falling down during the bout, hammering home that the whole thing was fake.

Abdullah the Butcher ended up strapped to the chair for a lame fireworks display, ending the bout. In the 26 years since, nothing similar has been tried... except, perhaps, until April 30?


Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013