10 Biggest WWE Missed Opportunities In SummerSlam History

Some of them helped with the benefit of hindsight... some of them should have been obvious at the time!

SummerSlam is coming up on Sunday, August 17. WWE's summer classic is one of the biggest events of the year for the company and one that fans are highly anticipating. The reason for that is due to the main event that has been booked for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. John Cena will be defending the title against The Beast Incarnate Brock Lesnar in the long awaited return match from 2012. As fans know, Cena won that showdown and now many believe it's Brock's turn to go over. If Lesnar does indeed win the championship, it would likely mean the first step on the road for Roman Reigns to becoming WWE's new top guy. However if Cena wins, then it's back to business as usual for the company. Either result raises the very interesting point of "what it?" It's a question that fans have asked many times in the past concerning WWE's pay-per-views and SummerSlam is no different. The company is fallible and many times directions are taken that leave fans scratching their heads and wondering just exactly why certain moves are made and what it all means. It all comes down to missed opportunities. SummerSlam has seen its fair share and August 17 may actually bring more of the same. But thus far there are 10 that really stand out from the rest.

10. Rick Rude Does Not Win WWE Championship In 1990

Rick Rude was one of the best heels that the pro wrestling business had ever seen. He was cocky, he was arrogant and he had an air of self-importance that made fans shake their heads in disgust. Rude was convinced that he was not only the best but that he was also the best looking and that was enough to put him among the most hated in the eyes of fans. In WWE Rude was part of Bobby Heenan's family and that meant he moved to the front of the line in terms of both getting heat and getting opportunity. By the time his feud with The Ultimate Warrior began, some fans were likely expecting that Rude would be able to do the impossible and walk away with the WWE Championship. However, that was not the case. Vince McMahon's company revolved around three top Superstars at that time; Warrior, Randy Savage and of course, Hulk Hogan. Warrior and Hogan were babyface while Savage could work on either side of the fence and still be just as effective. It was a formula that worked for WWE and one that made money for them. Unfortunately, that formula had no room for someone like Rick Rude, who was probably viewed as just a strong heel used to get the top talent over. Rude did not win the championship from Warrior during this feud and in fact did not become WWE's top titleholder at all during his career. Looking back on it now, the possibilities that existed for Rick Rude as WWE champion were very rich indeed. He would have had three instant rivalries just waiting to begin and he would have had other protagonists ready to challenge him that could not get over on Hogan. Of course, WWE did not take the chance and chose instead to stay with what worked for them.

9. DX Defeats The Legacy In 2009

Triple H had spent some time in 2009 feuding with his former Evolution protegee, Randy Orton. The Viper had matured and truly come into his own as a main event star and working with The Game only helped elevate him in the company. By the time Orton had recruited his own faction in The Legacy, Hunter was attempting to play catch up. Despite what Triple H did, he could not overcome the odds he was faced with against three men. The Game was good but at the end of the day, he was just not good enough. He needed backup and he needed it in the worst way. Enter Shawn Michaels, who had not been seen on WWE TV for nearly four months at the time. Triple H convinced his best friend to come back to the fray and that meant working together to best Randy Orton's young tag team. At 2009's SummerSlam, that is exactly what they did. In a match that was considered by many to have stolen the show, the reunited Degeneration-X defeated Ted Dibiase and Cody Rhodes. The loss reaffirmed DX's position in the company and proved once again that younger talents are often no match for established veterans in WWE. However, this was a missed opportunity because the company could have done the unexpected. Fans likely knew that DX would not come back together to just lose, so they perhaps did not take The Legacy seriously. Rhodes and Dibiase would have been flying under the radar and a win at SummerSlam would very much have been a surprise. DX would have recovered by the next night, as one loss surely would have had no effect on them. For Legacy though, a win over WWE's legendary duo would have catapulted them even higher than before.

8. Yokozuna Retains The WWE Championship Against Lex Luger In 1993

In 1993, WWE was looking for the next Hulk Hogan and believed they had perhaps found him in Lex Luger. The former Horseman and NWA star had all the tools necessary to succeed on a high level in that role. He had a great look, he was in tremendous shape and he was someone that the fans could truly rally behind in the big match atmosphere. When Luger bodyslammed the gargantuan Yokozuna on the USS Intrepid, he found himself flying head first into that main event world. His actions on that aircraft carrier not only got him noticed, it also got him a WWE Championship match at SummerSlam. The company spent a lot of time and money hyping this championship match and at the time, it did seem that Luger was on his way to claiming the title of top guy. However, that was not to be as Yokozuna retained the belt. That left Luger to fight on his own and left him out of main event glory. There seems to be no good reason why Vince did not allow Luger to go over for the championship at SummerSlam. But according to interviews that Luger has done over the years, McMahon never approached him to replace Hogan or become WWE's new top guy. Luger also claims that he knew Yokozuna would keep the belt after SummerSlam because he was going to feud with The Undertaker. Despite what the company's reasoning was, the fact remained that Luger did not become WWE Champion at SummerSlam. For the fans that supported him and for the job that he did filling the spot formerly held by Hogan, the night may well have been a big missed opportunity.

7. Triple H Fails To Win His First WWE Title In 1999

In 1999, Triple H had emerged from Degeneration-X and had come into his own as a main event Superstar. Hunter had put the right amount of distance between himself and his former faction and it was a wise move on WWE's part. Fans were able to look past DX and see Hunter as The Cerebral Assassin, the man that would stop at nothing to become the best. However, the WWE Championship was not in the cards for him at SummerSlam in 1999. That night saw the title being contested in a triple threat match that also included Mankind and the champ, Stone Cold Steve Austin. While The Game's forward progress had become very evident among fans and many knew what was to come in terms of championships, none of that happened at SummerSlam. Triple H put in a very good effort at the event and looked impressive as always but championship immortality still remained just out of his reach. Rumors ran rampant online that perhaps Austin did not want to put The Game over, as he felt it was too soon for him. Since Austin was the company's top star at the time, he definitely would have had a great deal of influence in who would or would not beat him for the championship. And even though Triple H challenged and defeated Mankind on the following Monday Night Raw to become the New WWE champion, the rumors lived on. Had Austin prevented Triple H from winning the WWE title at SummerSlam? While Hunter's legacy and career accomplishments are not in question, the fact is that seemingly ill timed win still is. Fans are accustomed to seeing the best reach that top level on the pay-per-view stage so to see Triple H win it on Raw instead was a real curiosity. Was it seen as a consolation prize by some of the WWE faithful? Who knows perhaps how the company would have booked Hunter if he had won it all as many expected, at SummerSlam?

6. The Great Khali Retains World Title Against Batista In 2007

The Great Khali has never exactly been considered great by many WWE fans. The seven foot Punjabi Nightmare had been booked as an unstoppable monster in 2007 and it was that image that led to him becoming the World champion. While his title run should have been filled with one impressive victory after another, the fact is that his inability in the ring was clearly evident from the very beginning. So when Batista stepped up to face Khali at SummerSlam that year, many WWE fans likely believed that a title change was definitely in the cards. The Animal seemed to be the right man for the job and honestly, fans were anxious to see it happen. However, that title change did not occur as Batista won by disqualification. Even though he did eventually best Khali for the World Heavyweight Title at Unforgiven, the fact was that virtually no one wanted to see the giant as champion to begin with. Batista may have later been seen as an arrogant out-of-touch Superstar but in 2007, he was still a top face in the company. There was no better choice to take Khali down than The Animal and when it finally did happen, the WWE faithful surely breathed a sigh of relief. Of course, that title win was expected at SummerSlam and unfortunately, it did not happen.

5. Brock Lesnar Beats CM Punk In 2013

CM Punk had perhaps the best three year span of any WWE Superstar in recent memory. From the pipebomb and Summer of Punk in 2011, to his heel turn and association with Paul Heyman in 2012, to his face turn in 2013, Punk did it all. He faced John Cena, The Rock and The Undertaker in those three years and by the time he got to Brock Lesnar at Summerslam in 2013, he was a battle tested top guy in the company. A win over Lesnar would have been huge for Punk but unfortunately, it did not happen. The Beast Incarnate had been sent by Heyman as revenge for Punk betraying him in the first place, so a Lesnar win was perhaps the only way for WWE to go. Leaving Punk bruised and beaten put him at an incredible disadvantage and allowed Heyman to shine in the feud. After SummerSlam was over however, Brock left WWE once again. The win over Punk apparently meant nothing as The Beast moved on and Punk was left with no way to exact any revenge himself. Brock is a big money player, a top star that is brought in only for prime matches on pay-per-view; fans are very aware of this. So with that being the case, this match should have been either a breakdown or a win for Punk. The Best in the World did not get that moniker by losing to less than part time Superstars whenever the situation called for it and he should have been given more consideration at SummerSlam.

4. The Nexus Is Defeated By Team WWE In 2010

When The Nexus debuted in 2010, they did so with more impact and more controversy than any faction in WWE history. Led by Wade Barrett, the NXT rookies beat down John Cena, CM Punk, Luke Gallows, Jerry Lawler and anyone else that got in their way. They destroyed the ring, demolished the ringside area and left fans in stunned silence. The Nexus had wreaked total havoc on WWE and they spent the next several months continuing that trend. While many WWE Superstars stood up to fight them, no one was able to even make a dent. Barrett's crew was unstoppable and indestructible. However, all of that changed at SummerSlam. The Nexus faced off against Team WWE. Comprised of Daniel Bryan, Edge, Chris Jericho, R-Truth, John Morrison, Bret Hart and John Cena, Team WWE had a showdown with The Nexus that had been building since June of 2010. The Nexus had been completely dominant up to that point and fans expected more of the same at SummerSlam. However, that did not happen as Cena was the last man standing while The Nexus was left licking its wounds. And John did it in typical Cena style; he took his fair share of heat in this match, including a DDT on the floor, yet just kept right on going. Perhaps if WWE had more time for this main event, then the outcome would have been more realistic and more believable. But for many fans, nothing could have excused the most powerful faction that WWE had ever known coming out on the losing end of a match they should have won. This marked the first time that all seven members tasted real defeat on the same night and it ultimately led to their downfall just four months later. Fans had believed in their dominance to a point but when it became evident Cena would destroy them, they did not believe anymore. Had The Nexus won, who knows what direction WWE could have taken with the storyline for the rest of 2010, or perhaps even beyond that. Unfortunately, fans will never know.

3. Booker T Loses WCW Title To The Rock In 2001

The Rock returned to WWE in 2001 and the company he came back to was under siege. Shane McMahon had been at the helm of The Alliance, a massive stable of WCW and ECW stars that had invaded WWE and sought to take over. The union between both defunct companies took direct aim at Vince McMahon and the man with his finger on the trigger was the WCW champion, Booker T. The Rock represented WWE and was the one man that could physically stand up to The Alliance, to take momentum back for the fans. At SummerSlam, he did just that when he faced and defeated Booker T to become the new WCW champion. While WWE was obviously going to prevail in this storyline, the fact is that the company had a prime opportunity to do something different and it chose not to. A lot of work was done to convince fans that The Alliance could win the day and ultimately rule in WWE but of course that did not happen. Vince McMahon had defeated his biggest rival in WCW and to imagine that he would give them any sort of important moment on the air was perhaps too much of a stretch for anyone to believe. However, Booker T had put his time in and earned his spot; if anyone deserved to shine that night, it was him. Going over on The Rock would have been huge for Booker and been a major twist in this angle. Of course, that did not happen and it ranks as one of the biggest missed opportunities in SummerSlam history.

2. Hulk Hogan Beats Shawn Michaels In 2005

This match still ranks as one of the most infamous in WWE history and it's one that did not have to happen. The fact is that for many WWE fans, Shawn Michaels had no business losing to Hulk Hogan at SummerSlam in 2005. It was a loss that could have been prevented if only Hogan had truly wanted to do business and do it the right way. The Heartbreak Kid had all the momentum going into this match. Michaels had spent several weeks mocking Hogan, making fun of him and insulting him as only he could. HBK pulled out his DX bag of tricks and used everything he had to not only embarrass Hogan but to convince fans that their beloved Hulkster was nothing more than a sham. Shawn had incredible heat against Hogan and by all rights should have won this match. However, that did not happen and he spent the majority of the bout overselling Hogan's moves to the point that it was absolutely comical. Michaels looked more like a cartoon character than a pro wrestler and fans soon began to realize that his actions served a purpose. This was HBK's way of protesting the loss, of showing that despite the fact that he was willing to lay down for Hogan that he was not willing to do it without letting fans know how he truly felt about it. Hogan would not lose to Shawn at SummerSlam and later refused to work a second match with him. Michaels basically did the best he could with what he had and obviously enjoyed himself while doing it. WWE missed a prime opportunity with this match. Hogan should have played ball and done the job at SummerSlam. HBK was not a rookie, not a fresh face that Hogan would've had to carry through the match. And there is no reason why Michaels should have been treated that way. Hulk could have dropped the first one and then won the second; he would have come out on top and Shawn's character would have to eat crow for all the bashing he did against Hogan in this rivalry.

1. Alberto Del Rio Cashes In On CM Punk In 2011

Look up the definition of momentum and you will find a pic of CM Punk from 2011. It was during that year fans witnessed one of the biggest moments in WWE history, when Punk sat cross-legged on the Raw stage and dropped his first WWE pipebomb. In that promo, Punk attacked the company hierarchy and insulted everyone that he felt had stood in his way or sought to hold him down. He also laid the groundwork for the Summer of Punk, an angle that ran for the next several months and made him a star in the process. During the course of that angle however, a very confusing twist took place when Alberto Del Rio cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase on Punk at the end of the SummerSlam main event. Punk had just won the match against John Cena, establishing the one true WWE champion. Suddenly Kevin Nash unexpectedly came down to the ring and powerbombed Punk, opening the door for Del Rio to cash in and get the pin. The move left fans bewildered, in shock over what had happened. CM Punk had risen to the top of the company and just like that, he was left looking defeated in a ridiculous situation. The angle with Nash did nothing but slow Punk down and it all began at SummerSlam. That night could have been the crowning achievement in the Summer of Punk; it was the second time Punk had pinned Cena and that should have been the image fans were left with. WWE had it right with Punk, everything was going so smoothly and fans were buying into every moment of it. However, Nash's involvement led to Punk having even more heat with Triple H and that eventually led to a match between the two men, which Punk lost. That moment in particular stands out for many as being the one black eye on an otherwise perfect storyline.. Using Del Rio at SummerSlam was bad timing. Even though Punk continued on his path at the top of the main event scene, it was never quite the same for many fans that expected The Best in the World to overcome that night.

Contributor
Contributor

Host of Tom Clark's Main Event, WWE Featured Columnist for Bleacher Report and a Contributor for the Camel Clutch Blog http://tomclarkbr.wix.com/blog tomclarksmainevent.libsyn.com