10 Biggest Sacred Cows In Wrestling In 2018
Don't milk it...
For those unfamiliar, a literal sacred cow is a creature deified and celebrated by Hinduism without question or compromise. These (despite the utterly wonderful image you may have spotted of Kane dominating a herd of Knox County's finest milkers at the front of this article) will not be the beasts analysed within.
The idiom that emerges from this, however, can be applied to life beyond bovine beauties. Pro wrestling is fertile ground for the blind idolisation of talents by its very nature - it asks audiences to pick favourites in every single match - but the late-1990s growth of the Internet Wrestling Community (and the online branches that have sprung from that tree's roots ever since) has resulted in talents being seemingly immune from criticism if they had the right moves, looks or attributes that jived with broader received wisdom.
The declining mental and physical states of workrate sweethearts Dynamite Kid, Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero in the mid-2000s widened the net beyond the typical too - scroll below the line on this and other sites to find furious abuse in response to criticism directed at particular wrestlers. Give it a few days and those same remarks may appear below this article! Think about it like this - somebody, somewhere, is still absolutely f*cking livid that Jackson Andrews wasn't given an extended push alongside Tyson Kidd back in 2010.
And such is the reality of the sacred cow. Especially, recently, this first one...
10. Johnny Gargano
In a lot of ways, WrestleMania 34 was WWE's 2018 in a microcosm. Half of the show was a sheer delight; an exploration of the earthly pleasures the company can provide. The other half was at times disastrous, depressing and destructive.
Such was the case with Johnny Gargano's troubled journey at the top of the NXT card. He engaged in sublime matches with Andrade Almas and former partner Tomasso Ciampa on the first two TakeOvers of 2018, and though returns were diminished with his #DIY-destroying ex, Gargano's babyface fire still lit up every show he worked.
It was the dark, brooding version of his character that seemed to to trigger his fervent fanbase when reasoned criticisms came his way. Gargano's performance as he walked across Exposition Bridge outside Full Sail was, for some, utterly cringeworthy. He went on about loving "the dark" to justify his heel attack on Aleister Black, and was immediately pied by his TakeOver: War Games 2 opponent as a fraudulent teenage goth.
Certain fans dared to agree with Black's assessment, and were themselves pilloried by 'Johnny Wrestling's army of followers. The subsequent match undid much of the bickering - Black and Gargano should both stick to doing more talking in the ring than they do on Twitter - but the sooner the heart of NXT's beats through the audience rather than in spite of it again, the better.
9. Natalya
Has Natalya ever been as good as the vocal minority that make up her fanbase have suggested?
Assuming that those that pop during her entrance aren't doing so because they're thinking of Uncle Bret, there must be something that has resulted in the middling former Women's Champion being so often teflon to reasoned critique.
This is not to say she's not many things. It's very apparent what a figure for good she's been for the internal mechanisms of a still-ongoing women's wrestling revolution. Early Total Divas episode focussed on her in particular being scrapped from shows in favour of other less-savvy performers (both male and female) and the struggles she endured for brighter days. However, wrestling is so often about timing, and was hers just a little off all along?
Her matches are almost always middle-of-the-road in an era where the topline contests command main events on merit. Her genuinely pleasant personality presents a forced and fake heel persona, or a dishwater-dull babyface one. Dare to pull at these loose threads though, and her fans rage at the injustices as if these 2018 was still trapped in Diva doldrums.
8. Finn Bálor
'The Extraordinary Man That Can Do Extraordinary Things' isn't just saddled with nickname that tacitly questions why he wouldn't just do said 'things' all the time - he's basically spent 2018 being booked with all the logic of that exact moniker.
And it's because it's not all his fault that such rage flows.
Bálor supporters are right to stick up for the former NXT Champion, if only because he clearly doesn't seem to bother himself. He's been extraordinarily good at following Vince McMahon's dated "big smiles out there" credo, but name a top WWE star from the last 30 years that would have tolerated the sh*t he's gone through with a grin and you'll have your answer as to why he's not one himself.
Frankly, Finn shouldn't have cracked so much as an acceptant smirk since having his Universal Championship carefully poached by Mick Foley in August 2016. The fire and the fury didn't even burn before it could be extinguished. History has informed us that McMahon likes a bit of grit and gristle in his talent but even in ignoring his incredible physique, there isn't an ounce of such ugly fat anywhere near the shredded 'Demon'.
This is why it's actually okay to give up on 'Finn Bálor: WWE Main Event star' - because he has too.
7. AJ Styles
WWE's '365' Network special on Kevin Owens was an alarming and illuminating look at the realities of life for a man that didn't really know where he stood in an organisation he'd only recently been atop of. The sequel - a year-round profile on AJ Styles during his year-long reign with the WWE Championship - in contrast reflected a man who knew exactly where he stood; right in the middle ground.
There was a time when safe-pair-of-hands AJ was vital to the future of the title. As the aforementioned documentary covered, in between powerful losses to Finn Bálor and Brock Lesnar, Styles liberated the strap from Jinder Mahal and in doing so immediately restored it to former glories.
A year later though, and The New Daniel Bryan felt too like he was saving the day.
Styles' 371-day run - not entirely down to his own failings - was a moribund slew of middling matches and passable promos. His opponents were routinely more responsible for elevating their programmes than he was. It's largely the reason the Nakamura "dream match" triggered a load of nightmares that even Samoa Joe's bedtime stories couldn't placate. The truth hurt - a very, very good wrestler had a very, very ordinary year.
6. Kane
You're not allowed to have a go at Kane because he's been knocking about 21 years.
You're not allowed to have a go at Kane because he's Knox County Mayor in his other life, lol.
You're not allowed to have a go at Kane because he's a legend, pal, and he's a bigger star than Finn Bálor ever will be so that's why it's okay he beat him so easily all those times.
Are you allowed to have a go at Kane because he's not any good?
Kane - and this discussion has been had more times than is healthy - has had precisely one good gimmick-free singles match ever. The bizarrely brilliant 2001 SmackDown scrap with Albert is absolutely worth watching, but nothing he's done on his own over the aforementioned two decades-plus-one warrants a mention.
Your writer is no big fan of The Undertaker and has thus had threats and curses made on his person as a result. Your writer has also stuck with WWE's output for nearly 30 years and thus understands just how much 'The Deadman' has contributed to such a perfectly imperfect product. Kane has longevity without the legitimacy, unless you're a Knox County residence that needs something doing about your bins.
5. New Japan Pro Wrestling
WWE as an entire promotion doesn't feature in this list (despite its most ardent defenders finding anything to use to excuse its ills below the line) because it is too obvious to pick at all the moving parts instead. With New Japan Pro Wrestling, this becomes trickier.
It's end-of-year season, and countless other 2018 reviews will remind you of the superlative stuff from NJPW's workers and writers alike. Yet, a large swathe of supporters are deeply concerned with the future direction of the brand.
Blame is apportioned all over for what many consider something of a post-G1 Climax slump in 2018, even though longstanding fans accept a certain drop-off after the gruelling summer tournament. Kenny Omega's IWGP Championship run has met with mixed feedback from fans but endless snowflakes from Dave Meltzer. Chris Jericho's absence has resembled Brock Lesnar's indifference, but 'Y2J' was credited for a huge upswing in New Japan World Subscriber numbers this year. Tetsuya Naito is winning again, but to what end when only the Intercontinental Title is currently achievable.
It can be both of course - the best product in the world isn't yet in the reaches of utopian perfection. Criticise it and you're blind to the positives. Praise it and you're an 'Elite' interloper. The ley lines are in the middle of course - it's just a shame prolific head booker Gedo can't control those too.
4. Shane McMahon
Shane McMahon's 2016 generated a buzz so big it effectively helped WWE convincingly fib about setting an all-time attendance record.
The 100,000+ number they inflated for WrestleMania 32 was helped over the line by the skipping, ducking and diving 'Shane O Mac's late involvement. The curiosity factor was undeniable, but it killed the cat and the show when 'The Money' went toe-to-toe with The Undertaker for 30 minutes.
And herein lies the problem so many have with Shane if it wasn't so abundantly clear when he won Crown Jewel's World Cup. To many, he's that sweating, dancing, potato-lobbing fool every single time. He was playing at being insufferable in Saudi Arabia, but through the eyes of his critics he's that every single time.
It's the strangest thing; such large sections of the crowd adore him that they effectively shout down any negativity towards the spoiled-brat done good. More than benefitting from a charmed life, he's perhaps the biggest lesser of the biggest two evils in comparison with either his Sister or his Dad. This is almost entirely lost in translation though, moving through a common sense filtration system moving faster than his poorly-worked-punches.
Maybe Virgil had it right all along. "F*ck Money".
3. Dean Ambrose
This article was planned ahead of WWE's final pay-per-view of 2018, but the December supershow delivered at least one lump of coal that helped argue points for two separate entries within it.
When Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins stunk up Tables, Ladders and Chairs, the fury from the live audience seemed borne out of surprise for the snoozer they were being forced to endure. It was a match that actually lived down to the build-up, rather than rendering the wretched story redundant.
Why, and how, did long-tenured rivals and good hands Ambrose and Rollins get this one so wrong?
As much as anything, it's because they're long-tenured rivals and good hands. Ambrose and Rollins worked so often during The Shield's original split and have been through all their greatest hits over the prior two years that very little felt fresh. This is not just their fault of course, but the trick here was to deploy devious takes on old spots from Dean, and generate dizziness from Seth's dynamic retorts. These are the steps taken by elite performers though, not good hands. There's zero shame in occupying that space, but don't suggest it to the former 'Lunatic Fringe's lunatic fans.
Or, for that matter, those residing in a house of mediocrity assembled by 'The Architect'...
2. Seth Rollins
...Can I just shock you? I like Seth Rollins. Despite what I've just said earlier. At any one time I've got nine Seth Rollins matches queued up on my Network watchlist.
But he shouldn't get a second title reign.
WWE would love to make a really great Seth Rollins programme, it would seem. And yet, within 10 minutes of "Burn It Down" perforating eardrums within the arena, I'd rather be catching up on some Inner City Sumo or the Monkey Tennis grand final.
He's handy, but the begged-for babyface Championship reign will never undo the mistakes made in his first run. I've watched his main events, I've watched them all, and I haven't liked a single one. He's someone with a proven track record of having mostly bad singles programmes. Under his stewardship in 2015, Raw's ratings started badly and got worse. And that was when he was a heel. The laugh, the snarl, the grin. You can smell his cheese before he thrusts it in your face.
This take always puts the partridge amongst the pigeons though. Please don't take my chat away from me.
1. CM Punk
Has the milk that squirts from wrestling's most sacred udder finally begun to sour? Enough fans have ignored their parents and cried over the spillages.
CM Punk's legal victory over WWE doctor Chris Amann was an important one for the man himself but almost as crucial for those that cover the industry on podcasts and other mediums such as this. Ignoring some of the argued medical malpractice, the cynical inclusion of Colt Cabana in the suit implied that the host was as guilty should the words of his guest be considered slanderous.
It was an ugly scene - made even uglier when a follow-up suit between both plaintiffs revealed a deep rift over legal fees and loyalty.
Punk left wrestling behind before he'd even left the building in 2014 and thus shouldn't be judged for his subsequent decision-making. What can still be reappraised are his contributions nearly five years later. Chants for his name are as much a protest against boring booking as they are catcall for the 'Voice Of The Voiceless' to make a return, but the acrimony around his exit seems to fuel the deification.
Punk was, his in own words, a "jerk" to a lot of people and yet got let off the hook because he was a good mainstream wrestler before mainstream wrestling got great.
Amongst a myriad of other reasons, is it possible that Punk isn't returning because he knows he couldn't keep up anymore? Or worse, that the fans that idolised him have moved on?