10 Dumbest Decisions In Recent WWE History
Acknowledge him... but not your paper-thin WWE Women's Tag Team Division...
You may be quick to point out that taking aim at the routinely baffling choices made by Vince McMahon and his juggernaut Sports Entertainment machine is arguably the lowest hanging piece of fruit the wrestling business has had to offer over the last few decades.
But, even with that in mind, some of the more recent bizarre pitches that have eventually come to fruition over the last few years have made the vast majority of that largely inconsistent (to put it mildly) spell look like televised gold in comparison.
Now, as with all truly wretched WWE eras, there is still the odd gem to be discovered in the darkness, with Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins' epic recent trilogy sitting as some of the strongest in-ring work pumped into an increasingly tired product in an age.
Yet, for every American Nightmare's torn t*t masterclass, there's sadly still another mind-numbingly stupid occurrence waiting to rear its head either in front of a camera or behind the scenes.
From hilariously short-sighted booking decisions, to aggressive expansion leaving the boss with egg on his immovable face, WWE have truly outdone themselves when it comes to foolish calls as of late... and that is saying something.
10. What's In A Name? Quite A Bit, Actually...
For all of the issues fans have understandably had with Vinnie Mac's handling of called up NXT talents over the years, the Chairman of the Board still respected his son-in-law's babies enough to mostly refrain from entirely rebranding the incoming developmental darlings.
However, the same cannot be said for the majority of the unfortunate band of one-time Tuesday night talents who have rocked up on the scene over the last year or so. From the formidable longest reigning NXT UK Champion having his iconic moniker binned off for Gunther, to a Bruiserweight being stuffed in a flat cap and branded as Butch, this all stems from McMahon's recent order for talents to no longer boast a version of their real name or titles used outside of WWE when appearing on his product going forward.
Why? Well, it largely stems from the paranoid boss not wanting said stars to turn up on other shows later down the line using the names they'd boasted whilst establishing themselves in front of WWE's global audience.
Wouldn't it be easier to just not release waves of talented guys and gals every couple of months under the laughable guise of "budget cuts"? And speaking of which...
9. Releasing Waves Of Talented Wrestlers, Then Booking Countless Stale Rematches
One of the most consistent criticisms sent the biggest wrestling promotion on the planet's way in recent times centres on the company's odd obsession with running back the same fixture over and over again until a once-intriguing showdown feels like a painful everyday occurrence.
Look no further than the Monday night battles between Asuka and Becky Lynch over the last month or so, with the feuding faces going at it in singles competition a whopping three times on Raw in the space of just over a month.
And it's not as though WWE have been light on talent to dump into the mix to keep things fresh either. In the last year alone, the likes of Dakota Kai, Ember Moon, Mercedes Martinez, Mia Yim, and Tegan Nox were all given the heave-ho, with many more simply decided the grass was likely greener and walking out of their own volition.
The men's and women's sides of the roster would've likely benefitted from retaining even just a fraction of this ever-growing WWE release list. But who needs new directions and programmes when you can watch the same top stars run themselves into the ground week after week, eh?
8. Booking A Tag Team Tournament... For A Division With No Tag Teams
It has felt as though fans haven't been able to go a week without some form of wrestling tournament occupying their television over the last few months. And that's by no means always a bad thing when the stakes are high and the potential for many a compelling contest is prevalent.
However, WWE's decision to promote their own answer to the All Elite and NJPW brackets of late almost instantly backfired due to an element that had been painfully obvious long before Sasha Banks and Naomi decided to tell their employers where to go.
Thanks to the entire women's tag division being an undoubted afterthought for pretty much its entire existence - aside from a brief Golden Role Model period of excellence - the reality of the company not even having enough main roster numbers to fill out even a basic four-team bracket acted as another indictment of the overall handling of the straps since their inception.
The entire division would benefit from a complete reset at this point, but the fact WWE have barely even acknowledged the billed incoming tourney since its original unveiling tells you all you need to know about where it ranks in the boss' list of priorities.
7. Not Following Through On The Boss' WrestleMania Plans
Sticking with the latest walkout to rock WWE to its core, or at the very least completely scupper some already dumb plans, Naomi and Sasha Banks turning their backs on Vince McMahon's empire during a recent edition of Raw likely stemmed back from a decision that rubbed both The Boss and a few corners of the fanbase up the wrong way at January's Royal Rumble event.
Provoking a decent enough pop from those crammed inside of The Dome, Ronda Rousey's return paved the way for a victory in the titular 30-person contest as The Baddest Woman on the Planet was quickly shuffled into the main event scene for 'Mania season.
However, to make space for Rousey's challenging for Charlotte Flair's SmackDown Women's Champion, it was Banks who was ultimately bumped out of the spotlight despite the Horsewoman being positioned in that spot for months, according to the Wrestling Observer Newsletter.
Banks was eventually handed another Women's Tag Team title consolation at the Show of Shows. But opting to stupidly not find a place for The Mandalorian star towards the top of the card no doubt influenced The Boss's call to vacate the WWE landscape for the second time in three years.
6. Making The WrestleMania Brand The Be All And End All
There's no getting away from the fact that WrestleMania is and likely will always be the biggest event on the wrestling calendar.
That being said, what made WrestleMania such an illustrious stage in the first place was the fact that it played host to the culmination of many a stellar and compelling feud over the years. It wasn't solely about stealing the show or having a "WrestleMania Moment". It was about winning the big one, reaching the top of the mountain, or finally knocking off a long-time rival in emphatic fashion.
In recent times, however, Vince McMahon has blatantly doubled-down on the 'Mania brand being more important than titles or grudge matches, with Seth Rollins' recent relentless Monday night quest to earn a spot on the show feeling particularly ridiculous - what with the event now spanning two inflated nights.
It's nothing new either as John Cena was at the centre of a similarly dumb pursuit back in 2018. But with 'Mania still breaking records in WWE's attempts to pull in the mainstream crowd, expect even more "Stupendous" selling of just appearing on this Grandest Stage alone being more important than intriguing storylines or World Championship victories in the years to come.
5. Shane O'Mac's Rumble Romp
Acting as the physical embodiment of just how underwhelming WWE's male iteration of their usually eye-catching Royal Rumble ultimately came to be in 2022, the decision to have Shane McMahon play the part of "shocking" returnee was as uninspiring as it was eventually disastrous for all involved.
On top of lighting up the rest of the full-time participants, Shane O'Mac was said to have attempted to hijack the producing of said rumble encounter coming into the event to the point of pitching to become the undisputed MVP of the bout.
Needless to say, with the match itself going down in history as one of the worst of its kind and Shane being on the receiving end of substantial heat for his part in the contest, his father would quietly nudge him out the door despite tentative plans to have him throwdown with Seth Rollins at the incoming Show of Shows.
The fact Shane was given the chance to put his fingerprints all over the bout in the first place is a baffling development in its own right. But at least WWE had the sense to cut their losses quickly and set the stage for an American Nightmare's re-emergence later down the road.
4. Nudging The Wrong Folks Into The Dark Side
No matter how hard WWE try to force a talent down a particular road, there's no denying that some stars are just better suited to being a pain in the ass than they are fighting the good fight for the folks at home.
The same is obviously true of the opposite, too. And it's because of Vince McMahon's insistence on trying to get fans to genuinely rain down boos on rather likeable talents that it often feels like many performers are entirely miscast and difficult to connect with.
In the case of "heelish" workers like Seth Rollins and Edge, who have both endeared themselves to the masses either through scintillating in-ring showings or heartwarming comeback stories, it's evident next to no one is legitimately vexed at their presence on the product. Instead, WWE simply have them blurt out paint-by-numbers insults as they lazily sidestep the flickers of support being sent their way.
Whereas talents like Ronda Rousey, a star clearly better suited to being an anti-pro-wrestling villain, are forced to grin and spew out phrases like "you're on-skis" due to WWE's consistent inability to hone in on a talent's true strengths and squeezing of many a round peg into a square hole.
3. Banning Twitch And Third Party Services
Quite rightly p*ss*ng off a number of talents who'd pumped their heart and soul into forging and cultivating a passionate online following, Vince McMahon's enforcing of a new policy that would require all of his workers to cease their third party involvement and shut down the likes of their Twitch and Cameo accounts looked like a senseless call out of the gates.
Coming during the height of a pandemic that had seriously impact many a talent's bottom line due to a lack of touring, the controversial move felt like little more than another greedy attempt to squeeze more money out of their personalities. And it also denied stars the chance to further connect with their audience in an alternate and much more authentic capacity, similarly to how they would at various FanFest and signing events.
Sure enough, WWE ultimately saw the error of their ways almost two years later, with Triple H holding a meeting with talents around WrestleMania weekend to announce the lifting of said restrictions. But there's no denying that the rule being brought into play in the first place likely influenced the departures of Twitch darlings like Adam Cole and Cesaro in recent times.
2. Trying To Cram Money In The Back Into The Stadium Mix
Coming into 2022, Nick Khan and WWE made it their mission to apply the special stadium-sized atmosphere to more of their incoming special events than ever before.
Because if WWE comes to town, who wouldn't want to fork out their hard-earned cash for a chance to see their favourites in the flesh, right?
Well, in what would eventually become a rather sobering turn of events for the company, it turns out that trying to sell-out Las Vegas' Allegiant Stadium isn't actually all that easy when you're not boasting the first fully attended big-four PPV since the start of the pandemic or a show including the name "WrestleMania".
So, some five weeks out from a Money in the Bank show that Khan once stated would act as the new member of the rechristened "big five", Vince McMahon was forced to move the show, that had only moved around 17,000 tickets for a venue that held 51,000 for the aforementioned SummerSlam 2021 event, to the MGM Grand Garden Arena instead.
Having to refund said Allegiant tickets and admit stadium-sized defeat is simply the latest repercussion of WWE not giving their fans enough of a reason to dip their hands in their pockets.
1. Double Strapping A Part-Time Tribal Chief
Another development that likely hasn't aided WWE's quest to fill out stadiums comes in the form of the undisputed top name in the company signing a new contract that would see his previously stacked schedule reduced.
Few would argue with Roman Reigns being gifted the opportunity to get well and truly paid for a less gruelling workload. But WWE's decision to stick both of their world titles on The Tribal Chief at WrestleMania 38, just before he penned this improved deal, is now looking like one of the biggest company missteps of recent times.
Without The Head of Table consistently being called upon to put his Undisputed WWE Universal Championship title on the line at PLE's, or even just to rock up on Raw or SmackDown to throw his finger up into the air, the company have looked completely devoid of ideas as to how to proceed with or sell their product.
Cody Rhodes' torn pec hasn't exactly helped their main event picture either. But what at first looked like another way of elevating an already untouchable entity has now paved the way for one of the most desperate and uncertain periods in modern WWE history.
But, they only have themselves to blame.