10 Best WWE Raw Brand Pay-Per-Views Ever

No Mercy is shaping up to be a great show - will it top some of these red brand classics?

John Cena Edge Unforgiven 2006 TLC
WWE.com

WWE No Mercy is looking like the most stacked pay-per-view in a long time. The event is a RAW-exclusive show, featuring the stars and championships of the flagship brand, and will include a number of genuine WrestleMania-worthy matches. Braun Strowman vs. Brock Lesnar and John Cena vs. Roman Reigns have long been dream matches, and mean No Mercy could be the best WWE pay-per-view in a long time.

There have been 28 RAW-exclusive pay-per-views in history, stretching from Insurrextion all the way back in May 2002 to the modern day. The brand split returned in 2016, and the red show pay-per-views have followed a frustrating theme ever since - lots of good wrestling brought down by nonsensical booking and lame finishes.

Even so, it is difficult to complain about Samoa Joe vs. Seth Rollins when you compare it with Maven vs. Rodney Mack or Tyson Tomko vs. Stevie Richards (in drag). RAW pay-per-views have been a mixed bag throughout history. The good has been very good but the bad has been absolutely atrocious. Let’s just focus on the best of the best.


10. Vengeance 2006

Randy Orton Vengeance 2006
WWE.com

It is pretty hard to complain about a show that opens with Randy Orton vs. Kurt Angle, right? This was actually Kurt Angle’s last pay-per-view match in WWE, as he was soon granted early release from his contract because of health issues. Orton won the match via RKO, and the popularity of that move was clear even here.

This show featured a couple of extremely disappointing matches (Sabu vs. Cena, Flair vs. Foley), but there was more good than bad. Rob Van Dam and Edge had an excellent WWE Championship match in the middle of the card, a step below what they were capable of but still a great match. RVD looked like a star, but just over a week later his push was done.

Shelton Benjamin, Carlito, and Johnny Nitro had a fun Intercontinental Championship triple threat match, with Carlito giving one of his best performances in a losing effort. D-Generation X vanquished The Spirit Squad in the main event, one of the rare occasions where two men were right in defeating five. Mid 2000s WWE gets a rough deal, but there was a lot of good there.


9. Vengeance 2004

Randy Orton Edge Vengeance 2004
WWE.com

More Vengeance, albeit painful retribution from two years prior. This was another excellent example of WWE in the mid 2000s, as top quality main event wrestling was dragged down a little bit by shenanigans and a woefully-flimsy midcard.

The show opened with a tag team match that saw Rhyno and Tajiri defeat Jonathan Coachman and Garrison Cade, a bout that was far better than it had any right to be. Edge defeated Randy Orton for the Intercontinental Championship in a match that went 26 minutes, and within 18 months both men would win their first world championships. When was the last time that happened?

Elsewhere, Eugene and Ric Flair unsuccessfully challenged for the World Tag Team Championships, proving to be a far more entertaining team than one would imagine. Batista also continued his development with a win over Chris Jericho, gaining vital experience working against one of the best of all time.

The main event was mid 2000s WWE in a nutshell. Chris Benoit and Triple H put on a clinic, an excellent high level world championship bout that was brought down by a nutty finish featuring Eugene. Benoit retained, but his title reign would be over the following month.


8. Hell In A Cell 2016

Charlotte, Sasha Banks
WWE.com

At the time, Hell in a Cell 2016 was met with mixed opinions. The show featured three Hell in a Cell matches, only one of which truly justified the use of the structure. You could argue that the cell was needed to keep Chris Jericho out of the WWE Universal Championship match, but the cage failed to succeed on that front.

Still, the wrestling on this show was generally excellent. Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins had a terrific match inside the cell, and Cesaro & Sheamus defeated The New Day in another good match. Both bouts were tainted by shoddy finishes, but the action was great for the most part. The Brian Kendrick also defeated TJ Perkins for the Cruiserweight Championship, a low-key belter that suffered from a disinterested crowd.

This show was all about the history-making main event however. A lot has been made of ‘history for history’s sake’, but it is difficult to argue with Charlotte and Sasha Banks deserving top billing here. Their feud was the most heated on the show, the only one deserving of Hell in a Cell. The match suffered a little because of a lengthy stretcher spot and an uncooperative table, but was better than given credit for.


7. Great Balls Of Fire 2017

Brock Lesnar Samoa Joe
WWE.com

Whilst it will almost certainly go down as the stupidest name for a pay-per-view in WWE history, Great Balls of Fire turned out to be a rather fun show. There was always a sense that WWE was treating it as a throwaway summer event, as it was headlined by a one-and-done Universal Championship shot for Samoa Joe. Expectations were low.

That main event only went six minutes, but the 'Samoan Submission Machine' came out of it looking like a star. Lesnar and Joe had an excellent mean guy match, battering each other with strikes and suplexes in a mile-a-minute brawl that had the crowd enthralled from start to finish. You can complain about the abrupt ending, but maybe that says more about presumptions than presentations.

Braun Strowman and Roman Reigns continued their feud in an Ambulance Match, another wonderful mean guy contest that featured a whole lot of brutality and not a lot of subtlety. Strowman won via Reigns’ own stupidity, but 'The Big Dog' got his revenge on the 'Monster Among Men' with a little bit of attempted murder after the bout.

Cesaro & Sheamus defeated The Hardy Boyz in a fun Iron Man match earlier in the show, whilst Big Cass squashed Enzo Amore like the bug he is. It wasn’t perfect, but this show was far better than most thought it was going to be.


6. Backlash 2005

Edge Chris Benoit Last Man Standing Match Backlash 2005
WWE.com

Backlash was one of the more consistent shows of the Ruthless Aggression era, with the 2006 edition just missing out on this list. There’s something about a tag team match featuring God that is either incredible or downright awful, after all.

The 2005 edition of the show was strong from top to bottom, as long as you discard the inevitably terrible Kane and Viscera match in the middle. The show opened with an excellent Intercontinental Championship match between Shelton Benjamin and Chris Jericho, before The Hurricane and Rosey finally ascended to the top of RAW’s tag team division. The superhero duo’s tag team championship win is largely forgotten now, but at the time it was a moment of true euphoria for the good guys of wrestling.

The show was topped off by two fine matches, featuring four of RAW’s biggest stars. Edge continued his rise to superstardom by besting Chris Benoit in a brutal Last Man Standing match, laying the 'Rabid Wolverine' out with a brick-filled briefcase.

The main event saw Batista further solidify himself as the number one guy on the flagship show, repeating his WrestleMania 21 victory with another win over Triple H. Hunter may have hurt a number of guys throughout his career, but he did everything he could to get 'The Animal' over as a top star.


5. Unforgiven 2005

Kurt Angle John Cena Unforgiven 2005
WWE.com

Though the feud was eventually booked in confusing fashion, the initial buzz surrounding the Edge and Matt Hardy story in 2005 was huge. Whilst away from the company, Hardy became a bigger star than he had ever been in WWE, and the prospect of him storming RAW to attack Edge made this the must-see rivalry of the year.

The in-ring portion of the feud got off to a silly start when Edge decimated Hardy at SummerSlam, but the mistakes were largely rectified inside a steel cage at Unforgiven 2005. This was as close to revenge as Matt was going to get, a violent victory secured with a memorable leg drop from the top of the cage.

The main event of the show saw John Cena and Kurt Angle do battle in another good match between the two. Angle was arguably the best in the world at this time, and not even the interference of Eric Bischoff could hurt this bout. Angle won by DQ, setting up some after-match shenanigans with Easy E.

Shawn Michaels pulled out a decent match from an inexperienced Chris Masters, and the show started with an emotional Ric Flair winning his first ever WWE Intercontinental Championship. Even Ashley Massaro put in a good showing on this night in Oklahoma City.


4. Clash Of Champions 2016

Kevin Owens Seth Rollins
WWE.com

There are a lot of things to complain about when it comes to modern day Monday Night RAW. The 50/50 booking of WWE means nobody ever gets over. Part-timers dominate the most important shows of the year, and the dreary times of LOL CENA WINS have been replaced by a never-ending struggle to make Roman Reigns the face of the company. It is all rather infuriating.

The negatives make it easy to ignore the incredible wrestling times we live in. The 2016 Clash of the Champions was the first RAW-exclusive pay-per-view of the new brand split, and the card featured great wrestling from top to bottom.

Kevin Owens vs. Seth Rollins? Chris Jericho vs. Sami Zayn? Charlotte vs. Sasha vs. Bayley? Cesaro vs. Sheamus? All of these matches were good to great, with Reigns vs. Rusev and TJP vs. Kendrick also veering on the better side of things. Cesaro and Sheamus brought their best of seven series to an end with a bruising encounter, and Owens and Rollins brought ROH-credibility to the WWE main event.

Clash of Champions 2016 was a night of great wrestling. Nothing more, nothing less.


3. Unforgiven 2006

Lita Trish Stratus Unforgiven 2006
WWE.com

The 2006 edition of Unforgiven was without doubt the best in its history. The pay-per-view was a night of memorable moments, including a main event that ended with one of the biggest bumps the company had ever seen. This was the last WWE pay-per-view in Toronto for over a decade, and what a way to go out.

John Cena once again stood tall at the end of the show, a sight which became a frequent occurrence on RAW in the mid 2000s. Edge was his challenger here, and it was Edge that Cena dropped through a stack of tables to win their Tables, Ladders and Chairs match. The finish was accentuated by a great call from Jim Ross, who screamed "God, don’t do this John!" in his own inimitable style.

Trish Stratus won gold in her final singles match, defeating Lita for the WWE Women’s Championship in her home town. The show also featured one of the first memorable RKO’s ‘Outta Nowhere’, as Randy Orton caught Carlito in mid-air as the Puerto Rican tried to deliver a springboard, well, nothing.


2. Backlash 2004

randy orton cactus jack backlash 2004
WWE.com

Many would rank Backlash 2004 as the greatest RAW-exclusive pay-per-view in history, and a solid argument can be made for that point of view. The card was a lot of fun from top to bottom, featuring the rise of a new star (Shelton Benjamin), Canadian mixed-gender awesomeness (Jericho vs. Christian and Trish), and a whole lot more.

It was a two-match show though, if we are being honest. The first of those saw Randy Orton truly arrive as a major star, as he overcame Mick Foley in a violent No Holds Barred battle. 13 years later, this may well still be Orton’s best match of his career. Foley well and truly put Orton on the map here.

The main event was a replay of the WrestleMania headliner, as Chris Benoit, Shawn Michaels, and Triple H fought over the World Heavyweight Championship. Benoit was the hometown hero here, and the crowd were absolutely rabid from start to finish. Was it as good as the WrestleMania XX main event? Not quite, but this shouldn’t be seen as a knock. Benoit prevailed, tapping HBK out to the Sharpshooter.

Wrestling fans all over the world owe it to themselves to watch those two matches.


1. Vengeance 2005

Kurt Angle Shawn Michaels Vengeance 2005
WWE

Timing can make a lot of difference for WWE pay-per-views. Backlash 2017 was undeniably hurt by the Superstar Shake-Up, which rendered a number of matches entirely toothless. Vengeance 2005 also took place in the middle of draft season, but this had the complete opposite impact. The draft meant that this show was packed with star quality from top to bottom, a rarity in mid-2000s WWE.

Any show featuring Kurt Angle vs. Shawn Michaels is on to a winner too, and the two all-time greats put on another clinic prior to the main event matches. Angle and Michaels had once-in-a-lifetime chemistry, and this match was as good as anything else in WWE in 2005.

The semi-main event saw John Cena defend his WWE Championship against Chris Jericho and Christian, the two Canadians going all out to make the new champ look like a million bucks. They succeeded too, putting together a smart triple threat match that benefited from the talent and personality of Christian and Jericho.

Batista and Triple H ended their rivalry in the main event, the perfect climax to a feud that made Batista a star. The mistakes WWE made in breaking Orton away from Evolution were rectified here, and WWE came out of this show with two new faces at the top of the company.

Vengeance 2005 may well be the best brand-exclusive pay-per-view in WWE history. A show featuring Lesnar vs. Strowman, Reigns vs. Cena, and Ambrose/Rollins vs. Cesaro/Sheamus has a good chance at usurping it however. Roll on 24 September .


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.