10 Best Wrestlers Who Never Held The ROH World Title

Many prestigious names missed out on this prestigious championship.

christopher daniels roh
ROH

Ring of Honor celebrated its 15th anniversary with a pay-per-view in Las Vegas last night, a show that saw Christopher Daniels finally ascend to the top of the ROH mountain when The Fallen Angel defeated Adam Cole for the ROH World Championship. That title was established way back in July 2002 when Low Ki outlasted Spanky (Brian Kendrick), Doug Williams and Daniels in a 60-man Iron Match to become the inaugural champion.

Some of the greatest names in the modern history of the sport have held the ROH World Championship in the 15 years since. Bryan Danielson, CM Punk, Tyler Black (Seth Rollins) and Kevin Steen all held the ROH World Championship before going on to win world titles in WWE, and the top ROH strap has also been held by Samoa Joe, Austin Aries and Jay Lethal.

But what of the greats who never managed to win the title? There are a number of men who are vital to the 15-year history of Ring of Honor yet never managed to make it to the top of the mountain, men who are synonymous with the company yet never had a run as the true face of the promotion.

Some of these 10 individuals may yet have the opportunity to right this wrong, but for many of them the chance to call themselves 'Ring of Honor World Champion' has gone.


10. KENTA

Bryan Danielson Kenta Hideo Itami
ROH

The man known to NXT fans as Hideo Itami came excruciatingly close to winning the ROH World Championship on not one but two occasions. KENTA made his first appearance for Ring of Honor at Final Battle 2005 where he defended the GHC Junior Heavyweight Championship against inaugural ROH World Champion Low Ki and the Japanese star went on to compete in ROH frequently over the next four years.

KENTA defeated Danielson twice whilst the future Daniel Bryan was ROH World Champion, but it was Danielson who came out on top when the title was put on the line at Glory By Honor V: Night 2. Danielson was injured going into this match and his immediate future wasn't clear, yet KENTA still wasn't able to wrestle the title from the grasp of the American Dragon.

KENTA fell short in eerily similar circumstances a few years later against another injured champion, this time in the shape of Nigel McGuinness. McGuinness tore his bicep the night before yet he still managed to put on the match of the night with KENTA before dropping the title to Jerry Lynn soon after.

Whilst KENTA was never a true full-timer with Ring of Honor he was still a more than credible presence in the company and his international standing meant that a title win wasn't out of the question. The future Hideo Itami would have been a popular choice as ROH World Champion.


9. Jimmy Jacobs

Jimmy Jacobs Ring Of Honor
ROHwrestling.com

Jimmy Jacobs may currently be working for WWE as a writer but it was as an evil presence that he made his name in Ring of Honor. Jacobs was a five-time tag champion in the promotion, winning gold alongside Tyler Black (twice), BJ Whitmer (twice) and Steve Corino, yet the Zombie Princess was never able to win singles gold in ROH.

Jacobs was an integral part of Ring of Honor throughout his 12 years with the company but was unable to dethrone the champion on the nine occasions he challenged for the title. When The Age of the Fall arrived on the scene in 2007 Jacobs found himself positioned as the big bad of the company, yet despite defeating former champion Bryan Danielson it would be a year before Jacobs received a world title shot.

He was unsuccessful against Nigel McGuiness (obviously) and the ROH World Championship would elude him throughout his in-ring career. Jacobs is remembered more for his character work than his wrestling but his heel persona and ability to make all stories work in the company surely earned him a run as the top guy, a run that unfortunately never came.


8. Mark Briscoe

Mark Briscoe Ring Of Honor
ROHwrestling.com

Whilst big brother Jay is one of only three men to win the ROH World Championship on more than one occasion (Austin Aries and Adam Cole) Mark Briscoe is yet to come within a sniff of the biggest prize in the company he has been with since the very beginning. Mark was involved with the very first show but was unable to perform because of Pennsylvania's child labour laws, but Chicken was soon an important part of the promotion.

Mark has spent the overwhelming majority of his career working in the tag team ranks with his brother, but over the past 15 years he has had four singles opportunities at the biggest prize in the company. Kevin Steen, Adam Cole, Samoa Joe and Jay Briscoe have stood in his way, and all four have remained standing when the bell rang to end the bout.

Mark doesn't quite have the singles cache that brother Jay does but this isn't to say a future world title run is out of the question. For now Mark Briscoe remains the longest serving member of the ROH roster to never win the top belt in the promotion.


7. Jimmy Rave

Jimmy Rave Ring Of Honor
ROHwrestling.com

Another Jimmy who many believe deserved a run as ROH World Champion, Jimmy Rave was one of the most important parts of the Ring of Honor's early days. Rave had classic feuds with CM Punk and AJ Styles and for a while he was clearly the most hated man on the entire ROH roster, gaining such intense heel heat that throwing toilet paper was banned at ROH events after an altercation with fans.

There are many reasons why Rave was unsuccessful in winning the ROH World Championship however. One is that when Rave and The Embassy parted ways the horse had already bolted and by that point the ROH audience were unwilling to fully accept Rave as a major heel. A losing streak didn't help matters either.

Rave was also hurt by Samoa Joe's death grip on the title between 2003 and 2004. Joe was the champion but Rave was arguably the biggest heel on the roster and a singles match for the championship never came. Injuries led to an addiction to pain medication that also worked against The Crown Jewel of The Embassy, but for a while Jimmy Rave was the number one heel in Ring of Honor and would have been a great champion.


6. Colt Cabana

Colt Cabana
ROH

Colt Cabana came close to winning the ROH World Championship at Global Wars 2016, but just as it seemed as though Jay Lethal was going to tap out to the Billy Goat's Curse the Bullet Club rushed the ring to ruin the night for everybody. Not many viewers believed going into the match that Colt had a chance, but the combination of a new serious demeanour and hometown advantage gave hope to those that did.

Colt Cabana is one of the biggest names in all of independent pro wrestling but this has less to do with his in-ring performances and more to do with his podcast and comedic chops. It is those chops that have arguably held Boom Boom back regarding in-ring success throughout his career.

But when one takes a step back and looks critically at Cabana's ROH career it is clear that the Chicago native has more than brought the goods when seriousness was needed. Cabana's biggest issue may not have been his comedy stylings but more than incredible talent that was also in ROH when Colt was at his peak.


5. Chris Hero

Chris Hero
RF Video

Hero has just returned to NXT after a career-rebuilding stint on the independent scene but it was arguably his run in ROH alongside Claudio Castagnoli as the Kings of Wrestling that made him a major household name in the first place. This showed that Hero was more than capable of being a major player in the company yet is still didn't lead to a ROH World Championship reign.

At the beginning of his ROH career it was argued that Hero's character was simply too light-hearted to be considered world champion material, but the quality of his matches alongside added edges all but made that argument null and void. Others also said that he was best suited in the tag division, but prevailing wisdom suggests that Hero never won the ROH World Championship because he simply didn't need to.

Hero consistently proved to be an excellent challenger to new champions and despite challenging Homicide, Jerry Lynn, Tyler Black, Bryan Danielson, Eddie Edwards and more for the title Hero never managed to succeed. In many ways Hero was a gatekeeper for ROH.


4. El Generico

El Generico Ring Of Honor
ROHwrestling.om

When news broke that El Generico was going to be performing in WWE without his mask as Sami Zayn many fans felt that WWE were making a huge mistake. Despite the clear limitations of the gimmick Generico had become one of the most popular wrestlers in the world based on talent and perceived personality alone. These same skills surely earned him a run as ROH World Champion.

Generico never really came close to winning the big one. He had five singles matches for the title but with the exception of his final challenge against Kevin Steen the Generic Luchador was always a plucky transitional challenger that ultimately fell short. Did he deserve more? His popularity in WWE suggests he almost certainly did.

Generico came out on top in what was arguably ROH's greatest feud, but after forcing Kevin Steen out of the company (for a short while) Generico unsuccessfully challenged Roderick Strong for the title before moving back to the middle of the card. That was the role that ROH saw as right for Generico, and despite winning the ROH Television Championship and Tag Team titles the biggest prize in the company always eluded him.


3. Claudio Castagnoli

Claudio Castagnoli
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Castagnoli_2CW.jpg

When 2007 became 2008 it seemed as though the man wrestling fans now know as Cesaro was primed and ready to become the top guy in Ring of Honor. A number of main event performers had left the company and it was the Swiss Superman who seemed best prepared to fill the gap, and wins over Austin Aries, Bryan Danielson and Naomichi Marufuji further confirmed this.

Surprisingly the ROH World Championship eluded him however, with some pointing to a disappointing title challenge against Nigel McGuinness as the reason the door shut on Claudio. From this point on Claudio Castagnoli found himself in position to challenge many champions but much like his tag partner Chris Hero his role was to put the new king over.

Castagnoli was always credible enough to become champion at any time but ROH seemed reluctant to pull the trigger on him for whatever reason. Much like Hero he became a gatekeeper in the company, a role that he seems to be taking on in WWE as well. The Cesaro Section may be best served getting used to championship disappointment.


2. Alex Shelley

Alex Shelley Ring Of Honor
rohwrestling.com

It might seem strange to some fans to see Alex Shelley's name so high in the list and above current WWE stars like Cesaro, Sami Zayn and Hideo Itami, but for a brief period in 2005 it seemed for all the world as though it would be Alex Shelley who would dethrone Austin Aries as ROH World Champion. It was CM Punk who eventually got the nod in rather ironic circumstances.

In early 2005 Ring of Honor crowds were going wild for Alex Shelley and the stars seemed to be aligning for the man from Detroit, but when Shelley decided to sign with TNA the plug was pulled on his ROH World Championship ambitions. The irony comes from Punk being the man who defeated Aries when news had already broke about Punk signing with WWE.

Shelley and Aries had a heated feud to start off 2005 after A Double and Roderick Strong kicked Shelley out of Generation Next, and all of a sudden Baby Bear found himself in the position of being one of the top babyfaces on the entire roster. By the time the year had ended Shelley had turned heel again and the boat on an Alex Shelly ROH World Championship run had been missed.

Sometimes everything falls into place for a wrestling company yet they still decide against pulling the trigger.


1. AJ Styles

AJ Styles
WWE.com

AJ Styles may well be the best wrestler in the world in 2017, but in 2002 he was another talented independent performer looking to establish themselves in the post-Monday Night Wars world. Styles appeared on Ring of Honor's third ever show and quickly became an integral part of the top tier of the company, but was never able to win the big prize. Styles won pretty much else in the company except the ROH World Championship.

What is arguably more surprising is that Styles only ever had three one-on-one opportunities to win the championship despite being one of the biggest names in the company during both of his stints in ROH. Styles first challenged Samoa Joe for the title at War of the Wire in November 2003, but it was be another year before Joe relinquished the belt to Austin Aries.

Styles next championship opportunity came against Bryan Danielson at Dissension in January 2006 after Danielson hand-picked Styles as challenger, but The Phenomenal One again came up short. Almost a decade passed before Styles' third and final singles shot at the title, an unsuccessful run at Jay Lethal at Final Battle 2015.

If AJ Styles hadn't finally signed with WWE in 2016 then it is likely he would have eventually won the ROH World Championship. Some things just aren't meant to be.


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.