10 Biggest Downgrades In WWE History
When once-awesome wrestlers are chewed up and spat out of the WWE barmy gimmick machine.
As one-time WWE veteran and current AEW Sports Entertainer Chris Jericho has marvellously showcased throughout his stellar 30+ year run within the industry, evolution is the key to longevity in this wrasslin' game.
Or as Triple H less convincingly put it on-screen a few years back, "you either adapt or perish... that is evolution."
Either way, the sight of a star being thoroughly changed up when it comes to their overall gimmick has become an ever-present part of Vince McMahon's empire in particular, with an Eater of Worlds disappearing for a spell before returning as a Fiendish Children's TV Presenter, a Big Dog taking some time off before settling into their spot at The Head of the Table, and even a long-time MMA Beast deciding to dust off their cowboy hat for a bit of shameless fun.
Yet, not every performer is gifted with the chance to fully dive into a new character that exudes cool, excitement, or is even remotely compelling.
In the case of the following WWE workers, upon diving into the wrestling juggernaut's hilariously unpredictable gimmick-change machine, the utter mess that tumbled out of the other end can only be described as a serious backwards step in hindsight.
10. Karrion Kross To Discount Gladiator
It's become arguably WWE's most depressingly long-running theme in recent times - and seriously think of the ground that covers - but even with the knowledge of Vince McMahon's penchant for completely dismantling and unnecessarily diluting a winning NXT formula, fans were understandably under the impression that it would take a monumental piece of mishandling to screw up a dominant black and gold powerhouse tailer-made for the "main roster".
Or as Vinnie Mac saw it; challenge accepted.
Gone were the bells and whistles and atmospheric presentation that helped build Karrion Kross into the indomitable NXT force he'd become over the course of his 18-month undefeated run as part of Triple H's baby. In his place was a stripped back, vanilla brute, shuffled straight into the mid-card with a tacky gladiator aesthetic that was evidently an attempt to shamelessly market the former NXT Champion as Monday Night Raw's resident coliseum fighter.
The shift fell flat on its arse from the get-go and it was even rumoured that Vinnie Mac was set to change-up Kross' character once again before he was unceremoniously let go in November.
9. Chad Gable To Shorty G
Finally being given some space to prove precisely why he has long been one of WWE's best kept secrets, the Chad Gable now seen "SHOOOOOOOSH"ing those filing in to watch the latest edition of Monday Night Raw showcases a star in his absolute element.
Jumping back to the often dark times that were 2019-2020, though, and a worker who had once formed one half of arguably the most promising up-and-coming tag team the company had seen in an age found himself floundering in a gimmick that simply felt like a gross misuse of his undoubted talents.
Decked out in a vest and dorky basketball shorts, the re-christened Shorty G - because LOL he's not 7ft tall - was a far cry from the electric former Olympian who looked destined to walk a similar path to that of Kurt Angle. Routinely acting as the butt of the unfunny jokes, it looked as though Gable's time in the company was all but certain to come to an end when the next round of cuts reared their heads.
But, the opening of the Alpha Academy, recruiting of an Otis, and the burial of all mentions of Baron Corbin's lazy height digs at the one-of-a-kind technical master has thankfully salvaged a one-time doomed performer.
8. Kane To Corporate Kane
Trying to remain a fresh and compelling face on the back of taking up a spot on WWE's active roster for the better part of two decades is no mean feat. And it's not uncommon for a legendary performer to simply stick to what they know in later life; playing the greatest hits, if you will, as they slowly enjoy a victory lap en-route to heading out the full-time door.
In fairness to the current Mayor of Knox County, at least The Big Red Machine tried to change things up a little towards the latter stages of his over-exposed run on the main roster. Yet, to class his Corporate makeover as an enthralling success would be a bit of a stretch.
Sure, there were the odd flickers of fun in the form of Kane's Demon and Corporate personas being flirted between during his feud with then-WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins in 2015. But few will ever get over the image of this dulled down Glenn Jacobs bumping around a ring in trousers with a business trim, and WWE wisely made the decision to revert back to his demonic persona for the remainder of his work in-between the ropes post-Authority.
7. Nikki Cross To Nikki A.S.H.
Provoking the sort of knee-jerk response that often accompanies a drastic WWE makeover that looks as though it tumbled straight out of Vince McMahon's nutty, '80s-obsessed mind, the revelation of it actually being entirely Nikki Cross' idea to completely revamp her chaotic ball of fury character into an Almost a Superhero brought with it a slither of hope.
Said hope was then emphatically squashed about two months on from the super-gimmick's debut as fans quickly rejected the squeaky clean underdog in favour of Rhea Ripley and Charlotte Flair laying into each other for a few more weeks.
At a glance, the fact the now-devious wannabe hero can boast a Raw Women's Championship, Money in the Bank briefcase win, and a Women's Tag Team Championship reign suggests the change-up has at least resembled a success for the often overlooked talent. But Cross' new spot alongside the likes of Tamina, Dana Brooke, and the rest of the 24-7 title brigade on Raw more accurately reflects just how much of a backwards step this effort to get the younger generation onboard actually has been for the one-time Sanity member.
6. Chave Guerrero To Kerwin White
Oh, Chavo.
His recent and largely forgettable wander into the All Elite universe may come across as an all out failure to some. But it looks like a damn career highlight when held up against the jaw-dropping decision to strip away the heritage that instantly carved him out as a highly respected in-ring worker... and replace it with a golf cart, bleach blonde hair, and a new-found love of all things white.
Yep, 2005 wasn't all Batista Bombs and FU's, folks.
What makes matters worse was the fact that, on top of being forced to utter phrases such as "if it's not white, it's not right", Guerrero also found himself being decked out in the embarrassing middle class America, Kerwin White get-up during the tragic tribute show dedicated to his fallen uncle Eddie Guerrero a few months later.
Thankfully, WWE had the sense to drop the tone-deaf gimmick shortly after, but that still hasn't erased some of the most questionable beats Chavo ever had the misfortune of bringing to life on a WWE stage.
5. Dudley Boy To Reverend D-Von
Like a few of the other dodgy character shifts that make up this list of underwhelming faces, Reverend D-Von's short detour into singles competition on SmackDown in the wake of WrestleMania X8 did at least open the door for a certain Animal to make his first few imprints on the WWE landscape.
Aside from Big Dave's introduction, though, just about everything that made up the former Dudley Boy's lazily designed angry pastor gimmick resulted in a flop out of the gates. Any character who can boast highlights such as blasting a live crowd for indulging in masturbation was hardly ever going to immortalise itself as one of Vinnie Mac's most inspired creations.
Hilarious to the boss? No doubt. But an embarrassing misstep, all the same.
Again, clearly sensing there was little left to explore in a shift that was almost-instantly tired, D-Von was ultimately betrayed by Batista en-route to reuniting with his trusty Bubba down the road.
4. Owen Hart To The Blue Blazer
Without question one of the defining in-ring performers of his generation, inspiring everyone from Kevin Owens to Chris Jericho over the years, it sits as a heart-breaking double-whammy that the iconic Owen Hart's career was not only cut tragically short in 1999, but that his last moments came whilst under the guise of the Blue Blazer.
Ever the generational professional, Owen did everything in his power to get over the bumbling blue superhero schtick that he'd first brought into being back in the late '80s. But away from the odd admittedly entertaining backstage promo involving Hart refusing to declare Val Venis' last name because of what it rhymed with, to class this comedic change in direction away from the masterful technician and Hart Family member work that had put him on the map in the first place as an upgrade would be fanciful thinking at best.
Owen's respected legacy whilst decked in the Hart Family's black and pink will finally be honoured in The Land of All Elite this year. But you can pretty much guarantee next to no mention of this slapstick last hurrah of a gimmick will be made over the course of either gripping tournaments.
3. War Raiders To Viking Raiders
Not exactly getting off to the most effective of starts upon finally being drafted up to the main roster, one-time NXT Tag Team Champions War Raiders saw themselves typically transform into a fully fledged Viking Experience over night before Vinnie Mac and the gang saw the understandable social media backlash to yet more unnecessary tampering.
A week later, said think tank name was swapped into a finishing capacity and Erik and Ivar were christened The Viking Raiders as developmental fans clenched their fists (and arses) at the thought of what was to come for a unit who had waged electric war on the black and gold brand.
Sure enough, despite still putting in gripping shifts for men of their size and trying their utmost to make Viking lemonade out of the main roster's usual brand of rotting lemons, the terrifying twosome were reduced to a comedy double act more excited about the thought of besting The Street Profits in a bowling showdown than establishing themselves as the most dominant team in the land.
Injuries haven't helped, but the sight of the former Hanson and Rowe being entirely overlooked at this year's Show of Shows once again highlights just how far their stock has fallen in recent times.
2. Cody Rhodes To Stardust
Reliving the absolute American Nightmare that was Cody Rhodes' last real stint inside of the Sports Entertainment giant proves that even the most painful of professional wounds can find a way to heal themselves over time.
Going from being presented as the talented offspring of the highly respected Dusty Rhodes, exuding arrogant charm in his "Dashing" days, and showing flickers of a more menacing and sadistic edge in his clear-mask "Undashing" era, Rhodes' reward for this steady evolution into becoming a reliable and often entertaining WWE act was as disheartening as it was ultimately catastrophic for the company in the long run.
Lumping Cody with a Goldust 2.0 gimmick, the eventual AEW EVP never shied away from his utter disdain towards McMahon's attempts to make Stardust a thing - blasting the enigmatic splatter of face paint as a "f***ing space clown" later down the road.
Said disenchantment with WWE on the back of this character change would result in Cody calling it quits and eventually setting an All Elite ball of competition in motion, of course. And even with WWE swallowing their pride and bowing to Rhodes' demands of never uttering that star-faced menace's name again upon re-signing with McMahon's circus, Cody's WWE legacy (pun intended) will forever come equipped with a sparkly blotch.
1. Elias To Ezekiel
Whilst many would be quick to fall back on the laughable adage of "wait and see how it plays out" when it pertains to the one-time audience provoker returning on the Raw after WrestleMania 38 minus his trusty instrument or grizzled fur, recent history suggests that this train of thought often leads to a full-blown derailment later down the line.
Even at this early stage, the identity shenanigans involving Ezekiel or Elias depending on who is being interviewed backstage on Monday nights feel as ill-thought-out as they are largely unfunny, with even the mighty Kevin Owens struggling to get over the supposed hilarity of everyone but him being convinced about the arrival of The Drifter's apparent brother.
Sure, WWE do at least appear to be in on the joke a little this time around, even posting a photo of Elias posing next to his faux sibling on Instagram as a way of riling up KO.
However, if the endgame here is to finally transform Elias/Ezekiel into a star capable of captivating a crowd inside of the squared-circle as much as he once did whilst sat on a stool, you can't imagine that having the string-plucking menace slap on a fake beard and flirt between his two current personas over the course of three dull hours is going to finally catapult him into main event contention.
But you never know, if we wait and see how it plays out long enough, Elias might just grow his beard back for realsies and go back to popping the crowd with his routinely entertaining strumming sessions.