10 Dream WWE Matches Between Stars From Different Eras

If not for the limits of time, we could have seen some seriously brilliant matches.

Cm Punk Randy Savage Professional wrestling has a rich and storied history populated with captivating performers capable of luring the audience in with promos and angles, then delivering classic matches that provide varied emotional reactions. Most fans latched onto wrestling at a reasonably young age, be it as children fascinated with the larger than life characters who seemed to leap through the television screen, or as teenagers drawn to the simulated violence and envelope-pushing stories. Everyone wistfully muses on their own personal glory days, the time period when they most enjoyed following wrestling. It's hard to imagine that any fans - even the most ardently committed to following the product now - would admit that they enjoy it to the level they did when they first discovered it, and in honesty, virtually any form of pop cultural entertainment is always looked upon more fondly through nostalgic eyes. That isn't the reductive culture it could be though, as nostalgia encourages debate: put any two or more serious wrestling fans in a room and you're almost always likely to get a discussion of favourite matches, performers, shows and angles, and my favourite vs. your favourite is a debate that will never get old. It's amazing and almost depressing to look back and think about some potentially classic moments and matches we could have been witness to had time not stood in the way. Even some wrestlers who were in the same company during the same time hit their prime in vastly different eras and made real face-offs either less likely or just less compelling. So let's take a look at some of these dream matches we missed out on had some of WWE's most enduring stars existed at the same point in time...

10. Dusty Rhodes (1986) vs. The Rock (1999)

The Rock Dusty Rhodes Few babyfaces in the history of wrestling could rally the fans to their side like "The American Dream". Dusty was the textbook everyman; overweight, unattractive and plagued with a lisp, he set the Florida territory on fire and was one of the biggest stars of Jim Crockett Promotions. He's a 3-time NWA World Heavyweight champion and his wars with Terry Funk, Kevin Sullivan, Ric Flair and the Four Horsemen are quite literally the stuff of legend. In 1999 The Rock was WWE's "Corporate Champion" and tearing it up as a heel. He was embroiled in hot feuds with Mankind and Steve Austin and was one of the most entertaining characters we'd ever seen. Rock's persona during this time period is the perfect antitheses of Dusty: while Rhodes was the blue collar son of a plumber, Rock was the blue chip hand-picked favourite of the boss. The story would have practically written itself. In much the same vein as Austin gave fans the opportunity to live vicariously through his actions against his evil boss, Dusty would be an ideal avatar for the regular joes. Being two of the best promo men of all-time, the lead up to the match would be intense. Dusty would lament Rock for never experiencing "hard times", while Rock would wisecrack on Dusty's physique and speech impediment. The match itself would likely deliver, as both men were above-average workers during their respective time periods, but the in-ring action for this one is secondary, as this dream match is all about the characters.

9. Goldberg (1998) vs. Nikita Koloff (1986)

Goldberg Nikita Koloff

During Goldberg's incredible undefeated streak that included his WCW Heavyweight Championship win over Hulk Hogan in the Georgia Dome, the company always struggled to find opponents who could serve as credible threats to defeat the intense former Atlanta Falcon. When the streak was finally broken, it took Kevin Nash, Scott Hall and a cattle prod to beat him. Scott Steiner, Sid Vicious and Bam Bam Bigelow all had runs with Goldberg during WCW's dying days but none of those feuds truly managed to capture the fans' interest. Enter Nikita Koloff. In 1986 Koloff was one of the hottest heels in Jim Crockett Promotions. He was a massive, explosive powerhouse, built in the same vein as The Road Warriors and every bit as nasty. In 1985 Koloff had a title match vs. Ric Flair at the Great American Bash that cemented him as a star, so much so that Vince McMahon approached him about joining the WWE to feud with Hulk Hogan, leading to the main event of WrestleMania 2 (which is a topic for a future entry). The year that followed was the peak of his heel run. 1986 gave us the best-of-seven series against Magnum TA, in one of the most fondly remembered feuds ever seen. Koloff was on fire and he looked unstoppable. Goldberg vs. Nikita Koloff would have been a natural matchup between two monsters of similar size, strength and limited ability who made the most of what they had. Nikita could have provided Goldberg with the daunting threat his character needed to stay fresh and we would have been treated to two bulls locking horns until someone dropped. It would have been ugly, but it would have been fun.

8. Brock Lesnar (2013) vs. Ricky Steamboat (1989)

Ricky Steamboat Brock Lesnar Both guys in this one could be featured in numerous entries, such is their iconic status: both have shown themselves to be capable of having great matches with virtually anyone they face, with very different formulas. When Brock Lesnar debuted he took WWE by storm, rocketing to the top of the company while delivering classic matches with The Rock and Kurt Angle, as well as getting the best of the Undertaker, a rarity in any era. After a successful run in UFC, he returned in 2012 and despite being nearly a decade older than his last appearance, was not noticeably slower and definitely a smarter worker. His matches with Punk and Cena (we'll ignore the Triple H trilogy) were masterpieces of brutality and human suffering. Ricky Steamboat is one of the most acclaimed wrestlers of any generation, by fans and peers alike. Ric Flair's called him the greatest babyface of all-time, and it's hard to argue against that assessment. Their classic series in 1989, as well as Steamboat's match with Randy Savage hold special places in wrestling lore. What made "The Dragon" so great was his ability to sell the offense of his opponent as if he were dying and draw tremendous sympathy from the crowd. A match between these two would have a very simple yet effective story. After opening with some nice exchanges and displays of technical brilliance, "The Beast Incarnate" would start pulverizing Steamboat for 20 minutes, beating him within an inch of his life. Steamboat would be on the verge of his demise, crying in agony at the pain the monster has inflicted on him. Then, when it seems all hope is lost, he briefly escapes the clutches of death's dark embrace and pulls out the inconceivable victory. It would be quite the emotional roller coaster.

7. Steve Austin (1998) vs. The Four Horsemen (1988)

The biggest star of all-time vs. the most influential stable in history. This one is a no-brainer. 1998 was the year that "Stone Cold' blew up and became a household name. His popularity transcended wrestling and helped WWE break into the pop culture consciousness. His feud with Vince McMahon is the most successful angle the company has ever done and he caused a ruckus on every show he appeared on. Austin truly was a phenomenon the likes of which we'll probably never see again. The 1988 version of The Four Horsemen (Ric Flair, Arn Anderson, Tully Blanchard and Barry Windham) had a stranglehold on all the championships in the NWA. The 3rd incarnation of the group, this one is typically the most fondly remembered. The Horsemen were masters at making their opponents look like superstars and elevating everyone they worked with while never losing their heat. They made life a living hell for Dusty Rhodes, the Rock n' Roll Express, the Road Warriors and many others. Had these men been together during their primes we would have seen Flair trying to halt Austin's ascent to the top of the mountain. "To be the man, you have to beat the man" was Flair's mantra, and that often meant beat the man and his 3 friends as well. We could have easily gotten a year or more out of the Horsemen throwing obstacles in Austin's path, forcing him to overcome Blanchard, Anderson and Windham in main events before finally leaving Flair with no choice but to face him one on one. The ultimate loner tough guy vs. the bad boys with the pack mentality is a story that we'd likely never forget.

6. The Steiner Brothers (1991) vs. The British Bulldogs (1985)

Two of the greatest tag teams who unfortunately never crossed paths, the Steiners and Bulldogs missed each other by just a few years, and when discussing the best tag workers, both teams always appear at the top of lists. Rick and Scott Steiner possessed the kind of natural chemistry that brothers often do. Their innovative offense was groundbreaking for its time and the athleticism both men displayed despite frames packed with muscle was astounding. Their late 80s to early 90s run is a catalog of great matches. The British Bulldogs made a huge impact in a relatively short amount of time. Their peak years were cut far too short due to Dynamite Kid's back injury. Even though he was apparently a miserably unpleasant human being, Kid was an amazing performer in the ring. He was far ahead of his time and has inspired countless other wrestlers. Together with Davey Boy Smith, who served as the team's powerhouse, the Bulldogs were absolutely awesome. The two teams match up well in nearly every aspect. None of the four are outstanding promos (although Scott would go on to be incredibly and incoherently entertaining on the mic in later years). But when it comes to in-ring action they had few peers. They both worked a fast-paced, explosive style filled with effective teamwork and innovative maneuvers. The match doesn't need much of a story. Just two teams who prided themselves on being the best competing to answer the question of who was.

5. The Undertaker (1999) vs. Sting (1997)

If rumours are to be believed, we're possibly in line to experience a version of this dream match, although much too late in either man's careers for it to be as effective as it once could have been. In 1999 The Undertaker was in his dark period, leading the Ministry in an attempt to take over WWE. He committed such dastardly deeds as human "sacrifices", kidnapping Stephanie McMahon and hanging the Big Bossman. Several different wrestlers, including Steve Austin would serve as foils for the Ministry, but it ultimately fizzled out with no one really stepping up to vanquish the beast. Just a few years earlier, Sting was one of the most popular performers in the business despite not actually wrestling any matches. Brooding in the rafters, pointing his baseball bat at his enemies and occasionally attacking them was enough to drive fans into a frenzy. He was booked perfectly and the anticipation for Sting was at a fever pitch. He was the last remaining hope of conquering the nWo (which WCW dropped the ball on, but that's been covered to death). What if Sting had jumped to WWE in 1999? Appearing in the rafters during a Ministry segment, creating weeks of speculation on whether he was with or against the Undertaker, before revealing his attention to bring the Ministry to its knees. The angle would have been filled with supernatural-esque elements and imagery, crows, crucifiixes, lightning and darkness. And it would have been awesome.

4. Mr. Perfect (1993) vs. Chris Jericho (2008)

Mr Perfect Chris Jericho Chris Jericho and Curt Hennig are two of the most entertaining performers in and outside of the ring to ever grace the squared circle. Mr. Perfect was one of the top wrestlers in WWE from 1988 - 1993. He was technically gifted and amazing at the art of selling. Hennig could make routine offense look devasting, and wrestlers were almost always better off after working with him. When he finally turned babyface in late 1992, the fans were dying to cheer him. Chris Jericho comes in and out of WWE at his leisure, and each time he shows that he hasn't lost a step. Probably the best example of the difference in star-making between WCW and WWE, Jericho debuted on Raw in 1999 to the one of the loudest pops ever and was instantly a superstar. He's alternated between heel and face frequently and excels at both, but for my money his feud with Shawn Michaels is the pinnacle of his career. He took everything the fans loved about him and stripped it away, creating the most effective heel character he ever played. The two present an interesting mesh of styles. Both are athletic workers with impressive skills, and it would be a technical masterpiece as well as a great conflict of two of wrestling's strongest personalities.

3. Randy Savage (1988) vs. CM Punk (2013)

Randy Savage Cm Punk The beauty of this match is you could easily switch the heel/face dynamic and it would likely still be just as compelling. CM Punk, while wildly popular among fans, is clearly at his most comfortable when he's playing the heel, so for that reason I'm going with the 2013 version of Punk. Randy Savage is obviously a big inspiration for Punk, and much like oft-requested dream match against Steve Austin, this is a match Punk would have loved to take place. "The Macho Man" is one of the most beloved stars of any era, as evidenced by the fact that crowds still chant his name at arenas to this day. A truly elite worker, Savage is one of the greats. Imagine the build up to a match between WWE Champion Savage from 1987, being assaulted at every turn by the same CM Punk who went toe to toe verbally with The Rock and relentlessly pursued the Undertaker. Best of all, it would have led to a showdown that would have been a classic for the ages.

2. The Outsiders (1996) Vs. D-Generation X (1997)

D Generation X The Outsiders This doesn't quite fit into the criteria of the other entries for the simple fact that all of these men have wrestled each other multiple times while being in the same company together for a significant period. But a feud between the 4 Kliq members as their on-screen factions of the Outsiders and DX would have been big money. Even during this time period it was no secret to fans that these guys were best friends. The MSG curtain call that broke kayfabe (which had been dead for years anyway) was an influential moment with implications that affected the business in a major way. When DX attempted to "invade" WCW by showing up at their arenas during Nitro (and yes I realize this was after Shawn's departure but bear with me here), what if they had actually been met by Hall and Nash? Regardless which company the feud took place in (hopefully WWE due to their willingness to push the envelope) it would have been incredibly entertaining. The two groups would be constantly trying to one up each other on the mic and in the ring, and it would have been a treat to behold.

1. Kurt Angle (2001) vs. Daniel Bryan (2014)

Kurt Angle Daniel Bryan There's no science behind this one other than the science behind this one. Two of the greatest workers ever facing off in what could potentially be one of the pinnacles of the business. You could choose multiple years for both guys to represent them in this match. Purists would probably argue that Ring Of Honor's Brian Danielson was a superior worker to Daniel Bryan. He definitely had more creative freedom in his matches due to the constraints of the mainstream WWE style. Kurt Angle has been awesome since basically the moment he stepped foot in the ring. Daniel Bryan in 2014 is riding a wave of momentum and popularity we haven't seen since the heyday of Stone Cold. He's having great matches with everyone he faces and is in line for a WWE Championship run and hopefully the full support of the company. 2001's Kurt Angle gave us an incredible series of matches with Chris Benoit (these two were always magic) as well as pretty much every other top star in WWE. The only story you really need for this one is the heel Olympic gold medalist, patronizing underdog Bryan for his impressive ability that isn't quite on his level. Bryan would be eager to test himself against the best in the business and would be up for the challenge. The resulting match would be an absolute feast for fans who enjoy the very best that professional wrestling has to offer. Sound off with your own dream matches in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Brad Hamilton is a writer, musician and marketer/social media manager from Atlanta, Georgia. He's an undefeated freestyle rap battle champion, spends too little time being productive and defines himself as the literary version of Brock Lesnar.