10 Current WWE Stars That Would Have Ruled In ECW

Heyman's ECW with today's current roster would be fun to watch.

The Extreme Championship Wrestling brand in its original form has been dead since 2001, yet it's still celebrated by wrestling fans as a revolutionary company that had a huge impact on the business. It only existed for seven years, yet it will never truly die because wrestling fans and people in wrestling will never forget it. Paul Heyman was the driving force behind ECW. He was a wrestling manager before the launch of ECW, but once the brand started he became the main booker. It seemed like it was the right role for him because he has such a great mind in terms of telling stories while always getting the most out of talents. There are many things that Heyman has said about being behind the creative direction of a wrestling show, but one of the things that always made sense was that he wanted to accentuate the positives of a performer and hide the negatives. In other words, if a guy isn't great at doing promos then he'd rather keep them from doing promos. If somebody has the look of a powerful guy then he wants that person to look dominant. It makes sense. Why complicate things when you don't have to? ECW wasn't just about the blood and violence. When people think that they're wrong. They also had regular performers that were great technical wrestlers, guys that could do the aerial stuff and above average talkers who were average in the ring too. When thinking about current WWE guys in an ECW setting, it's not just the guy that could get in a bloody brawl. It could be anybody. Heyman's current role is only an on screen performer. He does interact with the performers backstage and maybe helps with promos or certain things, but he's not a part of the creative process as far as we know. He may never join the creative team again, which is fine if that's what he wants. However, if that ever happened it would be interesting to see what superstars might get more of a spotlight with Heyman running things. Here's a look at the current WWE wrestlers that might have benefitted from ECW run by Paul Heyman.

10. Jack Swagger

It seems like Jack Swagger is at a point in his career where he's at a crossroads. It's unlikely that he's going to become a main event level performer, but he's also a considered a good enough performer that he's always going to have a job too. Maybe he has a future as a tag team wrestler. Anything more than that would be a surprise. If he was a part of ECW, he'd probably be booked a lot better just because he's a pretty big guy with a submission wrestler skill set. They have him use the Patriot Lock submission move as a finisher, but other than that he's basic. Heyman probably would use him as more of a submission specialist that had more than one move that could make somebody tap out. Think about how Taz was booked in ECW. He had a "shooter" gimmick where he was presented as a badass. Obviously he's a much shorter guy than Swagger is, but the same philosophy could apply. If you book somebody to be a badass wrestler that knows a lot of submission then that person could beat anybody no matter their size. It's all about the presentation. Swagger would likely be a deadly submission expert in ECW with Heyman booking him. Instead, he's just another guy in WWE.

9. Curtis Axel

Curtis Axel was known as Michael McGillicutty before he was known as a "Paul Heyman Guy." It was a great name change for him because Axel has much more of a presence than McGillicutty and it's certainly easier to say. WWE tried to push him as an upper midcard heel, but it just didn't get that far for him in 2013. There had to have been a reason why Axel was paired with Heyman. Perhaps it was done because Heyman wanted it that way or WWE just wanted them together because they felt like Heyman could help Axel reach his potential. His skills are solid, but not spectacular. He can have pretty good matches with just about anybody yet there are few moments where somebody is going to go out of their way to watch an Axel match. That has to change. It's all about the presentation. What ECW might have done with Axel is paired him up with a diva to make him more presentable. Think about how Shane Douglas was booked with Francine and other women in ECW. When you do something like that, it makes a boring wrestler look more appealing. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn't. At least with Heyman booking you know he'd try something.


8. Tyson Kidd

When watching Tyson Kidd in the ring, there's an ECW comparison that immediately comes to mind: Lance Storm. They are both technical wrestlers from Calgary...Alberta, Canada and they're not the biggest guys out there, but they are so incredibly talented. Kidd had a breakthrough in 2014 by turning into this over the top heel character that loves talking about his cats, which is awkward and funny at the same time. It gives him more of a reason to be on the shows since he's getting more of a chance to talk and show that he's just a great wrestler. What Kidd needs is that showcase to have longer matches on television. It seems as though he's going to be a part of a team with Cesaro and they might have good matches if they get time, but chances are if he was booked by Heyman he'd be a singles star. Kidd might not be a top guy. However, he could have a lot of success as a midcard champion. There was a time when Kidd was called the "workhorse" by WWE. The name didn't get over huge. If he was in Heyman's ECW, that would be his name and it would get over because he knows how to get a talent over the right way.

7. Kevin Owens

A WWE "rookie" like Kevin Owens is still very unknown to a lot of WWE fans, but if you watched him in Ring of Honor or other indy promotions then you know he's a gifted all around performer. It was great that WWE signed him because he deserves to be working there. Remember Rhyno? That's who Owens is very similar to at least in terms of his body type. Owens might be a little bit taller than Rhyno was, but they would be booked the same way. What Owens has over Rhyno is an ability to talk. Rhyno was limited in that area while Owens is gifted. When you give a guy that combination of being an absolute physical force plus the ability to deliver great promos, that is a character that you know Heyman would love to have on his shows. Any time Owens got into a feud with somebody, he always had an ability to make it feel personal. He knows how to show the right emotions at all time. That's something Heyman would take advantage of because Owens wouldn't have to be in the title picture a lot. All he needs is a reason to feud with somebody and he can make it great. He's done it many times before. We're seeing it happen in NXT with Sami Zayn too. Owens is the kind of guy Heyman would probably love to book. No doubt about that.

6. Bray Wyatt

Wyatt is one of the darkest characters in WWE right now. He delivers cryptic promos on a regular basis unlike anybody else on the show. In Heyman's ECW, there was a unique guy like that too. That was Raven. He became one of the biggest stars in ECW that a lot of people think of first whenever they discuss the promotion. What made Raven great was his ability to capture the attention of the audience. For his in-ring promos, he sat in the corner and talked in a regular voice. There was no yelling or demonstrative action. He was always very deliberate in his promos. They were well thought out. It's why he became a main event guy. In the ring he was fine, but it's his character that really got him over. With Wyatt, there are some aspects about him that are really cheesy like the hologram thing that he did with Ambrose at Hell in a Cell. However, the basis of the character is great because he's unlike anybody else on the show. There are so many great things that Wyatt could be doing in WWE that he's not doing because he's being held back due to the PG rating or the creative restrictions caused by a below average writing team. If he had the chance to be booked by Heyman, he'd probably thrive even more.

5. Cesaro

As a former "Paul Heyman Guy" that should still be a Heyman Guy, Cesaro is an obvious choice. What's holding Cesaro back is a lack of a connection to the fans according to WWE Chairman Vince McMahon. It's a ridiculous claim because back at WrestleMania 30 he got one of the loudest ovations when he briefly turned face against Jack Swagger and Zeb Colter while also getting cheered after winning the battle royal. That sure sounded like a connection to most of us. Putting Cesaro with Heyman was a great idea. Heyman's the best talker in WWE, so he could do promos for him although really Cesaro has untapped potential as a talker too. What Heyman gave Cesaro was a lot of confidence and the ability to just show off in the ring by utilizing his power moves. If he was in Heyman's ECW, Cesaro wouldn't the guy wrestling a lot of hardcore matches or things like that. It would be more about showcasing his in-ring prowess by having great technical wrestling matches while also knocking people out with that uppercut strike. There is so much potential with Cesaro. We don't know if it will ever truly be realized in WWE, but if Heyman booked him in ECW it would probably happen.

4. Daniel Bryan

This is a no brainer because Daniel Bryan is arguably the best wrestler in the world and somebody that could easily fit in Heyman's ECW due to his ability to have a great match with anybody. What has always been great about Heyman's booking whether it was in ECW or Smackdown in 2002 is that he didn't care about the size of a wrestler. To him, it's the talent that matters more than anything, which is the right way to look at things. Bryan's only about 5'10" and weighs around 200 pounds. He looks like he shouldn't beat almost anybody in the match, yet when you watch him he looks as credible as anybody. It was mentioned earlier that Jack Swagger could thrive as a submission wrestler. Obviously Bryan can do that too. When he was the man in Ring of Honor, he was presented as a guy that could do it all in the ring and the submission moves were a big part of that. Since WWE finally booked Bryan the right way in early 2014 there isn't as much of a yearning for Heyman to book him, but it would still be amazing to watch.

3. Dean Ambrose

Dean Ambrose was a guy that was meant for a promotion like ECW. He's the kind of free spirit that Heyman would love to have on his show because he could mould him into a great villain or hero as a character with many layers to him. Ambrose has a background working for some violent indy promotions like Insanity Pro Wrestling and Combat Zone Wrestling. If you spent any time searching for some of his indy matches as Jon Moxley, you can easily find bloody brawls that you would never see in WWE because they don't allow blood anymore. The stuff he did in CZW really got him noticed in the indy scene. When Ambrose was on Chris Jericho's podcast recently he said he really didn't love any of his WWE promos because they really didn't come from the heart. He said they came from WWE writers, so he didn't like them as much as when he did his own. In Heyman's ECW, there were no writers. Wrestlers were given bullet points for their promos to hit on key things and otherwise were left on their own to do them as they saw fit. Those three minute promos in front of a screen were classics. Ambrose could kill it in a setting like that. For all of WWE's talk about Ambrose being the "unhinged superstar" that is a bit crazy, they really hold him back a lot. He could be doing and saying so much more than he already does, but the PG rating prevents quite a bit as well as the mediocre writing team. It would be nice to see Heyman booking a guy like Ambrose. He could really get the most out of him.

2. Dolph Ziggler

Ziggler would be the Rob Van Dam of Heyman's new ECW because he's the guy that the fans genuinely love even though he's the cockiest guy in the room. It's one of those things where fans have always liked Ziggler just because of the way he carries himself with an aura of confidence. The interesting thing about RVD's rise in ECW is that he was booked as a heel in the early part of his ECW run, but he was such a great performer that the fans started to cheer when they saw him. It's similar to Ziggler because even though he had been a heel for a few years, he was cheered loudly when he won his second World Title in 2013. That's that special connection that a wrestler wants to have with the fans, but not all of them do. There have been too many stop and start kind of pushes for Ziggler in WWE. There are times when we think maybe he's going to be some main event level guy, but then he gets pulled down and it doesn't happen. That leads to a lot of frustration. Something that Heyman was great at as a booker was his ability to get the most out of his performers whether they were going for titles or not. Out of everybody currently in WWE, Ziggler seems to be a guy that Heyman could do the most with just because we want to see more from Ziggler and Heyman definitely has a good feeling of what the fans want.

1. Brock Lesnar

This is an obvious choice for the top spot because Lesnar is the ultimate "Paul Heyman Guy" that has been with Heyman since 2002 when Lesnar debuted on WWE TV. Even when Lesnar and Heyman were both out of WWE, they remained close friends. They wrote a book together too. Heyman was also involved with Lesnar during his UFC run. When Lesnar came back in 2012, Heyman wasn't there right away, but he showed up soon after. The ECW name that immediately comes to mind is Mike Awesome. He was a guy that was similar in size to Lesnar although Lesnar looks more impressive physically. The way Heyman booked Awesome was perfect because he was presented as this bigger guy that could destroy everybody in his path. It's a shame that the Awesome story couldn't be told the right way since he jumped to WCW for more money, but if it did he probably would have dropped the ECW Title to a smaller guy like Rob Van Dam and it would have been a great angle. Lesnar is booked strongly in WWE, but the fact that he has lost several matches in the last three years is wrong. Heyman wouldn't book him like that. He probably would have booked him to win every single matches leading up to that one loss at the end of a major storyline. Remember, WWE booked Lesnar to lose to John Cena in his first match back after eight years. It was ridiculous. Heyman would know better. It would be great to see Lesnar on a show booked like Heyman again like he was in 2002. It's probably not going to happen again, but Lesnar could do some great things with Heyman running the show ECW style.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.