10 DUMB WWE Returns (We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS!)
Stupid stinking WWE returns that were actually stupid stinking genius!
'That's dumb'. 'Why did they bring him/her back?'. 'Nobody wants to see THAT guy wrestle again'. Some WWE signings are considered stupid by fans who just fancy a right good moan, but they turn out to be inspired decisions that either help creative or the company's financial bottom line. The same goes for re-signings; in other words, returns.
Loads of wrestlers have roared back into view before thousands (if not millions) of rolling eyes. Then, something wonderful happens: They show their value to the product. Even if that isn't true long term, it was worth trying...right? You bet. One thing WWE cannot be criticised for is experimenting with things to see what might happen.
You'll need your time machine for this piece too, because we're shooting all the way back to the glory days of the 'Attitude Era'. 1998 is the earliest landing point for one of the entries going under our microscope, but modern day fans shouldn't fret. There are examples from 2023 and even 2024 too.
These so-called silly WWE comebacks paid huge dividends for the folks in charge, and fans gleaned a lot from them into the bargain.
Dig into the "dumb".
10. Mabel (1999)
Even The Undertaker has openly bashed ex-WWE man Mabel/Viscera/Big Daddy D for being a clumsy oaf who injured numerous peers during a legitimately dangerous push in the mid-1990s. He crushed Diesel's back, broke 'Taker's orbital bone and generally acted as a menace to workers who just wanted a wrestle without needing surgery afterwards.
So, it was a bit of a surprise when Vince McMahon brought Mabel back into the fold for the 1999 Royal Rumble match. It was even more shocking when 'The Deadman' had his Ministry Of Darkness underlings abduct the former King Of The Ring and turn him into a contact lens-rocking, bin bag-wearing nightmare bodyguard for the faction.
Viscera was (re)born in the role, and he was absolutely perfect for it. He had visually impressive physical size, and could realistically rag doll some of Undertaker's enemies next to the Acolytes, Mideon and more. Nobody had him spinning out of this gig into an eventual 'World's Largest Love Machine' gimmick, right enough. That raised some eyebrows.
Bringing Mabel back might've tanked, but the WWF found a spot that helped to mask his limitations and mitigate some of his ungainly in-ring work.
9. The Headbangers (2016)
Mosh! Thrasher! They're into goth culture and more nu-metal bands than you could name!
Of course, The Headbangers gimmick was a little too late-90s to fly with a younger crowd in 2016, but that didn't stop WWE from bringing the underrated 'Attitude Era' tag-team back for another whirl just to see what might happen. This was a solid idea, because nostalgia is one hell of a drug and SmackDown's tag division needed some legacy depth at the time.
Heath Slater and Rhyno were champs, for crying out loud. No offence intended to them, 'cause the unlikely lads were over as a squeezy cheese on crackers-loving duo who only wanted to help Heath take care of his kids, but they were never going to be a long-term pick in the title hot seat. Thus, Headbangers returned to bolster the ranks.
Mosh and Thrasher's comeback was far too brief. This writer might be biased, 'cause he was always a fan of the pair (not their "cones" though - that was a prop nobody needed!) and always thought they could've done more in WWE. Still, trying to lean on sentimentality and make fans say, 'Oh yeah, those guys' was a good idea.
8. New Age Outlaws (2014)
Speaking of sudden nostalgia trips that thrilled ones in the know.
New Age Outlaws pair Billy Gunn and Road Dogg had been making several cameos on TV before launching headfirst into a full-time run come 2014. They'd typically show up as part of D-Generation X, spew through some catchphrases and then vanish again. This time, things would be different. This time, the Outlaws were going to win tag-team gold.
The famous tandem shockingly beat Cody Rhodes and Goldust in a pre-show bout before the 2014 Royal Rumble kicked off properly. Anyone thinking this would be a one-off pop that'd be corrected on Raw the next night would be wrong - WWE kept the belts on Billy and Roadie until March, and even had them go over The Usos.
Eventually, Jimmy and Jey managed to yeet the retro pair back onto the shelf by winning the titles. That'd be a wrap on New Age Outlaws 2K14, and they went back to working the cameo circuit over the next few years before Gunn stunned everyone by getting over in AEW as part of The Acclaimed.
Scissor me? Gunn had those WWE Tag straps in a vice like grip for a while!
7. James Ellsworth (2018)
Cue the band and get them to play some no chin music.
It looked for all the world like little Jimmy Ellsworth's unlikely WWE rags to riches success story had come to an end when Carmella belittled then battered him on an episode of SmackDown in November 2017. The enhancement worker had come a long way since bursting onto the scene as a brave victim for squash monster Braun Strowman on Raw in 2016, but he was realistically never going to last forever on the roster.
Surprise! James returned at Money In The Bank 2018, reunited with Mella and helped her retain the SmackDown Women's Title vs. Asuka. Nobody was ready for Ellsworth (sorry). The dude would ride this second go-around out for another month or so. That brevity made some call his return pointless. Ooooooh no.
Time to defend Ellsworth: Folie à Deux. He was a perfect sidekick for Carmella, and probably shouldn't have been taken off her in the first place. They meshed well together. Seeing James ham it up by trying to look cool was a constant giggle, and it was great to give fans a bit more of that in 2018.
6. Big Boss Man (1998)
Anyone who watched Ray Traylor's work for the promotion throughout 1997 and into early-1998 could agree on one thing: He wasn't going to star in any of WCW's best ever moments. Traylor's WCW deal lapsed, and most figured that was that for someone who'd shot to fame as the blue-uniformed Big Boss Man in the WWF.
Nope, the federation picked him up and retooled Boss Man into a killer heel.
He returned on the 12 October '98 Raw as a weapon for Vince McMahon and The Corporation. It was a fitting role for this new 'evil' Boss Man (he'd been bad before, but this was the most vicious version of the famous character yet). Those worried about in-ring quality didn't have to concern themselves either, 'cause Boss Man 2.0 was deployed mainly in the Hardcore Title division or in brawls vs. Corporation rivals like Steve Austin.
McMahon rehiring Boss Man and making him a heavy for the stable was genius creative. Talk about maximising value for someone who looked to have none at that stage in his career. This was an inspired bit of booking from all involved, and Traylor played his part.
5. Spirit Squad (2016)
You can't spell "Spirit Squad" without Mikey and Kenny. OK, so that doesn't make any sense whatsoever. Y'know what did? The Miz bringing some of Dolph Ziggler's old stablemates back to haunt the one-time Nicky in 2016. Oh yes, the Squad might not have been as nostalgic as The Headbangers, but they felt like ancient history 10 years on from their heyday nonetheless.
WWE didn't need to wheel out the entire gang either. They only needed Mikey and Kenny to sarcastically encourage Dolph to show some spirit before showing that they were only back to sabotage his singles success. Even so, a few fans scratched their heads and wondered why these hyper-enthusiastic dorks were back on TV.
Storytelling, that's why.
The Spirit Squad gave Ziggler his first real breakout gig of any worth on WWE's roster, so it was clever to link back and have Miz play some mind games with his Intercontinental Title foe. This, without going over the top, was one of the best stories SmackDown produced straight after the revived Draft earlier that year. It made for really good television, and it couldn't have happened without Kenny Dykstra or Mike Mondo.
4. Big Show (2020)
Desperation does funny things to wrestling legends.
By 2020, Big Show realised opportunities were thin on the ground (so thin on the ground in real life that he'd leave WWE for AEW the next year), and so he had to make the most of every chance. After working some tag shots in January, Show targeted the biggest prize of all: Drew McIntyre's newly won WWE Title.
He gatecrashed Drew's victory celebrations at the mega-weird WrestleMania 36, and immediately challenged the hot Scot to put his belt on the line. If Show could win this, then all would be well. That was how WWE presented his story. It was actually really frenzied, and cast the giant as an erratic fading star who understood time was running out for him to make an impact.
Weirdly, WWE taped this match straight after McIntyre's triumph over Brock Lesnar but placed it on the Raw after 'Mania like it had happened then. News broke quickly that Drew vs. Show took place following WrestleMania though, which only heaped more desperation onto an already-urgent situation.
This past vs. present and future tale was arguably bungled, but it did more for Show than anything in the previous five years minimum.
3. Goldberg (2024)
Admittedly, there's time for all of this to go pear-shaped yet, but recent news suggests Bill Goldberg won't be there for WWE's Crown Jewel 2024 PLE (which might've happened by the time you read this). That means he'll keep his nose out of GUNTHER's already-unwanted Crown Jewel Championship match vs. Cody Rhodes; well, the title is unwanted, not that particular combo.
Triple H does seem intrigued by the thought of putting Goldberg in the ring with GUNTHER at some stage though. He wouldn't have slapped a green light on their confrontation at Bad Blood otherwise. Social media blew up overnight with the usual discourse about Goldberg stealing the spotlight and fans saying there's no room for him in 2024.
Newsflash, there is.
Goldberg's clip pulled massive numbers on YouTube and socials for WWE's various accounts. That speaks to the value he still has as a performer. Yes, even in the year of our lord 2024. X and hate microcosm platforms like that might not want to admit it, but a lot of people still want to see big Bill spear fools and hit the odd Jackhammer.
Social and YouTube numbers matter to WWE, so it was genius to feature him recently.
2. Nia Jax (2023)
We're over one full year into Nia Jax's second WWE run and it's been a total blast.
That might not read like the most universally popular statement, but you've got to call 'em how you see 'em. Nia has been busting out the best work of her career in-ring and on the microphone since returning as a heel mauler starting with the 11 September 2023 Raw. Her annihilator/a-Nia-lator (however you want to spell it) makes Yokozuna's banzai drop look like a love tap.
Critics were rather confused when Triple H brought Jax back. After all, she'd been the female coming of Mabel during her first foray - Nia injured a few of her peers, and never seemed totally in control of her body during matches. Something has clicked in 2023 and 2024, being fair. She's blossomed into the best version of herself, and it's awesome to witness.
Time away from WWE's spotlight did Jax some good. Since coming back, she's been a heel linchpin for divisions on Raw and SmackDown. Seeing her win Queen Of The Ring and then become Women's Champ has been a joy.
1. Hulk Hogan (2002)
Hulk Hogan's final WCW year was stacked full of guff like a 'Yappapi Indian Strap' match vs. Ric Flair, walkouts, superhuman vision, and the infamous 'Fingerpoke Of Doom'. Well let me tell you something, brother: That didn't do much to create excitement for what Hulk returning to his old stomping grounds in the WWF would throw up.
The nWo arrived on federation screens in February 2002. Scott Hall quickly faded away, Kevin Nash struggled with injuries, and Hogan...became the last ever WWF Champion before everyone 'got the F out' and WWE became the norm. Where are creaking Anchorman memes about things escalating quickly when you need them?
WWF/WWE understood something that many just flat out didn't want to admit in '02. 'Hulkamania' still had merit, and people gagging at Hogan's latter-day WCW output were choking to see the red and yellow come home for one last hurrah. The merchandise sales alone for those 'Hulk STILL Rules' t-shirts must've been astronomical.
This was a very shrewd business decision that worked out for both parties, and don't let anybody tell you different.
Which other WWE returns looked silly but turned out to be genius moves? For more wrestling content, check out 10 Small WWE Character Tweaks That Became DISASTERS! and 50 Best WCW Moments Ever!