10 Best Wrestlers To Never Win WWE Intercontinental Title
WWE? Check. US? Check. Tag? Check. IC? Not quite...
For almost 40 years, the WWE Intercontinental Championship has had a reputation for wrestling greatness. While the belt's lineage has been diluted in recent years, during the 1980s, it was famous for being the "workers'" title - men like Don Muraco, Tito Santana, Randy Savage, Ricky Steamboat, and Rick Rude all held the belt and defended it in bouts that could be counted on to steal the show.
This continued in the 1990s, with Bret Hart, Owen Hart, The Rock, and The British Bulldog all holding the belt - sometimes as a precursor to multiple reigns as WWE Champion. In the 2000s, it found a place around the waists of Rob Van Dam, Chris Jericho, Chris Benoit, and Kurt Angle.
Yes, there have been sore spots - in recent years, fans have had to suffer through reigns from the likes of Santino Marella, Ryback, and a not-yet-ready Drew McIntyre - but currently, the belt is in a pretty good place, as The Miz spent 2016 making it important and former WWE Champion Dean Ambrose currently lays claim to it.
Looking back through the title's history, there aren't many greats who haven't gotten a run with it - but there are a few notable exceptions who might surprise some fans, and who could have made the belt's lineage even stronger.
Here are the 10 best wrestlers to never win the Intercontinental Title:
10. Jake Roberts
Jake Roberts was one of WWE's most successful stars in the 1980s and 1990s, but for all of his talent and popularity, he never claimed any championship gold in the company. Even when he returned to the ring in 1996 as a sentimental babyface and made it to the finals of the King of the Ring tournament, he came up short.
A run with the Intercontinental Title would have undoubtedly made Roberts an even greater star, but he came up short in his attempts. In late 1986, Roberts challenged Randy Savage for the belt and failed to win it, but he's better remembered for his program the following year with The Honky Tonk Man. Though the two clashed at WrestleMania III, once HTM won the IC Title from Ricky Steamboat, their feud continued with the belt on the line.
Honky Tonk Man turned back Roberts's challenges, but it wasn't always supposed to be that way. Roberts was originally scheduled to win the belt, but injuries he suffered courtesy of a guitar shot from The Honky Tonk Man changed the plans.
9. Bruno Sammartino
No wrestler is synonymous with championship success in WWE quite like Bruno Sammartino. The star held the WWE Championship for an unfathomable seven years and seven months for his first reign, and less than three years after losing the belt, he recaptured it. The second reign lasted three years and five months, only coming to an end when Bruno requested to drop the belt due to injury.
Sammartino was never able to capture the same success when it came to the Intercontinental Title - which, granted, wasn't even introduced until far after his prime. Still, Pedro Morales - the second-biggest babyface of WWE's early days and a partner of Sammartino's - won the title on two separate occasions, making him the very first triple crown champion in WWE history.
The closest Sammartino ever came to holding the belt was during his brief comeback in the 1980s. Then in his 50s, Sammartino feuded with Randy Savage, who was in the midst of the greatest IC title run of all time. "The Living Legend" challenged "Macho Man" for the title at the Boston Garden and won - by disqualification. Savage retained the belt and Sammartino never got it.
8. Mick Foley
Mick Foley's first WWE Championship win remains one of the greatest feel-good moments in the history of the company. Years before Daniel Bryan conquered the world at WrestleMania XXX or CM Punk fled Chicago with the title, Foley was the star who wasn't supposed to make it, but who reached the top via hard work and fan support.
Prior to becoming WWE Champion, Foley held numerous tag titles and was the inaugural Hardcore Champion, but the Intercontinental Title eluded him. Just two months before he won the big one, Mankind challenged Ken Shamrock for the Intercontinental Title at Judgment Day. That match saw the beloved star trapped in the Ankle Lock for so long that, refusing to tap out, he rendered himself unconscious with the Mandible Claw.
Better remembered, though, is the challenge Foley mustered years later, after his official retirement. A disrespectful Randy Orton managed to goad Foley into a hardcore match at Backlash 2004, putting his Intercontinental Title on the line. Much like Foley did for Triple H, he took a beating to create a new star, coming up short in his attempt to win the prestigious belt.
7. Matt Hardy
Many years before "Broken" Matt Hardy became one of the hottest stars in wrestling, he was tapped as a future main-event player in WWE. Unfortunately, it just never panned out - he was part of the successful Hardy Boyz tandem, but his brother Jeff was the flashier member of the team and eventually became a true superstar.
Matt had his singles success in WWE - he held the revived ECW Championship, the U.S. Championship, the Cruiserweight Championship, and more - but never the Intercontinental Championship. It didn't help matters that he spent much of the original brand split on Smackdown, a time in which the blue brand boasted the U.S. Title, but even before the split, Hardy was picking up singles titles.
In 2009, the IC Title came to Smackdown, where Hardy finally got a chance to contend for it. He feuded with then-champion Drew McIntyre, but the preferential treatment that McIntyre got from Vince McMahon ensured that he retained the belt throughout the program.
6. Seth Rollins
Seth Rollins has only been on WWE's main roster for a relatively short time, but he's already accomplished quite a bit. While in The Shield, he and Roman Reigns racked up a lengthy run as WWE Tag Team Champions. After splitting from the group, he won the Money in the Bank briefcase, then cashed it in at WrestleMania 31 to become WWE Champion. He actually scored the United States Title while holding the WWE Championship, and while he vacated the belt due to injury, he recaptured it (for a couple of minutes, anyway) upon his return.
Rollins is only one belt short of amassing a very quick grand slam championship, and that one belt is the Intercontinental Title. On the November 3, 2014 episode of Raw, The Authority gifted Rollins with a shot at the title (then held by Dolph Ziggler), but interference from Randy Orton resulted in the match being declared a no contest.
That's been Rollins's only interaction with the IC Title, and being as how he and the belt are now on different brands, he'll have to wait a while to complete the quartet.
5. MVP
MVP was one of WWE's most promising stars during the late 2000s, and he was one of many stars with whom the company dropped the ball. He should have been a multi-time world champion and one of the men to lead WWE into the new decade, but he ended up requesting his release in 2010 after the company pulled back on pushing him yet again.
Earlier in his WWE career, though, he had quite a bit of fanfare, including what was arguably the greatest United States Title reign WWE's version of the championship ever had. MVP won the title and held it for 343 days, and while Dean Ambrose would ultimately break that record with a 351-day reign, Ambrose never defended the title, making it little more than a prop.
Of course, MVP's holding the U.S. Title meant he was a Smackdown superstar, which in turn meant he didn't have much of a chance of winning Raw's Intercontinental Title. Once the belt came to Smackdown, he challenged Dolph Ziggler for it unsuccessfully, then left the company weeks later. It should be noted, though, that he soon arrived in New Japan Pro Wrestling, and became the first man to win that promotion's Intercontinental Title.
4. Batista
Batista's size and look ensured that he was rocketed right to the top of WWE in nearly record time. He missed much of 2003 with injuries, but after a huge push in 2004, he won the 2005 Royal Rumble and headlined WrestleMania 21. He won the World Heavyweight Title at the show.
After that, Batista was a bona fide main eventer, collecting world titles like candy. By the time he left the company in 2010, he was a four-time World Heavyweight Champion and a two-time WWE Champion, and one of the few men to ever reach that status without having held any singles undercard titles.
Of course, Batista's failure to win the Intercontinental Title wasn't about a lack of trying. He received a high-profile title shot at SummerSlam 2004, taking on Chris Jericho and Champion Edge in a triple threat match. Though Batista was protected in the bout (Edge and Jericho had to team up to stop him and Edge ultimately pinned Jericho), he didn't walk away with the championship.
3. Brock Lesnar
If Batista rode a rocket to the top of WWE, Brock Lesnar was strapped to a meteor. The former NCAA heavyweight wrestling champion debuted on Raw in March of 2002. In August, he defeated The Rock for the WWE Championship. Like Batista, Lesnar would never hold an undercard singles championship, but the antisocial "Beast" also abstained from tag team title glory - he's purely collected world titles during his career.
However, during his initial five-month run to greatness, Lesnar faced a stumbling block in the form of Rob Van Dam and the Intercontinental Championship. Lesnar handily defeated RVD at the 2002 King of the Ring PPV to win the titular tournament, but the following month at Vengeance, he faced Van Dam again - this time with the former ECW star's Intercontinental Title on the line.
Lesnar couldn't repeat his feat from the previous month. RVD hit him with the Five Star Frog Splash, and when he went for the cover, Paul Heyman pulled the referee out of the ring. That meant that Lesnar was disqualified, and while "The Beast" laid Van Dam out with an F5 after the match, he ultimately failed in his quest that evening.
2. John Cena
When it comes to WWE, John Cena's almost literally done everything there is to do. He's captured a total of 25 championships, from World Titles to U.S. Titles to Tag Team Titles, and he's also won a pair of Royal Rumbles and a Money in the Bank match. Finally, since 2006, he's headlined an incredible five separate WrestleMania shows.
You'd think John Cena would be a grand slam champion many times over, and you'd be right... if it wasn't for that pesky Intercontinental Championship. It's not Cena's fault, though - where the other stars on this list have all attempted to win the coveted prize only to see it slip through their fingers, Cena has never had a televised match for the Intercontinental Championship. His one shot at the belt came at an Abu Dhabi house show in 2015, where he beat Bad News Barrett by DQ.
It's not too late for Cena, though - he's currently part of the Smackdown brand, as is the Intercontinental Title. Being as how he's the current WWE Champion, though, odds are that he'll be focusing on that for the time being.
1. The Undertaker
It's been an incredible 26 years since The Undertaker first debuted on WWE programming. When he made his inaugural appearance at Survivor Series 1990, Rich Swann, Sasha Banks, Paige, Alexa Bliss, and The Authors of Pain hadn't even been born yet. When he won the WWE Championship at the show the following year, it marked only the 17th reign in the belt's history - they're up to 129 now.
In all that time, The Undertaker has never managed to win the Intercontinental Title. While some would argue that the belt is somehow "beneath" him, he won the far less prestigious Hardcore Championship. While others would say that he never needed a title to be "The Phenom," that didn't stop him from claiming seven world titles and seven tag team titles.
Most of Undertaker's feuds have been at the very top of the card, admittedly, but in 1996, he did challenge Goldust for the Intercontinental Title in a casket match. Undertaker looked to have the title won, but when he opened the casket, Mankind was inside. The deranged superstar attacked Undertaker and knocked him out with the Mandible Claw, leaving him easy prey for Goldust.