10 Famous WWE Matches That Actually Sucked

Ten of the most iconic WWE tussles that plain sucked when it came to the action inside the squared circle.

In this modern era of professional wrestling, the actual concept of positive, exciting wrestling seems to become more and more lost on those who make the big decisions in colossal wrestling conglomerates. These days it's merchandise and sending out the right PG image out which seems to take precedence over the actual wrestling side of pro wrestling - so it's worth asking to all WWE fans: what is it that makes a good match? To some, it's all about the impact and significance the storyline around the match had on WWE history. But for others, it's the wrestling which has to be brilliant in order for the match to be regarded as brilliant. If you ask a wrestling fan to put together a list of the most infamous WWE matches of all-time, how many of them would actually contain brilliant, edge of your seat wrestling? The kind of action that genuinely makes you wonder who will win the contest, and you become lost in some incredible technique being played out in front of your eyes. Believe it or not, some of the most famous matches in WWE history were appalling to watch, yet somehow are more memorable than hundreds of outstanding wrestling matches. Across the last 30 years there have been lots of matches that fit that particular bill. Here are ten of the most iconic WWE tussles that plain sucked when it came to the action inside the squared circle.

10. 1992 Royal Rumble Match

It's often singled out as perhaps the best Royal Rumble match of all-time, but the 1992 Rumble contest really isn't all that great when you scratch beneath the surface. Sure, Ric Flair put in perhaps the best performance of his entire career during that match to win the WWE Championship - but what else of note happened during that contest? Flair seemed like the only guy who really delivered throughout the most part of that match, with a number of bigger names flattering to deceive in a largely forgettable Royal Rumble match. It probably didn't help that, at that time, there was no consistency with the entrance times, with guys just rolling out whenever they really felt like it - or so it seemed. The most notable moment about the whole match (and the one people remember the most) is Flair's promo after the match with Gene Okerlund. Surely that tells you everything you need to know about how poor a match the 1992 Royal Rumble was? When you stack it up against the rest in terms of quality of wrestling, it really doesn't look all that brilliant.

9. The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels II - WrestleMania 26

This one was very hard to include, but when you look at the facts - and the background of the match - it simply has to be included; albeit nowhere near the top of the list. Unlike John Cena and The Rock's duo of matches at WrestleMania, the first contest between Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker at WrestleMania 25 is rightly regarded as one of the finest wrestling matches ever seen. However, when you try to follow up an iconic match with a rematch between the two same guys a year later, it invariably tends to end in failure. Having Michaels put his career on the line immediately felt like overkill to be honest, as we all knew what was going to happen from that moment onwards. The wrestling that took place in the match just felt like a bit of a rehash from the previous year, with both guys looking like they were going through repeated motions. If you sat down in front of a recording of both matches between these two guys, you would always choose to watch the first one. That's where the magic was - probably because it was so unique. Doing it all over again just a year later wasn't the smartest move from the WWE, and it did show on occasions throughout the second bout. All in all, it just couldn't live up to the hype from the first match. That's why it was a letdown.

8. Shawn Michaels vs. Bret Hart - WrestleMania 12

It feels a little bit harsh to put this match on the list - hell, there are some who think this is the best WrestleMania match of all-time. But hear me out; there are a valid reason or two for this match making it on the list. There's a reason you don't see too many Iron Man matches anymore, and that's because it's so, so hard to captivate the imagination of the audience for a full hour of wrestling. The WWE are barely capable of rolling out a 20-minute match that is enthralling these days, so scratch the possibility of them doing an hour-long contest! Sure, Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart did a decent job of putting a good show on for certain periods, but it just couldn't keep going for a full hour. Watching it back, you can see how the crowd gradually get less interested in things as we roll past the half-hour mark. It becomes painfully obvious that it's going to be 0-0, and it will be decided in sudden death. That left a real lull for the last half of the match, and it just didn't flow as it should have done. Again, it does feel a bit harsh to place it on this list, but it didn't have the same level of intensity and chemistry for a full hour. The crowd knew it, and so did Shawn and Bret.

7. John Cena vs. The Rock - WrestleMania 28

That's right folks, it's the "Once In A Lifetime" match (that actually happened two years in succession) between John Cena and The Rock! How exciting was it when they announced the main event of WrestleMania a whole year before the event itself? Well, not really exciting at all. And perhaps unsurprisingly, both Cena and The Rock failed to deliver when it really mattered, producing one of the most disappointing main events in WWE history. In truth, the second match between the two was even worse, but it was their tussle at WrestleMania 28 that really was billed as the big one. The Rock did a decent enough job of keeping up with Cena in patches, but for the most part it looked like he was chasing Cena around the ring. Cena did little to contribute to the contest, either. Perhaps it was too optimistic to expect Cena to break out of his usual repertoire of moves in the biggest match of his entire career, but it was the same old garbage. Perhaps the ending saved it to a certain extent, with few expecting that John Cena would lose against The Rock. But as we all know, he avenged that defeat a year later. Both matches were forgettable, but the hype around this one made it worse to watch.

6. Team WWE vs. Team Alliance - Survivor Series 2001

The significance of this match instantly ensures it makes it onto many wrestling fan's list of greatest wrestling matches of all-time. Sure, there were some nice swerves towards the back end that ensured an eventual win for Team WWE (like they were going to lose), but the actual action was appalling. Guys like Shane McMahon and Big Show delivered largely forgettable performances, and the real action didn't even get going until seven or eight men had been eliminated. For a traditional Survivor Series match, that's absolutely appalling. Some of the eliminations were pitiful; with roll-ups everywhere - which just led to a feeling that the whole match was being rushed through to the ending. It was obvious the WWE had put all their chips on the ending being superb, rather than ensuring the whole match was watchable. If you head over to YouTube and watch it back, you'll find it's such a chore to look back at. When we were all younger and felt like the WWE actually could possibly lose, it was awesome, and we were all sucked into it. But watching it back makes you realise how much the first three-quarters of that "iconic" match was.

5. The Undertaker vs. Brock Lesnar - WrestleMania 30

There's a general consensus amongst wrestling fans (or at least there was before Sting signed with WWE) that The Undertaker's defeat at WrestleMania 30 was the end of the road. The way he walked off at the end of the contest and trudged to the back was a real sign that he wouldn't be wrestling again. But if you look closer, there's an even bigger sign that Taker should call it a day after his match against Brock Lesnar - the actual match itself. Taker has been getting slower and slower inside the ring for the last few years - which is probably expected given how he only competes once a year. We can all forgive him for that, as he's provided wrestling fans with some absolutely outstanding moments that will stand the test of time. But he was miles behind Lesnar - another part-time guy who has been lamented himself for being sluggish in the ring - all the way through the match, and he actually looked hurt at the end of the contest. He ended up in hospital after the match, which perhaps told Taker and Vince McMahon all they needed to know about his future. The match itself was poor, and it never got going due to Taker's poor physical shape. At least the WWE didn't go with it as the main event, and they let Daniel Bryan have his moment.

4. 1999 Royal Rumble Match

Back to the Royal Rumble now, and another notable Rumble match that just wasn't all that. The general consensus was that everything that Steve Austin touched in the Attitude Era turned into gold, but one of his most famous wins was an absolutely hideous match. Back in 1999, the Steve Austin vs. Vince McMahon rivalry was at its peak, and it bubbled over at the 1999 Rumble in a huge manner. Austin and McMahon entered first and second, and - after Golga was eliminated seconds after being the third man in the match - both men would flee to the back by going under the bottom rope. The Rumble continued with a real lack of star power; Droz lasted well over 12 minutes, and The Big Boss Man stayed in the match for almost 19 minutes. Kurrgan and Gillberg are hardly star names (some younger fans may not even know who they are), but their appearance in the Rumble that year showed just how poor the depth of the WWE roster was. McMahon eventually returned from the back, but ended up doing commentary. As we all know, he would eventually eliminate Austin last thanks to a distraction from The Rock - but it was just done all wrong. Why McMahon had to win the Rumble in the first place was anyone's guess, but having the two biggest stars in the match be absent for the most of it was an even worse booking decision. Sure, the fact the crowd probably forgot about them when the match was actually going on made it a nice surprise for everyone when they returned - but if you watch it back, you'll see it just isn't all that.

3. Hulk Hogan vs. Andre The Giant - WrestleMania 3

Hogan Vs Andreew Mention this match to 1000 people, and it's likely that at least 999 of them would instantly think of Hulk Hogan slamming Andre. And so they should, as it was an incredibly iconic moment when WrestleMania was still in its infancy as a concept. But although that slam was unbelievable, there was literally nothing else happening after or before it. That's not an exaggeration, either. Literally nothing happened apart from that slam. It was clear the whole match was built up towards Hogan lifting Andre up, as it was incredibly limp and stale all the way through the match. To be fair, Andre's best years were well behind him at this point - and it really did show. Where people get confused is labeling Hulk Hogan vs. Andre The Giant as a great match, all because of that one moment. That's way over the top - the slam itself was a great moment, but the match was absolutely pitiful. Everyone knew the slam was going to happen (which was no bad thing), but there wasn't enough going on around that moment to make the match even vaguely interesting.

2. Hulk Hogan vs. The Rock - WrestleMania 18

There's a big urban legend surrounding this match, which claims that Steve Austin refused to take the gig against Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania 18 because he was worried Hogan was just too out of shape to pull a match of this type off. Turns out he was bang right, as we found out when The Rock stepped in and took the job instead. Looking back, it was easy to see why we were all so absorbed regarding this match. Here was a guy (Hogan) who had been away from the WWE for so long, that we were all desperate to see him wrestle in a WWE match again. It's like your favourite sportsman returns to your team after a ten-year absence - then you realise he's into his late-30s and is massively out of shape. The audience carried the match through to an underwhelming end after plenty of dismal in-ring action, mostly from Hogan. For large parts it felt like The Rock was as much a spectator as the rest of us; whilst he was watching Hogan doing his usual mid-1990s routine on the biggest stage of them all. There are some matches on this list that although they sucked, they had brief moments of enjoyment. This wasn't one of them.

1. CM Punk vs. John Cena - Money in the Bank 2011

CM Punk fans might want to look away right now. The most famous match in his (now over) career can't be excused from this list - as it just plain sucked. The storyline surrounding the match was absolute wrestling perfection, there's no doubting that. And the ending was completely out of left-field, with nobody really expecting Punk to get the win and leave the arena with the WWE Championship. But this isn't about the storyline, it's about the match itself. And it was a really poor experience for those watching it, with everyone probably getting more caught up in the "Will CM Punk leave?" story, rather than focusing on the actual action taking place inside the ring. The athletic ability between both guys just wasn't there, and the chemistry just didn't seem to be right. It should have been at a much higher level than what it was, given the significance of the storyline. Without towing a regular party line, Cena has to take a fair bit of flak for his role in the match - he was clumpy and pretty scratchy all the way through. Nobody can question that everything that happened before and after this match was astonishing to watch. It's perhaps the finest angle of this century so far, and everyone involved has to take credit for that. But that night, the wrestling match that took place just didn't cut it.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance sports journalist from Bradford, West Yorkshire. Specialize in primarily Rugby League and Football.