10 Disturbing WWE Storylines That Got Way Too Dark

Only in pro wrestling can one man get away with hanging another on live television.

Kane Lita
WWE.com

Wrestling, like any other form of entertainment, is supposed to offer escapism. It should remove the viewer from reality for a couple of hours, and as the most unique storytelling medium on the planet, few things can replicate its highs. From Hogan slamming Andre, to Mick Foley's first WWF Championship win, wrestling's greatest moments are pure euphoria, and make the weeks of struggle it gets to reach that point entirely worth it.

At its worst, however, wrestling can be downright miserable. The pseudo-sport will never be known for its taste and decency, and as much as WWE would love you to believe that they've "grown up" in the PG Era, their storytelling still dips into the crude, crass, and clumsy from time to time.

WWE have always run into problems when exploring heavier themes like race, addiction, and sexuality. For the most part, subtlety is dead in professional wrestling, and for all the great stories WWE have told over the years, they tend to let themselves down when it comes to the darker side of the human condition.

A sport that's supposed to be about triumph and elation soon becomes a nightmare, and when WWE tries to be "dark" and "edgy," they inevitably go way too far down the rabbit hole...

10. The Undertaker's Sacrificial Spree

Boss Man Hanging
WWE

The Undertaker has attempted to kill off numerous wrestlers over the years, particularly during his run with the Ministry of Darkness. The Ministry kidnapped and recruited the likes of The Acolytes, tortured Mideon into servitude, and sacrificed Ryan Shamrock to the "Higher Power." They then went one step further by attempting to crucify Stephanie McMahon during her Black Wedding to The Undertaker, but were foiled by Steve Austin.

Austin was a regular target, particularly in the lead-up to his Buried Alive match with 'Taker at In Your House: Rock Bottom. Along with chaining Austin to his symbol and hoisting him above the arena, 'Taker kidnapped Austin, took him to a funeral home, and tried to embalm him. Kane fortunately intervened before the ceremonial knife could be plunged into Stone Cold's chest- but it was disturbing, nonetheless.

The most startling visual came at the heart of the higher power story, with Undertaker vying for control of WWE. Vince McMahon sent the Big Boss Man, his Corporation enforcer, to deal with The Deadman at Wrestlemania XV, and the two met inside Hell In A Cell.

Taker defeated Boss Man, and The Brood descended from the rafters. They lowered a noose to their leader, which Undertaker secured around Boss Man's neck before ordering the Cell to be raised. Undertaker had "killed" Boss Man to send a message to Vince, and while his victim obviously survived, the sight of Boss Man's lifeless body dangling from the noose was both harrowing and tasteless.


9. Al Wilson

al wilson dawn marie
WWE.com

Debuting as part of the ill-fated Invasion angle, Torrie Wilson spent seven eventful years in WWE. Unfortunately, her 2002-3 feud with Dawn Marie remains her biggest talking point, thanks to its horrendous tone.

The rivalry kicked off when Dawn entered a relationship with Al Wilson, Torrie’s real-life father. Bringing blood relatives into wrestling storylines is often problematic, and shortly after losing to Torrie at No Mercy 2002, Dawn became engaged to Al. As if that wasn’t bad enough, WWE stepped even further over the line of taste and decency by having Dawn promise to break the relationship off in exchange for a night with Torrie - though this was later revealed as a lie.

Al and Dawn were married in January (in their underwear, of course) - and that’s when things got really hairy. One week later, Al died from a heart attack after sleeping with Dawn on their honeymoon, and the feud continued. The beef was eventually settled in a Stepmother vs. Stepdaughter match at the Royal Rumble, and lasted four agonising months in total.

Perhaps there’s a way to tastefully work an old man’s death into a wrestling storyline, but this definitely wasn’t it. Fortunately, Al Wilson is still alive and well today.


8. Pillman's XXX Files

marlena goldust
WWE.com

Brian Pillman indulged in more than his fair share of shady storylines during his WWE run. The Steve Austin/gun angle was harrowing enough, and left many fans questioning The Loose Cannon’s real-life sanity, but Pillman’s creative lowpoint didn’t arrive until the following year. Having concluded his feud with Austin, Pillman moved into a fresh story with Goldust. Things got really weird at In Your House: Ground Zero.

The match stipulated that if Pillman won, he’d “own” Goldust’s wife Marlena for 30 days. The Loose Cannon was inevitably victorious, and some of the most tasteless segments in WWF history followed. Pillman’s XXX Files saw Marlena become Pillman’s personal slave, and in the final installment, a terrified Marlena was shown in bed, clutching a comforter to her chin.

Marlena never looked comfortable throughout these segments, and neither were the audience. They did a tremendous job running Pillman down throughout this run, and he was never given the opportunity to redeem himself after the XXX Files. Pillman tragically passed away just a month after defeating Goldust at In Your House, and their rivalry went unresolved.


7. Booker T Vs. Triple H

Booker T Triple H Wrestlemania
WWE.com

Triple H has found himself at the heart of many a subpar feud throughout his career, but none were worse than his WrestleMania XIX rivalry with Booker T. As with any other sensitive subject, WWE’s approach to race has always been incredibly ham-fisted. They’ve wisely shied away from such heavy subject matter in recent years. Triple H vs. Booker T is surely one of many reasons why.

Booker, a former WCW Champion, had just become number one contender to The Game’s title - but when Triple H stated that “people like YOU don’t get to be World Champion,” the implications were obvious. Such overtones remained a constant theme for the rest of the feud, and several weeks later, Triple H gave Booker the option of becoming his limo driver and carrying his bags into the building.

WWE attempted to sell this as Triple H making fun of Booker T’s past run-ins with the law, but they couldn’t have done a worse job of hiding the bigotry. As bad as it was, however, Booker defeating Triple H at WrestleMania would have at least given him a measure of revenge. That was apparently too much to ask. The Game handily defeated his opponent, rendering the whole feud pointless, and eventually sent Booker packing to the Intercontinental Title division.


6. Hawk's Drinking Problem

hawk droz legion of doom
WWE

The last few years of Road Warrior Hawk’s life were pretty rough, by all accounts.

He was battling alcoholism by the time he and Animal had returned to the WWF in 1997, and with their shift towards a more adult-oriented product in the Attitude Era, the company decided to place the Legion of Doom in a storyline based on Hawk’s personal problems.

It was a mess from start to finish. Both Hawk and Animal protested the storyline at first, but the WWF wouldn’t relent, and they were forced into performing a number of awkward segments against their better judgement. It started with the team falling apart, as Hawk started appearing for matches drunk or under the influence of harder substances. Hawk soon developed suicidal tendencies, and in an effort to pull the team back together, Droz was recruited as “Puke.”

The conclusion came on a particularly hairy episode of Monday Night Raw. Hawk was at the height of his misery, and climbed to the top of the Titantron with the intention of hurling himself to his death. Puke climbed up to try and talk him down, before eventually pushing the beleaguered tag team legend to his presumed death. It was later revealed that Puke was the one enabling Hawk’s addiction in the first place, but Hawk and Animal both quit shortly afterwards, having finally had enough of the storyline.


5. Heidenreich & Michael Cole

Heidenreich Michael Cole
WWE Network

Heidenreich was never a particularly exciting wrestler, but his failed WWE run owes as much to misbooking as his own shortcomings.

The big man was handed some of the weirdest gimmicks in modern WWE history throughout his run, and it started with a split-personality character in 2003. Heidenreich was seemingly under the control of a possessed doll named Little Johnny, but the gimmick was canned after a few months, and Heidenreich went back to OVW for further training.

He returned to SmackDown the following year. Paul Heyman became his manager, and Heidenreich took on a psychotic new persona that saw him interfere in random matches, assault fans, and recite poetry. It was extremely odd, and peaked during a particularly disturbing segment with announcer Michael Cole.

The angle saw Heidenreich attack Cole, then drag him into a backstage bathroom. Pinning Cole to a door, the implication was that Heidenreich was sexually assaulting Cole, and the announcer’s pained moaning only made the situation all the more uncomfortable.

WWE would be rightly crucified for airing a segment like this in 2017, but really, 2004 isn’t all that long ago. It’s one of the worst ideas that the company have ever let leave the writing room, and the grimmest moment of either man’s career.


4. Pepper The Chihuahua

Big Boss Man Al Snow Pepper
WWE Network

1999 was a dark, dark year for the Big Boss Man. Being hung by The Undertaker flipped a switch in him, and after being spared from certain death, he went on a rampage through the Hardcore division. His main feud during this time period was Al Snow, and for whatever reason, WWE decided to bring Snow’s pet chihuahua Pepper into the mix.

The two met in a Falls Count Anywhere bout at SummerSlam 1999, and it soon spilled into the backstage area, and eventually a nearby bar. Snow had set Pepper’s carrier box near the entrance way minutes into the match, so Boss Man picked it up, teased Pepper, then struck Snow with the carrier before carelessly tossing it overhead.

Jim Ross was made to apologise for the incident, and revealed that Pepper had been removed from the box beforehand - but it got worse. Boss Man kidnapped the dog two weeks later, and arranged a hotel room meeting in which, unbeknown to Snow, he fed his foe a meat dish made from Pepper’s remains.

The duo eventually settled their differences in the infamous Kennel From Hell match at Unforgiven, in which the “attack dogs” surrounding the ring looked more content to chill out than go after the combatants.


3. Kane & Lita

Kane Lita
WWE Network

Kane deserves a medal for some of the nonsense he has put up with throughout his WWE career. He’s one of the best big men in wrestling history, and a surefire Hall Of Famer, but he has been part of some of the worst storylines in the company’s history. We’ll get to the absolute worst later, but Kane and Lita’s romance is definitely near the top of the pile.

Lita was in a relationship with Matt Hardy in spring 2007, but Kane had taken a fondness to her. She found herself stalked and harassed by the Big Red Machine on a weekly basis, and things reaching a boiling point when it was revealed Lita was pregnant. Matt Hardy was not the father, however: Kane was, and at that point, it was safe to assume that the conception probably wasn’t entirely consensual.

This led to a “Death Do Us Part” match between Kane and Hardy, and if Kane won, he’d get to marry Lita. He was victorious, the duo were married on Raw, and somehow, things got even worse a few months later.

Lita was by now heavily pregnant, and Kane was feuding with Gene Snitsky. Snitsky pushed Kane into his pregnant bride, Lita suffered a miscarriage, and that’s when the story hit its darkest point. WWE have run a handful of miscarriage angles in the past, but this was probably the grimmest, particularly given the suggestions of rape and torture.

Brutal, uncomfortable viewing from start to finish.


2. Tim White's Lunchtime Suicides

The Friendly Tap Armageddon 2005 Tim White
WWE Network

Earl Hebner aside, it’s pretty rare for WWE to involve their referees in storylines, particularly today when the officials have no real defining character traits.

2005 saw them involve Tim White as a means of selling the horrors of Hell In A Cell, however. Having retired from refereeing after a shoulder injury in 2004, White had opened a bar in Cumberland, Rhode Island, and SmackDown reporter Josh Mathews tracked him down on an episode of SmackDown.

White was found drinking himself into oblivion. He claimed that refereeing the 2002 Hell In A Cell bout between Chris Jericho and Triple H had “ruined his life,” then grabbed a shotgun from beneath the bar. Offscreen, White pulled the trigger, apparently killing himself on air barely a month after the death of Eddie Guerrero.

The whole thing was incredible distasteful - but it escalated.

They explained that White had accidentally shot his foot during the incident, but when Mathews interviewed him for a second time, White consumed a box full of rat poison. He survived again, but tried to hang himself two weeks later, and White’s “Lunchtime Suicide” vignettes became a regular feature on WWE.com. The situation ended that April, when WWE finally aired a video in which White didn’t try to off himself, but shot Mathews instead.

Brilliant...


1. Katie Vick

Katie Vick
WWE Network

As far as dark, disturbing, and depressing WWE storylines go, it doesn’t get any worse than Katie Vick. It is comfortably the most distasteful thing that WWE have ever done, and frankly, it’s a miracle either participant was able to enjoy a successful career in the aftermath.

The year was 2002, and Kane had just started feuding with Triple H. The duo were set to meet at No Mercy with both Kane’s Intercontinental Championship and Triple H’s World Heavyweight Title on the line, and it should have been a relatively easy sell. They were both among WWE’s biggest stars at the time, and their professional rivalry should have been enough basis for a solid series of matches.

Instead, WWE decided to bring necrophilia into the equation.

In the run-up to No Mercy, The Game suggested that Kane had embarked on an unrequited relationship with a woman named Katie Vick a few years prior. Claiming that Kane had defiled Vick’s corpse after she’d died in a car crash, Triple H threatened Kane with footage of the act. While this obviously never aired, what WWE presented in its place was almost as bad.

Triple H dressed himself up as Kane, walked into a funeral parlour, and simulated sex with a mannequin in a casket. WWE faced an immediate backlash for the angle, but fortunately responded appropriately. They toned everything down ahead of No Mercy, and there was barely a mention of Katie Vick’s name in the aftermath - but the story remains the biggest “what on Earth were they thinking?!” moment in WWE history.


In this post: 
Kane Lita
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.