10 Best WWE Storylines Of 2017
Writing To Reach You
Ex-WWE writer Tom Casiello had a number of fascinating stories to tell about his time with the company in a recent podcast postmortem. His notes on working underneath Vince McMahon (and a structure created in his image) echoed sentiments from many others to walk the Titan Tower corridors during the past several years.
In a nutshell, the chaotic nature of modern storylines is a complete mirroring the process in which they are crafted. A character may turn heel on a whim literally due to the whims of McMahon himself. Similarly, an idea can take flight only to have its wings clipped because the Chairman had a bad cup of coffee at the time the angle was discussed.
Surviving the revolving door turnaround for several years, (Casiello noted how John Cena didn't care to learn his name because talent assumed writers would be gone within weeks anyway) he classified a 'Whodunnit' arc as a major no-no despite an enjoyable, tension-filled journey for the viewer. He felt the company was too often guilty of losing interest in the payoff, and maintaining the necessary patience, logic and forethought to get there. Jason Jordan as Kurt Angle's son was a rare success in this regard, but typical of Casiello's assessment, the negligence with Jordan's persona since then hasn't helped him adjust to life as the son of the Olympic Gold Medallist.
The mere fact that the following storylines clicked at all, not least as well as they did, is by this account at least, a minor miracle.
10. Kingslayer
A pre-WrestleMania injury to Seth Rollins cast yet more doubt that the two would ever make it to the 'Show Of Shows' as rivals, but an electric NXT interjection from the 'Architect' as well as a selection of underrated promos from the former Authority golden child added genuine pathos to the delayed and diffused angle.
Trapped in rehabilitation hell, Rollins took to Monday Night Raw not to fight, but to talk his way to the 'Grandest Stage'. Having been such an unconvincing babyface following his forced turn in 2016, he finally forged an organic bond with the audience when he dared to behave like a real human being. Away from t-shirt-flogging clichés and a tired smirking babyface veneer, Seth showed honest contrition for ever abandoning his Shield brethren to take residence in the pocket of 'The Game'.
Believable and relatable, Rollins' rethink finally gave the programme some emotional heft. This built on an electric segment at TakeOver: San Antonio, in which Seth held the show hostage to force NXT overlord Triple H to briefly expose himself as the main roster d*ckhead version of himself.
The eventual contest between the pair divided opinion, but a palpable sense of vindication for the former WWE Champion following his victory (and Stephanie McMahon's plunge through a table) highlighted the subtle success of the story.
9. Failing Upwards
Enzo Amore is really really good at one aspect of professional wrestling, but titles are not given to wrestlers solely for being excellent on a microphone. Not normally, anyway. And certainly not titles almost exclusively designed for those that excel between the ropes.
But excelling was what Amore did on a regular basis before an allegedly awful backstage attitude resulted in several ego-checking storylines for the 'Smacktalker Skywalker'. Over and popular, the 'Enzo and Big Cass' pairing was diffused, diluted and dissolved with a view of pushing the seven-footer to the moon after he'd buried the little loudmouth six feet under. An injury in their final battle changed everything.
Unable to continue punishing Enzo with demeaning defeats and banal beatdowns, the company instead used their unloved Cruiserweight league to do it instead. Only, talent is talent, and Amore refused to turn down everything he genuinely believed got him to the stage in the first place. Over a period of weeks, Enzo cut through the entire roster of lightweights and in turn gave them all personas to finally cling to.
His current relationship with Drew Gulak speaks to his success. Now, several talented technicians and fearless fliers want to claw the belt away from him, but thankfully do so to an emotional response, rather than deafening silence. To this end, Enzo remains an unheralded and unlikely saviour.
8. Welcome To The Blue Brand
Few needed a change of scenery in April's 'Superstar Shake-up' more than Charlotte Flair. Having traded the Monday Night Raw Women's Title for the better part of a year on the red brand in an inescapable rivalry with Sasha Banks that occasionally dragged in supporting players Bayley, Dana Brooke and Nia Jax, Charlotte had proved herself the most versatile all-rounder in the division, but risked going staler than her old man's hotel sheets if she continued on with the same conflicts.
Furthermore, she'd built up far too much credibility with the audience to remain a heel. Her introduction to SmackDown Live! was even used as a stick to beat the less-than-thrilling Tamina's own arrival on the show, despite no official babyface turn occuring during the transition.
That was the inherent brilliance behind the Welcoming Committee. As former self-appointed SmackDown Live! gaffer, Natalya had an instant cross to bear. As did Carmella, gradually gaining confidence thanks to aura-enhancing feud with Nikki Bella and a curious relationship with James Ellsworth. Tamina's aforementioned slight made her a natural ally, and the three's uncharacteristic unity gave Charlotte an immediate axe to grind in her new surroundings.
Levelling the playing field somewhat as the division's nicest babyface, Becky Lynch's decision to help her fellow 'Horsewoman' reestablished their on-screen bond too, redrawing SmackDown Live! battle lines for the year ahead.
7. Double Down
Prior to their SmackDown Live! trade, WrestleMania 'guest host' roles for Kofi Kingston, Big E and Xavier Woods disguised how desperately they needed a new creative direction if they wanted to continue milking those sweet sweet Booty-O dollars.
That direction came in the form of just being f*cking outstanding pro wrestlers in matches with The Usos.
The storyline thread was, as the best ones often are, brilliant in its simplicity. The New Day enjoyed a skylark more than most, with their hijinks getting under the skin of SmackDown Live! Tag Team Champions Jimmy and Jey. Stationed ringside munching cereal and generally getting up to no good, the triumvirate lulled the Samoans into a false sense of security and took their titles in grand fashion at July's Battleground pay-per-view.
Realising they'd been drawn into something far more serious, The Usos pledged to up their game in the rematch, and brilliantly, did just that.
Pr*ck heels they may have been, but Jimmy and Jey threatened swift justice and delivered it in one of the best contests of the entire year. Regaining the belts on the SummerSlam kickoff, their validation was short-lived following another trade on television three weeks later, but earned the respect of their opponents, the fanbase at large, and presumably WWE management when the claimed them conclusively in a grandiose Hell In A Cell payoff. The New Day had somehow gained new purpose, whilst The Usos had at long last gained respect.
6. Barred
Often looking like it would rapidly degenerate into a renewed feud after their forced coming together resulted in the 'boo/yay' treatment for Sheamus and Cesaro respectively, WWE's decision to have the 'Swiss Superman' embrace the dark side was one of the true creative masterstrokes of 2017.
Many heaped grief upon Vince McMahon for his podcast comments on the outrageously talented master of the 'Cesaro Swing'. Noting, amongst other criticisms, that his European heritage was a barrier to mainstream success, the Chairman was tacitly protecting him in the form of a listless dig. Cesaro's real problem was that he didn't quite yet have the requisite charisma to truly pave a way as a major solo star. Sheamus, somehow, has been the man to bring it out of him.
One of the few performers almost unanimously , 'The Celtic Warrior's unfiltered obnoxiousness rubbed off on Cesaro when he pledged full loyalty to the evil cause following the pair's frustrated turn on The Hardy Boyz. From there, every crack was permanently polyfilla'd. Matching entrance and wrestling gear followed, whilst their in-ring cohesiveness tightened further. Their matches became the best of the year on Monday Night Raw, in polar opposition to the groans their 'Best Of Seven' series received before it became the genesis of their unit.
5. Release The Hounds
The successful reunion of The Shield remains one of the undisputed highlights of 2017 not only for how gratifying it was to see Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns get the band back together on Monday Night Raw, but also for how much graft had gone in to making it so credible.
It really began with the redemption of Seth Rollins discussed elsewhere in this list. 'The Architect's contrition for his formerly evil ways reestablished a trust with the audience not quite as present during his forced 2016 babyface turn. That same turn saw him team on and off with Roman Reigns, but again it felt as much out of fulfilling good guy duties as it did old habits.
Dean Ambrose arriving back on Raw in April was the true marker that the 'Hounds Of Justice' would soon savage the roster again. Showing care for the characters as real humans rather than cartoon fools, Ambrose had to look deep within himself to forgive Seth, whilst Rollins had to show genuine patience not to give in on his redemptive quest.
Their SummerSlam Raw Tag Team Title victory over The Bar was the first glorious step in reviving the triumvirate. That they all wore red that night even foreshadowed it. The climactic coming together months later on Monday Night Raw generated one of the loudest pops of the year, and the act haven't been diluted since.
4. Father And Son
Shane McMahon mystifyingly avoids similar criticisms than his sister seemingly due to his willingness to take some ludicrous and psychologically unsound bumps every few months, but as SmackDown Live! Commissioner and in general since his 2016 return, he's been quite the leech.
Mirror man McMahon matched The Undertaker strike-for-strike, stood down The Shield, out-wrestled AJ Styles and fought dirty against Kevin Owens. Losing is somehow Shane's free pass, but the response from most live crowds reflects that he's the perfect example of wins and losses meaning frustratingly little in the big angles. He insists on making the moments about him, even if he's laid flat on his back.
Kevin Owens was as selfish as ever in his motivations, but spoke about this powerful contradiction during their absorbing summer rivalry on SmackDown Live! McMahon really had put himself front and centre at the expense of talent, giving 'KO' a kernel of truth to open up and exploit.
It wasn't the only thing opened up and exploited.
The peak of the angle, (and maybe the second best segment of the year) didn't even feature 'Shane-O-Mac' on screen. A heated showdown between Vince himself and the 'Prizefighter' ended in carnage when Owens opened up The Chairman with a headbutt and flattened him with a frog splash.
More than his son ever will, Vince understood the inconceivable line between megalomania and sympathy. His blood, generated the hardest of hard ways, fittingly powered the heart of the issue going forward.
3. Totally Awesome
Nobody need cry for The Miz as he films the latest instalment of the company's 'Marine' franchise ahead the birth of his first child and a welcome return to the Monday Night Raw roster in 2018. But as per bloody usual when the two come together, the 'A-Lister' deserved a lot more from John Cena at WrestleMania 33.
In 2011, Miz was an afterthought in victory over 'The Champ' as he played third wheel to an impending programme between Cena and The Rock, but the mixed tag team match pitting him and wife Maryse against 'Big Match John' and partner Nikki Bella this year was a senselessly disposable spectacle.
The layout was particularly shameful considering the effort made by Mr and Mrs Mizanin to get the conflict over. A series of skits parodying John and Nikki's portrayal on 'Total Divas' were an absolute riot. Again proving himself as one of the best actual actors on the roster, The Miz getting into character as his WrestleMania rival was a sheer delight. As too was Maryse's p*ss-funny take on Bella's unhinged infatuation with her beau.
It made for palpable, uncooperative tension when the four took the ring on select editions of SmackDown Live! too. The promo battles were fierce and believable, even if their eventual contest was decidedly less so. In defeat, The Miz was worshipped by the WrestleMania audience unlike any crowd he'd ever worked in front of. It was a resounding acknowledgment of his graft, regardless of the outcome.
2. Monster Mash
Responsible for some of the company's all-time great physical spectacles in 2017, Braun Strowman and Roman Reigns' incredible rivalry afforded the 'Monster Among Men' welcome elevation to the upper echelon on the Raw brand thanks to the unadulterated carnage caused.
Though 'The Big Dog' was the first to dent Braun's post-roster split unbeaten streak in a choice March clash, their real story began just a week removed from Roman's historic retirement of The Undertaker at WrestleMania. Barely able to reflect on the contest, Reigns was decked by Strowman in an attack that's already reached iconic status for the cavalcade of cinematic visuals employed. Braun rearranged the backstage area with Roman's lifeless frame before tipping over the ambulance attempting to take him to hospital.
It kicked off an increasingly wild game of can-you-top-this between the two than invariably included at least one vehicle and awful lot of thunderous impact in the process. Best of all, perhaps more by accident than design, Braun actually got to win the feud. After months of battle and injuries sustained to both, Roman never definitively vanquished his devastating foe before the pair spun off into new feuds.
Pointedly, and with praise to both for how they handled themselves in the rivalry just persistently standing toe-to-toe with Raw's newest killer did far more for Reigns' megastar aura than forced 'torch-passing' victories over John Cena, The Undertaker, Triple H and others.
1. Worst Of Friends
Ahead of getting himself the sack via selfie, Chris 'Jimmy Jacobs' Scoville worked extensively with Chris Jericho in redefining 'Y2J' as an inch-perfect villainous sidekick to Universal Champion Kevin Owens. Their 'Best Friends' union was doused in cynicism, portrayed exquisitely by both with an air of uncertainty before finally delivering the severance in spectacular fashion.
Owens' motivation was endlessly apparent - hold on to the red brand's top title at all costs. Jericho, older but no less wiser, was in glorious form as his run-in buddy, oblivious to his subservient role with the young 'Prizefighter'.
Months of tension concluded in the most spectacular fashion imaginable, representing the peak of the angle when it found itself demoted to secondary title status at WrestleMania 33. February's 'Festival Of Friendship' was an all-time great Monday Night Raw masterclass.
Driven by Jericho's idea of circus frivolities with a 'Red Wedding' conclusion, the segment was timed and paced to sheer perfection, delivering a payoff made all the more satisfying (and heartbreaking) by the commitment the company afforded to the gradual breakdown in relations over the prior months. Owens, an evil manipulator, chose the most vile moment to sever ties, concluding his assault with a loving tribute to Jericho's own assault on Shawn Michaels nearly a decade earlier, which itself was a callback to 'HBK's vicious attack on Marty Jannetty. It was masterful.