10 Best Wrestlers Of 2019 (So Far)
All of these men & women are having better years than Seth Rollins.
A sacred cow amongst WWE fans and a tremendous performer he may be, but Seth Rollins put his foot in the muck with a pre-Stomping Grounds tweet claiming the PPV would show the "best pro wrestling on the planet," then doubling, tripling, and quadrupling down.
Perhaps these tweets wouldn't resonate so poorly had WWE's 'Beast Slayer' not laid a colossal egg in the aforementioned show's main event. Regardless, having only one truly great singles match (vs. AJ Styles) means Rollins has no place on our list, despite his obvious skill and popularity.
He isn't the only notable honourable mention, with Daniel Bryan falling out of contention after a lacklustre post-WrestleMania run, Kazuchika Okada suffering through a lack of high-calibre singles bouts, and injury robbing Tommaso Ciampa of a spot. Indie standouts PAC and Rey Fenix almost made it. Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks, shoe-ins in any other year, haven't worked enough matches to justify their inclusion, despite their obvious impact on the business in 2019.
Matches, promos, character work, presence, aura, and charisma comprised our criteria's backbone, as did how well the performers come off in their respective environments. You can't be a 'best in the world' contender if you aren't showing it...
10. Jon Moxley
Volume is not on Jon Moxley's side, with the former Dean Ambrose working just four bouts (one of which was against Big Cass, for goodness sake) since breaking free from his WWE prison. Regardless, the speed at which he has gone from burned-out Sports Entertainment rodeo clown to legitimately the hottest thing in the wrestling justifies his inclusion.
Bantered off for much of his dying WWE run, the 33-year-old nonetheless played a key role in Fastlane 2019's blistering Shield six-man versus Baron Corbin, Bobby Lashley, and Drew McIntyre. He has since partaken in one of the most memorable debuts in recent memory, attacking Chris Jericho, an official, and Kenny Omega at AEW Double Or Nothing's conclusion, placing him back amongst the sport's most buzz-worthy, then enhancing his star further with a brilliant, bloody brawl to snatch Juice Robinson's IWGP United States Title in NJPW.
A G1 Climax run now beckons for Moxley, who's already back to the best version of himself less than two months after leaving WWE. An electric presence on any show, his post-Stamford promo and character work have been exemplary and if the Robinson match is evidence, his G1 stint should shoot him further up this list.
9. Bayley
From the depths of despair in 2018 to the pinnacle of the profession a year later, Bayley's journey to blue brand supremacy has been as challenging as the rest of her main roster career, but 2019 reflects the best consistent period she's had in the company since her 2016 call-up.
Contesting the most underrated match of Ronda Rousey's remarkable run, 'The Hugger' then moved into the tag team ranks with Sasha Banks to help establish new doubles straps the pair had clearly campaigned hard for.
Rewarded with what appeared to be a passion project run across all brands, the pair were perplexingly put out to pasture by The IIconics in a WrestleMania 35 four-way that had ramifications still being felt months later.
Infuriated by the wanton destruction of all they'd worked for, 'The Boss' pied her bosses entirely, freeing Bayley up for a singles stint on SmackDown that has thus far totally transformed her career. Finding the edge her brilliantly-drawn NXT persona occasionally deployed, she claimed the Money In The Bank contract and SmackDown Women's Championship on the same night, earning thunderous reactions in the process.
Booking is everything with Bayley - 2019's thus far been a welcome reminder that the wrestling is evidently the easy bit.
8. Matt Riddle
Scintillating performances on the high-pressure TakeOver stage augmented by spirited television performances have expedited Matt Riddle's NXT progress quicker than a Bill Goldberg squash match, but the 'Original Bro's second half of 2019 could be even more important than all he's achieved thus far.
A brutal and creative battle with Kassius Ohno wrong-footed Mauro Ranallo at TakeOver: Phoenix before Riddle advanced beyond banterific beginnings to absolutely kick the f*ck out of matches with Velveteen Dream and Roderick Strong on TakeOvers New York and XXV respectively.
Presenting both sides of his offering, the former MMA star pumped nuance by the bowlful into his battle with Dream, babyfacing the cocky youngster with his offence until the North American Champion picked his spot to retain his title. In contrast, the contest with Strong was a back and neck-cracking war of attrition, won by Riddle at his most earnest following a breathtaking sequence that wouldn't be topped until the show's transcendent main event.
Riddle is an NXT Champion-in-waiting for whoever escapes the epic Adam Cole/Johnny Gargano feud with the strap, particularly if any of the current crop get a call-up.
7. Adam Cole
So much more than just the other half of an instantly iconic series, Adam Cole's 2019 can't be discussed without mention of somebody else on this list. But more in detail on him later. As for their matches though...whew.
Stepping in for the injured Tomasso Ciampa for a match initially crafted to pay off a three year story, Cole instead wrote his own one with Johnny Gargano, redrafting every wrestling headline in the process. Their TakeOver: New York 2-Out-Of-3 Falls Title match was a masterpiece of all the genres it straddled, popping the f*cking hearts out of an explosive Brooklyn crowd whilst earning Dave Meltzer's highest ever WWE/NXT star rating.
The leader of the Undisputed Era started 2019 making big promises about his group grabbing all the gold, and made good on his end of the deal with a TakeOver: XXV victory over 'Johnny Wrestling' in a match almost as good as their frenzied first. That they managed to deliver on that expectation was another unfathomable personal and professional victory.
The best character and all-round worker on the entire roster, howls for his call-up are perhaps misguided - WWE has now proven itself so dreadful at this bit of the process that it's far more satisfying to see the likes of Cole shine on this "smaller" stage than be dulled by supposedly grander ones.
6. Hiroshi Tanahashi
It's unlikely that Hiroshi Tanahashi somehow can recapture the magnetic form that led him to out-of-nowhere 2018 G1 Climax glory in this year's tournament, but the 'Ace Of The Universe' continues to defy expectations and his own aging frame with evocative encounters that refuse to compromise on the requisite NJPW physicality.
A symbolic and sensational Wrestle Kingdom 13 IWGP Heavyweight Championship victory over Kenny Omega in January proved Tana's sustained worth at the very highest level before he used some of his seemingly-limitless star-making finesse in surrendering the strap to Jay White at New Beginning a month later. Injuries forced him out of action in an interim that saw 'Switch Blade' drop the prize to Kazuchika Okada, but a rematch between the pair underneath the Best Of The Super Juniors Final was a contest that rivaled the titular headliners and revealed yet another level to their incredible chemistry.
Ailing frame notwithstanding, Tanahashi will tangle with Okada, Ospreay, Zack Sabre Jr and Kota Ibushi in G1 A Block battles sure to steal the shows they're on and remains a vital part of the organisation as they continue their post-Elite rebrand.
5. Kota Ibushi
Your take on Kota Ibushi's 2019 likely depends on your tolerance for what we at WhatCulture HQ call Neck Stuff ("Neck Sturf," if you're nasty): the wild, reckless, career-shortening head drops and bumps that so often push NJPW's modern take on Strong Style through dangerous, controversial territory.
Those who can stomach it would be hard pressed to argue Ibushi's place among the best in the world. Teetering perilously on the edge of control while well as highlighting obvious safety concerns, the violent Naito series has won widespread critical acclaim, with each instalment somehow escalating the intense psychology. Elsewhere, matches with Will Ospreay and Zack Sabre Jr. have hit similar high notes sans the terrifying risks.
Having finally signed the 'Golden Star' to a full-time deal, NJPW are about to strap the rocket to Ibushi. Shedding the IWGP Intercontinental Champion makes him a clear G1 Climax favourite. The bracket layout means potential barnstormers with Kazuchika Okada, Hiroshi Tanahashi, Ospreay, and more already lie in wait, and if he triumphs, the enigmatic daredevil will ascend into the main event slot that has eluded him for so long. Miss the electrifying, eye-popping wrestling genius' rise at your peril.
4. Shingo Takagi
NJPW have handled Shingo Takagi marvellously since the former Dragon Gate standout debuted King of Pro Wrestling 2018.
Arriving as Los Ingobernables de Japon's Mr. X, 'The Dragon' was immediately presented as an overpowered Junior Heavyweight brute bludgeoning New Japan's lighter weight class with bruising power and concussive Pumping Bomber lariats. His 2019 started with a big win as he and BUSHI became Junior Heavyweight Tag Champions. Roppongi 3K took those straps two months later, but Takagi was the highlight in every two-on-two he competed in and didn't eat a single pinfall or submission along the way, establishing him as the clear Best of the Super Juniors XXVI tournament favourite.
BOSJ was where Shingo's year came alive. Besting rival SHO in a bitter night one grudge match, a staggeringly prolific streak took Takagi to the finals via standout matches with Dragon Lee, Taiji Ishimori, Marty Scurll, and more. Finally, after years of Dragon Gate excellence, the gym class bully was having his way with Japan's biggest promotion, and no puny junior could stand his way.
A superfluous tourney finale with Will Ospreay followed. Shingo lost, but it mattered not: he had already emerged as a future Tokyo Dome headliner.
3. Kofi Kingston
That KofiMania was the biggest thing heading into and coming out of WrestleMania 35 in a year when WWE pulled the trigger on a first-time-ever women's main event speaks volumes of Kofi Kingston's surge. Gratifying, exciting, and completely organic, his rise from midcard tag act to WWE Champion has provided many of 2019's greatest thrills.
February saw the New Day man grab an opportunity that may not have existed without Ali's injury, and he hasn't let go since. Stirring performances in his SmackDown gauntlet and in the Elimination Chamber's final fall established the moment. From there, a Fastlane screwjob poured more fuel on Kingston's sympathy fire before finally, at long last, after leaping every hurdle, Kofi did battle with Daniel Bryan, helping craft a near-perfect modern WWE Title fight on wrestling's 'Grandest Stage.'
An instant classic yielded the most emotional title win in years. Creative inconsistencies have threatened to blight his run, but Kingston's personal standards haven't dipped an inch since then. The 37-year-old is at the peak of his powers after over a decade on the main roster, showing, definitively, that all he ever needed was a chance to bring his babyface fire into a bigger spotlight.
2. Johnny Gargano
There are some that resolutely refuse to acknowledge just how good Johnny Gargano is, thanks, presumably, to his iffy promo work and occasionally-unconvincing selling. Your writer once shared those concerns until the arguments became more futile with every passing f*cking amazing five-star classic.
He is, for those that are able to truly feel it, quite possibly the best wrestler in North America.
Nicknamed 'Johnny TakeOver' thanks to the quality of performances on NXT's biggest nights, Gargano lived up to the moniker and then some in 2019, tearing the house down as a sly heel with Ricochet at January's TakeOver: Phoenix before babyfacing himself halfway through a Brooklyn battle with Adam Cole at TakeOver: New York that elevated and enhanced the finisher-trading trope to a hitherto-unseen apex.
Their rematch at TakeOver: XXV was almost as good, which remains perhaps the biggest shock of the year until they potentially top it in what's sure to be a dramatic decider. Now seemingly incapable of having a bad match, beyond TakeOvers, Gargano offered his body to cocaine classic Halftime Heat after offering his mind to a Tommaso Ciampa programme that will surely find its final chapter when the former champion returns.
1. Will Ospreay
Though your writers spent time debating dozens of wrestlers' inclusion and placement on this list, one opinion was unanimous: that Will Ospreay is unquestionably the best wrestler in the world today.
Even in 2019 alone, the Englishman's growth is staggering. Though he hasn't been a spot-dependent, one-dimensional flier for years (those who cling to those complaints simply aren't watching), the past six months have seen him edge even closer to physical, mental, and intangible eliteness. The 26-year-old is evolving. While he's still a world-class athlete, his style is becoming less dependent on gif-worthy moments. He has become a master in-ring storyteller, seller, bumper, and, indeed, psychologist, with his new Hidden Blade finisher (an exposed back elbow to the opponent's skull) a perfect representation of his upgraded pseudo-heavyweight style. 'The Assassin' still gets 'Aerial': he's just adapting his approach to preserve his body and ready him for a place amongst the all-time greats.
No other candidate even comes close to touching Ospreay for volume. Shingo Takagi, Dragon Lee, Bandido, and PAC have all had their best matches with him this year. Bouts with Kazuchika Okada, Hiroshi Tanahashi, Jay White, and Rey Fenix hit similar standards. The depth of Will's résumé is so outstanding, even an obscure Spanish indie clash with the 22-year-old A-Kid stands as a Match of the Year candidate.
The scariest thing about Ospreay's 2019? The G1 Climax is still to come. He'll be untouchable if his standards continue throughout NJPW's signature round robin.