10 Best WWE Taboo Tuesday Fan Decisions

No Holds Barred or Extreme Rules? You decide!

Taboo Tuesday
WWE.com

Whatever its foibles, the news that Taboo Tuesday could return to the WWE pay-per-view calendar after a near-10-year absence has been largely well received by wrestling fans online.

The only question now is: Do we want Brock Lesnar to defend his Universal Championship against Heath Slater, Bo Dallas, or Roman Reigns? And should Braun Strowman and Samoa Joe battle each other in a Street Fight, a No Holds Barred match, or - and this is where it gets interesting - under Extreme Rules?

We have some big decisions ahead of us, but what about Taboo Tuesdays and Cyber Sundays past? Giving fans the opportunity to vote on match stipulations and title challengers always seemed like a great idea, so how come the concept only lasted five years before being killed dead?

Whilst our ability to outright change the direction of WWE storylines with the click of a mouse always seemed somewhat limited, we did at least have the power - from time to time - to interrupt their course somewhat (albeit, in most cases, to only a superficial extent).

And, more often than not, we called it right.

10. CM Punk Vs. The Miz (2007)

This was back when almost everyone thought that The Miz sucked - and not just within the context of him being a super-annoying heel, but rather: we legitimately thought that he was a terrible professional wrestler.

Some fans obviously saw something in him, though. At Cyber Sunday, he won 39% of the vote on who would challenge CM Punk for the ECW Championship, narrowly beating off competition from John Morrison (33%) and Big Daddy V (28%).

He lost the match, of course. The Miz was still a few years away from being anywhere near ready to hold a world title (even the ECW title).

But it was, perhaps, also an important moment in his early career, and given how many of us hastily had written him off by this stage, we really owe a debt of gratitude to those who kept the faith.


9. Batista Vs. Coach In A Street Fight (2005)

To be fair, it would have been pretty funny (in the Boaty McBoatFace tradition of pretty funny) if fans had voted for Batista and Jonathan Coachman to face each other in a "verbal debate" instead of a Street Fight.

But, ultimately, both of them - along with the third option, an arm wrestle - would have probably ended in the same way: Coach eating a Batista Bomb. The only difference was, by voting for a wrestling match, we made sure things weren't dragged out any longer than completely necessary.

Some 91% of fans went for the Street Fight in the end, which had to be the largest winning margin of any vote in the event's history. If that many people want to see you get violently beaten up by a 300lb muscle man, you have to begin to wonder.


8. Undertaker Vs. Big Show (2008)

Undertaker Big Show Cyber Sunday
WWE

Undertaker and Big Show - who, for all their many matches (and there were too many), never really shared much chemistry in the ring - were going to face each other at Cyber Sunday 2008. There was nothing we could do to change that.

But we at least had a say in the type of match in which they would be competing. WWE was saving the Casket Match for Survivor Series, so they gave us three options: Last Man Standing, Knockout Match, or "I Quit".

We chose Last Man Standing. And when you spend a few moments imagining how awful a Knockout Match would have been, or how damaging to Big Show's character it would have been to see the 500-pounder - miked up - begging Undertaker to stop, we were probably bang on the money.


7. Eric Bischoff As Guest Referee (2006)

Bischoff Cyber Sunday
WWE

This was, quite plainly, one of those occasions on which our vote didn't count for a thing.

Rated-RKO - the short-lived stable made up of Randy Orton and Edge - were going to fight D-Generation X, whether you liked it or not.

It was going to be a standard tag team bout - more exciting stipulations being off the table - and Orton and Edge were going to win. Why else would they give us three heel special guest referee options from which to choose? Sure enough, that happened.

But the fans were right to sense that opting for VInce McMahon - and a possible continuation of the McMahon-DX feud (if only for one night) - would have been the wrong decision. Plus - love him or hate him - seeing Bischoff back in wrestling for the first time in more than a year was nice.


6. Hair Vs. Hair (2004)

Bischoff Eugene Taboo Tuesdsy
WWE Network

This was essentially an exercise in damage limitation.

Nobody wanted to see Eugene face Uncle Eric on pay-per-view (although, mercifully, the match itself only lasted about two minutes), but fans at least had the sense to recognise that Bischoff getting his head shaved was preferable to the loser having to wear a dress or being the winner's servant.

Why? Apart from the fact that the former WCW stalwart actually looked kind of cool with his new silver bonce, it meant that we only had to stomach one cringe-inducing segment, on the night itself, rather than a series of them spread out over the course of the next three or four episodes of Monday Night Raw.

As wrestling fans, we are grateful for small blessings.


5. Shelton Benjamin Vs. Chris Jericho (2004)

You can't say that WWE didn't give us a broad range of choice for this one. There were 15 potential challengers to Chris Jericho's Intercontinental title from which to choose - among them Steven Richards, Val Venis, and Jonathan Coachman.

In the end, though, the fans went for Shelton Benjamin - with a resounding 37% of the vote - and it was definitely the right choice. The former Team Angle member went on to beat Y2J to claim his maiden singles championship, the start of a push that would, in an alternative universe, end with a world title victory a year later.

Alas, in our time-line, Shelton was left to a career in the mid-card, but ask yourself: would you really have rather seen Jericho against Rosey?


4. Randy Orton Vs. Shawn Michaels (2007)

HBK Orton
WWE.com

Fans were crying out for some fresh blood in the main event around about this time - yet when given the opportunity to make that a reality, they voted instead for the status quo, giving Shawn Michaels the nod, over Jeff Hardy and Mr. Kennedy, to challenge for Randy Orton's WWE Championship.

But did they get it wrong, really? The reality is, neither Jeff Hardy nor Mr. Kennedy were yet ready to push for WWE's main event, and although they may have benefited from a short-term rub after a title match with Orton, their futures were arguably better served - for the time being - in the mid-card.

Meanwhile, we got a pretty good match, and subsequent feud, between Orton and Michaels, which helped the Legend Killer no end in his efforts to re-establish himself at the top of the card.


3. Roddy Piper Partnering Ric Flair (2006)

Piper Flair Taboo Tuesday
WWE

If it had to be a pair of veterans competing for - and, as it turned out, winning - the World Tag Team Championships, it was at least a good idea to keep them as young as possible. And, however over-the-hill, Piper was only 52 to Sgt. Slaughter's 58 and Dusty Rhodes' 61.

Ultimately, we got the best ever seven-minute match between two fifty-somethings and a gang of peppy male cheerleaders that we possibly could have, and for that we deserve a little bit of credit.

Plus, Piper and Flair - even in the later (read: slower) years - was something of a dream pairing for the many fans who watched them back in their hey-day during the 1980s. And a brief run as tag team champs didn't really hurt anyone - apart from the Spirit Squad, obviously.


2. Shawn Michaels Joining Cena And Angle (2005)

Kurt Angle Shawn Michaels Taboo Tuesday 2005
WWE.com

A triple threat between John Cena, Kurt Angle, and Shawn Michaels would be a veritable dream match these days, but back in 2005 Cena - the defending WWE Champion - felt like something of a third wheel.

Not that he was a bad wrestler as such - just that we would have preferred to see Angle renew acquaintances with the 'Heartbreak Kid', after three stellar matches, including a WrestleMania classic in Los Angeles, earlier in the year.

But, all things considered, we ought to be count ourselves pretty lucky that we got this triple threat line-up, and not one that involved Kane or Big Show (worryingly, some 54% of the voters didn't cast their ballot in favour of HBK - which must have been one of the early examples of internet trolling).


1. Triple H Vs. Jeff Hardy (2008)

JEFF HARDY TRIPLE H CYBER
WWE Network

We're back in 2008, and this time the fans were tasked with choosing who would face Triple H for the WWE Championship. The options? Jeff Hardy, Vladimir Kozlov, or Jeff Hardy and Vladimir Kozlov. They were spoiling us, really.

Jeff on his own won with a landslide 57% of the vote, while Kozlov on his own received only 5%. This was important for two reasons: it let WWE know we wanted to see Jeff become a permanent fixture in the main event scene, and conversely, that we didn't want to see Kozlov become a permanent fixture in the main event scene.

Sure enough, we got our wish. The 'Charismatic Enigma' won his maiden world title two months later at Armageddon, and as for the 'Moscow Mauler' - well, the less said the better.


Contributor