10 Best Wrestling Pay-Per-Views Of 2018
Glory Days.
First, some honourable mentions, and a few words on the make-up of the actual list:
The WWE fan already faces an arduous task on Sunday nights, especially those Brits who watch the new model of Network pay-per-views into an ungodly hour of Monday morning. To artificially inflate the success of the Network, all events must exceed the three-hour mark. Inherently, every show, no matter how good, now feels in some way like a slog. You're meant to buzz after a pro wrestling pay-per-view; you're not meant to wish Monday morning into existence.
It is for this reason that the Royal Rumble and Hell In A Cell don't feature here, superb as they were in part. The completely disposable nature of WWE's main roster product has all but ruined the former in retrospect, too. Shinsuke Nakamura won what subjectively was the greatest Royal Rumble (as opposed to Greatest) after a pulsating, manipulative masterclass of a finishing sequence. Asuka won the first-ever Women's Royal Rumble with a performance so superb it elevated the match from the farcical to (belatedly) the fantastic.
Both would-be top-tier titleholders rotted over the summer months. The Rumble used to inspire optimism with its triumph. It hasn't been the same for years, and cruelly, eventually, 2018 followed that dark road.
For inclusion here, any show exceeding three hours must be utterly insane, momentous, or the greatest pro wrestling show of all time...
10. WWE WrestleMania 34
Both the best and worst of WWE, this marathon, momentous show nonetheless lived up to the 'Ultimate Thrill Ride' moniker a year late. To quote Martin Tyler's iconic call of Manchester City's last-gasp 2011-12 Premier League title win, I swear, you'll never see anything like this ever again.
The opening Triple Threat Intercontinental Title match was perfect for the slot - all action and unpredictable drama, it excited but did not exhaust. In one of several shocks, Charlotte Flair ended Asuka's legendary streak. Even if Asuka was since ruined to an extent that it feels now like that streak never happened, the match was excellent, if slightly flawed in the storytelling department.
The set design was gorgeous, as was the attire on show. The action lived up to the spectacle, at least initially.
Ronda Rousey wrestled the greatest debut match of all time, entering an incandescent performance in a match stunning in its storytelling. The wider in-ring norm of 2018 is dangerous to the point of near-disaster. With Ronda's blitzkrieg offence, and Stephanie McMahon's amazing, terrified selling (!), this masterpiece conveyed danger better than most matches exhibit it.
Jinder Mahal won a singles title. The Usos' first main card 'Mania match, something we've rooted for for years, was forgotten within seconds. A knackered Undertaker squashed a half-drunk John Cena. Improbably and or morbidly entertaining, the show was f*cking nuts. Its remaining three feature bouts were all in some way or another disappointing and worthy, but all subverted 'Mania's old selling point. Shane > Bryan, Shinsuke's testicular destruction, Roman's bloodied carcass...WWE favoured the heat over the party in New Orleans.
It wasn't a show for the kids, and yet, a kid won a belt.
Again: f*cking nuts. Unforgettably nuts.
9. NJPW Sakura Genesis
We've selected Sakura Genesis here - but really, two ultra-rare clunkers excepted, virtually any of New Japan's B shows merits inclusion; the company offers incredible action all year 'round. Well, except for the World Tag League. Nobody cares about the World Tag League, even (especially) its top stars.
Sakura Genesis gets the nod here because it reflected, brilliantly, so much of what makes New Japan Pro Wrestling great in 2018 - and subverted what elsewhere dragged it down.
The fruits of Gedo's genius approach to the push ripened in the headliner between Kazuchika Okada and main event newcomer Zack Sabre, Jr. This was a relentlessly gripping war - a description that fits also Zack's awesome Venus fly trap submission game - that underscored the effectiveness of legitimate wins and protective, stature-enhancing losses.
They were likely motivated by the death-defying IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title match between Will Ospreay and Marty Scurll. That famous rivalry was shaped elsewhere, but Gedo allowed it to reach a crescendo in a New Japan ring. And why not? Why not put the power into the hands of this ridiculous generation of talent? He afforded similar creative license to the Golden Lovers, who continued their own, self-devised reunion in a d*mn good match against Cody and Hangman Page.
Elevated by a sterling undercard, on which the divisive Suzuki-gun operated at their best, Sakura Genesis was outstanding.
8. NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia
Headlined by the greatest WWE match in several years. Johnny Gargano's unsuccessful challenge of Andrade Almas' NXT Title was incredible.
Dried black blood on his lips, his eyes made vacant though the mushing of the brain behind them, this was an elite-level babyface performance. Gargano did a lot - a lot - of cool-looking sh*t in that ring, and Almas kicked even more out of him. But everything was sold and paced so well that it never became too much.
You could make the argument that Adam Cole's spine-first bump across two standing chairs was too much, in the semi-main - but, in a great, restrained Extreme Rules match against Aleister Black, they earned and built towards that retributive spot by positioning the latter as a "weapon unto himself" who only used weapons when he realised the scope of his task and his opponent.
The Velveteen Dream's performance level faltered, in an undercard match with Kassius Ohno, but the reaction to his powerful charisma heightened, if anything. In a lowkey spot of storytelling, Shayna Baszler's inexperience cost her against Ember Moon. Astutely, NXT management made certain Baszler put over the craft before they put her over.
Opened by what may sadly be the last really good Authors of Pain bout, TakeOver: Philadelphia was the perfect event for its host city: raw, violent, exciting.
7. NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn IV
The match between Adam Cole and Ricochet was a stunning marriage of their Independent work and NXT's advancement of traditional WWE storytelling.
That take might annoy some - they didn't need the TakeOver arena to prove they are worthy of it - but there was a big time heft to this, nonetheless. Cole, in refusing to buy into Ricochet's special factor, was in a state of denial. He couldn't deny it when Ricochet unleashed a match-winning spot so spectacular he didn't account for it. Calculated study is one thing - but Ricochet is so special that he invents new, astonishing ways of putting opponents away every time he steps foot in the ring.
Johnny Gargano Vs. Tommaso Ciampa and Undisputed Era Vs. Moustache Mountain were both slightly lesser versions of their best, outright classic matches - but NXT is so consistently excellent that you cannot really criticise it. You can only nitpick.
Let down slightly by EC3 Vs. Velveteen Dream - a spluttering non-starter of a match with zero narrative build - this was the outlier of yet another yellow brand triumph, elevated into this list by Kairi Sane's excellent win over Shayna Baszler.
Wrestling is always amazing on Saturday nights - and for all the whining, Sundays are sometimes glorious, too...
6. WWE Evolution
An event that promised a celebration of women's wrestling delivered it.
Celebration is right; a very welcome departure from the heat-seeking missile that is the WWE product at large, Evolution was inspiring. Even a match as on-paper underwhelming as Bayley, Sasha Banks and Natalya Vs. The Riott Squad over-delivered - crucially, because it yielded a rare, conclusive moment of babyface triumph. Much like the nostalgia-driven, nuclear-heated opener, this was a WWE fan getting nice things - in 2018!
Things turned nasty as Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair, over the course of 29 seminal minutes, rendered their real-life friendship a virtual impossibility. They beat the piss out of each other, with an unhinged and motivated relish, in arguably the greatest-ever Last Man Standing match. And, again, WWE delivered the right result: on a show pitched under the most cynical circumstances imaginable, WWE put over an organic fan favourite, inspiring an overdue optimism in the process.
The NXT component of the show delivered, too; while neither Io Shirai Vs. Toni Storm nor Kairi Sane Vs. Shayna Baszler was the best version of itself, we saw just enough of Storm's star potential, Sane's unreal babyface fire, Shirai's subtle and spectacular character work, and Baszler's bastardry - and the truncated run-times resulted in a legit show, as opposed to a collection of great matches.
5. NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 12
New Japan's annual spectacular presented us with incredible action...from unexpected sources.
Expectations were too high for Kazuchika Okada and Tetsuya Naito's IWGP Heavyweight Title match. This is such a luxurious problem to have as a New Japan fan; the main event of Wrestle Kingdom 12 was merely excellent. How dare they not put on a ****** classic.
What was meant to be Naito's night was instead gifted to Chris Jericho - which, in turn, gifted us their brilliant programme. Alpha and Kenny Omega put on a total thriller, generating laughs and gasps. Jericho was a black comedy delight, problematically mimicking a certain...accent, before getting the comeuppance his reinvented d*ckhead warranted. Jay White didn't emerge as the star Gedo had envisioned on January 5, but his match with Hiroshi Tanahashi, while dry, told an excellent story.
A rare Four-Way match showcased the diverse complexion of the Junior Heavyweight division superbly; Minoru Suzuki and Hirooki Goto excelled in another atypical stipulation match; the Young Bucks sold struggle as effectively as they sell merch in their Junior Heavyweight Tag Title victory over SHO and YOH, who themselves inspired hope for the company's future with eye-catching performances; Kota Ibushi and Cody wrestled one of the year's better sports entertainment matches in a pro wrestling league; even Davey Boy Smith, Jr. wrestled a minor classic...
Wrestle Kingdom 12 was an unreal show.
Somehow, New Japan bettered it months later...
4. ALL IN
Ironically, timing issues almost contrived to ruin the defining pay-per-view event of our times.
Still, while Kazuchika Okada Vs. Marty Scurll went too long, to the detriment of the match itself and to an extent the show, those last five minutes represented one of the Rainmaker's greatest achievements. He made you believe, with a twisting finishing sequence loaded with character work, that a Junior Heavyweight had his number. The main event suffered in its wake, but it feels almost obnoxious to quibble over a breathtaking spot sprint that, when you did manage a breath, you could only use it to shriek or swear your f*cking head off.
The tonal range of Hangman Page Vs. Joey Janela - a match as hilarious as it was terrifying - climaxed in a sensational, unforgettable parody of sports entertainment. Kenny Omega survived Penta El 0M in a sickening, thrilling war all the better for its unvarnished ugliness. Cody's uplifting NWA World's Heavyweight Title win was a very heated, gratifying throwback to an old-school big match feel. Really, beyond a strange, unscheduled opener, nothing disappointed on a night both eclectic and electric. Against all the odds, ALL IN drew 10,000+ punters, and it rocked them all.
ALL IN wasn't just superb; it was vital.
3. WWE Survivor Series
Yes Samoa Joe, yes Drake Maverick, yes the fugly f*cking t-shirts, yes the one-sided Monday night massacre, yes Shane McMahon > everybody on SmackDown, which itself is terrible in kayfabe now.
Yes to all of this.
But those last two matches, holy sh*t. They weren't just great in and of themselves. Between the blood-pumping, grisly, shoot-style realism of Ronda Rousey and Charlotte Flair's breathless fight, and the immaculate storytelling of pro wrestling's strategy versus MMA's legitimate ferocity in the main event, WWE quietly ushered in a new era of its narrative. Both matches, which boasted scintillating performances from UFC megastars, may have forged WWE's future. Watching both back-to-back, the spell of suspended disbelief was unbroken for what, literally, was one of WWE's finest ever hours. As a result, the prospect of Shayna Baszler, Jessamyn Duke, Marina Shafir and Matt Riddle performing in this very ring became an awesome one: a goofy and defective wider product narrowed to an incredible, sports-oriented focus.
The undercard yielded much entertainment, too: Buddy Murphy and Mustafa Ali killed it out there, dead brand be damned; the embers of Shinsuke Nakamura's famed fighting spirit still burned; Finn Bálor and Rey Mysterio planted the golden seed of a rare midcard dream match.
Survivor Series 2018 - like SummerSlam 2013, only better - delivered as much as it promised.
2. NXT TakeOver: New Orleans
If WrestleMania X-Seven and Money In The Bank 2011 are one and two on the list of greatest WWE shows ever, of all time, in history - then TakeOver: New Orleans is a big easy third.
The opening six-man ladder match, to crown the inaugural NXT North American Champion, wasn't merely the guaranteed, scintillating spot-fest most expected. The propulsive Ricochet was everywhere all at once. The slimy Adam Cole still evaded him. EC3 is the top 1%, and fittingly, everything seemed to fit in his lap in the opening phase. The Velveteen Dream continued his ironic, suicidal quest for immortality. Killian Dain and "Five Stars Lars" fused brute force and strategy. This wasn't a spot fest. It was an ensemble motion picture.
Shayna Baszler arrived on the night as both NXT Women's Champion and a performer of real, lasting substance. The Authors of Pain Vs. The Undisputed Era Vs. Roderick Strong & Pete Dunn was a bloody good match - and an even better angle. The NXT Championship match between Aleister Black and Andrade Almas is a candidate for most astute NXT match layout ever, which is some praise, given the brand's famed production crew. Faced with a subdued crowd, Black grabbed them by the scruff of the neck instantly with a moonsault to the outside.
The main event was a cast-iron, all-time WWE classic. Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa constructed something very special; pitched as something epic and cinematic, it succeeded on those terms, but was so punishingly brutal that it never once lost sight of its blood feud stakes.
1. NJPW Dominion
Kenny Omega Vs. Kazuchika Okada IV, subjectively, was the greatest pro wrestling match of all time. Reviewed in its entirety here, it was flawless. Perfection. Built on the back of an era-defining trilogy, Omega and Okada somehow managed to achieve all of the following:
- The greatest display of athleticism ever. The stamina required to pull all 70 minutes off was astounding.
- The greatest babyface performance ever. It helps that Okada, the most dominant storyline performer of the modern era, entered his most dominant performance ever in the opening fall.
- The greatest dynamic ever, one so revered that it justified the absurd content level and duration. Okada entered the match as a God; Omega, who cosplayed as a God at Wrestle Kingdom, entered Dominion as a humbled, better version of himself, having reunited with Golden Lover Kota Ibushi.
- The greatest match layout ever. Everything was calibrated to direct support towards Omega. Credited with much of it, Okada left no room for a divided reaction. Literally: when he attempted to pin him, he used his entire body. To kick out, Omega literally had to give everything.
- The greatest selling ever. Subverting a key spot in their second match, Okada could only slide down Omega's frame, having failed to deliver the Rainmaker. His everything wasn't enough.
You cannot escape the word "ever" when revisiting or reviewing this match, because it was so definitive in greatness. That extends to the rest of the show.
Chris Jericho slaughtered Tetsuya Naito in a brilliant bastard foreigner throwback; Will Ospreay and Hiromu Takahashi fought to decide who was the better man and not the most unhinged, thank Christ; a crossover event of actual pro wrestling babyface superheroes put over the Bullet Club; that faction excelled throughout their swansong, as the Bucks graduated to the Heavyweight ranks in a psychologically rich thriller: nothing's ever going to top Dominion, surely.
There's that word again.