Out of all the performers who make it through NXT and onto the rosters of Raw and Smackdown, only a finite number of those wrestlers can become top-tier talent, hold the WWE World Heavyweight Championship and carve out a memorable legacy in the company. Countless others will fail trying, be relegated to working on the mid-card, or just never receive that final push they deserve, no matter how charismatic, athletic or talented they are. Not to mention, the WWE are processing more fresh, original and hot new wrestling talent than ever, with the rapid success of NXT as a developmental promotion. This means the top spots will be more competitive, more hard-fought over and harder to gain than ever. There are already several veterans in the company who have been there 5-10 years who have not truly succeeded on the main stage, never mind those looking to make a fresh start in the WWE. It's just a sheer matter of statistics - some will make it to the top rung of the WWE ladder, but the majority won't, they'll flounder, struggle to get over, suffer from awful booking and bizarre, unreasonable gimmicks. We're not here to speculate on who'll make it to the very top or on who has what it takes, this is a list detailing those who have probably lost the struggle, and are trapped in mediocrity. Here's ten current WWE talents doomed to go nowhere.
10. Damien Sandow
Damien Sandow, when did it all go wrong? Probably the only instance in history where a wrestler won a Money in the Bank ladder match, and it instantly hurt his career, instead of helping. There's no confirmed reason as to why WWE creative pushed the abort button on Sandow's push, but the situation isn't important, all that matters are his chances of being a top-tier talent, which are mostly dead and gone at this point. Before his cash-in, Sandow went on a huge losing streak on both Raw and Smackdown, proceeding to lose his title match against Cena, cleanly. After losses against the likes of R-Truth and Santino Marella, and after being the fast man eliminated from the Royal Rumble 2014, Sandow would go on an epic losing streak, which has only started to improve recently. Since becoming The Miz's 'stunt double', Damien Mizdow seems to have picked up some momentum as a fan favorite, for some reason. Damien's charismatic enough to get over, but it's hard to think this gimmick will pan out in the long run or actually warrant any kind of significant push. It's not impossible, but a lot of things would have to go in Sandow's favor if he's to become anything more than a joke.
9. Bo Dallas
It's hard not to feel at least slightly sympathetic for Bo Dallas. He's a talented third-generation of wrestler with a lot of heart, but as soon as he gets drafted to Raw, he gets instantly stuck with a bad gimmick and starts his first few months wrestling jobbers exclusively. That's not to say the Bo Dallas character isn't popular, it is, he deserves a lot of praise for making that work. Thing is, his momentum is already starting to wear off and soon he'll probably end up wrestling on Main Event or Superstars, if he's not put into a meaningful feud or some kind of character evolution soon. The inherent problem with the character is that it already has an expiration date - its reached the peak of its amusement and ultimately it'll be impossible to take Bo Dallas seriously as a competitor, until the character is dropped, or changes in some obvious way. From what we've seen from NXT, Bo Dallas deserves to make it to the top, but in his current gimmick and with the tides slowly turning against him booking wise, he'll have a hard road ahead unless a drastic transformation occurs soon.
8. Jack Swagger
At one point, Swagger seem set to be one of WWE's most prominent stars, but the momentum died down, the steam cooled off, and his chances dwindled. The days of Swagger being a 2-time World Champion with his ECW and World Heavyweight Championship wins are far behind us, since, he's mainly been used in various tag-teams, on the mid-card and as an enhancement talent. Thing's could be worse for Swagger, he's often used on Raw and on pay-per-view, he's an upper mid-carder, he's in a better position than most talent who aren't top-tier on the roster. This doesn't change the fact that Swagger's spot seems cemented, it doesn't appear as though he'll rise or fall much higher from where he is now in the immediate future. He puts over newer talent, regains wins over those lower on the roster, while his reputation stays relatively solid. Perhaps that's just what Swagger is meant to be - a dependable, reliable no thrills mid-carder, as it's likely that's what he'll remain as for the majority of his WWE tenure.
7. Fandango
We can only imagine what kind of meeting went underway to decide what kind of persona Johnny Curtis would debut on the main roster as. 'Yep, dancer gimmick, dances all the time, loves to dance'. That'll get this great young talent over with the fans, because that worked so well when Disco Inferno did it twenty years ago, whoever it is in WWE management who's responsible for these stupid occupational gimmicks needs to be fired. Fandango's been in the WWE for 2 years now and what has he accomplished? Literally nothing. The gimmick somehow got over at the very beginning, with fans buying and singing the entrance theme, but as time went by the booking made sure Fandango was little more than a comedic jobber. Johnny Curtis no doubt deserves better, but there's very little chance of that happening, a character like Fandango was always going to sink to jobber status, it's just a shame that a genuine talent got stuck with it. Unless Curtis gets an immediate repackaging, he'll be going nowhere. The situation is remarkably similar to the next entry...
6. Adam Rose
The Adam Rose gimmick has 'doomed to fail' written all over it. It may get over, it may be quirky or amusing for five minutes, but it just isn't what wrestling fans want to see. Since his debut, Adam Rose has scored a few minor victories against the likes of Damien Sandow and Jack Swagger, though he recently took a loss to Kane. The inherent problem in this kind of booking is that these fresh former NXT talents are put above the lower mid-carders, but creative are afraid to pull the trigger on any of them. As soon as they get close to any kind of title, opportunity or top-tier opponent, they just get shuffled to the back of the pile - what happened to Fandango and what's beginning to happen to Bo Dallas will soon happen to Adam Rose. The clean loss to Kane already shows this, while Rose is beginning to appear less and less on TV since his debut, already. If a newly debuted talent's momentum drys up in the first few months, they'll have no chance in the months to come, especially with how many stars there are on the rise because of the fantastic NXT roster. The addition of The Bunny will only make him more irrelevant as a solo competitor. In the competitive world of main roster spots and in the hunt for new rising stars, Adam Rose's trashy, needless gimmick will ensure he's always picked below those who are taken seriously. The best thing for Ray Leppan at this point, would be to go back to NXT.
5. Titus O'Neil
The worst thing management could have done to Titus O'Neil was breaking up the Prime Time Players, which they did in early 2014. The duo were a great component of the new and improved tag-team division, but regardless, they were separated. Soon after, Titus would go on to be a solo competitor with very little success, losing to Dolph Ziggler, Kofi Kingston, Adam Rose and Big E on a consistent basis. He was then thrown in a tag-team with Heath Slater, after a few early successes, the team would start to feud with Adam Rose and The Bunny, ending up on the losing end of the situation, almost every time. Titus O'Neil was never going to be World Championship material, but he could have been a mainstay in the tag division, could have maybe held a few mid-card belts and became a reasonable mid-carder, but his current association with Heath Slater will almost certainly damage his career for years to come. Hope you enjoy it there on Superstars, Titus.
4. Kofi Kingston
Kofi Kingston is a king of the mid-card, having been a 4-time Intercontinental Champion, a 3-time United States Champion, and a 2-time WWE Tag-Team Champion. As impressive as those accolades are, he'll never win the big belt, he's too boring, played out and its just been far too long since his huge push fizzled. Thing is, there's little else to do in the WWE for Kofi besides win a World Championship, which will probably never happen now the World Heavyweight Championship doesn't exist. He's a solid mid-carder and has held his position for years in the company, but in terms of advancement, he'll never make it to the main event. Kofi has the athleticism, but not the look, charisma or momentum of a World Champion. Plus, he's arguably too valuable for the WWE as a middle-of-the-pack veteran who puts on decent matches, time after time. He'll probably go on to win numerous more Intercontinental Championships, as well as Tag and United States, but he's been there and done all of that before. The only likely direction for Kofi to go from here, is down.
3. R-Truth
Regardless of the fact he's had two different stints in the WWE, R-Truth has failed to get anywhere in over eight years with the company. Besides a United States Championship and a Tag-Team Championship won with Kofi Kingston, Truth has achieved incredibly little since 2008. That's not say that Truth hasn't been on the cusp of greatness - the team of Awesome Truth seemed to be gathering momentum and were a dominant force for a few weeks, but ultimately the team was short-lived as punishment of a wellness violation by Truth. R-Truth has tried to exceed his role as that of a filler guy his whole run, but nothing seems to gel. He's never been part of a tag-team for more than a few months, he's never had any truly heated feuds, his match against John Cena for the WWE Championship, his biggest match to date, was somewhat forgettable. Ron Killings isn't a bad talent, but he's not an outstanding one either. He's a reliable, tried and tested lower-card veteran, that's where his place is and it's never likely to change.
2. The Miz
The Miz will never break the glass ceiling, but that's because he already has before and the results were thoroughly unsatisfying. In late 2010, Miz gained the WWE Championship, after winning the Money In The Bank ladder match. He suffered from an incredibly weak booking, he required interference to win almost every match and rarely won cleanly, for some reason he also worked a program with Jerry Lawler, which just made The Miz look even more pathetic. The point here is, is that Miz has already been to the very top and it wasn't well received, or well remembered. For that reason, The Miz will never hold another world title, his ball has been thoroughly dropped and forgotten, now doomed to flounder and wane in WWE's barren mid-card for his entire career. That's the state of WWE creative booking now, they simply don't know how to create new rising stars, if it doesn't work the first time, then it'll just get worse from there. It could be worse for The Miz, he isn't jobbing nearly as much as he used to. Sadly, that is the full extent of his capacity now, he may have held the World Heavyweight Championship if it wasn't defunct, but that's not the case. The Miz stands out as one of the most doomed current WWE talents, as he's already held the big time gold, and was promptly buried months after. If a pure talent like Ziggler who puts on a show each and every night can't get there, what's an average talent who has already tried and failed suppose to do? The Miz isn't a showstopper, he's not a technician, he's not over and none of these facts are likely to change now.
1. Zack Ryder
Zack Ryder did everything he possibly could to get over and when he finally did with the help of his internet show, he was rewarded with a mediocre run with the United States Championship and a feud with Kane, which saw Ryder lose every match. After the forgetful messy love triangle with Cena and Eve Torres, Ryder was gradually relegated back to his position at the bottom of the card, rarely appearing on TV in 2013, and even less so this year. Presumably, Zack Ryder is a guy that management and creative just don't want to push, even John Cena vouched for him, yet even after he got over himself on his own merits, Ryder was still squashed back into nothing for no apparent reason, it's not as if Kane was gaining anything from that extended feud. At this point, Ryder's role is purely that of a jobber, wheeled out to put over others on Superstars. It's surprising that Ryder's still employed, surely his contract can't be worth the money they're paying him, for a few jobber appearances that could be fulfilled by anyone. If any current talent has literal no chance of going places in the WWE, its Zack Ryder.
Sam is an experienced Film, Gaming and Wrestling writer, critic and journalist who was written for a vast number of different entertainment websites. Follow him on twitter at @Sams_Reel_Views.