10 Biggest Disappointments In WWE Elimination Chamber History
Screwjob finishes, a couple of botches and some outcomes that defied all reason...
The Elimination Chamber has provided us with some pretty great moments over the years. Shawn Michaels’ World Heavyweight Title win from Survivor Series 2002, Edge’s Money in the Bank cash-in at New Year’s Revolution 2006 and that time Shawn Michaels superkicked The Undertaker.
Ever since the Elimination Chamber was given its own dedicated pay-per-view, more matches and more events have in turn meant more moments to write home about - but it hasn't necessarily been a cakewalk. For every Shawn Michaels of 2002, every Edge of 2006, there’s been a screwjob finish or a December to Dismember, as well as other memories we’d rather forget from the other end of the spectrum.
From shows that didn’t deliver the results we might have liked, to shows that didn’t deliver anything at all, this article looks back at some of the most disappointing moments in the history of the Elimination Chamber match - as well as the self-titled PPV it spawned...
10. Santino Comes Up Short
In the World Heavyweight Championship match from Elimination Chamber 2012, an ordinary line-up produced an ordinary match that looked all set to plodder to its ordinary conclusion. That is, until Santino Marella decided to step things up a notch.
After he eliminated Wade Barrett to reach the final two, the fans began to rally. Suddenly they believed that Marella just might be able to upset the odds, defeat the defending champion Daniel Bryan, and go on to WrestleMania with the gold in tow.
A manic few minutes saw the challenger hang on in there, before a missed diving headbutt from Bryan allowed Marella to strike with the Cobra. We all envisioned the headlines - Santino Marella Headlines WrestleMania! - but after Bryan managed to get the shoulder up, seconds later he’d apply the Lebell Lock and, after a bit of a struggle, force the submission.
In the heat of the moment, it was a massive let-down to see Marella come up short but in hindsight, it’s probably a good thing that a comedy character, whose finishing move involved jabbing folk with a pretend snake, didn’t go on to defend the World Title at the biggest event of the year.
9. Daniel Bryan Gets Screwed
Two years later and the tides had turned. It was now Daniel Bryan’s turn to fall at the final hurdle. In this case, though, it was hardly under the fairest of circumstances.
In the WWE Championship match at the 2014 event, Bryan and Randy Orton were the final two remaining in the Chamber. Countering an RKO, Bryan rebounded from the corner to hit his patented running knee and seemingly lay Orton out for the count.
Cue a timely intervention from Corporate Kane, who heaved the referee from the ring, buying Orton time to recover and nail the RKO. Somehow Bryan kicked out of that first one but, after another run-in from Kane, a second soon followed and Orton picked up the victory.
Looking back, you could argue that this finish was worth it in the end. Having been screwed out of the title at SummerSlam, Night of Champions, Battleground and Hell in a Cell, this was just another of many roadblocks that made Bryan’s eventual coronation at WrestleMania XXX all the more enjoyable.
Not that it felt that way at the time, though.
8. John Cena Main Events The 2012 Show
In 2012, John Cena was in the business of main eventing PPVs - regardless of whether he was a WWE or World Heavyweight Champion or not. Naturally, this rubbed some fans the wrong way. One of the biggest slaps to the face of fans arrived at that year's Elimination Chamber show.
On a card that saw a total of four Championships defended, two of which were World Title bouts staged inside the Chamber, somehow John Cena vs. Kane was given precedence over everything else that night. Not only that, but the match was saddled with an overly-contrived Ambulance match gimmick.
Admittedly, the match itself wasn’t necessarily that bad, aside from the multiple (that’s right, multiple) wheelchair spots. Either way, it didn’t feel worthy of headlining the PPV, especially when you consider the other matches on the card that were more deserving of that spot.
It’s instances like this, with WWE Champion CM Punk being relegated down the card, despite featuring in an Elimination Chamber match, that contributed to such vast swathes of the audience turning on the posterboy Cena.
7. Alberto Del Rio Vs. The Big Show
This one was a let-down for a couple of reasons.
First-off, when Alberto Del Rio defended his World Heavyweight Championship against the Big Show at Elimination Chamber 2013, the feud was anything but fresh.
The pair had already faced each other in singles action three times in the preceding months, and two of those matches had been Last Man Standing bouts. To then regress to a straightforward one-on-one match seemed a little counter-intuitive. Their best work with one another was already behind them - and this blow-off match suffered as a result.
Secondly, the knock-on effect of this meeting meant there was no World Heavyweight Title Chamber match on the 2013 show. Instead, six title hopefuls battled for a shot at Del Rio’s belt at WrestleMania 29, with Jack Swagger coming out on top.
I guess you could say that a number one contender’s bout inside the Elimination Chamber may have helped the belt seem like a big deal, but it didn’t do the match’s billing any favours.
Ultimately, removing the World Title from the Chamber match to facilitate round four of Del Rio vs. Big Show didn't seem like a worthwhile trade-off.
6. No World Title Chamber Match In 2015
The story of the Elimination Chamber 2015 event isn’t particularly straightforward.
Having been replaced by Fastlane in the February PPV slot, it looked like the show had been dropped from the company calendar altogether. But, at the last minute, WWE announced a bonus PPV under the Elimination Chamber banner, sandwiched in the four-week period between the Payback and Money in the Bank shows.
A hastily-arranged card was put together, headlined by an excellent WWE World Heavyweight Championship match between Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose. As awesome as that meeting was, though, it was just a singles match - meaning it could have taken place on just about any other show of the year.
That seemed to cheapen the Chamber stipulation somewhat. On its big return, it was relegated from one of the most extreme match-types in WWE to a run-of-the-mill gimmick that featured on the undercard.
Granted we did at least get a couple of Elimination Chamber matches earlier on in the show but as we’ll soon see, neither were anything to shout about…
5. Tag Team Title Match In 2015
One of those matches was the bumper Tag Team Championship bout, in which the New Day defended their straps against five other teams in the most jam-packed Elimination Chamber match on record.
In principle that may have sounded like a good idea - but in practice that wasn’t quite the case.
Too many bodies - 13 in total - made the match feel more like a Battle Royal free-for-all, and there were a couple of timing issues that compromised some of the major spots.
Twice we saw Kalisto go for a climb, the first instance resulting in him essentially being crotched on top of the New Day’s pod, where he then lay around waiting for a solid four minutes. Then, when he made his second ascent, this time to the apex of the chamber roof, he seemed to run out of space when he got there. After some more time spent dangling around, he tamely dropped onto a mass of bodies below. The spot just ran out of steam.
Add in the fact that we had tag teams breaking up pinning attempts on other rival teams, and this one just felt like a bit of a hot mess.
4. Intercontinental Title Match In 2015
Even worse than that Tag Team Championship match was the Intercontinental title fiasco from the same 2015 show.
It all fell apart fairly early on, when King Barrett inadvertently broke Mark Henry’s pod, forcing the big man to enter the match sooner than initially planned. This threw the rest of the script out the window, as no one really knew who to go after, where they should be or, in which order the entries and eliminations would now arrive. The resulting action yielded many an awkward stand-off, which isn’t really what you want to see from an Elimination Chamber match. Or any, for that matter.
Meanwhile, Sheamus had spent much of the match holed up inside his pod as the referees were having trouble opening up his door. Eventually, the Irishman revealed that he had in fact locked the door shut with his Celtic Cross pendant - but no one on commentary picked this up, to the point that JBL and Jerry Lawler made the whole thing feel like yet another botch.
While that first issue may have been beyond their control, the second one was just plain sloppy - and they both contributed to this Chamber match going down as one of the worst in history.
3. Cancellation Of The PPV
Despite the impression this article may be giving, on the whole the Elimination chamber PPV has been a pretty solid event - which is why it was a massive disappointment when the show was once again dropped from the calendar in 2016.
This time, though, unlike in the previous year, there wasn’t to be any hastily-arranged compensatory show shoehorned into the PPV calendar. Instead, we had our first year since 2007 without any Elimination Chamber action.
It was later revealed that the logistics of transporting and accommodating the Chamber were the main reason behind the show’s cancellation. In an appearance on the Wrestling Compadres Slamcast, Stephanie McMahon spoke about difficulties of hanging the Chamber in arenas with scoreboards positioned above the ring.
I suppose you can’t argue with such issues, but that doesn't change the fact that, given how important the Elimination Chamber has been in helping to promote WrestleMania, it was a major blow to see the show scrapped from the schedule altogether.
2. Extreme Elimination Chamber
Though this one didn’t take place at an Elimination Chamber PPV, per se, it still employed the stipulation. In fact, this rendition was a lesser-spotted Extreme Elimination Chamber match, although the added gimmickry didn’t do much to save the contest from failure.
Headlining the infamous December to Dismember 2006 show, this particular Chamber match was a whole series of disappointments.
First, Sabu was pulled from the line-up on the very same day of the show. His replacement? Hardcore Holly- not quite a like-for-like substitute given that this was an ECW-branded show. Then, when the match eventually got underway, CM Punk was eliminated first. That’s the same CM Punk who was arguably the most over guy on the ECW roster, as well as Paul Heyman’s pick to win the match outright and become the new face of the brand.
Instead, though, and to add further insult to injury, it was Bobby Lashley - Vince McMahon’s pet project - who escaped with the win to be crowned the new ECW Champion.
Whichever way you look at this one, the match was poorly booked. It was also an illustration of the fundamental issues that plagued the ECW reboot; namely, the conflict between Heyman and McMahon in terms of the overall direction of the product.
Eventually it was Vince who won that battle, though the real losers in all of this were the fans.
1. Triple H Defeats Goldberg
As far as disappointing outcomes go, they don’t get much worse than this.
In only the second-ever Elimination Chamber match, a red-hot Goldberg had his sights set on Triple H and the World Heavyweight Championship. He was still undefeated since his debut a few months prior, and with the match taking place on the big stage of SummerSlam, this was the perfect time and place for Goldberg to capture the gold.
The majority of the match went exactly to what should have been the plan. Entering at number five, Goldberg tore through the competition, eliminating Randy Orton, Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho within minutes of being released from his pod. The only man left to topple was Triple H - and Goldberg showed no signs of slowing down.
Until, of course, the Trips got his hands on his sledgehammer and countered a spear with a single blow to Goldberg’s head It proved enough to keep him down for the count. Just like that, one of the most memorable rampages in Chamber match history had been abruptly ended, in the blink of an eye, as the villain laid waste to the hero.
A number of factors contributed to make Goldberg’s WWE stint a year to forget, though this was arguably the most damaging of them all.
It was a huge
disappointment both on the night and in the grand scheme of his entire run with the company.