10 Best Wrestlers Of 2024
The very best WWE and AEW had to offer in 2024
As always - and just to try and offset inevitable rage about anybody that may not have made the final list - there are always qualifiers and caveats when narrowing a list down to 10. Here are the key ones:
- In line with WhatCulture.com's primary coverage, the list is centred around those wrestling for WWE and AEW. Impact Wrestling, ROH, GCW, NJPW, Stardom, TJPW, or anybody promotion or performer outside of the mainstream North American bubble, but please consider these parameters before contacting your local authorities over an omission.
- In 2024, there was yet another glorious surplus of great wrestling in the same way, post-2000, there became a glorious surplus of great prestige television shows. As much as anything the wrestlers have done bell-to-bell, this list features performers that - like all great characters in said shows - grabbed you by the throat and forced you to sit up and actually pay attention to what they were doing. Quality of matches matters, but quality of promos and ability to build said matches factors in. Particularly in a year where WWE's boom as improbably expanded and the 2023 AEW creative decline has largely been arrested. Who are the players claiming responsibility?
- Like many articles on this and every website, it's a subjective selection. If you're the type of person that only wants to agree with what they're reading, navigate away. That said, that might also mean you like exclusively positive content, and there's loads incoming...
10. Toni Storm
Toni Storm broke out beyond the boundaries of mere pro wrestler in 2024, capitalising on the success she'd found with her 'Timeless' persona in late-2023 to become one of AEW's bona fide drawing cards.
The gimmick was an instant hit and a much-needed bit of character development away from The Outcasts, and became the sort of persona that just about everybody else on the roster was able to bounce off of. Programmes against Thunder Rosa, Serena Deeb and Deonna Purrazzo were stronger for Storm just being so committed to the bit, and her longstanding alliance/break-up with Mariah May resulted in one of AEW's best angles of the year and the outright making of the understudy.
Not that the quality of the work suffered for her overblown theatrics. Storm's in-ring remained strong enough to keep her as the ace of the entire division, proven beyond reasonable doubt when she put over May in one of the highlights of a critically acclaimed All In Wembley card.
9. Hangman Page
Hangman Page's heel-turn-that-might-not-even-really-be-a-heel-turn has completely reinvigorated the man, his matches and large elements of All Elite Wrestling's uneven output in 2024.
Though the former AEW Champion engaged in strong scraps with legacy rival Swerve Strickland in the early half of the year, it was his return in the Owen Hart Cup that began a transformational arc for both performer and promotion.
After cruelly dispatching Jeff Jarrett just days removed from 'Double J' pouring his heart and soul out to the world about why the tournament meant so much to him, Page fell further into his own dark psyche when he lost the chance to face Strickland at Wembley thanks to defeat against Bryan Danielson. Plan B stood for Blood & Guts, which he entered alongside The Elite in yet another attempt to claim the redemption he craved.
That was at long last arrived at in the form of an epic and grisly Steel Cage showdown with the now-former titleholder at All Out, but Page topped that headliner in the opening slot a month later. The WrestleDream opener against Jay White was one of the most thrilling of either man's year, and set 'Switchblade' on his own new path as a babyface whilst preserving the sad sense that all can never be well for this version of the Hangman.
8. Drew McIntyre
The half of WWE's best feud of the year that had to wrestle with more regularity to keep the train on the tracks, Drew McIntyre's strongest WWE run yet opposite CM Punk also folded in some of his best ever matches.
Aside from their instant classic Hell In A Cell payoff in October, 'The Scottish Warrior' dominated proceedings in his Elimination Chamber spot, was in career-best form against Seth Rollins at WrestleMania, drew the house (and a monster one at that) in spectacular defeat against Damian Priest in Glasgow, and has been one of the safest pairs of hands on a Monday Night Raw that continues to be the best and most consistent weekly show in North America.
Away from leaving some of the insides of his head behind at Bad Blood, Drew also played his role against The Punker to perfection in their Strap Match at Bash In Berlin, was awesome in their divisive bout alongside Seth Rollins at SummerSlam, and has continued to elevate his promo game per the raised stakes against the 'Straight Edge Superstar'.
7. Darby Allin
Nobody calls Darby Allin a bad wrestler, but it's reasonable to consider him one of the most underrated professional wrestlers of all time for how normalised its become to expect the world from his matches.
People simply don't have bad or boring matches with the former TNT and Tag Team Champion, and after five years as a mainstream North American star, he's realistically the best in-ring wrestler across either majors to never hold a World Heavyweight Championship.
His bout with Konosuke Takeshita was the first of either man's year but was making Match Of The Year arguments well into the winter months, and this is ultimately the norm for Allin. The big singles and tags stacked up as normal, most notably when he scored gold with Sting before 'The Icon's amazing Revolution retirement, and he continued to be the easiest performer to best sum up AEW's increasingly fragile USP.
He approached everything with reckless intent, but the key word remains the latter more than the former ever was. One of the realest-feeling wrestlers ever, he now attaches the gravitas of a half-decade long relationship with the fans to his brutal bumps, and feels a lock to become AEW Champion in 2025 at the expense of Jon Moxley or whomever else holds the gold hostage.
6. Gunther
One year on from being high in these lists as Intercontinental Champion, Gunther wraps 2024 as yet another WWE boom success story.
His ascent to the World Championship slot was almost joyously predictable, thanks mostly to his routine brilliance in big matches and a floor higher than most people's ceilings. Not all the Gunther matches are epics, but he has a zero stinker policy, has made magic as a Raw midcard and main event maestro, and cuts logical, real feeling promos like he's been working as a circuit heel for half a decade.
Aside from his weekly responsibilities as Raw's biggest baddest boss fight, he drew choice and evocative matches out of Randy Orton in entirely different settings, and lost his secondary strap in the coolest way possible - by stealing WrestleMania 40 Night One from underneath The Rock.
That last line - like so many others that describe his run with the market leader - still scans as an impossibility through the lens of absolutely anybody tearing up the scene pre-WWE.
5. Willow Nightingale
Hot on the heels of Toni Storm as All Elite Wrestling's next female ace, Willow Nightingale has continued to be the one of the most consistently fantastic and over wrestlers in the entire company.
Quantity and quality have defined her 2024, but the sheer amount of matches she's worked (40+ at time of writing - a high number for a weekly television wrestler in the modern era) might have counted against her had she not been so awesome every single time out. She's one of AEW's newest common denominators - everybody has their best matches with her, and the likes of Mercedes Moné and Mariah May in particular have been truly established in the division's top spots as result of their bouts with Willow.
A vital player in the continued growth of the division and somebody so good and so over that she’ll future-proof it for herself and others, Nightingale is without question as valuable a full-time wrestler as anybody in the industry.
4. Will Ospreay
2024 was the year Will Ospreay committed to the grind of North American television wrestling, and while that decision resulted in Triple H taking potshots at the ‘Aerial Assassin’, Ospreay responded with a slate of matches so wickedly hard-going that they put some of ‘The Game’s busiest full-timer years to shame.
As well as proving any remaining doubters wrong, Ospreay adjusted to TV wrestling seamlessly, and became an MVP in AEW for the noise he’s been able to generate in noticeably quieter and emptier buildings. And the volume is rooted in reason - he continued to stack up yet more contemporary bangers against Bryan Danielson and Konosuke Takeshita and alongside Kyle Fletcher in trios and tags against The Young Bucks.
Currently the perfect version of himself in terms of reliability between the ropes and with a bar so consistently high that it’s rendered many of his workrate peers feeling somewhat surplus, Ospreay continues to simultaneously push boundaries of wrestling expectation and reality.
3. Bryan Danielson
Bryan Danielson could have comfortably been part of lists like this for every year of his full time career, and it's only fitting that if that really has come to an end, it's done so with yet more glowing praise.
A regular across Dynamite, Collision and pay-per-view, the 'American Dragon' waved away obvious injury niggles to embark on a banger-after-banger run against seemingly any and everybody he asked for. Along the way, he assembled match-of-the-year candidates against Will Ospreay, Zack Sabre Jr and Swerve Strickland.
And in the latter, at long last, he became AEW World Champion.
A middling run had the most epic of beginnings and ends - Jon Moxley wasn't in the ring for Danielson's Wembley celebration at All In, nor did he need to be as the rest of the BCC finished the All Out hatchet job at WrestleDream. The jury's out on how much of a retirement this exit even is, but the blood, sweat and tears of everything he accomplished during his last few months marked what the Dragon himself would presumably consider a perfect sendoff.
2. Cody Rhodes
Since WrestleMania 40, Cody Rhodes has been in programmes that are nothing to do with him finally winning the WWE Championship and/or "Finishing The Story". And yet, he remains the most over babyface in the company. Dumb luck on WWE's part, or the sheer genius of the 'American Nightmare' himself?
Those were the words that opened the entry on Rhodes from the version of this list for 2023, only with the WrestleMania information changed. And yet again, Rhodes continues to be acing the company's tests.
Away from the biggest stages (Cody won the Royal Rumble via a blinding mini-match with CM Punk, had WrestleMania epics with Roman Reigns and The Rock and steals every SmackDown he works), the face of the organisation has been a joy in his other singles outings. A SummerSlam outlier with Solo Sikoa notwithstanding, Rhodes has shone opposite Kevin Owens, Logan Paul and especially AJ Styles. Their Backlash encounter was one of the company's strongest matches of the year that played out in front of a rabid audience indicative of Cody's influence and success.
He's still undeniable even if and when he drops the gold to 'The Great One'. WrestleMania 41 will show that.
1. Swerve Strickland
Swerve Strickland's 2024 can't be defined simply by what he achieved, but more how he went about achieving it and to just how well his plan for world domination worked.
By the end of 2023, his ascension to the position of AEW World Heavyweight Champion was so undeniable that people stopped panicking he wouldn't make it. Even when the company appeared to miss the golden moment and/or peak of his popularity by not strapping him up at Revolution in three-way with Champion Samoa Joe and his arch rival Hangman Page, they got it done at Dynasty, and Strickland wasn't going to allow the minor setback to be the first of many.
After his first Dynamite and Collision as Champion passed with whimpers rather than roars, he set about immediately making himself a bigger deal than the booking looked like it was about to. Featuring multiple times per episode as opposed to the usual AEW formula, Strickland's presence became more notable than that of anybody else on the show, as every Champion's should be. From there, he tweaked his matches slightly to take on a certain quality more attached to that of a main eventer, and banked killer contests against Will Ospreay, Roderick Strong, Christian Cage and Bryan Danielson to solidify his place as one of the company's best-booked champions in years.
In the meantime, he's continued to be excellent in his best-in-class programme opposite Hangman Page, folding their hatred into Blood & Guts as well as a powerful All Out steel cage showdown. That rivalry may never be over, but Swerve always will be. Whose house?