10 Elimination Chamber Participants Who Never Stood A Chance

If only their plexiglass pods were kept locked all match instead...

Elimination Chamber 2012
WWE.com

Have you ever watched a match and thought to yourself: how are they involved in this? If you've seen any of the Elimination Chamber matches after the first three, you know exactly what we're talking about. With six places to fill on the Road to WrestleMania, it sometimes falls to a lucky and plucky midcarder to make up the numbers.

When the Elimination Chamber moved to the start of the year, (taking up residence in January before moving to February), it became the place where storylines are finalised leading into WrestleMania. Belts have moved, number one contenders have been set, and landscapes have been completely altered. With all of this happening around them, some wrestlers promoted to the main event for one night only have won over fans, eliminated established stars, and even been runner-up.

Others have been gone as soon as they arrived, pushed from their pods back into the oblivion of the midcard. We've seen breakout stars like Kofi Kingston take advantage of a shrunken main event scene and reach for Vince McMahon's imaginary brass ring. For every one of those, there's 10 (how very convenient for this list...) or so entrants who everybody knew would be cannon fodder for the big boys.

10. Santino Marella

Santino Marella Daniel Bryan Elimination Chamber 2012
WWE.com

(Daniel Bryan Vs. Santino Marella Vs. Wade Barrett Vs. Cody Rhodes Vs. Big Show Vs. The Great Khali – Elimination Chamber 2012)

A comedy jobber in one of the biggest matches of the year.

Hot off the heels of a losing effort teaming with “Hacksaw” Jim Duggan, Santino Marella won a Battle Royal to take the last spot inside the unforgiving steel. The funny Italian was somehow challenging for the World Heavyweight Championship. Surely, he’d be out of the match straight away when his opponents were current champion Bryan, Wade Barrett, Cody Rhodes, Big Show and The Great Khali.

The King of the Cobra entered third and avoided his giant rivals, with Khali and Show the first to be eliminated. Three to go. Yet, within just over five minutes the WWE Universe was in a state of shock. Santino had pinned Rhodes and Barrett.

On paper the scene sounds absurd. From comedy jobber to finalist in an Elimination Chamber match. But it worked. The Bradley Center in Milwaukee, Wisconsin was 100% behind the underdog. The pop when Santino hit the Cobra raised the roof and the entire arena counting going “ONE, TWO, AHHH” as Bryan kicked out is one of the loudest reactions of the 2010s.

This isn’t a list of underdog victories though… the man who was in this match against all odds tapped out and normal service resumed. He never had a chance but he came oh so close.


9. Elias

Elias King of the Ring
WWE.com

(Roman Reigns Vs. Braun Strowman Vs. Seth Rollins Vs. Finn Bálor Vs. John Cena Vs. Elias Vs. The Miz - Elimination Chamber 2018)

Three things in life are certain: death, taxes, and if Brock Lesnar's walking into WrestleMania as champion then Roman Reigns is challenging him.

The result of this match was set in stone as soon as it was announced, but one entrant stood out for all the wrong reasons. Despite fans shouting "WWE stands for walk with Elias" for the prior few years, their man was entering the elimination chamber with five former world champions... he couldn't go all the way could he?

No. No he couldn't. Not even close. To be fair, The Miz was the first to be eliminated as Braun Strowman squashed the competition. Even Big Match John wasn't safe in this one though. With an extra competitor in the match this year Elias hold the dubious record of being the only person to enter an Elimination Chamber match seventh, even if he spent just five minutes in the bout.

WIth all the hard work done by Strowman, Reigns hit three superman punches and two spears to win his place in the main event at WrestleMania. Meanwhile Elias went on to tease Cena before his match against The Undertaker that night.


8. Randy Orton

Randy Orton Shawn Michaels Summerslam 2003
WWE.com

(Triple H Vs. Goldberg Vs. Chris Jericho Vs. Shawn Michaels Vs. Randy Orton Vs. Kevin Nash - SummerSlam 2003)

Five world champions and one man who'd never had a pay-per-view match before.

The faith Randy Orton was shown when he was put in the Elimination Chamber at SummerSlam 2003 for his PPV debut is unmatched, even if he was just there to fill a pod. He'd go on to great things, winning this match type himself in 2014, but for now he was there to make up the numbers.

This was peak Triple H goes over WCW's biggest and brightest. He'd seen off Scott Steiner, Booker T, and Kevin Nash in the months leading up to this, with Goldberg the next in line for the shovel. Orton was there as Triple H's Evolution buddy but was gone long before the Game's pod opened.

It was a serviceable debut for the future Viper, however this match was simply all about the last two entrants. Sure, Kliq partners Shawn Michaels and Nash also had issues with Triple H in 2003, but even they played second fiddle here. It's just a shame that the rise of Goldberg was over before it began; as Ric Flair slid a sledgehammer to the World Heavyweight Champion the writing was on the wall.

Orton did get to take part in the beatdown of Goldberg after the match, but in terms of chances in the bout itself, zilch.


7. Ted DiBiase

Ted DiBiase Jr Randy Orton
WWE.com

(John Cena Vs. Triple H Vs. Sheamus Vs. Kofi Kingston Vs. Ted DiBiase Vs. Randy Orton - Elimination Chamber 2010)

Ted DiBiase's stock was high in 2010.

His storyline leading into the pay-per-view involved the breakup of The Legacy, with former leader Randy Orton taking up a pod of his own in the same match. The Viper had failed to beat Sheamus for the WWE Championship at the Royal Rumble after a young Cody Rhodes interfered and caused a disqualification, which lead to a beatdown that ended the stable once and for all.

When it came time for Orton and DiBiase to come face-to-face inside the steel there was a twist in the tale. Rhodes was on the outside and still hadn't decided which of his two former stable-mates to side with. He slid a pipe into the ring which DiBiase got hold of first, hitting his opponent with it and making the elimination. Orton was overly protected here - he took an Attitude Adjustment from John Cena before DiBiase scored the pinfall...

Although it was clear Sheamus wouldn't be winning this match, it was even clearer that DiBiase was only in there to push The Legacy's story to WrestleMania. The trio would face off in a Triple Threat Match, where Orton got the better of the two younger wrestlers; he got his pinfall victory back over DiBiase too.


6. R-Truth

R-Truth 2011
WWE.com

(John Cena Vs. CM Punk Vs. John Morrison Vs. King Sheamus Vs. Randy Orton Vs. R-Truth - Elimination Chamber 2011)

There's times when it's clear a wrestler is in a match to make up the numbers.

Usually there's at least one in every Elimination Chamber match and you could argue that this one had three. R-Truth gets the nod this time, partly because of how he got there.

There was a seven-man Battle Royal on Raw to determine a number one contender for The Miz's WWE Championship, with the remaining six going into the chamber to see who would face the champion at WrestleMania. If you can believe it, in the year 2011 we saw Jerry "The King" Lawler see off four former champions to earn the right to face the A-Lister at the pay-per-view. R-Truth was eliminated from that match first, and was gone before the last pod opened in the unforgiving steel as well.

Poor R-Truth has been eliminated first in three Elimination Chamber matches which is a record. He managed to get rid of King Barrett in 2015. but was gone three minutes later in his most recent appearance in the match type. He's reliable for making up the numbers, that's for sure.


5. Hardcore Holly

Hardcore Holly Paul Heyman
WWE.com

(Bobby Lashley Vs. Big Show Vs. Test Vs. Rob Van Dam Vs. Hardcore Holly Vs. CM Punk - December to Dismember 2006)

The night that the Elimination Chamber went extreme!

December to Dismember was the first purely ECW pay-per-view since the brand was relaunched after One Night Stand, but it wasn't exactly what fans were dreaming of. With a mere two matches announced for the show, the main event would see ECW World Champion Big Show defend his title against a host of ECW legends, surely?

Only Rob Van Dam and Sabu had wrestled in the original Land of Extreme, but Sabu was taken out backstage and didn't even compete. Fortunately, he was replaced by Test... which is definitely a like-for-like swap! It was hard to decide who was in this just to make up the numbers most, especially when it was clear that everything other than Bobby Lashley walking out with the belt was a mere formality.

Bob Holly only had one win in 2006 to his name going into the match, which was way back in August, so he gets the nod. The fact that there was virtually no storyline reason for him to be there speaks volumes too; he was simply trusted as a longterm WWE man.

The cousin of Crash started the match along with RVD, but was eliminated quickly when Test left his pod and started to clean house. He lasted longer than a young CM Punk though, which is still a talking point to this day.

The entire pay-per-view was a disaster. Paul Heyman was given his marching orders that night (although he'll tell you he quit) and ECW never hosted a standalone PPV again.


4. Chris Masters

Carlito Chris Masters John Cena Elimination Chamber
WWE

(John Cena Vs. Carlito Vs. Chris Masters Vs. Shawn Michaels Vs. Kane Vs. Kurt Angle - New Year's Revolution 2006)

The one where Carlito got three eliminations. This really happened; It's why we've picked Chris Masters over him here.

John Cena had been WWE Champion since WrestleMania 21 when he walked into his first Elimination Chamber Match against three former champions and two plucky upstarts. From that list, who would you expect to be put out of their misery first? If you didn't say Carlito or Masters then you must've seen this match before.

Yet, it wasn't as simple as all that. Carlito and Masters got rid of Kane, then before long they'd seen off HBK too. What was happening? Masters had looked impressive in midcard matches, but somehow he was in the final three, ahead of a trio of bonafide Attitude Era legends. Had he gone from no hope in hell to shock title contender?

Unfortunately, the answer to that question was a profound no.

Carlito double-crossed Masters and hit a low blow, making the elimination just before he was caught out with a roll-up by the Chain Gang Soldier. Order was restored and Cena kept the coveted gold... for another few minutes at least. Carlito and Masters went on to challenge for the World Tag Team Championship instead, returning to their postions as Raw's nearly men.


3. Finlay

Finlay wwe
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Finlay_Oskhosk_WI_030808.jpg

(The Undertaker Vs. Batista Vs. Finlay Vs. Montel Vontavious Porter Vs. The Great Khali Vs. Big Daddy V - No Way Out 2008)

Take a look at the competitors and picture a scene where The Undertaker and Batista aren't the final two. You just can't. The Great Khali was World Heavyweight Champion six months before and even he wasn't a contender, so how do you justify the midcard fodder that was thrown in? That's not to criticise Finlay, MVP and Big Daddy V, they were just in over their head. Two of them were coming to the ends of their careers, having enjoyed their heyday way back in the 1990s.

Billed as the SmackDown/ECW Elimination Chamber match, this was the first time the match had taken place twice on the same pay-per-view; obviously this one went on earlier in the show...

Finlay put the work in when it came to being a body in multi-man matches between 2006 and 2009, whether it was on this night, at Survivor Series, or Bragging Rights. He was reliable, but he wasn't going to get close to SmackDown's two biggest stars in the Animal and 'Taker. He pinned MVP, then was eliminated by the Deadman after a valiant effort in one of the worst chamber matches ever.


2. Big Daddy V

Big Daddy V Elimination Chamber
WWE

(The Undertaker Vs. Batista Vs. Finlay Vs. Montel Vontavious Porter Vs. The Great Khali Vs. Big Daddy V - No Way Out 2008)

Consider this entry the redemption of Finlay, who at least wasn't the worst contender in the match.

WWE had tried to make Nelson Frazier Jr. happen so many times. Firstly, he was the positive role model Mabel in Men on a Mission. Then he was crowned King of the Ring in 1995 and became King Mabel, challenging Diesel for the WWE Championship at that year's SummerSlam in a much maligned match. After leaving the WWE and returning a few years later, he was thrown into the Ministry of Darkness as Viscera. Following a stint in the Hardcore division he left again, before coming back once more as the World's Largest Love Machine. When that didn't work he was shipped off to ECW, where he had his shirt removed and was christened Big Daddy V; his worst gimmick from a long list of nonstarters.

Combining ECW and SmackDown for this match proved how much more valuable the blue brand was. Big Daddy V's pod was the first to open, but he was met by match starters Batista and The Undertaker. He was gone after a DDT on the steel floor of the chamber; not even a finishing move was needed to take him out.

Poor Nelson Frazier Jr. was somebody WWE just didn't know how to book, no matter how many times they repackaged him.


1. Mike Knox

Mike Knox Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

(Edge Vs. Rey Mysterio Vs. Chris Jericho Vs. John Cena Vs. Mike Knox Vs. Kane - No Way Out 2009)

"Who's that?" asked Shawn Michaels. "He's a guy in ECW," replied Triple H.

That burial from Survivor Series 2006 tells you everything you need to know about Mike Knox's chances when he's put into a big match.

Three years after suffering the earliest elimination in Survivor Series history, he was being pushed on Raw as a monster heel. When the Elimination Chamber came round at No Way Out 2009 we'd once again see Knox knocking around with main event stars, this time for the chance to win the World Heavyweight Championship from John Cena. Can you image?

This match is remembered for Edge taking Kofi Kingston out of the equation and replacing him. This was perfectly fine and nobody on the roster questioned how he was allowed to leave with the gold. That's wrestling though. What it's not remembered for is Knox, who outlasted Kane before being pinned by Chris Jericho after a Codebreaker. Thanks for coming.

Nobody thought he would win... and he didn't. A week after the match, nobody remembered that he was even in it. Perhaps most damning of all is that this was his only time main eventing a pay-per-view or challenging for a championship in WWE.


Contributor

Christopher Sharman hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.