10 Booking Decisions AEW Should Make Before Double Or Nothing 2023

Tony Khan must make some BIG changes to AEW before next year's "WrestleMania".

Jon Moxley MJF Tony Khan
AEW

AEW in 2022 has been... erratic.

Backstage controversies have overshadowed pretty much everything that's happened on TV, and that's a shame when Tony Khan's company is still in its infancy. Everything should be rosy in the garden right now, but it isn't - all that nasty CM Punk/Elite/Sammy Guevara/Andrade El Idolo nonsense isn't quite finished yet.

Tony will have to put that behind him eventually though. AEW's future depends on his ability to do just that, and it's important to remember that Khan's own "WrestleMania season" looms. Yes, 'AEW 'Mania' is exactly what Double Or Nothing is to most AEW hardcores. It's the event that launched a revolution, after all, and it's the kind of show that can cure a lot of ills.

How do All Elite get there, and what decisions should they make on the road to DoN? The place has a lot to sort out off-screen, sure, but backstage disagreements are just part of the package. These are the booking steps Tony must make in meetings before his biggest pay-per-view of the entire year happens in late-May 2023.

Title changes, title deletions, brand new shows and mighty comebacks await.

10. Move On From The Firm

Ethan Page AEW
AEW.com

Yes, already.

Listen, The Firm sounded good on paper. Stokely Hathaway's new group debuted at All Out and helped pave the way for MJF to win the 'Casino Ladder Match'. Then, eh... things have been rough ever since. Start Googling something like, "The Firm AEW" and you'll see the top result is: "The Firm AEW members".

People don't even know who's in the stable! Honestly, at this point, just scrap the whole thing - MJF doesn't need the backup these days, and The Firm concept is only starting to hold Ethan Page back too. That dude should've leapt out of the American Top Team/Men Of The Year shadow into his own thing.

Instead, he's getting involved in stories that either don't focus on him or that fans don't really give a toss about. Speaking of which, that last point is a real problem on shows like Dynamite and Rampage these days. Attention, Tony Khan...


9. Drop Stories Nobody Cares About

Matt Hardy Stokely Hathaway Ethan Page The Firm
AEW

... please drop several of the stories you're clinging onto.

This whole 'The Firm now controls Matt Hardy and Private Party's contracts' angle is boring as f*ck. It's a weekly reminder that Stokely's brand new takeover group is second-rate, and it isn't even logical that he'd poke his nose into Andrade El Idolo's business anyway.

There are far too many background noise narratives going on in AEW's world these days. The Hardy/Party contract thing is dull, no-one wants to see Hook feuding with The Trustbusters, Nyla Rose stealing Jade Cargill's TBS Title sucks and more. So much for great storytelling or compelling drama, eh?

AEW should seriously think about dropping these stories from the lineup before getting to Double Or Nothing. Remember, that pay-per-view is regularly hyped as the biggest of the year, and it definitely doesn't need this rubbish hanging around creating a bad smell.

Is it admirable that Tony wants to give everyone something to do? Sure. Does that excuse lifeless storylines? Nope.


8. Ditch A Lesser Title

Hook FTW Title
AEW

All Elite is starting to fall into the same trap so many major wrestling companies do. Rather than look for ways to produce interesting stories that eventually prepare workers for title tilts, they're adding endless amounts of belts to the trophy cabinet and diluting the importance of each as a result.

Why is the dreadful FTW Title still on TV in 2022, for example? That's a prime candidate to get binned, and so is the unnecessary All-Atlantic belt. Neither championship is actually exciting to wrestling fans, so it'd be cool if somebody had a word backstage and stopped these sorry straps from chewing up airtime any longer.

They're useless.

The Trios Titles have already lost some steam thanks to The Elite's suspensions woes too. Obviously, that's not really TK's fault, but he must realise that chucking so much gold onto programming is making it harder to care about any of them.


7. Stop Signing So Many Wrestlers

W Morrissey
AEW

Several years back, Vince McMahon began stockpiling talent so AEW couldn't get its hands on them. In retrospect, WWE should receive some kind of public service award, because Tony Khan has gone wild between 2020-2022. His signing policy is simple: SIGN. F**KING. EVERYBODY.

Currently, the AEW roster houses a whopping 139 wrestlers. Some of those are serving suspensions and others are out injured, but man - do you think that's enough?! The promotion's weekly output is two hours of Dynamite, one hour of Rampage and other supplemental programming like Dark and Dark: Elevation.

There isn't enough TV time to go around for one hundred and thirty nine workers.

Nobody's advocating to see some lose their gig, but few tears would be shed if AEW trimmed the roster sheets. Failing that, just stop adding more wrestlers to it. This is getting ridiculous now, and it's hard to keep track of who's actually in that locker room.


6. Quit The One-Offs

Jay White AEW
AEW

Psst! It's called the "Forbidden Door", and it's a sweet premise designed to show that AEW plays well with others. That's all well and good, but the idea has run its course in 2022. Seeing workers stop by for a cup of coffee before dashing back off to Japan (for example) is now tiresome.

Worse, All Elite's announcers hype up these mini-invasions as the biggest thing to ever happen on pro wrestling telly. Y'know what happens when you constantly claim the inconsequential thing you just booked topped the last? Yeah, people stop believing it and subsequent signings that are major shed some sparkle as a result.

Admittedly, even Tony knows the "Forbidden Door" scheme has been done to death. He's started moving away from calling it that, and yet these little excursions persist. That needs to stop before Double Or Nothing 2023, because it only presents AEW as a pro wrestling pick n' mix rather than a company with clear direction.

Nail that door shut.


5. Separate ROH A Little More

Chris Jericho Daniel Garcia
AEW

In theory, putting the ROH World Title on Chris Jericho does elevate AEW's sister company and make it seem like a bigger deal. That won't please the purists who thought Claudio Castagnoli's reign was far too short, but it's easy to see why All Elite made the switch.

Now, they must go further with this brand development.

Currently, ROH is leeching off AEW something fierce. In fact, scratch that - Ring Of Honor is trying to suck the life out of Rampage by turning that Friday night show into an Honor-heavy 60 minutes. So, why not just turn it into ROH Rampage then, or something like that?

One thing's clear: Tony Khan has to start separating ROH from the core AEW product more than he has been since acquiring the company. It's messy to have Honor announcers drop in for a match here or there, and the promotion's belts add even more gold to an already-bursting lineup.


4. Put The ROH Belt On Bryan Danielson

Bryan Danielson
All Elite Wrestling

Long-term, AEW's plan will surely involve Bryan Danielson dethroning Jericho to grab a belt he hasn't put hands on since losing it to Homicide at Final Battle on 23 December 2006. Wrestling for titles like that ROH World Championship is exactly why Bryan decided to leave WWE behind in the first place.

He craves competitive, hard-fought wrestling matches.

If Chris Jericho is a placeholder who's only there to put some new eyes on the brand temporarily, then Danielson should be viewed as the permanent replacement who'll keep star power strong whilst working bouts anyone else could only dream of. This is his chance to work with all of those young names he wanted to.

Imagine seeing the 'American Dragon' front a new ROH weekly TV show. Danielson's pride would leap off your telly, 'cause he has so much love and respect for that Honor brand. This is a lay-up that TK simply can't miss.


3. Fix The Mess That Is Rampage

AEW Rampage logo
AEW

Right, where to start with this one?

Rampage should be a snappy complement to the main Dynamite flagship. Interesting stories that can't get minutes on Wednesdays should seek solace on Friday nights, so there are no reasonable excuses for why Rampage has been such a state for much of 2022.

Tony has to sit down and seriously think about what he wants the third hour to be. Is it Dynamite-lite? Is it Sunday Night Heat? Or, is it a blistering, must-see weekly that shines just as brightly as the main show? Fans were kinda hoping it'd be the latter - at least, that's what Rampage was presented as before launch.

It'd be great to see the show become more important heading into Double Or Nothing season. Dynamite is often bursting with content, so it wouldn't be a hassle to keep one or two of those matches/moments back for Rampage every week.

It's either that or the program dies a slow death next year.


2. Give MJF A Lengthy World Title Run

MJF Smug
AEW

Roman Reigns is the best all-rounder in pro wrestling, but MJF could reach that level someday. A bold statement, sure, but Friedman is fire on the mic and is only gonna get better and better in-ring with more experience. He's the definitive future AEW World Champion, put it that way.

Forget CM Punk - this is the guy you build your company around.

AEW might put its top prize on MJF at Full Gear on 19 November. Jon Moxley was never supposed to be around as World Champ recently anyway, and it'd make sense to start the MJF era off with a strong win after he calls his shot a month prior. Then, and only then, will Friedman look like the man.

It's hard to see anyone taking the belt from him before Double Or Nothing. A lengthy, dominant World Title reign is exactly what the product needs right now, and MJF is the man to deliver it. He'll drag lesser talkers up on the mic, then hang with the best in-ring.


1. Push Malakai Black To The Moon

Malakai Black
AEW

Who knows when (or even if) Malakai Black will return to AEW TV? Tony Khan was generous enough to give Black some much needed time off to sort out personal issues, and nobody should even think about rushing the man back. However, the road to Double Or Nothing sounds like a fun return point.

Ooh, the possibilities.

If MJF wins the World Title then beats a few challengers, his smugness will be off the charts and fans will start wondering who's going to shut him down. Then, assuming he's ready to come back, Malakai would bounce into view and start racking up impressive win after impressive win.

Slowly-but-surely, Black would be readied for a crack at MJF and perhaps his own banner moment on the All Elite roster. The dude deserves it, and he's one of the best in the biz when motivated and allowed to get creative.

What else should AEW do before Double Or Nothing 2023? For more wrestling, check out 10 Wrestling Gimmicks More Disturbing Than You Think and 10 Surprise WWE Returns That Are About To Happen!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.