10 Biggest WWE Pay-Per-View Disappointments

Don't let me down, gently.

Goldberg The Rock
WWE

For WWE, a curse of being the biggest wrestling company in the world is the propensity to disappoint.

The weighty expectations of a vast audience awaiting satiation from your major shows and headline matches creates huge pressure amongst those within the organisation wishing to provide the most satisfying product possible to their fiercely loyal customers.

Often due to the collective talent of those involved, in-built predilections of wrestling fans or the spectacle of a high profile meeting between two wrestlers, presumptions are made that stretch beyond the ability of talent and creative alike.

However, on some occasions, every positive forecast is justified. Despite this, there have been several matches over the years that have almost guaranteed customer satisfaction in their promotion, but have ultimately failed to deliver on the lofty promise.

With WrestleMania just around the corner, the threat of a potential failure on the grandest stage lingers over many, with industry icons even guilty of under-performing at the worst possible times.

Looking back at some of the worst offenders from over thirty years promoting major shows to their global audience, here are the 10 biggest WWE pay-per-view disappointments.

10. Rey Mysterio Vs Sabu (One Night Stand 2006)

Sabu Rey Mysterio ECW one Night Stand 2006
WWE.com

One of the first signs that WWE's 2006 ECW relaunch may not be quite the renegade it promised, Rey Mysterio's 'Extreme Rules' World Title defence against Sabu was less of a hardcore war and more a harsh reminder of the passage of time.

Both were working at half speed, with most of the chair-based or high flying offence falling way short of expectations as the contest highlighted some huge impending issues with the muddled revival.

With Sabu a shell of his 1990s self and Rey Mysterio long-homogenised by extended runs in WWE and WCW (and playing it safe in the match itself), the fans in attendance had little convincing to latch onto, and completely lost their patience when the battle was abruptly waved of by doctors f following a springboard DDT through a table onto the World Champion.

It was a ludicrous finish, not least one that couldn't exist under ECW rules, nor the 'extreme' ones WWE placed on the contest themselves.

With spots throughout the broadcast that were ostensibly more 'hardcore' than the move as well as Sabu's entire schtick working around how insane and brave he was in the face of potential injury, it was the worst possible outcome in the worst possible match.


9. Shawn Michaels Vs Ric Flair (Bad Blood 2003)

Shawn Michaels Ric Flair
WWE

Dwarfed in stature compared to their outstanding WrestleMania 24 clash five years later, this first televised meeting of two of the all-time greats failed to live up to the billing and suffered the ignominy of being tucked away on a B-show in 2003.

Going less than fifteen minutes during Monday Night Raw's first post-Brand Extension pay-per-view, Flair and Michaels couldn't get going in the contest, with 'The Nature Boy' leaning on his cheapest heel spots as a member of Evolution whilst Michaels tried to find the vim that had spilled over during his outstanding feud with Chris Jericho earlier in the year.

Resorting to shortcuts at the end of a laboured affair, Michaels needlessly splashed Flair through a table at ringside and was about to polish off his opponent with Sweet Chin Music until Ric's 'Evolution' buddy Randy Orton waffled him with a steel chair for a callously cheap finish.

Considered a dream match in real life and storylines, the brawl was an inexcusable non-event between two iconic figures that only served to preserve the value of the flagging heel stable ahead of Triple H's World Title victory over Kevin Nash later in the night.


8. Bret Hart Vs Bob Backlund (WrestleMania 11)

Bret Hart Bob Backlund WrestleMania XI.jpg
WWE.com

Bret Hart knew his worth, his value, and the quality he brought to matches, and even he thinks his WrestleMania 11 match was a stinker.

A substantial let-down, the 'I Quit' match between Hart and Bob Backlund was the final payoff to an enjoyable feud the two had carried over from late-1994, after Backlund viscously snapped and dethroned 'The Hitman' to transition the WWE Title to Diesel.

In contrast to the choice Survivor Series title switch the prior November though, the submission-based stipulation murdered the bout, with guest referee Rowdy Roddy Piper gobbling up the heat by shoving a wired microphone in both wrestler's face as often as he could to register the opponent surrendering.

Whilst that structurally damaged the contest, the finish completely to deliver the promised outcome.

With Backlund trapped in his own devastating crossface chickenwing submission hold, Piper jammed the microphone in his face yet again, broadcasting the garbled screams of Pyscho Bob as he struggled, then inexplicably ordered the referee to ring the bell.

This apparently constituted a victory for Hart, who looked visibly cross in his celebrations as he presumably lamented comfortably the worst pay-per-view match he'd ever competed in.


7. Brock Lesnar Vs Bill Goldberg (WrestleMania 20)

Brock Lesnar Goldberg WM 20
WWE.com

The WrestleMania 33 Universal Title match infamously took place once before on the grandest stage, and became host to one of the most controversial crowd reactions to any match in the history of the 'Showcase of the Immortals'.

Fans had got wind of news that Brock Lesnar was shockingly departing WWE after only two years, with Goldberg following him right out the door after electing not to renew his contract following a rotten year with the promotion.

Goldberg was already due to receive some boos with his impending exit foreshadowed by disappearing from television completely in the build-up.To his credit, Lesnar was required to scuffle with guest referee Stone Cold Steve Austin to get the battle of the behemoths to WrestleMania with any remaining steam.

With both the subject of bile from the impassioned Madison Square Garden crowd, the match descended into farce with the two barely locking up in the opening minutes, then playing off 'This Match Sucks' and 'Boring' chants with a timid tussle thoroughly befitting of the abuse.

Though Goldberg won the match with a spear and jackhammer, the result had already been forgotten when the two were planted with Stone Cold Stunners just moments later, much to the delight of the crowd.


6. Triple H Vs Scott Steiner (Royal Rumble 2003)

Triple H Scott Steiner 2003 Royal Rumble.jpg
WWE.com

One of WCW's last great hopes as a heel World Champion, Scott Steiner was a menacing force atop the promotion during its dying days. The enticing prospect of him finally arriving in WWE after seeing out the remainder of his Turner contract was increased when it became apparent he was going in at the very top.

Pitched against Triple H, 'Big Poppa Pump' was promoted as bigger, stronger and more dangerous than 'The Game', and by far the biggest threat to his Monday Night Raw throne ahead of their blockbuster Royal Rumble 2003 clash.

There had been limited physical interaction between the pair in the build up, with WWE curiously employing every smoke-and-mirrors technique to get to the eventual match.

But despite passing a medical, the severity of Steiner's hidden drop foot condition was clear for the world to see within minutes of the catastrophic encounter.

With Triple H woefully unprepared to carry both Steiner and the match, the entire thing fell apart in minutes, as a shattered Scott threw Hunter around with increasingly weaker suplexes that only raised the ire of a crowd that had already turned on the contest.

Credibility in tatters, Steiner would lose the programme, and be gone from the promotion within a year.


5. Chris Jericho Vs Edge (WrestleMania 26)

Chris Jericho Edge WrestleMania 26 Post-Match
WWE.com

A match that unfortunately proved a long-held Vince McMahon stereotype about the power of pro wrestlers vs big stars, the Chris Jericho/Edge WrestleMania 26 World Title was devoid of heat to such a degree that no amount of excellent in-ring prowess could overcome the malaise.

The feud between the former tag team partners had struggled to inspire audiences, with Edge's failure to click as a babyface following his initially shocking Royal Rumble return becoming all-too-apparent.

Though the contest had months of in-built story thanks to Edge's real-life injury whilst the duo were tag team champions, it couldn't hold a candle to the John Cena/Batista WWE title match that followed.

With a 'SPEAR! SPEAR! SPEAR!' chant that wasn't exactly the next 'What?' and years of heel work already in the bank with audiences, Edge lacked the usual momentum of a Rumble winner and WrestleMania Number One Contender in his revived babyface persona, and clean defeat in the duo's titanically disappointing battle was the final nail in the coffin.

Edge was a heel again within a month of the failed experiment, whilst Jericho wouldn't even make it through the following week as Champion, losing the title to 'Money In The Bank' winner Jack Swagger two nights later.


4. John Bradshaw Layfield Vs The Big Show (No Way Out 2005)

Big Show JBL No Way Out 2005
WWE.com

Though expectations were low on what JBL and The Big Show could do from an in-ring perspective, the vaunted 'Barbed Wire Cage' set to surround them horribly under-delivered on both real life and storyline expectations.

Booked by Teddy Long in a desperate bid to reduce the level of interference that had defined Bradshaw's unexpectedly enjoyable WWE Title reign, the threat of facing the giant challenger in such a lethal structure had blighted the champion from the moment it was announced.

However, on the night itself, the rolls of spiky chickenwire atop the usual steel cage were visually unimpressive, and barely featured into the match which booked itself out of the stipulation anyway.

After a deathly dull brawl, JBL's 'Cabinet' cohorts arrived on the scene with bolt-cutters, aiming to crack the lock on the door and/or destroy the cage to allow the Champion a barb-less escape.

Though the heels were dispatched by Long, the bolt-cutters were slid in for JBL to cork Big Show with for a tepid nearfall.

The finish came when Show chokeslammed the bloodied JBL through the ring from halfway up the cage. With the Champion presumably well beaten, Show elected to leave through the door, but Layfield escaped from the hole he'd fallen through to steal yet another victory.


3. The Rock Vs Bill Goldberg (Backlash 2003)

Goldberg The Rock
WWE

Following a brief-yet-beautiful run as a hollywood heel since his February 2003 return, The Rock could just about do no wrong in-ring and on the microphone, and was set to depart via defeat to WWE's newest ex-WCW roster edition.

Promoting the arrival of Goldberg during the WrestleMania 19 broadcast, fans were rapturous for his appearance the night after on Raw. Predictably, he ploughed through 'The Great One' with a spear to cap off Rock's self-made 'Appreciation Night' as he basked in the glory of his victory over Stone Cold Steve Austin.

In a dark foreshadowing of how aggressively the company would fail with the Goldberg character, their Backlash pay-per-view main event was ultimately booked to go twenty minutes and follow typical WWE formula with a long heel beatdown to build to an eventual comeback.

It exposed the Goldberg act on night one, with perennial crowd favourite Rock stealing the remainder of the heat with an impossibly entertaining heel act he simply refused to curb.

As Rock's clear farewell from the organisation for the foreseeable future, years of loyalty to 'The Great One' flooded out from the live crowd, highlighting worrying disinterest in Big Bill.

Even re-watching his first night years later, it's abundantly clear why Goldberg would be gone less than twelve months later.


2. Eddie Guerrero Vs Rey Mysterio (WrestleMania 21)

Eddie Guerrero Rey Mysterio WrestleMania 21
WWE.com

A famously frustrating opener between the lifelong allies, Mysterio and Guerrero promised big things with their first high profile WWE clash following legendary contests in WCW years earlier.

The two had only become more polished as performers since then, and an uneasy tension between the best friends provided a thin veneer of competitiveness required to push the battle over the line.

However, whilst passable, the two noticeably failed to click in ways they had previously, particularly thanks to Mysterio's endless struggling with a new mask he'd had made specifically for the match.

His fumbling with the facial apparatus was a constant distraction as a viewer, let alone for both performers trying to tell a nuanced story around trademark highspots, especially when Rey attempted to re-adjust it whilst selling the supposed agony Eddie had put him in.

Rey's eventual victory triggered a series of events that lead to an excellent feud between the two that sprawled numerous pay-per-views and a dynamic final heel turn for Eddie before his untimely November death. That this underwhelming match with his best friend subsequently became his last WrestleMania match remains bittersweet.


1. Shawn Michaels Vs Mr Perfect (SummerSlam '93)

Shawn Michaels Mr Perfect SummerSlam 1993
WWE.com

The dearth of legitimate superstars and in-ring talent in 1993 forced several unusual creative decisions that would have previously been unthinkable in Vince McMahon's once-thriving organisation.

WWE had a potentially excellent match in the offing as SummerSlam approached, and with Lex Luger's bus tour failing to inspire, the quality of the contest basically had to be guaranteed in order to sell the required tickets and pay-per-view buys.

This was the case of the long-awaited meeting of Mr Perfect and Intercontinental Champion Shawn Michaels.

Since kicking off their rivalry with a spirited brawl at WrestleMania 9 earlier in the year, Perfect and Michaels had sniped at each other for months. With battle lines drawn emotionally, the company out-and-out promised a scientific masterpiece for the ages from the classy veteran and the emerging starlet.

It never happened.

Relying on a series of listless armbars, headlocks and takedowns, the match didn't get out of first gear, with both forcing some unusually clunky spots and neither having the wherewithal to turn the contest around.

The finish was equally poor, with Michaels' bodyguard Diesel running Perfect into the steel post outside the ring for a weak count-out victory for the champion.

It concluded a bewildering style clash that WWE never again revisited.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.