10 Biggest Busts In WWE History
Sin Cara = Epic Fail!
WWE.comThroughout the years, professional wrestling has always been about using the current stars to maximize profits while creating new stars to carry the torch in the future. In years past, younger wrestlers would be booked to go over old wrestlers or be taken under a mentor's wing in order to receive a rub and become stars in the pay customer's eyes. More recently, professional wrestling morphed into "sports entertainment" and the tactic of getting a younger wrestler has changed fairly dramatically. Nowadays, creative teams seem to be more dependent on the gimmick itself getting the wrestler over instead of the other way around. Vignettes to introduce talent are produced to build a buzz and then the wrestler is given a few wins over some lesser talent before (presumably) instantly becoming a star in the fan's mind. Obviously, things aren't that simple and lately it seems newer talent are thrown by the wayside before they are even able to establish a feel for their character. Wrestling rosters are woefully shallow, with names from 10 and even 20 years ago still populating the main events. With Daniel Bryan's recent title reign being labeled a "bust", I figured it was only fair to take a look back at a few superstars who were truly busts. The list will include debuts that were hyped for weeks and completely sucked when they happened or new superstar acquisitions that totally bombed. Much like first round draft picks, no one in wrestling is a sure thing...
10. Kenzo Suzuki
http://www.flickr.com/photos/48889108936@N01/3708251During the "lost period" when Smackdown was its own brand and was clearly treated as the B-show, WWE debuted a number of characters who fans would rather forget. Among these was Kenzo Suzuki who debuted in 2004 and became one of the biggest busts in recent memory. The original idea for the Suzuki character was for him to be named "Hirohito" and wage war against all the American wrestlers at the time. This was the reason that Canadian wrestlers such as Chris Benoit and Chris Jericho started to be announced as hailing from American cities instead of Canadian ones, because Vince McMahon didn't think fans would cheer Canadians against the evil Japanese. The main problem with this gimmick however was the name itself. The name "Hirohito" refers to the Japanese emperor during World War II, you know, the war that killed over 70 million people and defined a generation of people? This would be the same as some American wrestling in Japan and calling himself "George Washington" while spouting anti-Japanese nonsense. It was completely stupid and thankfully killed before the character debuted on television. http://youtu.be/_rcZRZud7SY?t=28s As for Suzuki, he debuted to very little fanfare and was immediately put into a feud with an over-the-hill Billy Gunn. He defeated Gunn at WWE's first version of the Great American Bash, one of the worst pay-per-views of all time. He went on the capture the tag titles with the underachieving Rene Dupree before being drafted to the Raw roster in June 2005. He was released though before ever appearing on Monday night television.
9. Heidenreich
WWE.comA former Super Bowl champion with the Washington Redskins, Jon Heidenreich turned to professional wrestling after his football career stalled out and he was signed to a WWE developmental contract. As with many mid-2000s signings, Heidenreich had a great look for a wrestler but his skills in the ring were less than stellar. Heidenreich made his debut on Raw in 2003 with a character who seemed to be controlled by someone called "Little Johnny". It was later revealed that Little Johnny was supposed to represent Heidenreich's inner child that still controlled him because he was born in a charity hospital. I know what you're thinking: Yes, people were actually paid to come up with this stuff. Heidenreich was sent back to OVW because he sucked in the ring and was brought back a year later to feud with the Undertaker. This time, he was given Paul Heyman as a manager and the gimmick of reading poetry to the crowd. After a planned Wrestlemania match with the Undertaker was nixed, Heidenreich formed an alliance with Snitsky over their mutual admiration for for poetry and miscarriages (no, seriously). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEK80zqUXWQ After a face turn led to him creepily "making friends" with the children in the audience, Heidenreich joined up with aging veteran Animal to form a new version of the Road Warriors. Of course, this version was a complete flop and Heidenreich was released in January 2006.
8. Nathan Jones
WWE.comGrowing up in Australia, Nathan Jones became one of the country's most wanted men when he committed a series of armed robberies over the course of two years. When he was finally caught, Jones served seven years in a maximum security prison and was introduced to powerlifting in jail. Soon after, Jones became Australia's Strongest Man and was an awesome sight at 355 lbs. Unfortunately for Jones, his success as a powerlifter did not translate to the wresting ring. Jones was immediately stuck with the Undertaker (poor guy) and was made his protege against the fearsome team of Albert and Big Show. Jones was scheduled to be the Undertaker's partner at Wrestlemania XIX against the heels but WWE officials realized he would absolutely suck and pulled him from the match at the last minute, using a pre-match attack as an excuse. After being sent back to OVW to try to improve his skills, he returned as a heel and was placed on Brock Lesnar's Survivor Series team alongside Albert, Matt Morgan, and the Big Show. Probably owing to the fact that 4 out of the 5 on that team are absolutely terrible, Lesnar's team lost to Kurt Angle's team and Jones was quickly shuffled down the card. Soon, Jones started to hate the WWE's travel schedule and, after waiting for a WWE Australian tour, he simply left from the airport and never returned. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zRN1BZs20jI As an aside, Jones was generally thought of as a clown in the locker room, mostly due to his lack of ring skills but also due to a peculiar "talent". Allegedly, years of steroid abuse had turned one of Nathan's pectoral muscles into a, for lack of better term, breast. His body allegedly began producing milk from one of his nipples, thus guaranteeing his lack of credibility from now until forever.
7. Mordecai
wwe.comOne of the protege's of Jim Cornette in OVW, Kevin Fertig performed as Seven in the Memphis territory, basing his character on the Seven Deadly Sins. After kicking around the independent scene, Fertig was brought up to the main show and started competing in tag matches alongside Tyson Tomko in 2003. In April 2004, vignettes began to air to hype everyone for the debut of Mordecai, a religious zealot who dressed in all white attire and promised to rid the world of sin. The promos were very well produced and people seemed genuinely interested in his debut for the company which would come at Judgment Day 2004 against Scotty 2 Hotty. When Mordecai's debut finally happened people were, safe to say, completely unimpressed. As rumors flew that Mordecai was being prepped for a feud with the Undertaker (why does he get stuck with all the new losers?), people realized that Mordecai wasn't as physically imposing as the vignettes made him out to be. As a matter of fact, he was rather lean and not the physical force that people expected. His in-ring work was rather uninspired as well and his use of the Razor's Edge as a finisher didn't exactly set the world on fire. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXzOJ9leBrc Mordecai disappeared almost as quickly as he appeared but that wouldn't be the end of the story for Kevin Fertig. He was rehired by WWE in 2006 and rechristened as Kevin Thorn, ECW's resident vampire. As a member of the New Breed stable in WWECW, Thorn participated in the feud against the ECW Originals before being released by his own request in 2009.
6. Gene Snitsky
Snitsky probably has the weirdest debut angle of all-time and it actually turned him into a weirdly hot heel for awhile before the power of WWE Creative buried him for good. In September 2004, Kane was a full-fledged heel but was managed by the babyface Lita. You see, Kane was beating up Lita's boyfriend Matt Hardy too much so Lita slept with Kane to bribe him into leaving Hardy alone. Kane then won Lita's managerial services in a match and set about preparing for his offspring to be born. Yes, I realize this whole thing is as stupid as it seemed in 2004 .Anyways, Kane was scheduled to face the debuting Snitsky in a no-disqualification match on Raw. Since no one had heard of Snitsky before, it was figured to be another Kane squash match. However, things took a turn when Snitsky hit Kane with a chair, causing him to fall on top of Lita and cause her to miscarry Kane's baby. This was supposed to be just a one-night appearance but the angle inexplicably got Snitsky over so much that he was kept on the main roster. Unfortunately, since the creative team had absolutely no ideas for him outside of one night, Snitsky was immediately lost in the shuffle and exposed as someone who didn't have nearly as much ring experience as was necessary. He was given a foot fetish gimmick that surprisingly failed to sell out arenas all over the country and was eventually moved to the Sunday Night Heat program. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AmsIf5aYkDM He drifted from aimless angle to aimless angle for the rest of his WWE career before being granted his release in late 2008. Recently, Snitsky appeared in TNA, attacking Bully Ray, but I wouldn't hold my breath for better booking on Impact Wrestling.
5. Chris Masters
WWE.comChris Mordetzky began training as a wrestler at only 16 years of age before he realized that WWE was recruiting people who looked like wrestlers, not necessarily people with great in-ring talent. Over the course of three years, Mordetzky built his body into the impressive sight we would see on WWE television and was signed to a developmental contract in 2003. The newly named "Masterpiece" Chris Masters made his debut in February 2005 and broke Stevie Richards' nose with a Polish Hammer in his first match. Since he proclaimed his full nelson finishing move, the Masterlock, to be unbreakable, his first angle with the company was to participate in a series of Masterlock Challenges where plants in the audience would be unable to break his hold. After a few minor feuds, Masters was put in a series of matches against John Cena for the WWE title where he was unsuccessful every time. This ultimately broke whatever momentum had been built up because crowds stopped reacting to Masters and he was shuffled down into a tag team with Carlito with no real direction for his character. After taking a break from WWE due problems with painkillers, Masters returned having lost much of his muscle mass, prompting Triple H to actually make fun of him on television...WWE Wellness what? He was also castrated by John Cena once again before feuding with Carlito...once again. A couple of Wellness Policy violations put Masters on the shelf for 60 days before he was released. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4a0sJhIRhc Masters briefly returned to WWE with a lame gimmick where he bounced his pectoral muscles for comedic effect. He bounced around from pointless feud to pointless feud before being released once again in 2011. Masters has actually done quite well for himself on the independent scene and made headlines all over the country when he saved his mother from a burning house by ripping down a ten foot tree with his bare hands and breaking down a door with it.
4. Mabel
WWE.comWhat do you get when you try to turn a comedic, hugely fat, babyface tag wrestler into a monster heel? If you answered "an embarrassingly negative fan reaction and an almost equally embarrassing pay-per-view main event" then give yourself a gold star and a pat on the back. In 1994, Mabel debuted alongside his partner Mo and manager Oscar as Men On A Mission, guys from the ghetto who wanted to make a difference with kids today. Oscar unintelligibly rapped them down to the ring while they wore their ridiculous purple and yellow outfits that made Mabel look like Barney the Dinosaur. Mo was fat but Mabel was grotesquely obese and the result was a feud with the Quebecers over the tag titles that no one cared about. It seemed as though Men On A Mission should just be fired but Vince McMahon had bigger plans for the obese Mabel. After a heel turn for the tag team, Mabel inexplicably was booked to win the 1995 King of the Ring tournament. During his match with Savio Vega in the finals, the Philadelphia crowd was so angry with the booking/match that they chanted "ECW" so loud that McMahon acknowledged it on television. When Mabel won the match and sat on the throne, he was pelted with garbage from the crowd. Because Vince McMahon can't take a hint, Mabel was then pushed to the main event against Kevin Nash and headlined the Summerslam 1995 event in Pittsburgh. Their match was one of the worst in the company's history with the crowd killed completely dead by Mabel's lack of heel offense and selling ability. Kevin Nash certainly won't be on anyone's list of top in-ring competitors anytime soon, so their combination was a cure to insomnia. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8R4Fp8FGmiE Nash was actually seriously hurt by Mabel during the match, as Mabel had a reputation for not taking care of his opponents in the ring. This is mostly due to the fact that he couldn't control the 43,827 pounds of fat around his waist but Vince McMahon was close to firing Mabel after the event but instead chose to replace him as the top heel with Davey Boy Smith. Mabel then went on to break the Undertaker's orbital bone, putting him on the shelf for two months. That was the death knell for Mabel's WWF run and we was fired shortly thereafter. Surprisingly, Mabel returned to the WWF as a member of the Ministry of Darkness and managed to scrape a career out of it as Viscera. Mainly competing in lower card feuds, Viscera was renamed Big Daddy V for a final run in ECW until his death in February 2014.
3. Bobby Lashley
wikiA former national champion wrestler, Bobby Lashley's debut wasn't all that dramatic as he defeated jobber Simon Dean on Smackdown and then once again on pay-per-view. He was entered into a rather boring feud with Finlay and came out on the losing end to JBL. He received his first push when he was booked to win the ECW world title (which really didn't mean that much anymore) and entered into a feud with Vince McMahon. Lashley was selected by Donald Trump to be his representative against Vince McMahon in the Battle of the Billionaires at Wrestlemania 22. Trump introduced Lashley as a "a black gentleman" and seemed to have no idea who Lashley was. Nevertheless, Lashley was triumphant over Umaga at Wrestlemania and caused McMahon to get his head shaved. Vince gained some measure of revenge when he pinned Lashley for the ECW title in a handicap match in a big middle finger to whatever ECW fans were left watching the product (not many). He received one shot at John Cena for the world title on pay-per-view but was unsuccessful and was released from his WWE contract in February 2008. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ivX-WSJ21Tk Lashley went from a showcasing match at Wrestlemania to an unceremonious release and never really clicked with the audience. McMahon never put the WWE world title on him (the ECW title doesn't count) but he was still a focal point of many of their television shows for an extended length of time. Recently, Lashley has resurfaced in TNA after a failed MMA career and captured the TNA world title from Eric Young. Hopefully his TNA run is a little more successful than his WWE stint.
2. Mr. Ken Kennedy (Anderson)
Ken Anderson has certainly made himself a controversial figure in wrestling despite not doing much in the way of accolades. He was not a favorite of Ohio Valley Wrestling booker Jim Cornette but, when Cornette was removed in favor of Paul Heyman, Heyman immediately took a liking to Anderson and sought to develop him as a performer. Heyman helped Anderson develop his cocky ring persona and changed Anderson's last name to "Kennedy" in a nod to Vince McMahon's middle name. He debuted on Smackdown in August 2005, defeating Funaki and making a name for himself due to his unique ring entrance. He entered into a brief feud with Eddie Guerrero but that was brought to an unfortunate end by the death of Guerrero in November. Kennedy was moved on to a feud with Batista that saw him hold his own against the established main eventer and then he won the United States title in 2006. Unfortunately, Kennedy was also extremely injury prone and would spend months at a time off of television due to his latest accident. Kennedy was seemingly set to make the jump to the main event for good when he won the Money in the Bank briefcase at Wrestlemania 23. He was also set to be revealed as Vince McMahon's illegitimate son in order to give him credibility as a main event star. Unfortunately for Kennedy, he lost his briefcase due to an injury and then lost his spot as Vince's son because got popped with a Wellness Policy violation. Kennedy left television for a while to film a direct-to-DVD movie and returned to compete in a main event 10-man tag match in the main event of Raw. Suddenly, Kennedy was fired four days after his return with rumors of Randy Orton going to the office and demanding that Kennedy be released because he injured Orton with a suplex in that tag match. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCOfeCNSxQE Kennedy joined TNA shortly after his WWE release and has been a featured player on Impact Wrestling. Unfortunately for Kennedy, being a main event player in TNA is like being the best downhill skier in Mexico...it just doesn't matter.
1. Sin Cara
WWE.comOh my, where to begin? In early 2011, WWE seemingly landed a big acquisition when they signed one of the most popular Mexican wrestlers of the day, Mistico, to a contract. Dubbing Mistico "Sin Cara", the new superstar was set to take the WWE by storm with his high-flying offense and innovative style. He debuted and formed an alliance with Daniel Bryan but that's when the problems started. Cara participated in the Money in the Bank ladder match but was kayfabe injured as an excuse for his first violation of the Wellness Policy. During this time, another Sin Cara appeared and began acting heelish. This led to a weird angle where the "real" Sin Cara came back and challenged the heel Sin Cara (now dressed in black) to a match at the Hell in a Cell pay-per-view. However, in November, Cara injured his knee and was put on the shelf for six months. After appearing mostly in midcard matches on Raw following his return in August 2012, Cara again injured his knee and was forced out of action for over a month. The office was starting to get impatient with Cara's constant injuries and bad attitude and one final incident seemed to be the straw that broke the camel's back. During the August 19th episode of Raw, Cara faced off with Alberto Del Rio. Only a few moments into the match, Cara performed a dive to the floor and dislocated his ring finger when he hit Del Rio. It was a very minor "injury" to be sure, but Cara still called the referee over and had the match stopped because he was hurt. Del Rio was rightly pissed off (high school kids play sports with dislocated fingers) and delivered a stiff beatdown to Cara after the bell. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGJyL1U3lQA Sin Cara, or at least Luis Urive (the man who was portraying Cara), was shipped back to Mexico and, in a confusing twist, he stated that he owned the Cara character and would still wear the mask in Mexico. Meanwhile, WWE placed Hunico underneath the Cara mask and he still occasionally appears on Raw.