10 Best WWE NXT Wrestlers Of 2017
If only they were the future.
For such a limited roster, in terms of numbers, there are multiple honourable mentions - highlighting the strength of what remains a superb wrestling product.
Omitted for his relatively short tenure is former brand talisman Shinsuke Nakamura, who did incredibly well to soften his incompatible, full-blooded King Of Strong Style schtick. A cerebral couplet of TakeOver matches opposite Bobby Roode proved, definitively, that there is a WWE sports entertainer within the puro practitioner. If only the main roster agent regime didn't paint the Artist with such broad strokes.
The Revival wrestled just one standout bout on the yellow brand - but what a match it was. Their incredible, shared-enemy work with #DIY opposite the Authors of Pain, at TakeOver: Orlando was something very special; a fitting and insanely dramatic bow to their thread on the gorgeous patchwork quilt that is the NXT doubles division.
Lars Sullivan ended the year in some style, as a monster both entertaining and believable. Nikki Cross worked wonders as a weirdo - ditto Alexander Wolfe. SAnitY ringleader Eric Young, meanwhile, quietly restored his aura after a middling start. Hideo Itami actually wrestled - and very well, in a sorely underrated bout with Roode overshadowed by the moonlighting Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne. The Velveteen Dream wrestled one categorical classic this year; his CV is prohibitively thin elsewhere.
Most everybody who faced Kassius Ohno emerged in a loftier position - but he was a star-maker, not a star...
10. Adam Cole
Of all the talents in the seemingly inexhaustible resource that is the modern Independent circuit, Adam Cole was best equipped to succeed in the realm of sports entertainment. The second Vince McMahon sets eyes on the Shawn Michaels doppelgänger, he will remove the rocket from Roman Reigns' back and bow down at the feet of his Patronus.
Less facetiously, Cole, as evidenced in a sterling TakeOver: Philadelphia qualifying effort with Aleister Black, has transitioned brilliantly to the world of WWE, with its emphasis on body language and character work - at which he already excelled. His Best In The World 'ADAM COLE, BAY-BAY!' call-and-response bit has lost none of its potency. If anything, the sheer, hilarious narcissism lends it an escalatory, immortal power. Of course, Cole's status as one of the elite practitioners of the athletic "workrate" style is well documented.
Cole was one of two standout performers during the balls-to-the-wall barbarism of the awesome WarGames match - and by design, he barely did anything in it. Perfecting the narrow space between moves, Cole compelled you to wish harm upon him with his slimy escapist routine. That is the work of a psychological expert.
The other standout performer was one...
9. Killian Dain
Killian Dain was deliriously entertaining in that aforementioned WarGames match: just a dictionary-definition awesome, absolute pleasure to watch.
He had already drawn glances for his killer old-school look and new age athleticism, with which he rose to the forefront of a stacked BritWres scene - but that incredible night in Houston finally made sense to the wider world his curious, one-off participation in WrestleMania 33's André The Giant Memorial Battle Royal. He swallowed the key to the cage to firmly and hilariously establish himself as a badass, before clearing the ring with the Coast To Coast in one of the very best spots performed in a stupendous year. Before that, he modified his already deadly arsenal to throw men at other men and throw himself on and into two men at once, tapping the vein of sports entertainment at its spectacularly OTT best.
Elsewhere, Dain did much with little in a series of brutal squash matches calibrated to make '90s kids salivate. Dain is the spiritual heir to the short-form warlords of yore - but his lengthy WarGames stint exhibited his potential to do far, far better than that.
2017 was the low key Year Of The Hoss. WALTER, Braun Strowman and Killian Dain emerged as the unholy valedictorian trinity of that class.
8. Drew Mcintyre
Among the more rigid pockets of the wrestling (read: WWE) fandom, the rehiring of Drew McIntyre was met with raised eyebrows - but then, those eyes weren't trained on the Celtic Colossus' redemptive and riveting tour of the Independent circuit. The lanky, slim McIntyre was reborn as the thick, imposing Drew Galloway - a believable and awe-inspiring sh*t-kicker who added a new flavour of intense physicality to the high spot-centric, technical "graps" scene of his home island.
Others dealt in his bruising style, but none did it with the presence and quality of Drew, who lit up NXT with a series of crunching matches - the best of which was a wincing affair with Oney Lorcan. Drew manhandled him with a smooth strand of brute strength, plucking the man from positions of midair velocity to widespread gasps from a seduced Full Sail audience.
Very quickly, McIntyre reassumed the Chosen One mantle and captured the top prize from the departing Bobby Roode in a very good, if very WWE match - before rocketing up the pace in a more dynamic and dramatic - albeit depressing - botched title loss to Andrade 'Cien' Almas at TakeOver: Brooklyn III.
"I always come back better," said Drew ahead of his surgery-enforced layoff. Given his form throughout 2016 and 2017, that is an immense prospect.
7. The Authors Of Pain
Once correctly perceived as dangerous and wholly undeserving of their telegraphed monster push, Akam and Rezar have improved massively in 2017, thanks in no small part to the atlas stylings of Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa - but at some point, we should probably drop that faint-praise, cold-take narrative altogether. Gradually, and with little fanfare, the Authors Of Pain have evolved from sentient baggage into an excellent tag team.
You simply do not enter convoluted performances like the brutal TakeOver: Chicago ladder war and the modernised masterclass that was WarGames, with all of their intricate moving parts, if you are entirely reliant upon your opponents to carry you through it all. Stripped of herculean opponents and flattering shortcut gimmicks, the Authors penned a fabulous no-frills chapter of their ascension at TakeOver: Brooklyn III in what was an unexpected triumph of a whirlwind war with SAnitY.
Akam and Rezar have deftly fused the classic power team philosophy of old, with its pop-generating brutality, and the content-stuffed mode perfected in 2017. A true Performance Center success story, the Authors have done so much to alter the NXT-as-glorified-Indy narrative.
6. Andrade 'Cien' Almas
The former La Sombra's credentials were never in doubt - but the discordant, smily generic New Mexican Babyface gimmick was deeply unflattering to a performer of Almas' aloof heel cool.
This year marked his redemption, and what's ironic is that he slowly seduced the audience through a spate of losses. That audience appreciated his underrated ability to flatter the likes of Roderick Strong - and especially Aleister Black - in defeat with the sort of fast-paced, back-and-forth matches designed to flatter undercards without stealing focus from the main attractions. This is a vastly overlooked role, and Almas perfected it; he was one of the crucial, low key reasons TakeOver cards were celebrated so universally throughout the year.
Good hand was an improvement on manufactured babyface - but with the simple yet profoundly effective addition of Zelina Vega to his act, Almas lived up to his star billing and reputation in a series of dastardly, deliriously-paced bouts with perfect foil Johnny Gargano, furnishing him with next-level confidence and credibility.
El Ídolo enters 2018 as the real, unmasked face of WWE's relentless attempt to recapture the Mexican market.
5. Ember Moon
It is to Ember Moon's immense credit that she was not overshadowed by the very good field of Mae Young Classic participants in 2017.
It did feel at times that NXT creative, usually so adept at engineering long-term storylines, had hesitated over the trigger. Ember's bout with Asuka at TakeOver: Orlando was a display of great storytelling, the elemental likes of which NXT has long perfected. The "War Goddess" - a curious nickname, perhaps indicative of Ember's shallow character - had the Empress beat in credible fashion. At the climax of a very well structured and worked match, Asuka was compelled to cheat to rescue her title. Again: it is to Ember Moon's immense credit that she exhibited the quality and presence - and the masterful psychology - required to make it work. That storyline failed to reach its logical, foreshadowed conclusion - Ember didn't force Asuka into full heel mode - but since their Brooklyn III sequel was so breathlessly, dramatically brilliant, it hardly mattered.
The currency generated by what was the best Women's match wrestled in the company all year allowed fans to both accept and savour Ember's belated, enforced title win at the expense of the fresher Kairi Sane.
4. Bobby Roode
The overarching dynamism of the wider 2017 in-ring style appears to have marginalised the superb body of work assembled by Bobby Roode - a CV inching ever closer to the shredder as a result of his problematic promotion to the main roster.
Increasingly, the classical WWE style - methodical and meticulous - is in danger of extinction. Which may render the Glorious One the last great practitioner of it; deceptively simple, Roode's wars with Shinsuke Nakamura were superb rewards for those with a patient appreciation for nuance. Rarely in WWE does the space between moves matter, but they did in San Antonio and Orlando; Roode attacked the knee of Nakamura with the classic, studious zeal of a Horseman in a seamless fusion of an on-paper rough styles clash.
Roode's successful defence of the NXT Championship opposite Hideo Itami pitched itself in a similar vein, with Roode providing a detestable platform on which to finally get the former KENTA over - proper - in what was otherwise a cursed NXT environment.
A great, mutually-beneficial traditional wrestling story with Roderick Strong and a surprisingly excellent title loss to the similarly stripped-down Drew McIntyre capped off a blinding year - or, sadly, half-year: Roode's criminally botched SmackDown run sadly obscured the shooting extent to which Roode, at his best, was a smug, searingly charismatic superstar.
3. Aleister Black
When WWE signed Tommy End, the decision to change his name either underscored a non-committal management perception or, simply, was a result of the trademark whims of a company with no fixed philosophy. Mercifully, the rechristened Aleister Black was awarded a push befitting his incredible talent.
So many WWE superstars were lumbered with generic rock themes at the turn of the decade. Black in contrast is the first truly metal WWE superstar, the presentation of whom is an incredible spectacle; lurching to the ring like a Hammer Horror villain - only far cooler and far more intimidating - Black models that aesthetic stripped entirely of its camp theatrics. In the ring, this translates to a futuristic amalgam of strong style and deathly serious psychology, the latter deployed impeccably to cast him as a muted, magnetic and and massively credible badass. Arguably wrestling the best NXT TV matches throughout the year, Black's is an unassumingly diverse and invariably thrilling CV, for a man with such a defined in-ring style aligned with his stoic persona.
A deserved recipient of NXT's winning long-term booking formula, Black is a genuinely great, understated performer as well as a great and unique pro wrestler.
2. Asuka
Much of the conversation surrounding Asuka right now is predicated on pure anxiety. When is WWE going to botch and or humiliate her? She has to win the first-ever Women's Royal Rumble Match, doesn't she? WWE tend to bend narratives as they go along: will "never defeated in singles competition" act as a bullsh*t caveat, come February?
The cynicism is understandable. Just look at the vast, sad majority of her fellow, recent NXT call-ups - but since the end of the year is often spent reflecting on what preceded it, the Empress deserves credit for both disproportionately dominating the NXT Women's ranks and elevating her opponents in inevitable defeat. There is a reason why Asuka - a frightening snap tornado of a performer dripping in physical charisma - remained NXT Women's Champion for a phenomenal 510 days: every opponent she faced emerged from what was invariably a killer match with their status enhanced.
She cast Nikki Cross as the authentic lunatic article in their vicious, overlooked Last Woman Standing war on NXT TV over the summer. Ruby Riot looked competitive against her in Chicago - no small feat, given the halfhearted TV build. And, best of all, Asuka in a performance of perfect balance all but positioned Ember Moon as the better (storyline) wrestler at TakeOver: Brooklyn III in a very subtle - and thus majorly effective - pseudo-heel role.
Tomorrow never knows - but for today, the Empress reigns supreme.
1. Johnny Gargano
Is there a better pure babyface in all of wrestling than Johnny Gargano?
Shawn Michaels' handsome stripper irked '90s WWF crowds. Times have changed in 2017, or Johnny Wrestling is far more likeable; TakeOver crowds took the pretty boy Gargano to their hearts with the obsessive clamour of a hormonal teenager, ignoring the (honourable mention) bad boy Tomasso Ciampa to throw their emotive weight behind his scorned former partner.
In an expertly-crafted story arc, they have been made to wait to consummate this passionate, symbiotic relationship; one of few performers with the currency and talent to pull off the losing streak angle, Gargano's authentic selling ability and perfectly-timed comebacks wrench elusive unpredictability from a by-design predictable booking pattern. Gargano's mastery of the convoluted, rapid 2017 in-ring mode has helped, obviously - but few fuse it with the emotion he engineers with such winning aplomb.
Prior to his singles run, Gargano somehow elevated an already sky-high superb NXT tag ranks with a spate of sublime performances rich in literary depth. The foreshadowing of the #DIY split; the threads of continuity picked up from the seminal Revival rivalry; the crazy, sympathy-generating bumps in his G.O.A.T-level luggage handling with the Authors of Pain: Gargano is writing his own grand story arc in WWE.