10 Most Controversial WWE "Wellness Policy" Scandals

Those wellness policy failures that caused Vince McMahon a chair-shot inducing headache.

WWE.comWWE.comIf you're of a certain age (and into American cartoons, of course), you'll remember Mr Mackey from South Park constantly telling us that drugs are bad. And whilst there can be no doubting that he's definitely right with that ethos, there are some who refuse to listen. WWE stars are a brazen bunch, and they are certainly no strangers to the spotlight - often for the wrong reasons. Since the WWE introduced their latest generation of the Wellness Policy in 2006, quite a few - well, lots - of wrestlers have fallen foul of the system. And when the company announced they would make violations public in 2007, it opened up a whole new door in terms of privacy. Sure, the system has its detractors, who claim there are simply too many loopholes in the system that wrestlers can exploit. There are even some who believe that certain WWE stars are exempt from the same treatment as everyone else. Whilst that may or may not be true (it's certainly not up for debate here), there have been some pretty big Wellness Policy scandals that have rocked the wrestling world. Some have cost wrestlers their jobs, whilst some have destroyed any sort of push a guy may have been on at that time. So, let's take a look at the 10 biggest Wellness Policy scandals

10. Evan Bourne

WWE.comWWE.comAs we all know, Evan Bourne is no more when it comes to the WWE. He was part of the big batch of stars that were released earlier this year, and it brought a limp couple of years in the career of Bourne to an end. He'd struggled with injuries over that time, but he also struggled with the Wellness Policy. He picked up two strikes, but the first came whilst he was on perhaps his finest run with the WWE. He was one half of the Unified Tag Team Champions at the time, forming Air Boom with Kofi Kingston. And they were a pretty decent team, but Bourne's first suspension was a real hammer blow on their title reign. Sure, they held it for a short while after Bourne came back from his ban, but the damage was done. They actually dropped the belts on a house show (a real rarity), and their little run was over. And amazingly, just two nights later, Bourne got his second ban - a 60-day suspension this time. He was rarely seen on WWE TV again, with just a few appearances on NXT to write home about. Although injuries got the better of him, you have to wonder what Evan Bourne could have achieved with the WWE had he not breached that Wellness Policy.

9. Booker T

Copyright: WWE Royal Rumble 2010 Blu-rayCopyright: WWE Royal Rumble 2010 Blu-rayHe's one of the finest World Champions of this generation (given how all of his reigns were seriously significant, both in WWE and WCW), but Booker T is no stranger to the legendary Wellness Policy, either. He was embroiled in the legendary Signature Pharmacy scandal, where a number of wrestlers were believed to be getting prescription drugs to clients without prescriptions. The WWE came down really hard on a bulk of stars - of which Booker T was one - and they hit them with suspensions. But Booker denied being a customer of the pharmacy, and he decided he didn't want to serve a suspension when he'd done nothing wrong. So he decided to tender his resignation with the company, and the WWE agreed. It's sad that one of the finest champions in recent years had to end it with the company this way - in fact, it was a real loss for the WWE, who had him feuding with Triple H at that time. But thankfully, he would make a triumphant return to the company in 2011, with that resignation hopefully never happening again.

8. Umaga

wikiwikiUsually with the Wellness Policy, the WWE have a right to terminate a wrestler's contract after three violations of the policy. But in some cases, they've released wrestlers earlier - just like they did with Umaga. The late Umaga is perhaps best remembered for the way he burst onto the scene with the company. That long undefeated run attracted much attention, and saw him tussle with some of the company's top stars, including John Cena. Umaga already had one strike to his name before June 2009, but his second strike would prove a fatal blow. Why? He refused to enter rehab because of the problem, which gives the company the right to dismiss said wrestler with immediate effect if they choose to. They did, and Umaga was gone. And tragically, his life would be cut short just months later, after he passed away in December that year.

7. Dolph Ziggler

WWE.comWWE.comFans of Dolph Ziggler will know that it took a long, long time for him to properly break into the WWE mainstream. Sure, the Spirit Squad had a touch of relevance at one time or another, but they were never really going anywhere as a group - and neither was Nicky. But in 2008, all that changed. Some time away in developmental wrestling brought about a repackage - under the now famous Dolph Ziggler name. After all that effort to get onto the main roster as a singles competitor, you'd think Ziggler wouldn't do anything stupid, right? Wrong. Ziggler debuted on Raw in September 2008. He wouldn't actually get round to wrestling in a match until December, because he was suspended for a violation of the WWE's Wellness Policy. That may have been enough for the WWE to simply tell Ziggler where to go - but thankfully, they stuck with him. You'd like to think that tiny bit of faith they showed in him paid off. A couple of reigns as World Heavyweight Champion - and masses of popularity - prove that.

6. Carlito

WWE.comWWE.comPer the rules with the WWE's Wellness Policy, if you refuse to enter a rehabilitate facility after a violation of the policy, you're dismissed immediately. It doesn't matter whether it's first, second or third strike - you're gone. And that ruling is what cost Carlito his WWE career. He had a pretty good run with the WWE, winning both the United States and Intercontinental Championship during his time with the company. However, not long after becoming one half of the unified tag champions - with brother Primo - Carlito was caught out by the WWE for violating the policy. It was for a reported addiction to painkillers, and after Carlito decided rehab wasn't for him, he was given the bullet immediately. That was a shame, as Carlito was a pretty decent guy to have around on the roster. He spat in the face of people who didn't want to be cool. But after refusing to enter rehab, the WWE spat in the face of Carlito's contract.

5. Rob Van Dam

WWE.comWWE.comOut of all the men who have lost the most when it comes to violating the infamous Wellness Policy, the consequences from Rob Van Dam's suspension were absolutely huge. The suspension came about after RVD and Sabu were stopped by police on their way home from an ECW show for speeding. However, police found drugs in their possession when they stopped the car, and they were ultimately arrested. Naturally, that led to a 30-day suspension for Van Dam, who was in a pretty hefty position with the company at that time. He was the WWE and the ECW Champion at that period, as it wasn't long after that epic victory against John Cena at ECW One Night Stand. He had Paul Heyman turn on him, and he lost both belts in the space of 48 hours. And rather predictably, RVD's career with the WWE hasn't been the same since. If there's one shining example of how a violation of the Wellness Policy can destroy your career, look straight at Rob Van Dam.

4. Jeff Hardy

WWE.comWWE.comIt's interesting to sit back for a minute and consider just what Jeff Hardy's career will be remembered for. His time in TNA? Probably not. It's more likely his WWE days will be what we remember Hardy for - but hopefully, that won't include a couple of suspensions for violating the Wellness Policy. In 2008, Hardy was on the rise to the top with the company. He had truly broken out as a singles competitor, and had already claimed the Intercontinental Championship. However, it wouldn't be long before he would pick up his second suspension (the first came in mid-2007), and he would have to take a 60-day suspension. Naturally, he had to drop the title, doing so to Chris Jericho on Raw. But perhaps even worse, the timing of his ban actually forced him to sit out WrestleMania that year - and the illustrious Money in the Bank match. Would he have claimed the briefcase? Possibly. Although CM Punk won it, there wasn't a lot of serious competition for Hardy to compete with that year. However, it mattered little, as he managed to win the World Heavyweight Championship later that year.

3. William Regal

flickrflickrBack in 2008, William Regal was enjoying a pretty significant push - at least for a guy of his stature in the WWE. He wasn't exactly WWE champion material, but he had just won the King of the Ring tournament. He was operating as a pretty substantial heel, working as the Raw General Manager. Things were interesting in the life of Regal - but it was all about to come crashing down. Regal already had one strike (and a subsequent 30-day ban) to his name with the WWE Wellness Policy, so when he was suspended for a second time, he had to take a 60-day break from proceedings. That forced the company to write him out of their storylines, and Regal was placed into a "Loser Gets Fired" match against Mr. Kennedy. Naturally, he lost it, and was kayfabe fired from the company. He would return after his suspension and compete with the WWE once again as a "free agent", but unfortunately, his push had absolutely collapsed.

2. Rey Mysterio

WWE.comWWE.comIt's truly amazing to think that one of the company's top stars (at least with younger viewers) has such a poor track record with the WWE Wellness Policy. One strike wasn't enough for Rey Mysterio, who actually picked up two suspensions over the years for violating the policy. His first came after he was unable to provide a prescription for what he claimed were drugs to treat his arm and knee. With no proof of any prescription drug, Mysterio picked up a ban. Like Jeff Hardy, he was also forced to drop the Intercontinental Championship, but reports at the time said he refused to drop it to Dolph Ziggler (who he was in the midst of a feud with). So, the plans changed, and John Morrison was given the strap. Fast forward three years though, and Mysterio was at it again. A second suspension in 2012 saw him miss a good chunk of the year - and Mysterio's career has rarely been the same since. With just one strike left (technically), Rey is very much on thin ice.

1. Randy Orton

WWE.comWWE.comThere's a lot of clamour and discussion that although the three strikes policy is pretty tight, Randy Orton has somehow slipped through the net. He's been suspended by the company three times - and was even involved in the Signature Pharmacy scandal that saw Booker T eventually leave the company. However, the first of those bans wasn't for a Wellness Policy violation, so Orton is sat on two strikes. He was suspended for unprofessional conduct in April of 2006, before picking up another ban later that year. With that said, it's amazing to consider Orton is a multiple World Champion with the WWE. And in 2012, his conflicts with the Wellness Policy reared their ugly head again. Another 60-day ban was slapped on Orton, meaning he had to take a big hit in terms of the push he was getting around that time. As we know, he regrouped to become the first ever WWE World Heavyweight Champion, but Orton is very much on thin ice. A number of incidents away from the Wellness Policy, as well as the two violations themselves, surely mean that if Randy Orton gets in hot water again, he may be shown the door. And that would be the most controversial violation of them all, you'd have to say.

In this post: 
Jeff Hardy
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Freelance sports journalist from Bradford, West Yorkshire. Specialize in primarily Rugby League and Football.