10 Biggest Ever Heel Vs. Heel WWE Matches

When both sides are evil, it's not always easy to pull off a great match.

A traditional wrestling match features a good guy (a face) taking on a bad guy (a heel). Most wrestling matches that we see on weekly basis on television and a monthly basis on Pay-Per-Views are like that. It's how the wrestling business has been and always will be. Sometimes WWE might say they are blurring the line between face and heel, but that's really not true. They are always going to tell stories that way. There are also times when two faces might face off in a match. It happens because they know the fans are going to give the match a positive reaction if they are two popular guys. A match that many consider to be the best in WWE history was The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 25, which was a face vs. face match. What about heel vs. heel matches? Those are rare. The reason that heel vs. heel matches are more rare than face vs. face is because there's always a worry that the crowd might be dead. Hearing a crowd boo two guys for an entire match is not the kind of reaction you want for a match. You want them to know who they are rooting for so they can support that person. From a promoter's standpoint, you don't want to do heel vs. heel matches very often. However, there are times when you have to do it. Sometimes it works out great. Other times it fails big time. A lot of times it's done for storyline reasons where one of the guys ends up turning face as a result of what happened. There's a very famous match that was definitely considered for this: Bret Hart vs. Shawn Michaels at Survivor Series 1997. They were both heels going into it. However, Hart was in a unique spot where he was getting cheered in Canada at that point, so he was clearly the babyface in Montreal. The criteria for this is heel vs. heel matches only. Here's a closer look at some of the biggest and best heel vs. heel matches in WWE history.

10. Shawn Michaels Vs. Rick Martel - SummerSlam 1992

It was a match between two very egotistical heels. Shawn Michaels was a fresh heel that dumped Rockers partner Marty Jannetty and then had Sensational Sherri as a manager. Rick Martel got rid of partner Tito Santana years earlier and ended up as an egotistical heel known as The Model. For whatever reason, WWE thought it would be a good idea to put them in a match at SummerSlam 1992 where the rule is nobody could be hit in the face because they were both too good looking and Sherri wanted it that way. It was a silly concept, but they were skilled enough to make it work. In terms of their in-ring talent, both guys were really good. Obviously this was early in Michaels singles career and by the time he retired he was arguably the best in-ring talent ever while Martel was also very good at times. What was cool about the match is the crowd was into it. The England fans were hot the whole night. After about seven minutes of action with each guy cheating as much as possible, the match broke down and Michaels was the first one to do a slap in the face. Martel also slapped him. Sherri fainted on the apron when she saw them slap each other. Both guys checked on Sherri, then they brawled outside the ring and it ended up as a double countout.

9. Stephanie McMahon Vs. Trish Stratus - No Way Out 2001

Stephanie McMahon was the heel wife of Triple H in the storyline that led to their eventual real marriage a few years later. Trish Stratus started in WWE about a year before their big match in February 2001 at No Way Out. Trish's role at the time was that of the mistress of Vince McMahon, who was so mean as a heel that he was drugging his wife Linda so that she was in a comatose state. The reason the match took place was because Stephanie was mad that Trish was "more than friends" with Vince even though Stephanie was a heel just like Vince and Trish were. It was still a match that made sense from the story perspective because fans just wanted to see these two women go at it. Give the women a lot of credit for putting on an entertaining match too. Neither woman had much experience in the ring yet they were able to have a solid match for the ten minutes they were given. William Regal showed up to decide the finish by helping Trish at first and then changing his mind to give Stephanie the win after he nailed Trish with a neckbreaker. They both stayed heel after this with Stephanie remaining in that role for over a year after this while Trish turned face a few months later once the angle with Vince was over.

8. Kurt Angle Vs. JBL - Smackdown 2005 (Last Man Standing)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtfgmVCglb4 This was on the last Smackdown before the 2005 Royal Rumble with an airdate of January 27, 2005. JBL was the WWE Champion and he was set to defend the title at the Rumble against Angle as well as Big Show, who was a babyface. Both JBL and Angle were top heels on the Smackdown brand. They had a really good match that went about twenty minutes. They ended it in a draw with Angle using a chair shot and JBL using a boot into the chair to knock down Angle, so neither man could answer the ten count in this Last Man Standing match. When it was over, they showed Show backstage laughing about it as if this would give him an advantage in the match at the Rumble. The story was that he convinced Teddy Long to book the match so that those two guys would be weak. JBL ended up retaining at the Rumble. It's one of those many forgotten good television matches just because it's not as common as some of the others we might remember.

7. Owen Hart vs. British Bulldog - Raw 1997

It was the match that crowned the first European Champion in WWE history. The match took place on February 26, 1997 in Berlin, Germany and aired on March 3. Owen was the tag team champion with Bulldog and they were heels. They were also brothers-in-law since Bulldog was married to Owen's sister Diana. The match was unique because you don't see heel tag team champions wrestling very often. Since it took place in Europe, Bulldog wrestled like more of a babyface that played to the fans while Owen did a lot of the great heel tactics he was known for. This match is one of the best in Raw history too. They were given about 15 minutes to wrestle a technical classic and that's what they did. It was no surprise that they had great chemistry since they knew each other so well as family members that were tag champs. After a number of great nearfalls, near submissions and great counter wrestling, Bulldog was able to win by countering a cradle. He was the first European Champion in WWE history. The team continued on for the rest of the year as part of The Hart Foundation with Bret hart. There's also a story associated with the match because Raw's ratings were poor for this show and it's apparently something that led to Vince Russo pitching to Vince McMahon the idea that they need to change the attitude of the company. Soon after this, Russo became a part of the creative team, McMahon was open to a lot of his ideas and WWE started to take off about a year after this with the Attitude Era going strong.

6. Edge Vs. Randy Orton - Raw 2007

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyAzc5zNyjI It was April 30, 2007 and Edge was one of the top heels in WWE along with Randy Orton. They had a great run as a duo known as Rated RKO that feuded with Shawn Michaels and Triple H (Degeneration X) as well as others. Due to their massive egos, they had a match on Raw that was excellent. It followed the Backlash PPV from a week earlier when they failed to beat John Cena for the WWE Title in a four way that also included Shawn Michaels. They went 16 minutes and the crowd really didn't cheer for one guy more than the other. As it was going on the cheers grew simply because the match was excellent and they appreciated the great wrestling action. Since both guys were closely connected due to the run as Rated RKO, it was really easy to get into a match like this. Each guy cheated in the match when they could and they also busted out their signature spots for a lot of great nearfalls that the crowd totally bought into. Give them credit for working their butts off to produce one of the better heel vs. heel matches you're going to see. After a number of great nearfalls and Orton busted open, Edge countered the RKO and got the win thanks to a Spear and it was enough to win the match. Both guys remained in heel roles after this match. Edge ended up moving to the Smackdown brand a few weeks later as the World Champion over there as well as the top heel while Orton was one of the top heels on Raw.

5. Damien Sandow Wins Money In The Bank - MITB 2013

This is one of the more unique heel matchups ever because WWE decided to have one of their Money in the Bank briefcases be contested only among heels. There were seven guys in the match: Damien Sandow, Wade Barrett, Cody Rhodes, Dean Ambrose, Fandango, Jack Swagger and Antonio Cesaro. A lot of us had no idea who was going to win. Ambrose was still fairly new with The Shield, Barrett was a guy that always seemed like a favorite in these kinds of matches, the same can be said about Cody Rhodes and then there was Damien Sandow, who ended up as the victor. The match was memorable for the finish. It looked like Cody Rhodes was going to win after he cleared everybody else out of the ring. It sounded like Cody was the favorite of the crowd too. Then his best friend Damien Sandow showed up, knocked Rhodes down and then Sandow climbed up to take the win. It was played up as a cheap move by Sandow against his buddy with Rhodes turning face as a result of the finish. It was a cool way of telling a story within the context of the match. We really didn't know how it was going to play out, yet by the end of it the reaction was more like "damn that was great" because it was.

4. The Undertaker Vs. Big Bossman - WrestleMania 15

A lot of people remember this match as the worst Hell in a Cell match in WWE history. It was also arguably the second biggest match at WrestleMania 15 and it involved two heels with The Undertaker taking on the Big Bossman. This was during the point in Undertaker's career where he became more of an evil, demonic heel that convinced people to follow him and do work for him. They called it the Ministry of Darkness. They had him do all kinds of crazy things like tying Steve Austin to a cross and also what he did to end this match: hanging Big Bossman by a noose. Undertaker won the match clean. It was boring. Post match, the Brood showed up to tie Bossman, then Undertaker hung him and they just moved on from them. It's pretty crazy that a wrestling show would go so far as to have somebody hang from a noose as if that was some great idea, but that's what happened. Looking back, it was such a stupid angle and also ridiculous that they barely paid attention to the sight of a grown man on the receiving end of a hanging like that.

3. Kurt Angle Vs. Triple H - Royal Rumble 2001

The Stephanie McMahon vs. Trish Stratus match that was mentioned earlier happened because of what took place during this match. At the time, Angle was the heel WWE Champion that had become friends with Stratus, who was still fairly new at the time. Triple H was also a heel after a year of dominating the title scene with his then storyline wife Stephanie McMahon. It made sense as a WWE Title match at a major PPV like the Royal Rumble because they were two top guys who didn't like eachother. Plus there were storylines from the previous summer where it looked like Angle had a crush on Stephanie and she might have liked him too. It was a very good rivalry although they really didn't have the kind of blowoff match to end things that people were expecting. The match had an interesting dynamic since both guys were heels. There were all kinds of crazy things happening with the women fighting at ringside, Vince McMahon breaking it up because Trish was his sidepiece at the time and then Steve Austin factoring into the finish with an attack on Triple H, which gave Angle the fluke win. They had a lot of good matches together. This was one of their better ones even with both guys riding the heel side of the fence.

2. The Undertaker Vs. Kane - Judgment Day 1998

With the WWE Title vacant, Vince McMahon put the evil brother duo of The Undertaker and Kane in a match for the WWE Title with popular babyface Steve Austin as the referee. The brothers were clearly in the heel role. They were also wreaking havoc everywhere they went. The storyline reason for it made sense. They worked together to screw Austin out of the WWE Title at the PPV before this one, so now Vince put them in a match to see who the champion would be while Austin would be forced to hand over the title to the new winner. It would humiliate Austin while putting over one of Vince's guys in the scenario. As was the case a lot of time during this period, Vince's evil plans didn't work and Austin found a way around it by counting both guys down. Neither man left as WWE Champion. "And the winner of the match is Stone Cold Steve Austin!" The crowd loved it. The match was pretty boring. A lot of Undertaker's matches with Kane were. They just didn't have a great chemistry sometimes, so that's what happens. The crowd was still into it because the story was strong. It's one of the biggest heel vs. heel matches because it ended a PPV, even with the controversial finish. That show ended with the famous line from Vince McMahon: "Screw you Austin, you're fired."

1. The Shield Vs. The Wyatt Family - Elimination Chamber 2014

This is the best match on here, that's for sure. Going into it, the anticipation was huge because The Shield were running roughshod in WWE for about 15 months at that point while The Wyatt Family made a huge impact after about seven months. They were kept apart for the most part until WWE needed something for them to do at the PPV between the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania, so that led to this match at Elimination Chamber. There might be people reading this saying "The Shield were faces at time" yet if you really think about it the turn wasn't totally complete yet. The thinking was that WWE just wanted to do this huge match between two big stables, let them go all out in the match and let the fans decide who they wanted to support. There were "this is awesome" chants at the start of the match as well as "Let's go Wyatts" and "Let's go Shield" chants. JBL on commentary said the crowd didn't know who to cheer for, but they just wanted to see a fight. That's a good way of summarizing it. They were given 22 minutes in the match, everybody got a chance to look like a star and the action never really slowed down with fighting all over the arena. Towards the end of the match, Wyatt brawled with Ambrose through the crowd, then Harper and Rowan gave Rollins a double Chokeslam through a table for the big spot of the match. That left Reigns alone to deal with the Wyatt Family himself and he couldn't get the job done because Wyatt was able to pin Reigns. It was the match of the year for a lot of people in 2014, myself included. Fans didn't care about rooting for one side or another. They just wanted a great match and that's what they got.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.