10 Disturbing Times WWE Flirted With Romance Angles
What's love got to do with it? Good question, since this is meant to be bloody wrestling.
The romance angle has only worked to a money-drawing level in two eras of WWE, but since those eras saw the market leader at their peak, you will see them forever.
Ignoring the bleak reality, and revisiting the saga through a naive child's eyes, the Randy Savage and Miss Elizabeth reconciliation was beautiful. At the time. The contrite, redeemed hero, the woman so pure that young fans on this side of the pond essentially perceived her as the Queen of the United States...their reunion at WrestleMania VII was an immortal moment, provided you had no knowledge of Savage's abusive over-protection and their very real marital strife.
The McMahon/Helmsley love affair drew monster ratings across 1999 and 2000, as Test and Kurt Angle were also booked to fall head over heels with Stephanie. John Cena wanted to slap her arse too, if you recall. All for naught; she only ever had eyes for the man who hogged all the gold. But enough about Ultimo Dragon; Triple H was her man in storylines, until she was revealed to be - being a woman and everything - a manipulative liar.
Weddings pop ratings, so more will follow.
Even if they're incredibly problematic!
10. Buddy Murphy Kisses Aalayah Mysterio
A thirty-something antipodean in a relationship with a very young girl drawn to his star status. In 2020.
Nope, not one brave, harrowing tale of many that filtered into a repulsed public as part of the #SpeakingOut movement: a WWE storyline!
The optics on this thing man, f*cking hell. Proving that WWE was out of touch with reality to a level not thought possible even to the most cynical observer, the Buddy Murphy and Aalayah Mysterio relationship was so beyond f*cked. For whatever reason, terrible ratings and a gross quest to correct them, most likely, Aalyah started to look at Buddy with googly eyes after he distanced himself from her family's tormentor Seth Rollins. They grew closer, and even kissed, though the real-life Matthew Adams, it should be noted, was bemused by and uncomfortable with this development...
...likely because he turned babyface subsequently.
The f*ck?
He was probably uncomfortable because it was unseemly in any context, but Jesus Christ, this would have been deeply ill-advised if WWE had damned gross power dynamics in an exploitative storyline. This, instead, was super-stud makes out with chick, so...cheer him?
In an even sicker twist, they treat elder sibling Dominik like he's some dipsh*t toddler who just learned how to tie his shoelaces.
How young must Aalayah have been in their eyes?!
9. Vince McMahon Wants To Bang His Daughter
"Style and grace, let me shoot my shot: sit on my face?"
No, not the lyrics to Jim Johnston's 'Welcome To The Queendom', but Vince McMahon actually pitching a romance angle to his own daughter. Vince made love to his wife at the time and nine months later, Stephanie, his own flesh and blood, popped out.
A couple of decades and some change later, and he's asking if he can pen a storyline in which he would be the biological father of her baby.
In 2003, Stephanie fell pregnant in real life, and so Vince, inveterate carny, said "Well we have to make an angle out of this, obviously".
Vince likely pitched this because times were rather desperate. WWE wasn't in significant trouble, but the glory days of skyscraper ratings and household infamy were over. When it was still possible to chase this height of popularity, WWE chased the f*ck out of it. Mock necrophilia? Why not?
And, as it was suggested, incest.
Mercifully, Stephanie rejected the article.
Vince agreed, but put forward a counter offer...
8. Vince McMahon Wants His Son To Bang His Daughter
"Daddy, obviously you're very attractive, and a few years ago who knows, maybe one thing would lead to another - but you're just a little old for me, sorry!"
This of course is not what Stephanie said. She was genuinely repulsed by the infamous pitch revealed, inexplicably, on the 2006 'McMahon' double disc DVD.
This however is what Vince must have thought Steph's thought process was. It is the only thing that can be inferred from his trade offer.
*Vince presses hands together finger tip to finger tip*
I receive: your rejected pitch.
You receive: your brother's ejaculate.
Yes: when Stephanie was appalled by the notion of her fictional character having sexual intercourse with a blood relative, Vince must have thought that the blood relative was too old, since he suggested that Shane be the father instead.
Steph shot this down too, for good reason. The notion was beyond disgusting, and if the moral objection wasn't enough, this storyline was hardly going to draw new or lapsed or fans. It was the charmless edge of "post" Attitude Era storytelling reaching a new nadir. What about Linda? Why didn't Vince just shag her?
Of course, this wasn't the first time WWE experimented with such an angle...
7. Beaver Cleavage
Beaver Cleavage debuted in 1999 as a sick riff on the Leave It To Beaver protagonist.
If you somehow missed the subtlety behind his name, it was a double reference to private areas. Unconfirmed rumours suggest that other scrapped suggestions included "M*nge McBreasts" and "P*ssy T*ts".
Introduced to fans via vignettes as a grown man playing a young boy who enjoyed sexual relations with his mother, the double entendres were less subtle than his friggin' name. At one point, he complained that his cereal was too dry. Instead of just taking a short trip to the fridge, he asked for "mother's milk". The implication, just in case you didn't grasp it, was that Beaver was going to suck his mother's t*s, spit out the milk, and pour it via his mouth over his frosted flakes. Or just bonk her senseless, since he was a professional combat athlete primarily interested in having it off with a family member.
As it transpired, the woman playing his mother was revealed to be his girlfriend, who he was abusing. Except he wasn't, because she was lying.
It will never not rule that pro wrestling in North America has finally exorcised the ghost of Vince Russo and is good now.
So no, McMahon's apesh*t 2000s period wasn't the first time WWE really wanted to run an incest angle before seeing sense.
Nor was it the last...
6. Paul Burchill Wants To Bang His Sister
Do you ever have a nagging thought that never truly goes away, something that isn't really practical to do?
Perhaps you wish to emigrate to some distant land, but you have certain obligations that make it impossible. Or maybe you want to undertake a grand project, like restoring a classic car, but can never find the time outside of the idle thought.
Vince McMahon - you guessed it! - always wanted not to finally build his model train set, but to run an incest angle.
The latest and hopefully last attempt saw Paul Burchill and his sister Katie Lea get a little too close for comfort. Acting as his valet in the mid-2000s, Katie Lea introduced Paul by placing her hands on his abs and calling him "the most brutal, vicious, and most beautiful man of all, my big brother Paul".
She paused before saying the word "Paul" with a lascivious look on her face, which was meant to imply "He drills me raw every night".
She said that all she ever wanted was to watch her brother inflict pain on others, to which he said "Whatever my little sister wants, she gets".
They're talking about his big British spotted dick, guv'nor! Cor blimey!
5. The Live Sex Celebration
Less of a romance angle, more of a ratings grab f*ck-fest, this was still disturbing.
You remember it well; Edge, overjoyed that he'd successfully cashed in his Money In The Bank briefcase, decided he would bang Lita live on Monday Night RAW, which was never so aptly named, if you catch my drift (he was going to enter Lita unsheathed).
The main disturbing element here is that Lita really, really didn't want to partake in the angle. Traumatised by every single arena that WWE ran calling her a slut, she was very understandably apprehensive about portraying a sex act with her exclusive partner because women are sluts for doing that, where men are legends.
She was told to do it else she'd be fired.
Lads - and it is the lads - just watch pornography. If you want to watch people actually bone, just...watch that. You are not going to see full, penetrative sex on a professional wrestling show. It isn't going to happen, unless of course NXT 2.0 ratings dip so low that Bruce Prichard gets desperate and books Duke Hudson to blow his beans up Persia Pirotta.
4. Billy & Chuck
In 2002, Billy and Chuck were a tag team that were heavily implied as being homosexual lovers.
Initially, they weren't, but two big dudes who truck people was too boring for WWE, so they were quickly paired with Rico, whose gay panic-adjacent act said the quiet part loud - the quiet part being "Psst you're meant to dislike these suspicious fellers but we're publicly traded now so we can't outright say why [wink wink]."
Eventually, after several months of innuendos and being "caught" in "compromising positions", Chuck finally said the quiet part loud and asked Billy to be his "partner for life". Billy agreed, and the wedding ceremony unfolded - with GLAAD's enthusiastic, unwitting approval - until they couldn't go through with it in the end. Their pretending to be gay was a mere publicity stunt. They each sounded appalled that people would think of them as actual gays.
WWE had decided that gay sex was something to mock...
...except when it involved women, in Hot Lesbian Action segments, in which case it was f*ckin' hot!
One gay sex act is something to masturbate over, the other is something to feel icky about.
Don't you get it?
3. Basically Everything Vince McMahon Did Throughout The 2000s
Vince McMahon went mad with power when he formally took over the wrestling world in 2001.
With total domination on the precipice, he started to evolve into a grotesque caricature by booking himself to have an affair with Trish Stratus, as part of which he necked on with her. When there was nowhere else to work, pointedly, he did this sort of thing far more often.
He got off with Torrie Wilson. And, later, Sable. Also Candice Michelle. He abused his power to - and this is cynical and presumptuous, since he's never outright said it - do the things he wanted to do. He was hardly going to main event WrestleMania with a Playboy model. He technically did this to build his megalomaniacal character and drive storylines in which his wife and daughter were the babyfaces, but the man did say on the Pat McAfee Show that he's never worked a day in his life.
So why was it disturbing?
The women obviously couldn't turn down the pitch. This was a gross onscreen power dynamic that was even more warped in real life.
Also: did you see him kiss these women?
More jacked than ever before, and as a result exponentially more sweaty and red, he looked like a Rottweiler with two cacks eating a hot bag of chips.
2. Kane Puts The Monster In His Nickname
In WWE storylines, Kane was a rapist.
He was revealed to be the father of Lita's unborn baby in 2004. Now, it had clearly been established that Lita was very, very much uninterested in his advances. She was terrified of him. Being a demon heel, he would not take "no" for an answer. So he did various things in an attempt to "seduce" her - like kidnap her backstage - until her pregnancy was disclosed to the world. Matt Hardy thought he was the father. He wasn't. Kane was, despite Lita not being in a consensual sexual relationship with him.
So how did he impregnate her?
It's disgusting even writing the answer down. WWE wrote this, willingly, in a bid to generate interest and an audience, into its script.
Kane defeated Hardy at SummerSlam 2004 and, per the stipulation, "won" Lita. The object was now his official property, which in WWE was a synonym of "wife". Despite being married to Kane, Lita - again, not remotely interested - sabotaged his matches and continued, at every juncture, to express this.
Until she was accidentally made to miscarry by Gene Snitsky, and then it was time to join forces and beat up the real baddie!
Eurgh, look at his teeth! And he's into feet!
Get him!
1. Women: Still Objects In 2021
In 2015, WWE benevolently allowed the women to wrestle long matches and not strip down to their underwear.
Since then, job done, really. Women's Revolution: completed!
There are few writers, all of the male writers are redundant because Vince McMahon is king anyway, the only main roster female commentator they had was screamed at and insulted by, yes, Vince McMahon, and looking at the absolute state of NXT 2.0, the developing talent are less interested in learning their craft and principally concerned with sitting on the nearest c*ck.
WWE deserves credit for almost splitting match time between men and women in half. This was inconceivable during the early 2010s. But there's always something with this company that prevents a rational person from putting it over. Specifically: in 2021, Indi Hartwell was booked as the property of either Dexter Lumis or Johnny Gargano, depending on who won the match.
In 2021, if Johnny Gargano defeated Dexter Lumis, Hartwell would be forbidden from going out with the guy she liked. This would absolutely not have happened had the gender roles been reversed because men aren't things.
It was a disturbing glimpse into a process that will never truly change. The storyline wasn't helped by Lumis at certain points simply assuming Indi's consent. Played for laughs, it was mostly too dumb to offend, but given what NXT 2.0 became, burying the sh*t out of it wasn't exactly hysterical.