10 Dumbest Ways WWE Wrestlers Lost Matches

DERP!

Dean Ambrose TLC 2014
WWE.com

Good Christ almighty is wrestling absolutely bloody stupid.

At its best, obviously, we forget about that, and immerse ourselves in the majesty of a show like no other. The Irish whip, really silly when scrutinised, mirrors our sense of dazzlement when performed by two masters at the emotional height of a rivalry. What comes next? A crunching lariat? A sumptuous dropkick delivered from an awe-inspiring height? A duck-behind reversal as a segue into a brutal suplex? The very best performers craft a fusion of spectacle and athleticism to keep the audience guessing, with hearts in mouths, simulating an idiosyncratic and breathless form of combat that is at once fantastical and credible. There really is nothing like pro wrestling when pro wrestling is done right. Nothing.

At its worst, WWE in particular does so much to undermine the painstaking graft between the ropes. Think of it like a pendulum; so silly is the central premise of sports entertainment that the swing back from one direction often obliterates the other. The political need to protect a performer often requires that his opponent looks like an idiot.

The irony is that this idiocy, magnified by WWE's lens, becomes all-encompassing...

10. "Same Old T*ts! Same Old T*ts!"

Commissioner Pillhead
WWE Network

On the May 10, 1999 RAW, Sable defended her Women's Championship opposite Debra in an Evening Gown match. After absolutely no action whatsoever, Sable tore Debra's gown off to retain. The sex object was distracted by stupid sexy Val Venis, and humiliated in public. End scene.

Only, that's not how the segment ended. Moonlighting babyface Commissioner Shawn Michaels, the man who helped put the Wrestling in the World Wrestling Federation, was naturally upset at the way in which the match ended. He demanded a restart, promising the fans an athletic contest, in the spirit of sportsmanship, which was to end decisively after the better woman outwrestled the other.

No he didn't.

He stripped the title from Sable, shutt down the protests of her manager Nicole Bass by calling her a bloke, and awarded the title to Debra on the basis that her breasts - sorry, puppies - were nicer than Sable's. Besides which, he'd already seen those puppies before. Boring! This is the wrestling Bayley and Sasha Banks grew up on, and yet still decided to become wrestlers. Lucky for them, the landscape changed, and women are presented as pure athletes in 2018.

Pure athletes whose achievements are credited to Stephanie McMahon, but pure wrestlers all the same.


9. Musical Distractions (Various)

Goldberg Kevin Owens Fastlane
www.wwe.com

The first time was understandable, whenever it happened. You're in the middle of a match. You're hurt. You need to juggle the task at hand with the braying cries of thousands upon thousands of fans. And then, the entrance theme of your most hated enemy blasts over the arena speakers. The enemy that you cannot help but think about every waking hour of the day. Naturally, this is distracting. Infuriating. And then: you're rolled up by your enemy on the night, your win/loss record tainted.

It's the "various" part that renders this hopelessly dumb. WWE opts for this trope so often that those who fall for it cannot be considered anything less than morons.

The problem is that buying the distraction finish requires so many leaps in logic that, in the end, you only want to leap off the nearest ledge for choosing a hobby so stupid and so repetitive. The distracted wrestler shouldn't get distracted because they should know how the song goes by this point. The wrestler doing the distraction must have to pay off or beat up some production staffer to control the sound equipment, creating in the mind's eye a visual image so pantomime that the entire enterprise is rendered a farce.


8. Macho Man Randy Stupid

Savage Rumble
WWE Network

Even by 1993, the rules to the Royal Rumble match were both simple and entrenched.

A wrestler was eliminated when they were thrown over the top rope, and both of their feet touched the floor. Howard Finkel made sure to remind the audience of this every year, but it wasn't the talent who needed the reminder: it was 'Macho Man' Randy Savage. Or whichever road agent mapped out the bout.

Now Savage, despite being an in-ring savant, was never the brightest - at WrestleMania IX, he claimed the Undertaker should be wary of Giant González because he's from "down uuunnnderrrrr!" - but this finish really portrayed him as a moron. After landing his famous flying elbow, he, during the 1993 Royal Rumble Match, attempted to pin Yokozuna. He wasn't the guy in the midst of a monster push, and was considered collateral damage, more or less - which is fitting, since he sold Yoko's push-up strength spot as if he were in the backdraft of an explosion. It looked preposterous.

An ambitious spot in theory, in execution, it looked less like Yokozuna was strong, more like Savage was high-tailing it out of the WWF altogether. Perhaps it was Vince McMahon just sending him a message.


7. Shane You Suicidal Moron

Hell in a Cell Shane McMahon Kevin Owens
WWE

High risk, no reward: no, that does not summarise Shane McMahon's failed legal cannabis investment, but rather his entire approach to pro wrestling strategy.

You would think, after the first time Shane McMahon scaled a stupendous height, only to fall from it without landing on his target, that he would save himself the bother. This was the case at SummerSlam 2000, when he at least, as a non-wrestler, had the good grace to be sh*t-scared of a pro wrestler. He scaled the staging area, followed by Steve Blackman, only to be removed from it by a few thwacks of the kendo stick. Years later, older and somehow harder, Shane - WWE's equivalent of Minoru Suzuki or something - took a liking to leaping from the Hell In A Cell structure as a deliberate offensive strategy. He failed at WrestleMania 32, for the love of Mankind (if any a line there was to be memorised...). That did not stop him from attempting ostensible suicide at Hell In A Cell one year later, foiled only by the "guardian angel" of opponent Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn.

You would think Shane would try wrestling since, as he demonstrated with AJ Styles, he's somehow elite at it - but since he essentially no-sold those feats of bravery, it probably doesn't matter.

They didn't hurt!


6. The Ghost Of Married Future

John Cena Spooky Lil Kid
WWE.com

Before he lost fairly regularly, and what an insane sentence that is to write, John Cena won. John Cena WONLOL.

Very little shook him. He could kick out of multiple finishers delivered by multiple time World Champions. Technicians; giants; fellow massively over-pushed developmental graduates: nobody could see SuperCena when SuperCena was at his peak. He shook off brain damage in under two minutes at SummerSlam 2010. He was a medical marvel as well as a DC superhero. WWE went to only slightly less absurd lengths to protect the Cena character throughout the years.

From the infuriating to the laughable, at Extreme Rules 2014, Cena handily fought off the combined might of three legit behemoths, one of whom possessed supernatural powers, in a Steel Cage match. Just as he had it won, a possessed child greeted him at the cage door, dressed like the Higher Power, microphone in hand. Into that modulated microphone he sang 'He's Got The Whole World In His Hands'. Cena, perhaps spooked by the ticking of Nikki's biological clock more than anything else, walked into Wyatt's Sister Abigail.

Nervous young children, Kevin Federline, and one superstar per year on average could see Cena. The rest he treated like jokes in the world's lamest stand-up club.


5. Catastrophic Cash-In

Baron Corbin
WWE.com

You were an idiot for arguing back to Medical Director Joseph Maroon, Baron Corbin. Now you must look like an idiot on television, undoing months' worth of steady build, and wasting completely the Money In The Bank briefcase. How this must have appeared to the casual audience, or the audience not yet accustomed to WWE's toxic ways, is anybody's guess.

"Daddy, why is that man not good all of a sudden?"

"He was never good, Timmy. He was never good."

Completely spiteful in nature, the Lone Wolf was booked on a howlingly bad suicide mission on the SummerSlam '17 go-home show. He was stupid enough to go after WWE Champion Jinder Mahal when PPV opponent John Cena was still lurking within the vicinity. That was strike one. Strike two was challenging a "weakened" champion in the first place. Had Corbin never watched wrestling? Cena just gets the p*ss beaten out of him for the first five minutes, at least. With the match at 08:44 in length, there's little chance Mahal broke a sweat. The second after the bell rang, Corbin was distracted by Cena, and Jinder rolled him up for the three count. Strike three.

That'll learn you.


4. Sh*t On A Big Shoe

Big Show GIF
WWE Network

Ideally, a match promoted to settle a wrestling rivalry actually settles a rivalry, otherwise that rivalry is pointless. One performer at least should emerge from it in a better position than they entered, using a definitive victory to either advance up the card or better define their character. This did not happen in 2012, when the feud between the Big Show and Cody Rhodes was extended beyond its organic conclusion.

Show redeemed his patchy WrestleMania record, the crux of Cody's bantering, at WrestleMania XXVIII. That was the end - but in WWE, there is no end. Cody invoked his rematch clause, the crux of so much pointlessness, at Extreme Rules, in a Tables Match - which Big Show lost by stepping backwards through a table like a Big Jabroni. He looked like he'd stepped in sh*t. He might as well have; the whole thing reeked. Show looked moronic, Cody "opportunistic". This benefitted nobody. Worse than Show's stupidity is that WWE themselves were stupid in selectively ignoring the rules of their own fictional universe; usually, in such matches, the fall only counts when a wrestler is actively driven through a table by their opponent. So WWE broke their own rules in service of something abysmal. The other way 'round is almost comprehendible. This?

It was all so utterly stupid that it was enough to compel Edge to embark on another anti-stupidity crusade for a week, before forgetting all about it.


3. Ooh, Me Bloody Foot's Stuck, Hang On

AJ DUMB
WWE Network

Several institutional WWE problems converged to make AJ Styles look a right t*t at Backlash '17.

Heels cannot win cleanly, so that result was out of the question - but WWE needed some way of prolonging the rivalry. The churn doesn't move itself. Every major programme must last beyond one match. So, with these two policies in place, the agents on duty devised a f*ck finish that was f*cking stupid. Kevin Owens avoided AJ's Styles Clash through the announce table. In the process, that bumbling buffoon AJ managed to get his leg stuck. This also required Styles to fumble around for some cable, and wrap it around his own feet to sell the idea that he was unable to escape of his own free will...even though he used his own free will to screw himself. Now, that obviously wasn't the intention - we weren't meant to see through the smoke and mirrors - but what an unenviable task that must have been, even for a guy seasoned in TNA. WWE's refusal to allow heels clean victories doesn't merely undermine them; it undermines babyfaces, too.

Now, AJ Styles is bulletproof. Nobody remembers this b*llocks, the 'Kami' zingers, nor the losses to Baron Corbin, when they think of him. But WWE has invited the risk more often than you might remember.


2. "Hologram".

Hologram Hell In A Cell
WWE Network

At the climax of a d*mn good Hell In A Cell match, Bray Wyatt interfered. The blood feud between former brothers Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins just couldn't have a happy ending, even for 24 hours. We instead were confronted with a horror show, though perhaps not in the way WWE intended.

Ambrose, after the arena lights went out, became spooked at a hologram in the middle of the ring - so much so that he walked into Wyatt's Sister Abigail. It's unclear what this was meant to be. It looked like both a shuffling cliché ghost and a Klan member. What is clear is that, in the words of Wyatt himself, this wasn't Sister Abigail. Speaking to Chad Dukes of CBS Radio Washington around those halcyon days of late 2014, Wyatt claimed the following:

"One thing, and I want to get this out there so no one’s misconstrued, that was not Abigail. I don’t think anyone has looked closely enough. I think everyone skipped over that part and chocked it up to being some fancy illusion or something. I don’t ever do something just to be doing it. There’s always a point behind everything."

There was no point to this, obviously, and it was never revisited. Wyatt did not help from beyond to win the resulting feud with Ambrose. All he had to do was sit in the corner of the ring...


1. Stupidity Monitor

Dean Ambrose TLC 2014
WWE.com

Sometimes, best laid plans blow up in your face. This was literally the case for Dean Ambrose at TLC 2014.

After a full-on war approaching the 25-minute mark, during which Ambrose and Bray Wyatt delivered an absurd and ungodly level of punishment to one another - Ambrose even broke policy in order to break a kendo stick over Wyatt's face - Ambrose grabbed a monitor. The cable was still attached to it. Thus, when the Lunatic attempted to use it to his advantage, the power supply separated and plumes of smoke exploded into his face. Because that always happens when you unplug electronic equipment. Only in WWE. Only in WWE could a babyface star, after suffering so much pain, resemble a Spinal Tap drummer having put forth a spirited losing effort. If this was an attempt to get Wyatt over, it did not work. He didn't win the match; Ambrose lost it. Ambrose misjudged the length of a cable and lost a wrestling match. It was, as is often the case with Wyatt, an awful stunt pitched purely for is apparent cosmetic value.

Wyatt wasn't the better man. For once in the miserable existence of the character, Wyatt was the slightly less stupid man.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!